Feasibility of an Ultrasound-Based Method for Measuring Talar Displacement during the Anterior Drawer Stress Test Using a Telos Device: A Preliminary Study

Diagnostic value of measuring the talofibular space using stress sonography in chronic lateral ankle instability

OBJECTIVES

To investigate the diagnostic value of measuring the talofibular space using stress sonography for chronic lateral ankle instability (CLAI).

MATERIALS & METHODS

We recruited patients who were clinically diagnosed with CLAI between October 2018 and December 2019 (CLAI group). A control group of healthy volunteers was also included for this study. Both groups underwent a preliminary stress sonographic examination. First, the ultrasonic characteristics of the anterior talofibular ligament (ATFL), including length, thickness, relaxation, calcification, and rupture, were observed using conventional sonography. Second, the talofibular space at the passive neutral position (D1) and maximum varus position (D2) was measured (by stress sonographic images), and the difference (ΔD = D1-D2) between them was determined. Third, the parameters of the two groups were statistically compared. Finally, receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves and area under the curve (AUC) analyses were performed for parameters with significant differences.

RESULTS

The CLAI group comprised 60 patients, yielding data on 60 ankles, whereas the control group comprised 35 participants, yielding data for 70 ankles. Differences in D1, D2, and ΔD of the talofibular space between the two groups were significant, with ΔD proving to be the best diagnostic indicator (P < 0.001). Its AUC, optimal cutoff value, sensitivity, and specificity were 0.922, 0.11 cm, 73 %, and 94 %, respectively, followed by D2 (0.850, 0.47 cm, 67 %, and 94 %, respectively; P < 0.001) and D1 (0.635, 0.47 cm, 67 %, and 94 %, respectively; P = 0.006).

CONCLUSION

Measurement of talofibular space in stress sonography is a valuable diagnostic indicator for CLAI, especially the ΔD between the neutral and stress position.

Do standardization of the procedure reduce measurement variability of the sonographic anterior drawer test of the ankle?

BACKGROUND

In quantitative ankle stress sonography, different examiners use different techniques, which may cause measurement variability. This study aimed to clarify whether standardizing stress sonography techniques reduces variability in the quantitative measurement of anterior talofibular ligament length change.

METHODS

Fourteen examiners with a mean ultrasound experience of 8.7 years participated in this study. Each examiner performed stress ultrasonography of the ankle using their preferred method on one patient with an intact anterior talofibular ligament (Patient 1) and on two patients with chronic ankle instability (Patient 2 and 3). Changes in the ligament length between the resting and stressed positions were determined. A consensus meeting was then conducted to standardize the sonographic technique, which was used by the examiners during a repeat stress sonography on the same patients. The variance and measured values were compared between the preferred and standardized techniques using F-tests and paired t-tests, respectively.

RESULTS

At a consensus meeting, a sonographic technique in which the examiner pushed the lower leg posteriorly against the fixed foot was adopted as the standardized technique. In Patient 1, the change in the anterior talofibular ligament length was 0.4 (range, -2.3-1.3) mm and 0.6 (-0.6-1.7) mm using the preferred and standardized techniques, respectively, with no significant difference in the variance (P = 0.51) or the measured value (P = 0.52). The length changes in Patient 2 were 2.0 (0.3-4.4) mm and 1.7 (-0.9-3.8) mm using the preferred and standardized techniques, respectively. In Patient 3, the length changes were 1.4 (-2.7-7.1) mm and 0.7 (-2.0-2.3) mm. There were no significant differences between the techniques in either patient group.

CONCLUSION

Variability in the quantitative measurement of ankle stress sonography was not reduced despite the standardization of the technique among examiners. Hence, comparing the measured values between different examiners should be avoided.

The effect of thickness and elastic modulus of the anterior talofibular ligament on anterior ankle joint stiffness: A subject-specific finite element study

Ankle sprain is a frequent type of sports injury leading to lateral ligament injury. The anterior talofibular ligament (ATFL) is a primary ligamentous stabilizer of the ankle joint and typically the most vulnerable ligament injured in a lateral ankle sprain (LAS). This study aimed to quantitively investigate the effect of the thickness and elastic modulus of ATFL on anterior ankle joint stiffness (AAJS) by developing nine subject-specific finite element (FE) models under acute injury, chronic injury, and control conditions of ATFL. A 120 N forward force was applied at the posterior calcaneus leading to an anterior translation of the calcaneus and talus to simulate the anterior drawer test (ADT). In the results, the ratio of the forward force to the talar displacement was used to assess the AAJS, which increased by 5.85% in the acute group and decreased by 19.78% in the chronic group, compared to those of the control group. An empirical equation described the relationship between AAJS, thickness, and elastic modulus (R-square 0.98). The equation proposed in this study provided an approach to quantify AAJS and revealed the effect of the thickness and the elastic modulus of ATFL on ankle stability, which may shed light on the potential diagnosis of lateral ligament injury.

Reliability and validity of ultrasonographic automated length measurement system for assessing talofibular anterior instability in acute lateral ankle sprain

Ankle joint instability after acute lateral ankle sprain (LAS) is an important factor for deciding treatment strategies. Nevertheless, the degree of ankle joint mechanical instability as a criterion for making clinical decisions is unclear. This study examined the reliability and validity of an Automated Length Measurement System (ALMS) in ultrasonography for assessing real-time anterior talofibular distance. Using a phantom model, we tested whether ALMS could detect two points within a landmark following movement of the ultrasonographic probe. Furthermore, we examined whether ALMS was comparable with the manual measurement method for 21 patients with an acute LAS (42 ankles) during the reverse anterior drawer test. Using the phantom model, ALMS measurements showed excellent reliability, with errors below 0.4 mm and with a small variance. The ALMS measurement was comparable to manually measured values (ICC = 0.53-0.71, p < 0.001) and detected differences in talofibular joint distances between unaffected and affected ankles of 1.41 mm (p < 0.001). ALMS shortened the measurement time by one-thirteenth for one sample compared to the manual measurement (p < 0.001). ALMS could be used to standardize and simplify ultrasonographic measurement methods for dynamic joint movements without human error in clinical applications.