Oxidized Regenerated Cellulose versus Polyglycolic Acid for Pleural Coverage in Pneumothorax Surgery

Comparison of early recurrence in young-onset primary spontaneous pneumothorax following surgery using different covering methods

OBJECTIVES

The treatment of primary spontaneous pneumothorax not only involves bulla resection via video-assisted thoracic surgery but also covers the lesion. Ideal treatment should minimize adhesions and reduce the recurrence rate. This study aimed to explore different covering methods and compare the frequency of early recurrence for each covering method.

METHODS

We included 370 subjects with primary spontaneous pneumothorax < 25 years who were treated with video-assisted thoracic surgery from August 2012 to December 2022. Subjects were divided into three groups depending on how the treated lesions were covered. The P group included 162 subjects treated between April 2012 and June 2017 whose lesions were covered using polyglycolic acid sheets on the staple line of the bulla resection lesion. The O group included 93 subjects treated between July 2017 and July 2019 whose lesions were covered with oxidized regenerated cellulose over a polyglycolic acid sheet. The N group included 115 subjects treated between August 2019 and December 2022 whose lesions were covered with oxidized regenerated cellulose over a polyglycolic acid nano sheet.

RESULTS

Recurrence rates were 3.7%, 8.6%, and 6.0% in the P, O, and N groups, respectively; however, the differences were not statistically significant. The adhesions were milder in the N group than in the P and O groups.

CONCLUSIONS

Although both covering methods were effective in preventing recurrence, further studies involving further treatment modifications and longer-term follow-ups are required.

Adhesion is a risk factor for postoperative recurrence of spontaneous pneumothorax

Background

Several risk factors for postoperative recurrence of spontaneous pneumothorax have been reported, but the identified risk factors differed among studies.

Methods

A total of 183 primary spontaneous pneumothorax patients were enrolled in this retrospective study, and the risk factors for postoperative recurrence were evaluated.

Results

Among the patients, more than 80% with ipsilateral postoperative recurrence (IPR) relapsed within 3 years and more than 80% with contralateral postoperative recurrence relapsed within 4 years. Compared with patients without IPR, patients with IPR had significantly more cases with history of pneumothorax (P<0.10), more cases without preoperative drainage (P=0.02), more cases with intraoperative adhesion (P<0.01), greater upward lung volume (P=0.04), more numbers of automatic sutures (P=0.04), and more cases with contralateral recurrence (P<0.01). Furthermore, compared with patients without adhesion, patients with adhesion had significantly older age (P<0.01), and more cases with adhesion on CT images (P<0.01). Patients with adhesion also had significantly greater upward lung volume (P<0.01), more cases that received covering with polyglycolic acid (PGA) sheet covering with fibrin glue (P=0.01), and more cases that received re-do surgery (P=0.04). IPR was significantly more common in the adhesion group (P<0.01), while contralateral postoperative recurrence did not differ significantly between the groups with and without adhesion (P=0.06). Univariate analyses showed that body mass index (BMI) <15.6 kg/m2 (P<0.01), history of pneumothorax (P=0.01), intraoperative adhesion (P<0.01), upward lung volume >80% (P=0.02), lateral lung volume >80% (P=0.02), 3 fire or more of automatic sutures (P=0.03), and contralateral recurrence (P=0.01) were significant risk factors for IPR. BMI <15.6 kg/m2 (odds ratio: 20.89; 95% confidence interval: 1.55-280.70; P=0.02) and intraoperative adhesion (odds ratio: 25.58; 95% confidence interval: 1.91-342.39; P=0.01) were identified as risk factors for IPR in a multivariate analysis.

Conclusions

The present findings suggest that low BMI and intraoperative adhesion are risk factors for postoperative recurrence of spontaneous pneumothorax. For such patients, additional intraoperative procedures, such as covering with PGA sheet absorbable oxidized cellulose may be required to reduce postoperative recurrence.