AFM Images of Viroid-Sized Rings That Self-Assemble from Mononucleotides through Wet-Dry Cycling: Implications for the Origin of Life

Hypothesis: bacteria live on the edge of phase transitions with a cell cycle regulated by a water-clock

A fundamental problem in biology is how cells obtain the reproducible, coherent phenotypes needed for natural selection to act or, put differently, how cells manage to limit their exploration of the vastness of phenotype space. A subset of this problem is how they regulate their cell cycle. Bacteria, like eukaryotic cells, are highly structured and contain scores of hyperstructures or assemblies of molecules and macromolecules. The existence and functioning of certain of these hyperstructures depend on phase transitions. Here, I propose a conceptual framework to facilitate the development of water-clock hypotheses in which cells use water to generate phenotypes by living 'on the edge of phase transitions'. I give an example of such a hypothesis in the case of the bacterial cell cycle and show how it offers a relatively novel 'view from here' that brings together a range of different findings about hyperstructures, phase transitions and water and that can be integrated with other hypotheses about differentiation, metabolism and the origins of life.

Visualizing ribonuclease digestion of RNA-like polymers produced by hot wet-dry cycles

Polymerization of nucleotides under prebiotic conditions simulating the early Earth has been extensively studied. Several independent methods have been used to verify that RNA-like polymers can be produced by hot wet-dry cycling of nucleotides. However, it has not been shown that these RNA-like polymers are similar to biological RNA with 3'-5' phosphodiester bonds. In the results described here, RNA-like polymers were generated from 5'-monophosphate nucleosides AMP and UMP. To confirm that the polymers resemble biological RNA, ribonuclease A should catalyze hydrolysis of the 3'-5' phosphodiester bonds between pyrimidine nucleotides to each other or to purine nucleotides, but not purine-purine nucleotide bonds. Here we show AFM images of specific polymers produced by hot wet-dry cycling of AMP, UMP and AMP/UMP (1:1) solutions on mica surfaces, before and after exposure to ribonuclease A. AMP polymers were unaffected by ribonuclease A but UMP polymers disappeared. This indicates that a major fraction of the bonds in the UMP polymers is indeed 3'-5' phosphodiester bonds. Some of the polymers generated from the AMP/UMP mixture also showed clear signs of cleavage. Because ribonuclease A recognizes the ester bonds in the polymers, we show for the first time that these prebiotically produced polymers are in fact similar to biological RNA but are likely to be linked by a mixture of 3'-5' and 2'-5' phosphodiester bonds.

The RNA-DNA world and the emergence of DNA-encoded heritable traits

The RNA world hypothesis confers a central role to RNA molecules in information encoding and catalysis. Even though evidence in support of this hypothesis has accumulated from both experiments and computational modelling, the transition from an RNA world to a world where heritable genetic information is encoded in DNA remains an open question. Recent experiments show that both RNA and DNA templates can extend complementary primers using free RNA/DNA nucleotides, either non-enzymatically or in the presence of a replicase ribozyme. Guided by these experiments, we analyse protocellular evolution with an expanded set of reaction pathways made possible through the presence of DNA nucleotides. By encapsulating these reactions inside three different types of protocellular compartments, each subject to distinct modes of selection, we show how protocells containing DNA-encoded replicases in low copy numbers and replicases in high copy numbers can dominate the population. This is facilitated by a reaction that leads to auto-catalytic synthesis of replicase ribozymes from DNA templates encoding the replicase after the chance emergence of a replicase through non-enzymatic reactions. Our work unveils a pathway for the transition from an RNA world to a mixed RNA-DNA world characterized by Darwinian evolution, where DNA sequences encode heritable phenotypes.

Crystallization as a selection force at the polymerization of nucleotides in a prebiotic context

Accumulation and selection of nucleotides is one of the most challenging problems surrounding the origin of the first RNA molecules on our planet. In the current work we propose that guanosine 3',5' cyclic monophosphate could selectively crystallize upon evaporation of an acidic prebiotic pool containing various other nucleotides. The conditions of the evaporative crystallization are fully compatible with the subsequent acid catalyzed polymerization of this cyclic nucleotide reported in earlier studies and may be relevant in a broad range of possible prebiotic environments. Albeit cytidine 3',5' cyclic monophosphate has the ability to selectively accumulate under the same conditions, its crystal structure is not likely to support polymer formation.

DNA and the origins of life in micaceous clay

Reproducible imaging of DNA by atomic force microscopy was a useful predecessor to Ned Seeman's DNA nanotechnology. Many of the products of DNA nanotechnology were imaged in the atomic force microscope. The mica substrate used in this atomic force microscopy research formed the inspiration for the hypothesis that micaceous clay was a likely habitat for the origins of life. Montmorillonite clay has been a successful substrate for the polymerization of amino acids and nucleotides into peptides and DNA oligomers in research on life's origins. Mica and montmorillonite have the same anionic lattice, with a hexagonal spacing of 0.5 nm. Micas are nonswelling clays, with potassium ions (K+) holding the crystal sheets together, providing a stable environment for the processes and molecular complexes needed for the emergence of living cells. Montmorillonite crystal sheets are held together by smaller sodium ions (Na+), which results in swelling and shrinking during wet-dry cycles, providing a less stable environment. Also, the cells in all types of living systems have high intracellular K+ concentrations, which makes mica a more likely habitat for the origins of life than montmorillonite. Finally, moving mica sheets provides mechanical energy at the split edges of the sheets in mica "books." This mechanical energy of mica sheets, moving open and shut, in response to fluid flow, may have preceded chemical energy at life's origins, powering early prebiotic processes, such as the formation of covalent bonds, the interactions of molecular complexes, and the budding off of protocells before the molecular mechanism of cell division had developed.

Rolling Circles as a Means of Encoding Genes in the RNA World

The rolling circle mechanism found in viroids and some RNA viruses is a likely way that replication could have begun in the RNA World. Here, we consider simulations of populations of protocells, each containing multiple copies of rolling circle RNAs that can replicate non-enzymatically. The mechanism requires the presence of short self-cleaving ribozymes such as hammerheads, which can cleave and re-circularize RNA strands. A rolling circle must encode a hammerhead and the complement of a hammerhead, so that both plus and minus strands can cleave. Thus, the minimal functional length is twice the length of the hammerhead sequence. Selection for speed of replication will tend to reduce circles to this minimum length. However, if sequence errors occur when copying the hammerhead sequence, this prevents cleavage at one point, but still allows cleavage on the next passage around the rolling circle. Thus, there is a natural doubling mechanism that creates strands that are multiple times the length of the minimal sequence. This can provide space for the origin of new genes with beneficial functions. We show that if a beneficial gene appears in this new space, the longer sequence with the beneficial function can be selected, even though it replicates more slowly. This provides a route for the evolution of longer circles encoding multiple genes.

The Effect of Environment on the Evolution and Proliferation of Protocells of Increasing Complexity

The formation, growth, division and proliferation of protocells containing RNA strands is an important step in ensuring the viability of a mixed RNA-lipid world. Experiments and computer simulations indicate that RNA encapsulated inside protocells can favor the protocell, promoting its growth while protecting the system from being over-run by selfish RNA sequences. Recent work has also shown that the rolling-circle replication mechanism can be harnessed to ensure the rapid growth of RNA strands and the probabilistic emergence and proliferation of protocells with functionally diverse ribozymes. Despite these advances in our understanding of a primordial RNA-lipid world, key questions remain about the ideal environment for the formation of protocells and its role in regulating the proliferation of functionally complex protocells. The hot spring hypothesis suggests that mineral-rich regions near hot springs, subject to dry-wet cycles, provide an ideal environment for the origin of primitive protocells. We develop a computational model to study protocellular evolution in such environments that are distinguished by the occurrence of three distinct phases, a wet phase, followed by a gel phase, and subsequently by a dry phase. We determine the conditions under which protocells containing multiple types of ribozymes can evolve and proliferate in such regions. We find that diffusion in the gel phase can inhibit the proliferation of complex protocells with the extent of inhibition being most significant when a small fraction of protocells is eliminated during environmental cycling. Our work clarifies how the environment can shape the evolution and proliferation of complex protocells.

Visualizing RNA polymers produced by hot wet-dry cycling

It is possible that the transition from abiotic systems to life relied on RNA polymers that served as ribozyme-like catalysts and for storing genetic information. The source of such polymers is uncertain, but previous investigations reported that wet-dry cycles simulating prebiotic hot springs provide sufficient energy to drive condensation reactions of mononucleotides to form oligomers and polymers. The aim of the study reported here was to verify this claim and visualize the products prepared from solutions composed of single mononucleotides and 1:1 mixture of two mononucleotides. Therefore, we designed experiments that allowed comparisons of all such mixtures representing six combinations of the four mononucleotides of RNA. We observed irregular stringy patches and crystal strands when wet-dry cycling was performed at room temperature (20 °C). However, when the same solutions were exposed to wet-dry cycles at 80 °C, we observed what appeared to be true polymers. Their thickness was consistent with RNA-like products composed of covalently bonded monomers, while irregular strings and crystal segments of mononucleotides dried or cycled at room temperature were consistent with structures assembled and stabilized by weak hydrogen bonds. In a few instances we observed rings with short polymer attachments. These observations are consistent with previous claims of polymerization during wet-dry cycling. We conclude that RNA-like polymers and rings could have been synthesized non-enzymatically in freshwater hot springs on the prebiotic Earth with sizes sufficient to fold into ribozymes and genetic molecules required for life to begin.

Protocells: Milestones and Recent Advances

The origin of life is still one of humankind's great mysteries. At the transition between nonliving and living matter, protocells, initially featureless aggregates of abiotic matter, gain the structure and functions necessary to fulfill the criteria of life. Research addressing protocells as a central element in this transition is diverse and increasingly interdisciplinary. The authors review current protocell concepts and research directions, address milestones, challenges and existing hypotheses in the context of conditions on the early Earth, and provide a concise overview of current protocell research methods.

Potassium at the Origins of Life: Did Biology Emerge from Biotite in Micaceous Clay?

Intracellular potassium concentrations, [K+], are high in all types of living cells, but the origins of this K+ are unknown. The simplest hypothesis is that life emerged in an environment that was high in K+. One such environment is the spaces between the sheets of the clay mineral mica. The best mica for life's origins is the black mica, biotite, because it has a high content of Mg++ and because it has iron in various oxidation states. Life also has many of the characteristics of the environment between mica sheets, giving further support for the possibility that mica was the substrate on and within which life emerged. Here, a scenario for life's origins is presented, in which the necessary processes and components for life arise in niches between mica sheets; vesicle membranes encapsulate these processes and components; the resulting vesicles fuse, forming protocells; and eventually, all of the necessary components and processes are encapsulated within individual cells, some of which survive to seed the early Earth with life. This paper presents three new foci for the hypothesis of life's origins between mica sheets: (1) that potassium is essential for life's origins on Earth; (2) that biotite mica has advantages over muscovite mica; and (3) that micaceous clay is a better environment than isolated mica for life's origins.

Rolling circle RNA synthesis catalysed by RNA

RNA-catalyzed RNA replication is widely considered a key step in the emergence of life’s first genetic system. However, RNA replication can be impeded by the extraordinary stability of duplex RNA products, which must be dissociated for re-initiation of the next replication cycle. Here, we have explored rolling circle synthesis (RCS) as a potential solution to this strand separation problem. We observe sustained RCS by a triplet polymerase ribozyme beyond full-length circle synthesis with strand displacement yielding concatemeric RNA products. Furthermore, we show RCS of a circular Hammerhead ribozyme capable of self-cleavage and re-circularization. Thus, all steps of a viroid-like RNA replication pathway can be catalyzed by RNA alone. Finally, we explore potential RCS mechanisms by molecular dynamics simulations, which indicate a progressive build-up of conformational strain upon RCS with destabilization of nascent strand 5′- and 3′-ends. Our results have implications for the emergence of RNA replication and for understanding the potential of RNA to support complex genetic processes.

Many organisms today rely on a trio of molecules for their survival: DNA, to store their genetic information; proteins, to conduct the biological processes required for growth or replication; and RNA, to mainly act as an intermediary between DNA and proteins. Yet, how these inanimate molecules first came together to form a living system remains unclear.

Circumstantial evidence suggests that the first lifeforms relied to a much greater exrtent on RNA to conduct all necessary biological processes. There is no trace of this ‘RNA world’ today, but molecular ‘fossils’ may exist in current biology. Viroids, for example, are agents which can infect and replicate inside plant cells. They are formed of nothing but a circular strand of RNA that serves not only as genetic storage but also as ribozymes (RNA-based enzymes). Viroids need proteins from the host plant to replicate, but scientists have been able to engineer ribozymes that can copy complex RNA strands. This suggests that viroid-like replication could be achieved using only RNA.

Kristoffersen et al. put this idea to the test and showed that it is possible to use RNA enzymatic activity alone to carry out all the steps of a viroid-like copying mechanism. This process included copying a viroid-like RNA circle with RNA, followed by trimming the copy to the right size and reforming the circle. These two latter steps could be carried out by a ribozyme that could itself be encoded on the RNA circle. A computer simulation indicated that RNA synthesis on the circle caused increasing tension that could ease some of the barriers to replication.

These results increase our understanding of how RNA copying by RNA could be possible. This may lead to developing molecular models of a primordial RNA-based replication, which could be used to investigate early genetic systems and may have potential applications in synthetic biology.

Evolution towards increasing complexity through functional diversification in a protocell model of the RNA world

The encapsulation of genetic material inside compartments together with the creation and sustenance of functionally diverse internal components are likely to have been key steps in the formation of 'live', replicating protocells in an RNA world. Several experiments have shown that RNA encapsulated inside lipid vesicles can lead to vesicular growth and division through physical processes alone. Replication of RNA inside such vesicles can produce a large number of RNA strands. Yet, the impact of such replication processes on the emergence of the first ribozymes inside such protocells and on the subsequent evolution of the protocell population remains an open question. In this paper, we present a model for the evolution of protocells with functionally diverse ribozymes. Distinct ribozymes can be created with small probabilities during the error-prone RNA replication process via the rolling circle mechanism. We identify the conditions that can synergistically enhance the number of different ribozymes inside a protocell and allow functionally diverse protocells containing multiple ribozymes to dominate the population. Our work demonstrates the existence of an effective pathway towards increasing complexity of protocells that might have eventually led to the origin of life in an RNA world.

Self-reproducing catalytic micelles as nanoscopic protocell precursors

Protocells at life's origin are often conceived as bilayer-enclosed precursors of life, whose self-reproduction rests on the early advent of replicating catalytic biopolymers. This Perspective describes an alternative scenario, wherein reproducing nanoscopic lipid micelles with catalytic capabilities were forerunners of biopolymer-containing protocells. This postulate gains considerable support from experiments describing micellar catalysis and autocatalytic proliferation, and, more recently, from reports on cross-catalysis in mixed micelles that lead to life-like steady-state dynamics. Such results, along with evidence for micellar prebiotic compatibility, synergize with predictions of our chemically stringent computer-simulated model, illustrating how mutually catalytic lipid networks may enable micellar compositional reproduction that could underlie primal selection and evolution. Finally, we highlight studies on how endogenously catalysed lipid modifications could guide further protocellular complexification, including micelle to vesicle transition and monomer to biopolymer progression. These portrayals substantiate the possibility that protocellular evolution could have been seeded by pre-RNA lipid assemblies.