IAM Chromatographic Models of Skin Permeation

Predicting retention on immobilized artificial membrane chromatography: Lipophilicity-based versus lipophilicity-independent models

Retention of molecules on immobilized artificial membrane (IAM) chromatography is a key physicochemical property for predictive models of permeability across biological barriers, with applications in drug design and ecotoxicology. Currently, IAM retention is solely experimentally determined, which limits its utility for screening virtual compound libraries or for predictions of yet not synthesized molecules. The present study focuses on developing predictive models of IAM retention factors (logkw(IAM)) for a structurally diverse set of drug compounds, scrutinizing the role of lipophilicity, experimental and calculated, as well as the contribution of additional molecular parameters, selected from a pool of physicochemical, constitutional, topological and 3D descriptors. After obtaining a data overview by principal component analysis, both multiple linear regression (MLR) and partial least squares (PLS) analyses were used to construct lipophilicity-based models and lipophilicity-independent models. Bulk, polarity and fraction of anionic species were common descriptors in all models. It was demonstrated that calculated lipophilicity values introduced additional uncertainty, depending on the software used. On the other hand, lipophilicity-independent MLR and PLS models, which relied solely on computational descriptors, showed comparable performance with lipophilicity-based models, while offering the advantage to more useful for screening large libraries in early drug discovery. The reliability of lipophilicity-independent MLR and PLS models was assessed by external validation as well as by using a blind test set. Error distribution between lipophilicity-based and lipophilicity-independent models was also investigated and found to be comparable, while it was better than the differences between experimental and calculated lipophilicity values.

Biomimetic separations in chemistry and life sciences

Since Otto Schmitt introduced the term "biomimetics" in 1957, the imitation of biological systems to develop separation methods and simulate biological processes has seen continuous growth, particularly over the past five decades. The biomimetic approach relies on the use of specific ligands-biospecific, biomimetic, or synthetic-which target biomolecules, such as proteins, antibodies, nucleic acids, enzymes, drugs, pesticides, and other bioactive analytes. This review highlights advances in biomimetic separations, focusing on biomimetic liquid chromatography (including immobilized artificial membrane chromatography, cell membrane chromatography, biomimetic affinity chromatography, weak affinity chromatography, micellar liquid chromatography, immobilized liposome chromatography, and liposome electrokinetic capillary chromatography) for the complex separation and purification of biomolecules and other important chemical compounds. It also explores their application in studying drug-receptor interactions, screening chemical permeability, absorption, distribution, toxicity, as well as predicting environmental risks. Additionally, this review discusses the application of biomimetic magnetic nanoparticles, which leverage biological membranes and proteins for drug discovery, protein purification, and diagnostics.

Pesticides' Cornea Permeability-How Serious Is This Problem?

Background: A total of 348 pesticides from different chemical families (carbamates, organochlorines organophosphorus compounds, pyrethroids, triazines and miscellaneous) were investigated in the context of their cornea permeability and potential to cause eye corrosion. Methods: Multivariate models of cornea permeability based on compounds whose cornea permeability has been determined experimentally were proposed. The models, applicable to compounds across a relatively broad lipophilicity range (e.g., pesticides with octanol-water partition coefficient log P up to ca. 8), assume a reverse-parabolic relationship between cornea permeability and lipophilicity, expressed as XLOGP3; other main descriptors present in the models are log D at pH 7.4 and polar surface area (PSA). Results: It appears that the trans-corneal transport of all studied pesticides is possible to some degree; however, it is more difficult for the majority of highly lipophilic pesticides from the organochlorine and pyrethroid families. The same set of 348 pesticides was also evaluated for their eye-corrosive potential using novel artificial neural network models involving simple physico-chemical properties of the compounds (lipophilicity, aqueous solubility, polar surface area, H-bond donor and acceptor count and the count of atoms such as N, NH, O, P, S and halogens). Conclusions: It was concluded that eye corrosion is an issue, especially among the pesticides from organochlorine and organophosphorus families.

Recent developments in the application of immobilized artificial membrane (IAM) chromatography to drug discovery

INTRODUCTION

Immobilized artificial membrane (IAM) chromatography is widely used in many aspects of drug discovery. It employs stationary phases, which contain phospholipids combining simulation of biological membranes with rapid measurements.

AREAS COVERED

Advances in IAM stationary phases, chromatographic conditions and the underlying retention mechanism are discussed. The potential of IAM chromatography to model permeability and drug-membrane interactions as well as its use to estimate pharmacokinetic properties and toxicity endpoints including ecotoxicity, is outlined. Efforts to construct models for prediction IAM retention factors are presented.

EXPERT OPINION

IAM chromatography, as a border case between partitioning and binding, has broadened its application from permeability studies to encompass processes involving tissue binding. Most IAM-based permeability models are hybrid models incorporating additional molecular descriptors, while for the estimation of pharmacokinetic properties and binding to off targets, IAM retention is combined with other biomimetic properties. However, for its integration into routine drug discovery protocols, reliable IAM prediction models implemented in relevant software should be developed, to enable its use in virtual screening and the design of new molecules. Conversely, preparation of new IAM columns with different phospholipids or mixed monomers offers enhanced flexibility and the potential to tailor the conditions according to the target property.

Modeling of small molecule's affinity to phospholipids using IAM-HPLC and QSRR approach enhanced by similarity-based machine algorithms

Immobilized artificial membrane chromatography (IAM) has been proposed as a more biosimilar alternative to classical lipophilicity measurement. Determination of small molecule's affinity to phospholipids can be supported for predicting their behavior in the human body. Therefore, a better understanding of the molecular interaction mechanism between small xenobiotics and phospholipids can accelerate drug discovery. Here, the quantitative structure-retention relationships (QSRR) approach was integrated with mechanistic descriptors calculated using Chemicalize software to propose an easy-to-interpretation QSRR model. Considering the heterogeneous character of the data set, locally weighted least squares kernel regression belonging to similarity-based machine learning methods have been applied. The results showed that lipophilicity, charge, and maximum projection area determine molecule binding to phospholipids. Full validation of the obtained model based on OECD recommendations has been performed and the applicability domain was defined using the probability-oriented distance-based approach. The high values of predictive squared correlation coefficient (Q2), and small root mean square error of prediction (RMSEP), 0.812 and 6.739, respectively, confirmed that the obtained QSRR model is not well-fitted to the training data but also showed prediction power. Additionally, only 1.5% of molecules from the training set and 2.8% from the validation test are outside the applicability domain, confirming great predictive abilities.

Immobilized Keratin HPLC Stationary Phase-A Forgotten Model of Transdermal Absorption: To What Molecular and Biological Properties Is It Relevant?

Chromatographic retention data collected on immobilized keratin (KER) or immobilized artificial membrane (IAM) stationary phases were used to predict skin permeability coefficient (log Kp) and bioconcentration factor (log BCF) of structurally unrelated compounds. Models of both properties contained, apart from chromatographic descriptors, calculated physico-chemical parameters. The log Kp model, containing keratin-based retention factor, has slightly better statistical parameters and is in a better agreement with experimental log Kp data than the model derived from IAM chromatography; both models are applicable primarily to non-ionized compounds.Based on the multiple linear regression (MLR) analyses conducted in this study, it was concluded that immobilized keratin chromatographic support is a moderately useful tool for skin permeability assessment.However, chromatography on immobilized keratin may also be of use for a different purpose-in studies of compounds' bioconcentration in aquatic organisms.

Comparison of supercritical fluid chromatographic methods to predict the skin permeability of pharmaceutical and cosmetic compounds

Supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) was explored as an alternative for liquid chromatography to predict the skin permeability of pharmaceutical and cosmetic compounds. Nine dissimilar stationary phases were applied to screen a test set of 58 compounds. The experimental retention factors (log k), in addition to two sets of theoretical molecular descriptors, were applied to model the skin permeability coefficient. Different modelling approaches, i.e. multiple linear regression (MLR) and partial least squares (PLS) regression, were used. In general, the MLR models performed better than the PLS models for a given descriptor set. The results obtained on a cyanopropyl (CN) column provided the best correlation with the skin permeability data. The retention factors obtained on this column were included in a simple MLR model, together with the octanol-water partition coefficient and the number of atoms (r² = 0.81, RMSEC = 0.537 or 20.5% and RMSECV = 0.580 or 22.1%). The overall best MLR model included the chromatographic descriptor from a phenyl column and 18 descriptors (r² = 0.98, RMSEC = 0.167 or 6.2% and RMSECV = 0.238 or 8.9%). This model showed a good fit, on top of very good predictive features. However, stepwise MLR models with a reduced complexity could also be determined, with the best performance parameters obtained with the CN-column based retention and eight descriptors (r² = 0.95, RMSEC = 0.282 or 10.7% and RMSECV = 0.353 or 13.4%). SFC thus provides a suitable alternative to the liquid chromatographic techniques previously applied to model the skin permeability.

Affinity of Compounds for Phosphatydylcholine-Based Immobilized Artificial Membrane-A Measure of Their Bioconcentration in Aquatic Organisms

The BCF (bioconcentration factor) of solutes in aquatic organisms is an important parameter because many undesired chemicals enter the ecosystem and affect the wildlife. Chromatographic retention factor log k_w^IAM obtained from immobilized artificial membrane (IAM) HPLC chromatography with buffered, aqueous mobile phases and calculated molecular descriptors obtained for a group of 120 structurally unrelated compounds were used to generate useful models of log BCF. It was established that log k_w^IAM obtained in the conditions described in this study is not sufficient as a sole predictor of bioconcentration. Simple, potentially useful models based on log k_w^IAM and a selection of readily available, calculated descriptors and accounting for over 88% of total variability were generated using multiple linear regression (MLR), partial least squares (PLS) regression and artificial neural networks (ANN). The models proposed in the study were tested on an external group of 120 compounds and on a group of 40 compounds with known experimental log BCF values. It was established that a relatively simple MLR model containing four independent variables leads to satisfying BCF predictions and is more intuitive than PLS or ANN models.