Inspired by Nature-Functional Analogues of Molybdenum and Tungsten-Dependent Oxidoreductases

Chemical and redox non-innocence in low-valent molybdenum β diketonate complexes: novel pathways for CO2 and CS2 activation

The investigation of fundamental properties of low-valent molybdenum complexes bearing anionic ligands is crucial for elucidating the molybdenum's role in critical enzymatic systems involved in the transformation of small molecules, including the nitrogenase's iron molybdenum cofactor, FeMoco. The β-diketonate ligands in [Mo(acac)3] (acac = acetylacetonate), one of the earliest low-valent Mo complexes reported, provide a robust anionic platform to stabilize Mo in its +III oxidation state. This complex played a key role in demonstrating the potential of low-valent molybdenum for small molecule activation, serving as the starting material for the preparation of the first reported molybdenum dinitrogen complex. Surprisingly however, given this fact and the widespread use of β-diketonate ligands in coordination chemistry, only a very limited number of low-valent Mo β-diketonate complexes have been reported. To address this gap, we explored the redox behavior of homoleptic molybdenum tris-β-diketonate complexes, employing a tertiary butyl substituted diketonate ligand (dipivaloylmethanate, tBudiket) to isolate and fully characterize the corresponding Mo complexes across three consecutive oxidation states (+IV, +III, +II). We observed marked reactivity of the most reduced congener with heterocumulenes CE2 (E = O, S), yet with very distinct outcomes. Specifically, CO2 stoichiometrically carboxylates one of the β-diketonate ligands, while in the presence of excess CS2, catalytic reductive dimerization to tetrathiooxalate occurs. Through the isolation and characterization of reaction products and intermediates, we demonstrate that the observed reactivity results from the chemical non-innocence of the β-diketonate ligands, which facilitates the formation of a common ligand-bound intermediate, [Mo( tBudiket)2( tBudiket·CE2)]1- (E = O, S). The stability of this proposed intermediate dictates the specific reduction products observed, highlighting the relevance of the chemically non-innocent nature of β-diketonate ligands.

Vinyl-pyrazole as a biomimetic acetaldehyde surrogate

Inspired by the enzyme acetylene hydratase, we investigated the reactivity of acetylene with tungsten(II) pyrazole complexes. Our research revealed that the complex [WBr2(pz-NHCCH3)(CO)3] (pz = 3,5-dimethyl-pyrazolate) facilitates the stochiometric reaction between pzH and acetylene to give N-vinyl-pz. This vinyl compound readily hydrolyzes to acetaldehyde, mirroring the product of acetylene hydration in the enzymatic process. The formation of the vinyl compound likely involves a reactive intermediate complex where acetylene acts as a two-electron donor, in contrast to isolable acetylene complexes that are inert to nucleophilic attack by water. Results suggest an alternative mechanism for the enzyme, including vinylation of a neighboring amino acid by acetylene in the active site prior to hydration.

The Effect of Selenium-Based Ligands on Tungsten Acetylene Complexes

Bioinspired tungsten acetylene complexes containing pyridine-2-selenolato (PySe) or 6-methyl-pyridine-2-selenolato (6-MePySe) ligands were synthesized. 77Se NMR spectroscopy allowed for an assessment of the resonance structures in the pyridine-2-selenolato ligands and the rationalization of chemoselectivity observed in regard to 1,2 migratory insertion of HC≡CH. [W(CO)(C2H2)(CHCH-PySe)(PySe)] is formed exclusively via insertion of HC≡CH into the W-N bond, while the use of bulkier 6-MePySe allows for the isolation of [W(CO)(C2H2)(6-MePySe)2], which only partially reacts with excess HC≡CH to give [W(CO)(C2H2)(CHCH-6-MePySe)(6-MePySe)]. Oxidation of [W(CO)(C2H2)(6-MePySe)2] with pyridine-N-oxide gave the tungsten(IV) complex [WO(C2H2)(6-MePySe)2]. Complexes [W(CO)(C2H2)(6-MePySe)2] and [WO(C2H2)(6-MePySe)2] react with trimethyl phosphine to carbyne complex [W(CO)(CCH2PMe3)(PMe3)2(6-MePySe)]Cl and alkylidene complex [WO(CHCHPMe3)(PMe3)2(6-MePySe)]Cl, respectively. The addition of substituted alkynes to [W(CO)3(PySe)2] via thermal decarbonylation gave complexes [W(CO)(MeC≡CMe)(PySe)2] and [W(CO)(HC≡Ct-Bu)(PySe)2], respectively. The here presented complexes are relevant for the modeling of the active site of acetylene hydratase from Pelobacter acetylenicus, in which a tungsten atom is enclosed in a sulfur-rich coordination sphere. A recently published theoretical study concluded that the exchange of sulfur for selenium would increase the activity of the enzyme. Our findings contrast this claim as comparative analysis concludes negligible structural and electronic differences between the selenium-based and previously published sulfur-based complexes.

Nucleophiles Target the Tungsten Center Over Acetylene in Biomimetic Models

Inspired by the first shell mechanism proposed for the tungstoenzyme acetylene hydratase, the electrophilic reactivity of tungsten-acetylene complexes [W(CO)(C2H2)(6-MePyS)2] (1) and [WO(C2H2)(6-MePyS)2] (2) was investigated. The biological nucleophile water/hydroxide and tert-butyl isocyanide were employed. Our findings consistently show that, regardless of the nucleophile used, both tungsten centers W(II) and W(IV), respectively, are the preferred targets over the coordinated acetylene. Treatment of 2 with aqueous NaOH led to protonation of coordinated acetylene to ethylene, pointing toward the Brønsted basic character of the coordinated alkyne instead of the anticipated electrophilic behavior. In cases involving isocyanides as nucleophiles, the attack on the W(II) center of 1 took place first, whereas the W(IV) complex 2 remained unchanged. These experiments indicate that the direct nucleophilic attack of W-coordinated acetylene by water, as some computational studies of acetylene hydratase propose, is unlikely to occur.

Dioxygen Activation by a Bioinspired Tungsten(IV) Complex

An increasing number of discovered tungstoenzymes raises interest in the biomimetic chemistry of tungsten complexes in oxidation states +IV, +V, and +VI. Bioinspired (sulfur-rich) tungsten(VI) dioxido complexes are relatively prevalent in literature. Still, their energetically demanding reduction directly correlates with a small number of known tungsten(IV) oxido complexes, whose chemistry is not well explored. In this paper, a reduction of the [WO₂(6-MePyS)₂] (6-MePyS = 6-methylpyridine-2-thiolate) complex with PMe₃ to a phosphine-stabilized tungsten(IV) oxido complex [WO(6-MePyS)₂(PMe₃)₂] is described. This tungsten(IV) complex partially releases one PMe₃ ligand in solution, creating a vacant coordination site capable of activating dioxygen to form [WO₂(6-MePyS)₂] and OPMe₃. Therefore, [WO₂(6-MePyS)₂] can be used as a catalyst for the aerobic oxidation of PMe₃, rendering this complex a rare example of a tungsten system utilizing dioxygen in homogeneous catalysis. Additionally, the investigation of the reactivity of the tungsten(IV) oxido complex with acetylene, substrate of a tungstoenzyme acetylene hydratase (AH), revealed the formation of the tungsten(IV) acetylene adduct. Although this adduct was previously reported as an oxidation product of the tungsten(II) acetylene carbonyl complex, here it is obtained via substitution at the sulfur-rich tungsten(IV) center, mimicking the initial step of the first shell mechanism for AH as suggested by computational studies.

Formate Dehydrogenase Mimics as Catalysts for Carbon Dioxide Reduction

Formate dehydrogenases (FDH) reversibly catalyze the interconversion of CO₂ to formate. They belong to the family of molybdenum and tungsten-dependent oxidoreductases. For several decades, scientists have been synthesizing structural and functional model complexes inspired by these enzymes. These studies not only allow for finding certain efficient catalysts but also in some cases to better understand the functioning of the enzymes. However, FDH models for catalytic CO₂ reduction are less studied compared to the oxygen atom transfer (OAT) reaction. Herein, we present recent results of structural and functional models of FDH.

Replacement of Molybdenum by Tungsten in a Biomimetic Complex Leads to an Increase in Oxygen Atom Transfer Catalytic Activity

Upon replacement of molybdenum by tungsten in DMSO reductase isolated from the Rhodobacteraceae family, the derived enzyme catalyzes DMSO reduction faster. To better understand this behavior, we synthesized two tungsten(VI) dioxido complexes [W^VIO₂L₂] with pyridine- (PyS) and pyrimidine-2-thiolate (PymS) ligands, isostructural to analogous molybdenum complexes we reported recently. Higher oxygen atom transfer (OAT) catalytic activity was observed with [WO₂(PyS)₂] compared to the Mo species, independent of whether PMe₃ or PPh₃ was used as the oxygen acceptor. [W^VIO₂L₂] complexes undergo reduction with an excess of PMe₃, yielding the tungsten(IV) oxido species [WOL₂(PMe₃)₂], while with PPh₃, no reactions are observed. Although OAT reactions from DMSO to phosphines are known for tungsten complexes, [WOL₂(PMe₃)₂] are the first fully characterized phosphine-stabilized intermediates. By following the reaction of these reduced species with excess DMSO via UV-vis spectroscopy, we observed that tungsten compounds directly react to W^VIO₂ complexes while the Mo analogues first form μ-oxo Mo(V) dimers [Mo₂O₃L₄]. Density functional theory calculations confirm that the oxygen atom abstraction from W^VIO₂ is an endergonic process contrasting the respective reaction with molybdenum. Here, we suggest that depending on the sacrificial oxygen acceptor, the tungsten complex may participate in catalysis either via a redox reaction or as an electrophile.