Bader's Topological Bond Path Does Not Necessarily Indicate Stabilizing Interaction-Proof Studies Based on the Ng@[3n]cyclophane Endohedral Complexes

Behavior of Trapped Molecules in Lantern-Like Carcerand Superphanes

Superphanes are a group of organic molecules from the cyclophane family. They are characterized by the presence of two parallel benzene rings joined together by six bridges. If these bridges are sufficiently long, the superphane cavity can be large enough to trap small molecules or ions. Using ab initio (time scale of 80 ps) and classical (up to 200 ns) molecular dynamics (MD) methods, we study the behavior of five fundamental molecules (M = H2O, NH3, HF, HCN, MeOH) encapsulated inside the experimentally reported lantern-like superphane and its two derivatives featuring slightly modified side bridges. The main focus is studying the dynamics of hydrogen bonds between the trapped M molecule and the imino nitrogen atoms of the side chains of the host superphane. The length of the N···H hydrogen bond increases in the following order: HF < HCN < H2O < MeOH < NH3. The mobility of the trapped molecule and its preferred position inside the superphane cage depend not only on the type of this molecule but also largely on the in/out conformational arrangement of the imino nitrogens in the side chains of the superphane. Their inward-pointing positions allow the formation of strong N···H hydrogen bonds. For this reason, these nitrogens are the preferred sites of interaction. The mobility of the molecules and their residence times on each side of the superphane have been explained by referring to the symmetry and conformation of the given superphane cage. All force field MD simulations have shown that the encapsulated molecule remained inside the superphane cage for 200 ns without any escape event to the outside. Moreover, our simulations based on some endohedral complexes in the water box also showed no exchange event. Thus, the superphanes we study are true carcerand molecules. We attribute this property to the hydrophobic side chains and their pinwheel arrangement, which makes the side walls of the studied superphanes fairly impenetrable to small molecules.

Electron Density and Molecular Orbital Analyses of the Nature of Bonding in the η3-CCH Agostic Rhodium Complexes Preceding the C-C and C-H Bond Cleavages

In our recent work, we revisited C-H and C-C bond activation in rhodium (I) complexes of pincer ligands PCP, PCN, PCO, POCOP, and SCS. Our findings indicated that an η3-Csp2Csp3H agostic intermediate acts as a common precursor to both C-C and C-H bond activation in these systems. We explore the electronic structure and bonding nature of these precleavage complexes using electron density and molecular orbital analyses. Using NBO, IBO, and ESI-3D methods, the bonding in the η3-CCH agostic moiety is depicted by two three-center agostic bonds: Rh-Csp2-Csp3 and Rh-Csp3-H, with all three atoms datively bound to Rh(I). IBO analysis specifically highlights the involvement of three orbitals (CC→Rh and CH→Rh σ donation, plus Rh→CCH π backdonation) in both C-C and C-H bond cleavages. NCIPLOT and QTAIM analyses highlight anagostic (Rh-H) or β-agostic (Rh-Csp2-H) interactions and the absence of Rh-Csp3 interactions. QTAIM molecular graphs suggest bond path instability under dynamic conditions due to the nearness of line and ring critical points. Several low-frequency and low-force vibrational modes interconvert various bonding patterns, reinforcing the dynamic η3-CCH agostic nature. The kinetic preference for C-H bond breaking is attributed to the smaller reduced mass of C-H vibrations compared to C-C vibrations.

Characteristics of Intermolecular Interactions between Encapsulated Molecules and the Lantern-Like Carcerand Superphanes

The main topic of the article is to provide the characteristics of individual intermolecular interactions present between three lantern-like superphanes and the H2O, NH3, HF, HCN, and MeOH molecules trapped inside them. Despite the large cavity, the freedom of the trapped molecules is significantly limited by the presence of numerous interaction sites on the side chains of the superphane molecule. It is shown that the molecule trapped inside the superphane is stabilized mainly by only one or, less often, two strong hydrogen bonds involving the imino nitrogen atom, but QTAIM calculations also suggest the presence of many other intermolecular interactions, mainly hydrogen bonds involving imino or central hydrogen atoms from the side chains of the superphane molecule. Moreover, it is also shown that the structural simplification of the side chains does not significantly affect both the size of the superphane molecule and the obtained encapsulation energies, which is important in modeling this type of carceplexes. Noticeably, the parent superphane considered here was previously synthesized by the group of Qing He, so the results obtained will help in understanding this type and similar systems.