Unfolding of Lignin Structure Using Size-Exclusion Fractionation

On the fractionation of lignin oligomers by stepwise gradient reversed-phase liquid chromatography

With the increased interest in lignin valorization, the analytical challenge to separate a complex mixture of a vast number of phenolics has made chromatography an indispensable step in lignin analysis. High-resolution separations, such as gas chromatography, reversed-phase liquid chromatography and supercritical fluid chromatography have typically been targeting low-molecular-weight compounds, while larger lignin oligomers have received less attention. These compounds have proven to be difficult to separate due to the inherent complexity of the high-molecular-weight fraction of lignins, in fact, even high-resolving linear reversed-phase gradients elute them as one wide zone. To tackle this, in this study we show that a crude fractionation of lignin oligomers can be achieved by applying stepwise reversed-phase gradients. A commonly employed reversed-phase system with water:acetonitrile mobile phase is evaluated for this task. Special attention was devoted to uncovering the molecular level explanation of the retention phenomenon. Our results indicate that separation is mainly governed by reversed-phase retention phenomena without any major exclusion or viscosity-related effects, shown by great fits to linear retention models (R2avg = 0.9599 for five different oligomers) and apparent differences in retentivity between different stationary phases. The influence of the gradient shape was demonstrated by the comparison of stepwise gradients with different number and frequency of steps, leading to the conclusion that gradients with a low number of steps yield fewer, but better resolved fractions, while finer multi-step gradients can be used to distinguish more fractions.

A Complementary Multitechnique Approach to Assess the Bias in Molecular Weight Determination of Lignin by Derivatization-Free Gel Permeation Chromatography

The growing interest in lignin valorization in the past decades calls for analytical techniques for lignin characterization, ranging from wet chemistry techniques to highly sophisticated chromatographic and spectroscopic methods. One of the key parameters to consider is the molecular weight profile of lignin, which is routinely determined by size-exclusion chromatography; however, this is by no means straightforward and is prone to being hampered by considerable errors. Our study expands the fundamental understanding of the bias-inducing mechanisms in gel permeation chromatography (GPC), the magnitude of error originating from using polystyrene standards for mass calibration, and an evaluation of the effects of the solvent and type of lignin on the observed bias. The developed partial least-squares (PLS) regression model for lignin-related monomers revealed that lignin is prone to association mainly via hydrogen bonding. This hypothesis was supported by functional group-based analysis of the bias as well as pulse field gradient (pfg) diffusion NMR spectroscopy of model compounds in THF-d8. Furthermore, although the lack of standards hindered drawing conclusions based on functionalities, direct infusion electrospray ionization mass spectrometry indicated that the relative bias decreases considerably for higher molecular weight species. The results from pfg-diffusion NMR spectroscopy on whole lignin samples were comparable when the same solvents were used in both experiments; in addition, the comparison between results obtained by pfg-diffusion NMR in different solvents gives some additional insights into the aggregation.

Advancing Molecular Weight Determination of Lignin by Multi-Angle Light Scattering

Due to the complexity and recalcitrance of lignin, its chemical characterization is a key factor preventing the valorization of this abundant material. Multi-angle light scattering (MALS) is becoming a sought-after technique for absolute molecular weight (MW) determination of polymers and proteins. Lignin is a suitable candidate for MW determination via MALS, yet further investigation is required to confirm its absolute MW values and molecular size. Studies aiming to break down lignin into a variety of renewable products will benefit greatly from a simple and reliable determination method like MALS. Recent pioneering studies, discussed in this review, addressed several key challenges in lignin's MW characterization. Nevertheless, some lignin-specific issues still need to be considered for in-depth characterization. This study explores how MALS instrumentation manages the complexities of determining lignin's MW, e.g., with simultaneous fractionation and fluorescence interference mitigation. Additionally, we rationalize the importance of a more detailed light scattering analysis for lignin characterization, including aspects like the second virial coefficient and radius of gyration.