Aluminium-Assisted Alloying of Carbon Steel in Submerged Arc Welding: Application of Al-Cr-Ti-Cu Unconstrained Metal Powders

Gas Formation of Cobalt and Copper in the Application of Unconstrained Co-Cr-Al-Cu Metal Powders in Submerged Arc Welding: Gas Phase Thermodynamics and 3D Slag SEM Evidence

Aluminium metal is not typically added to the submerged arc welding (SAW) process because it is easily oxidised to form unwanted slag in the weld pool. The successful application of aluminium as a de-oxidiser is illustrated in this study by preventing oxidation of Cr and Co to their oxides, thereby preventing element loss to the slag. Unconstrained pure metals of Al, Cr, Co and Cu were applied to investigate the gas formation behaviour of these elements in the SAW arc cavity. Of interest is the effect of copper in the arc cavity in terms of its possible substitution for aluminium. The results confirmed that the Al-Cr-Co-Cu alloyed weld metal total oxygen content was lowered to 176 ppm O, in comparison to 499 ppm O in the weld metal formed from welding with the original flux, which excluded metal powder additions. This lower ppm O value of 176 ppm O confirms that the added aluminium powder effectively lowered the original flux-induced partial oxygen pressure in the arc cavity, and at the molten flux–weld pool interface. Carbon steel was alloyed to 5.3% Co, 5.5% Cr, 5.3% Cu and 4.5% Al at 78% Co yield, 82% Cr yield, 78% Cu yield and 66% Al yield. Thermochemical equilibrium calculations confirm the partial oxygen pressure-lowering effect of aluminium when considering the gas–slag–alloy equilibrium. BSE (backscattered electron) images of the three-dimensional (3D) post-weld slag sample show dome structures which contain features of vapour formation and re-condensation. SEM-EDX (scanning electron microscope-energy dispersive X-ray) maps show that the dome surface matrix phase consists of Al-Mg-Ca-Si-Na-K-Ti-Fe-Mn oxy-fluoride. The spherical 3D structures of 10–40 µm in diameter consist of Fe-Mn-Si fluorides with some Cr, Cu and Co contained in some of the spheres. Cr and Co were observed in distinctive porous structures of approximately 10 µm in size, consisting partly of Cr oxy-fluoride and partly of Co oxy-fluoride. Nano-sized oxy-fluoride strands and spheres in the dome structures confirm vaporisation and re-condensation of oxy-fluorides. Cu and Na formed a distinct condensation pattern on the surface of the Si-Cu-Na-Mn-Fe-Co oxy-fluoride sphere. The results confirm the importance of including gas phase reactions in the interpretation of SAW process metallurgy.

A Review of the Thermochemical Behaviour of Fluxes in Submerged Arc Welding: Modelling of Gas Phase Reactions

This review is focused on the thermochemical behaviour of fluxes in submerged arc welding (SAW). The English-language literature from the 1970s onwards is reviewed. It was recognised early on that the thermochemical behaviour of fluxes sets the weld metal total ppm O and the element transfer extent from the molten flux (slag) to the weld pool. Despite the establishment of this link between the flux-induced oxygen potential and element transfer, it is also well accepted that the slag–metal equilibrium does not control SAW process metallurgy. Instead, the gas phase must be taken into account to better describe SAW process metallurgy equilibrium calculations. This is illustrated in the gas–slag–metal equilibrium simulation model developed by Coetsee. This model provides improved accuracy in predicting the weld metal total ppm O values as compared to the empirical trend of Tuliani et al. Recent works on the application of Al metal powder with alloying metal powders provide new insights into the likely gas phase reactions in the SAW process and the modification of the flux oxygen behaviour via Al additions. Aluminium may lower the partial oxygen pressure in the arc cavity, and aluminium also lowers the partial oxygen pressure at the weld pool–slag interface. The weld metal total ppm O is lowered with the addition of aluminium in SAW, but not to the same extent as would be expected from steelmaking ladle metallurgy de-oxidation practice when using Al as de-oxidiser. This difference indicates that slag–metal equilibrium is not maintained in the SAW process.

A Review on Parallel Development of Flux Design and Thermodynamics Subject to Submerged Arc Welding

Submerged arc welding is a complex metallurgical process with a temperature of nearly 2000 ∘C (a temperature much higher than that in traditional steelmaking) and different phases, including flux (slag), metal, and plasma. Flux serves vital functions in order to produce the weld metal with desired qualities. It is well known that understandings of the thermodynamic properties regarding flux and slag are essential to aid in flux design and optimization. Actually, the developments of flux design and thermodynamics have been promoting each other. Within this review, the flux design stages have been documented and reviewed in detail from the perspective of thermodynamics. The thermodynamic design principles for fluxes have been evaluated systematically, the limitations of each flux have been elucidated, and the thermodynamic significance of the designed fluxes upon the development of welding thermodynamics has been analyzed. Based on the hypothesis that thermodynamic equilibrium is attained locally considering that the high temperatures and surface-to-volume ratio counteract the short time available for chemical reactions to be completed, both slag–metal and gas–slag–metal equilibrium models have been evaluated, which may provide technical assistance for flux design and matching. Then, recent applications of Calphad (Computer Coupling of Phase Diagrams and Thermochemistry) technology in the fields of flux design and matching have been introduced. The incumbent review demonstrates that thermodynamic consideration is essential to develop new fluxes or upgrade existing ones to meet the growing demands concerning submerged arc welding quality. Furthermore, it is revealed that the thermodynamic approach is capable of facilitating the flux design process geared toward submerged arc welding. Finally, further investigation into welding thermodynamics is proposed to better aid in flux design and matching.

Probing Element Transfer Behavior during the Submerged Arc Welding Process for CaF2-SiO2-Na2O-Cr2O3 Agglomerated Fluxes: A Thermodynamic Approach

Submerged arc welding joins metal by the heating of the electrode, base metal, and flux in the arc plasma, while the weld pool is protected under the granular flux and molten slag. Due to complex chemical reactions occurring between the arc plasma, weld pool, and molten slag (flux), flux essentially affects the weld metal composition, which, in turn, dictates the mechanical properties of the weldment. Therefore, fine-tuning the weld metal composition is essential to ensure a sound weld, and efforts worldwide have been focused on the control mechanism of flux on the weld metal composition. Recently, agglomerated fluxes have been widely applied due to low energy consumption during manufacture. The Cr2O3-bearing agglomerated flux is one of the most commonly used flux types in fields of heavy industrial applications. However, few works concern the element transfer behavior when Cr2O3-bearing agglomerated fluxes are used. Within this framework, typical agglomerated CaF2-SiO2-Na2O-Cr2O3 fluxes with varying Cr2O3 content from 10 to 50 wt.% are designed and applied to Q345A steel. The influence of Cr2O3 content upon the transfer behaviors of essential elements, including O, Cr, and Mn, is quantified and interpreted from the point of thermodynamics. By incorporating a gas-slag-metal equilibrium consideration, the assumptions made in previous studies are justified. Additionally, evidence regarding the loss of Cr and Mn to the arc plasma is provided, and a possible thermodynamic approach to predict element transfer levels is proposed. It is revealed that the gas-slag-metal equilibrium consideration is able to qualitatively analyze the transfer behaviors involved in the submerged arc welding system, even under high temperatures. Based on the quantitative data, the practical implications as well as limitations of the gas-slag-metal equilibrium model are proposed.

Aluminium Assisted Nickel Alloying in Submerged Arc Welding of Carbon Steel: Application of Unconstrained Metal Powders

Nickel alloying of carbon steel is used to enhance steel strength and toughness. Nickel alloying of the weld metal via solid weld wire presents several difficulties as highlighted previously, such as work hardening of the solid weld wire in manufacturing and feeding through the SAW wire feeding mechanism, and expensive and time consuming manufacturing of multiple weld wire formulations. The application of nickel and aluminium powders in unconstrained format, meaning not as fluxed cored wire or as metal cored wire, is used to simplify weld metal alloying. Al powder is used to control the oxygen potential at the weld pool-molten flux interface. The results presented here show that the addition of Al powder to the weld metal enhances Ni yield to the weld metal, at 85%, compared to pre-alloyed powder Ni yields of 57–78% as applied in previous work. Carbon steel was alloyed to 6.9% Ni and 3.7% Al. Thermodynamic analysis is applied to elucidate the chemical interaction between Ni and Al, and its effects on Ni yield in the weld pool. Overall process productivity gains stem from weld metal alloying from unconstrained metal powders because the expensive and time consuming step of manufacturing alloyed wire and alloyed powder is eliminated.