Exploring TanDEM-X Interferometric Products for Crop-Type Mapping

Multi-Annual Evaluation of Time Series of Sentinel-1 Interferometric Coherence as a Tool for Crop Monitoring

Interferometric coherence from SAR data is a tool used in a variety of Earth observation applications. In the context of crop monitoring, vegetation indices are commonly used to describe crop dynamics. The most frequently used vegetation indices based on radar data are constructed using the backscattered intensity at different polarimetric channels. As coherence is sensitive to the changes in the scene caused by vegetation and its evolution, it may potentially be used as an alternative tool in this context. The objective of this work is to evaluate the potential of using Sentinel-1 interferometric coherence for this purpose. The study area is an agricultural region in Sevilla, Spain, mainly covered by 18 different crops. Time series of different backscatter-based radar vegetation indices and the coherence amplitude for both VV and VH channels from Sentinel-1 were compared to the NDVI derived from Sentinel-2 imagery for a 5-year period, from 2017 to 2021. The correlations between the series were studied both during and outside the growing season of the crops. Additionally, the use of the ratio of the two coherences measured at both polarimetric channels was explored. The results show that the coherence is generally well correlated with the NDVI across all seasons. The ratio between coherences at each channel is a potential alternative to the separate channels when the analysis is not restricted to the growing season of the crop, as its year-long temporal evolution more closely resembles that of the NDVI. Coherence and backscatter can be used as complementary sources of information, as backscatter-based indices describe the evolution of certain crops better than coherence.

The Evaluation of Spectral Vegetation Indexes and Redundancy Reduction on the Accuracy of Crop Type Detection

Knowledge about crop type distribution is valuable information for effective management of agricultural productivity, food security estimation, and natural resources protection. Algorithms for automatic crop type detection have great potential to positively influence these aspects as well as speed up the process of crop type mapping in larger areas. In the presented study, we used 14 Sentinel-2 images to calculate 12 widely used spectral vegetation indices. Further, to evaluate the effect of reduced dimensionality on the accuracy of crop type mapping, we utilized principal component analysis (PCA). For this purpose, random forest (RF)-supervised classifications were tested for each index separately, as well as for the combinations of various indices and the four initial PCA components. Additionally, for each RF classification feature importance was assessed, which enabled identification of the most relevant period of the year for the differentiation of crop types. We used 34.6% of the ground truth field data to train the classifier and calculate various accuracy measures such as the overall accuracy (OA) or Kappa index. The study showed a high effectiveness of the Modified Chlorophyll Absorption in Reflectance Index (MCARI) (OA = 86%, Kappa = 0.81), Normalized Difference Index 45 (NDI45) (OA = 85%, Kappa = 0.81), and Weighted Difference Vegetation Index (WDVI) (OA = 85%, Kappa = 0.80) in crop type mapping. However, utilization of all of them together did not increase the classification accuracy (OA = 78%, Kappa = 0.72). Additionally, the application of the initial three components of PCA allowed us to achieve an OA of 78% and Kappa of 0.72, which was unfortunately lower than the single-index classification (e.g., based on only NDVI45). This shows that dimensionality reductions did not increase the classification accuracy. Moreover, feature importance from RF indicated that images captured from June and July are the most relevant for differentiating crop types. This shows that this period of the year is crucial to effectively differentiate crop types and should be undeniably used in crop type mapping.

A Random Forest Algorithm for Retrieving Canopy Chlorophyll Content of Wheat and Soybean Trained with PROSAIL Simulations Using Adjusted Average Leaf Angle

Canopy chlorophyll content (CCC) is an important indicator for crop-growth monitoring and crop productivity estimation. The hybrid method, involving the PROSAIL radiative transfer model and machine learning algorithms, has been widely applied for crop CCC retrieval. However, PROSAIL’s homogeneous canopy hypothesis limits the ability to use the PROSAIL-based CCC estimation across different crops with a row structure. In addition to leaf area index (LAI), average leaf angle (ALA) is the most important canopy structure factor in the PROSAIL model. Under the same LAI, adjustment of the ALA can make a PROSAIL simulation obtain the same canopy gap as the heterogeneous canopy at a specific observation angle. Therefore, parameterization of an adjusted ALA (ALAadj) is an optimal choice to make the PROSAIL model suitable for specific row-planted crops. This paper attempted to improve PROSAIL-based CCC retrieval for different crops, using a random forest algorithm, by introducing the prior knowledge of crop-specific ALAadj. Based on the field reflectance spectrum at nadir, leaf area index, and leaf chlorophyll content, parameterization of the ALAadj in the PROSAIL model for wheat and soybean was carried out. An algorithm integrating the random forest and PROSAIL simulations with prior ALAadj information was developed for wheat and soybean CCC retrieval. Ground-measured CCC measurements were used to validate the CCC retrieved from canopy spectra. The results showed that the ALAadj values (62 degrees for wheat; 45 degrees for soybean) that were parameterized for the PROSAIL model demonstrated good discrimination between the two crops. The proposed algorithm improved the CCC retrieval accuracy for wheat and soybean, regardless of whether continuous visible to near-infrared spectra with 50 bands (RMSE from 39.9 to 32.9 μg cm−2; R2 from 0.67 to 0.76) or discrete spectra with 13 bands (RMSE from 43.9 to 33.7 μg cm−2; R2 from 0.63 to 0.74) and nine bands (RMSE from 45.1 to 37.0 μg cm−2; R2 from 0.61 to 0.71) were used. The proposed hybrid algorithm, based on PROSAIL simulations with ALAadj, has the potential for satellite-based CCC estimation across different crop types, and it also has a good reference value for the retrieval of other crop parameters.

On the Value of Sentinel-1 InSAR Coherence Time-Series for Vegetation Classification

Synthetic aperture radar (SAR) acquisitions are mainly deemed suitable for mapping dynamic land-cover and land-use scenarios due to their timeliness and reliability. This particularly applies to Sentinel-1 imagery. Nevertheless, the accurate mapping of regions characterized by a mixture of crops and grasses can still represent a challenge. Radar time-series have to date mainly been exploited through backscatter intensities, whereas only fewer contributions have focused on analyzing the potential of interferometric information, intuitively enhanced by the short revisit. In this paper, we evaluate, as primary objective, the added value of short-temporal baseline coherences over a complex agricultural area in the São Paulo state, cultivated with heterogeneously (asynchronously) managed annual crops, grasses for pasture and sugarcane plantations. We also investigated the sensitivity of the radar information to the classification methods as well as to the data preparation and sampling practices. Two supervised machine learning methods—namely support vector machine (SVM) and random forest (RF)—were applied to the Sentinel-1 time-series at the pixel and field levels. The results highlight that an improvement of 10 percentage points (p.p.) in the classification accuracy can be achieved by using the coherence in addition to the backscatter intensity and by combining co-polarized (VV) and cross-polarized (VH) information. It is shown that the largest contribution in class discrimination is brought during winter, when dry vegetation and bare soils can be expected. One of the added values of coherence was indeed identified in the enhanced sensitivity to harvest events in a small but significant number of cases.

Crop Monitoring and Classification Using Polarimetric RADARSAT-2 Time-Series Data Across Growing Season: A Case Study in Southwestern Ontario, Canada

Multitemporal polarimetric synthetic aperture radar (PolSAR) has proven as a very effective technique in agricultural monitoring and crop classification. This study presents a comprehensive evaluation of crop monitoring and classification over an agricultural area in southwestern Ontario, Canada. The time-series RADARSAT-2 C-Band PolSAR images throughout the entire growing season were exploited. A set of 27 representative polarimetric observables categorized into ten groups was selected and analyzed in this research. First, responses and temporal evolutions of each of the polarimetric observables over different crop types were quantitatively analyzed. The results reveal that the backscattering coefficients in cross-pol and Pauli second channel, the backscattering ratio between HV and VV channels (HV/VV), the polarimetric decomposition outputs, the correlation coefficient between HH and VV channelρ ρHHVV, and the radar vegetation index (RVI) show the highest sensitivity to crop growth. Then, the capability of PolSAR time-series data of the same beam mode was also explored for crop classification using the Random Forest (RF) algorithm. The results using single groups of polarimetric observables show that polarimetric decompositions, backscattering coefficients in Pauli and linear polarimetric channels, and correlation coefficients produced the best classification accuracies, with overall accuracies (OAs) higher than 87%. A forward selection procedure to pursue optimal classification accuracy was expanded to different perspectives, enabling an optimal combination of polarimetric observables and/or multitemporal SAR images. The results of optimal classifications show that a few polarimetric observables or a few images on certain critical dates may produce better accuracies than the whole dataset. The best result was achieved using an optimal combination of eight groups of polarimetric observables and six SAR images, with an OA of 94.04%. This suggests that an optimal combination considering both perspectives may be valuable for crop classification, which could serve as a guideline and is transferable for future research.