Dose Reduction and Diagnostic Performance of Tin Filter-Based Spectral Shaping CT in Patients with Colorectal Cancer

Implementing tin-prefiltration in routine clinical CT scans of the lower extremity: impact on radiation dose

OBJECTIVES

Several studies have demonstrated the potential of tin-prefiltration to reduce radiation dose while maintaining diagnostic image quality for musculoskeletal imaging. Still, no study has reported data on the impact of tin-prefiltration on radiation dose reduction for clinical routine scanning.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Retrospective inclusion of 300 clinically indicated CT scans of the pelvis, knee, and ankle before January 2020 (without tin filter) and after December 2020 (with tin filter). For each joint, 50 examinations with tin-prefiltration and 50 examinations without tin-prefiltration were selected. Dose parameters were extracted, calculated, and compared. Subjective and quantitative parameters for image quality were assessed.

RESULTS

The CTDIvol, DLP, and effective dose were reduced significantly in all tin-prefiltered examinations compared to the non-tin-prefiltered examinations (p < 0.001): CTDIvol was 65% lower in the pelvis, 73% lower in the knee, and 54% lower in the ankle. This reduced the effective dose of 61%, 71%, and 60%, respectively. In absolute numbers, the reduction of the median effective dose delivered in a single CT scan of the pelvis was - 2.29 mSv, - 0.15 mSv for the knee, and - 0.03 mSv for the ankle. No difference in diagnostic image quality, depiction of bone anatomy and soft tissues, and image artifacts was observed (p > 0.05). Subjective and objective image noise was higher in tin-prefiltered pelvis CT (p < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

The implementation of tin-prefiltration in clinical routine scan protocols significantly reduced the effective radiation dose for unenhanced CT scans of the lower extremities between 60 and 70%.

Spectral Shaping Computed Tomography Applications

Spectral shaping (also known as spectral filtration) has been utilized in some of the latest computed tomography (CT) systems. This technique involves using tin (Sn) or silver (Ag) filters, which selectively absorb low-energy photons. This review aims to demonstrate the utility of spectral shaping across a wide range of protocols and clinical situations. Spectral-shaped CT protocols using tin filters allow for the acquisition of diagnostic images and greatly reduce the radiation dose, metal artifacts, and photon starvation. These features make spectral shaping suitable for various clinical situations in diagnostic and interventional CT imaging.

Influence of spectral shaping and tube voltage modulation in ultralow-dose computed tomography of the abdomen

PURPOSE

Unenhanced abdominal CT constitutes the diagnostic standard of care in suspected urolithiasis. Aiming to identify potential for radiation dose reduction in this frequent imaging task, this experimental study compares the effect of spectral shaping and tube voltage modulation on image quality.

METHODS

Using a third-generation dual-source CT, eight cadaveric specimens were scanned with varying tube voltage settings with and without tin filter application (Sn 150, Sn 100, 120, 100, and 80 kVp) at three dose levels (3 mGy: standard; 1 mGy: low; 0.5 mGy: ultralow). Image quality was assessed quantitatively by calculation of signal-to-noise ratios (SNR) for various tissues (spleen, kidney, trabecular bone, fat) and subjectively by three independent radiologists based on a seven-point rating scale (7 = excellent; 1 = very poor).

RESULTS

Irrespective of dose level, Sn 100 kVp resulted in the highest SNR of all tube voltage settings. In direct comparison to Sn 150 kVp, superior SNR was ascertained for spleen (p ≤ 0.004) and kidney tissue (p ≤ 0.009). In ultralow-dose scans, subjective image quality of Sn 100 kVp (median score 3; interquartile range 3-3) was higher compared with conventional imaging at 120 kVp (2; 2-2), 100 kVp (1; 1-2), and 80 kVp (1; 1-1) (all p < 0.001). Indicated by an intraclass correlation coefficient of 0.945 (95% confidence interval: 0.927-0.960), interrater reliability was excellent.

CONCLUSIONS

In abdominal CT with maximised dose reduction, tin prefiltration at 100 kVp allows for superior image quality over Sn 150 kVp and conventional imaging without spectral shaping.

Evaluating Image Quality and Radiation Dose in Low-Dose Thoraco-Abdominal CT Angiography with a Tin Filter for Patients with Aortic Disease

Background: We aimed to compared radiation exposure and image quality between tin-filter-based and standard dose thoraco-abdominal computed tomography angiography (TACTA) protocols, aiming to address a gap in the existing literature. Methods: In this retrospective study, ninety consecutive patients undergoing TACTA were included. Of these, 45 followed a routine standard-dose protocol (ST100kV), and 45 underwent a low-dose protocol with a tin filter (TF100kV). Radiation metrics were compared. The signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR), and figure of merit (FOM) were calculated for the thoracic and abdominal aorta and right common iliac artery. Two independent readers assessed the image noise, image contrast, sharpness, and subjective image quality. Results: The mean dose for the TF100kV group was significantly lower (DLP 128.25 ± 18.18 mGy*cm vs. 662.75 ± 181.29, p < 0.001; CTDIvol 1.83 ± 0.25 mGy vs. 9.28 ± 2.17, p = 0.001), with an effective dose close to 2.3 mSv (2.31 ± 0.33 mSv; p < 0.001). The TF100kV group demonstrated greater dose efficiency (FOM, thoracic aorta: 36.70 ± 22.77 vs. 13.96 ± 13.18 mSv-1, p < 0.001) compared to the ST100kV group. Conclusions: Dedicated low-dose TACTA using a tin filter can significantly reduce the radiation dose while maintaining sufficient diagnostic image quality.

Establishment of local diagnostic reference levels for CT colonography at a tertiary hospital

Background

Diagnostic reference levels (DRLs) are an important metric in identifying abnormally high radiation doses in diagnostic examinations. National DRLs for CT colonography do not currently exist in South Africa, but there are efforts to collect data for a national DRL project.

Objectives

This study investigated radiation doses for CT colonography in adult patients at a large tertiary hospital in South Africa with the aim of setting local DRLs.

Method

Patient data from two CT scanners (Philips Ingenuity and Siemens Somatom go.Top) in the period March 2020 - March 2023 were obtained from the hospital's picture archiving and communication system (PACS) (n = 115). Analysis involved determining the median computed tomography dose index-volume (CTDIvol) and dose-length product (DLP) values. The findings were compared with DRLs established internationally.

Results

Ingenuity median CTDIvol was 20 mGy and DLP was 2169 mGy*cm; Somatom median CTDIvol was 6 mGy and DLP was 557 mGy*cm. Ingenuity exceeded the United Kingdom's (UK) recommended DRLs by 82% and 214%, respectively. Somatom median CTDIvol and DLP were 45% and 19% lower than UK NDRLs.

Conclusion

Somatom's tin filter and other dose reduction features provided significant dose reduction. These data were used to set DRLs for CT colonography at the hospital; CTDIvol: 6 mGy and DLP: 557 mGy*cm.

Contribution

In addition to informing radiation protection practices at the level of the institution, the established local DRLs contribute towards implementing regional and national DRLs.

Ultra-low dose CT scanning for PET/CT

BACKGROUND

The use of computed tomography (CT) for attenuation correction (AC) in whole-body PET/CT can result in a significant contribution to radiation exposure. This can become a limiting factor for reducing considerably the overall radiation exposure of the patient when using the new long axial field of view (LAFOV) PET scanners. However, recent CT technology have introduced features such as the tin (Sn) filter, which can substantially reduce the CT radiation dose.

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to investigate the ultra-low dose CT for attenuation correction using the Sn filter together with other dose reduction options such as tube current (mAs) reduction. We explore the impact of dose reduction in the context of AC-CT and how it affects PET image quality.

METHODS

The study evaluated a range of ultra-low dose CT protocols using five physical phantoms that represented a broad collection of tissue electron densities. A long axial field of view (LAFOV) PET/CT scanner was used to scan all phantoms, applying various CT dose reduction parameters such as reducing tube current (mAs), increasing the pitch value, and applying the Sn filter. The effective dose resulting from the CT scans was determined using the CTDIVol reported by the scanner. Several voxel-based and volumes of interest (VOI)-based comparisons were performed to compare the ultra-low dose CT images, the generated attenuation maps, and corresponding PET images against those images acquired with the standard low dose CT protocol. Finally, two patient datasets were acquired using one of the suggested ultra-low dose CT settings.

RESULTS

By incorporating the Sn filter and adjusting mAs to the lowest available value, the radiation dose in CT images of PBU-60 phantom was significantly reduced; resulting in an effective dose of nearly 2% compared to the routine low dose CT protocols currently in clinical use. The assessment of PET images using VOI and voxel-based comparisons indicated relative differences (RD%) of under 6% for mean activity concentration (AC) in the torso phantom and patient dataset and under 8% for a source point in the CIRS phantom. The maximum RD% value of AC was 14% for the point source in the CIRS phantom. Increasing the tube current from 6 mAs to 30 mAs in patients with high BMI, or with arms down, can suppress the photon starvation artifact, whilst still preserving a dose reduction of 90%.

CONCLUSIONS

Introducing a Sn filter in CT imaging lowers radiation dose by more than 90%. This reduction has minimal effect on PET image quantification at least for patients without Body Mass Index (BMI) higher than 30. Notably, this study results need validation using a larger clinical PET/CT dataset in the future, including patients with higher BMI.

Comparison of selected photon shield and organ-based tube current modulation for radiation dose reduction in head computed tomography: A phantom study

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study is to investigate the radiation dose and image quality of head CT using SPS and OBTCM techniques.

METHODS

Three anthropomorphic head phantoms (1-yr-old, 5-yr-old, and adult) were used. Images were acquired using four modes (Default protocol, OBTCM, SPS, and SPS+OBTCM). Absorbed dose to the lens, anterior brain (brain_A), and posterior brain (brain_P) was measured and compared. Image noise and CNR were assessed in the selected regions of interest (ROIs).

RESULTS

Compared with that in the Default protocol, the absorbed dose to the lens reduced by up to 28.33%,71.38%, and 71.12% in OBTCM, SPS, and SPS+OBTCM, respectively. The noise level in OBTCM slightly (≤1.45HU) increased than that in Default protocol, and the SPS or SPS+OBTCM mode resulted in a quantitatively small increase (≤2.58HU) in three phantoms. There was no significant difference in CNR of different phantoms under varies scanning modes (p >  0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

During head CT examinations, the SPS mode can reduce the radiation dose while maintaining image quality. SPS+OBTCM couldn't further effectively reduce the absorbed dose to the lens for 1-yr and 5-yr-old phantoms. Thus, SPS mode in pediatric and SPS+OBTCM mode in adult are better than other modes, and should be used in clinical practice.