Host Resistance, Genomics and Population Dynamics in a Salmonella Enteritidis and Phage System

Increased mutations in lipopolysaccharide biosynthetic genes cause time-dependent development of phage resistance in Salmonella

Understanding how bacteria evolve resistance to phages has implications for phage-based therapies and microbial evolution. In this study, the susceptibility of 335 Salmonella isolates to the wide host range Salmonella phage BPSELC-1 was tested. Potentially significant gene sets that could confer resistance were identified using bioinformatics approaches based on phage susceptibility phenotypes; more than 90 potential antiphage defense gene sets, including those involved in lipopolysaccharide (LPS) biosynthesis, DNA replication, secretion systems, and respiratory chain, were found. The evolutionary dynamics of Salmonella resistance to phage were assessed through laboratory evolution experiments, which showed that phage-resistant mutants rapidly developed and exhibited genetic heterogeneity. Most representative Salmonella hosts (58.1% of 62) rapidly developed phage resistance within 24 h. All phage-resistant mutant clones exhibited genetic heterogeneity and observed mutations in LPS-related genes (rfaJ and rfaK) as well as other genes such as cellular respiration, transport, and cell replication-related genes. The study also identified potential trade-offs, indicating that bacteria tend to escape fitness trade-offs through multi-site mutations, all tested mutants increased sensitivity to polymyxin B, but this does not always affect their relative fitness or biofilm-forming capacity. Furthermore, complementing the rfaJ mutant gene could partially restore the phage sensitivity of phage-resistant mutants. These results provide insight into the phage resistance mechanisms of Salmonella and the complexity of bacterial evolution resulting from phage predation, which can inform future strategies for phage-based therapies and microbial evolution.

Phage-driven coevolution reveals trade-off between antibiotic and phage resistance in Salmonella anatum

Phage therapy faces challenges against multidrug-resistant (MDR) Salmonella due to rapid phage-resistant mutant emergence. Understanding the intricate interplay between antibiotics and phages is essential for shaping Salmonella evolution and advancing phage therapy. In this study, MDR Salmonella anatum (S. anatum) 2089b coevolved with phage JNwz02 for 30 passages (60 days), then the effect of coevolution on the trade-off between phage and antibiotic resistance in bacteria was investigated. Our results demonstrated antagonistic coevolution between bacteria and phages, transitioning from arms race dynamics (ARD) to fluctuating selection dynamics (FSD). The fitness cost of phage resistance, manifested as reduced competitiveness, was observed. Bacteria evolved phage resistance while simultaneously regaining sensitivity to amoxicillin, ampicillin, and gentamicin, influenced by phage selection pressure and bacterial competitiveness. Moreover, the impact of phage selection pressure on the trade-off between antibiotic and phage resistance was more pronounced in the ARD stage than in the FSD stage. Whole genome analysis revealed mutations in the btuB gene in evolved S. anatum strains, with a notably higher mutation frequency in the ARD stage compared to the FSD stage. Subsequent knockout experiments confirmed BtuB as a receptor for phage JNwz02, and the deletion of btuB resulted in reduced bacterial competitiveness. Additionally, the mutations identified in the phage-resistant strains were linked to multiple single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) associated with membrane components. This correlation implies a potential role of these SNPs in reinstating antibiotic susceptibility. These findings significantly advance our understanding of phage-host interactions and the impact of bacterial adaptations on antibiotic resistance.

Anaerobiosis, a neglected factor in phage-bacteria interactions

IMPORTANCE

Many parameters affect phage-bacteria interaction. Some of these parameters depend on the environment in which the bacteria are present. Anaerobiosis effect on phage infection in facultative anaerobic bacteria has not yet been studied. The absence of oxygen triggers metabolic changes in facultative bacteria and this affects phage infection and viral life cycle. Understanding how an anaerobic environment can alter the behavior of phages during infection is relevant for the phage therapy success.

Biological and genomic characterization of a polyvalent bacteriophage (S19cd) strongly inhibiting Salmonella enterica serovar Choleraesuis

Bacteriophages are a promising alternative for the control of pathogenic bacteria. In this study, we isolated a virulent bacteriophage, S19cd, from pig gut that could infect both a non-pathogenic bacteria Escherichia coli 44 (EC44) and two pathogenic bacterial strains (ATCC 13312 (SC13312) and CICC 21493 (SC21493)) of Salmonella enterica serovar Choleraesuis (SC). S19cd exhibited strong lytic ability in both SC13312 and SC21493 with an optimal multiplicity of infection (MOI) of 10-6 and 10-5, respectively, and inhibited their growth at an MOI of 10-7 within 24 h. Mice pre-treated with S19cd exhibited protection against the SC13312 challenge. Moreover, S19cd has good heat resistance (80 ℃) and pH tolerance (pH 3-12). Genome analysis revealed that S19cd belongs to the Felixounavirus genus and does not contain any virulence or drug-resistance-related genes. Additionally, S19cd encodes an adenine-specific methyltransferase that has no similarity to methyltransferases from other Felixounavirus phages and shares limited similarity with other methyltransferases in the NCBI protein database. Metagenomic analysis of S19cd genomes from 500 pigs revealed that S19cd-like phages may be widespread in Chinese pig gut. In conclusion, S19cd can be a potential phage therapy targeting SC infections.

Phage-bacterial evolutionary interactions: experimental models and complications

Phage treatment of bacterial infections has offered some hope even as the crisis of antimicrobial resistance continues to be on the rise. However, bacterial resistance to phage is another looming challenge capable of undermining the effectiveness of phage therapy. Moreover, the consideration of including phage therapy in modern medicine calls for more careful research around every aspect of phage study. In an attempt to adequately prepare for the events of phage resistance, many studies have attempted to experimentally evolve phage resistance in different bacterial strains, as well as train phages to evolve counter-infectivity of resistant bacterial mutants, in view of answering such questions as coevolutionary dynamics between phage and bacteria, mechanisms of phage resistance, fitness costs of phage resistance on bacteria, etc. In this review, we summarised many such studies and by careful examination, highlighted critical issues to the outcome of phage therapy. We also discuss the insufficiency of many of these in vitro studies to represent actual disease conditions during phage application, alongside other complications that exist in phage-bacterial evolutionary interactions. Conclusively, we present the exploitation of phage-bacterial interactions for successful infection managements, as well as some future perspectives to direct phage research.

Multistep diversification in spatiotemporal bacterial-phage coevolution

The evolutionary arms race between phages and bacteria, where bacteria evolve resistance to phages and phages retaliate with resistance-countering mutations, is a major driving force of molecular innovation and genetic diversification. Yet attempting to reproduce such ongoing retaliation dynamics in the lab has been challenging; laboratory coevolution experiments of phage and bacteria are typically performed in well-mixed environments and often lead to rapid stagnation with little genetic variability. Here, co-culturing motile E. coli with the lytic bacteriophage T7 on swimming plates, we observe complex spatiotemporal dynamics with multiple genetically diversifying adaptive cycles. Systematically quantifying over 10,000 resistance-infectivity phenotypes between evolved bacteria and phage isolates, we observe diversification into multiple coexisting ecotypes showing a complex interaction network with both host-range expansion and host-switch tradeoffs. Whole-genome sequencing of these evolved phage and bacterial isolates revealed a rich set of adaptive mutations in multiple genetic pathways including in genes not previously linked with phage-bacteria interactions. Synthetically reconstructing these new mutations, we discover phage-general and phage-specific resistance phenotypes as well as a strong synergy with the more classically known phage-resistance mutations. These results highlight the importance of spatial structure and migration for driving phage-bacteria coevolution, providing a concrete system for revealing new molecular mechanisms across diverse phage-bacterial systems.

Long-Term Interactions of Salmonella Enteritidis With a Lytic Phage for 21 Days in High Nutrients Media

Salmonella spp. is a relevant foodborne pathogen with worldwide distribution. To mitigate Salmonella infections, bacteriophages represent an alternative to antimicrobials and chemicals in food animals and food in general. Bacteriophages (phages) are viruses that infect bacteria, which interact constantly with their host. Importantly, the study of these interactions is crucial for the use of phages as a mitigation strategy. In this study, experimental coevolution of Salmonella Enteritidis (S. Enteritidis) and a lytic phage was conducted in tryptic soy broth for 21 days. Transfer to fresh media was conducted daily and every 24 hours, 2 mL of the sample was collected to quantify Salmonella OD₆₀₀ and phage titter. Additionally, time-shift experiments were conducted on 20 colonies selected on days 1, 12, and 21 to evaluate the evolution of resistance to past (day 1), present (day 12), and future (day 21) phage populations. The behavior of the dynamics was modeled and simulated with mathematical mass-action models. Bacteria and phage from days 1 and 21 were sequenced to determine the emergence of mutations. We found that S. Enteritidis grew for 21 days in the presence and absence of the phage and developed resistance to the phage from day 1. Also, the phage was also able to survive in the media for 21 days, however, the phage titer decreased in approx. 3 logs PFU/mL. The stability of the lytic phage population was consistent with the leaky resistance model. The time-shift experiments showed resistance to phages from day 1 of at least 85% to the past, present, and future phages. Sequencing of S. Enteritidis showed mutations in genes involved in lipopolysaccharide biosynthesis genes rfbP and rfbN at day 21. The phage showed mutations in the tail phage proteins responsible for recognizing the cell surface receptors. These results suggest that interactions between bacteria and phage in a rich resource media generate a rapid resistance to the infective phage but a fraction of the population remains susceptible. Interactions between Salmonella and lytic phages are an important component for the rational use of phages to control this important foodborne pathogen.

Genetic Signatures from Adaptation of Bacteria to Lytic Phage Identify Potential Agents to Aid Phage-Killing of Multidrug-Resistant Acinetobacter baumannii

With the increasing morbidity and mortality rates associated with multidrug-resistant bacteria, interest in bacteriophage therapy has been revived. However, bacterial resistance to phage infection threatens the usefulness of phage therapy, especially its inclusion in modern medicine. Multidrug-resistant Acinetobacter baumannii is a top priority pathogen requiring urgent intervention and new therapeutic approaches, such as phage therapy. Here, we experimentally adapted A. baumannii WHG40004 to its lytic phage P21, and thereafter isolated a phage-resistant bacterial mutant, named Ev5-WHG. We then aimed to identify potential agents to aid phage-killing of Ev5-WHG by analyzing its genome and that of the wildtype strain. The enriched Gene Ontology (GO) analysis based on genetic alterations in minor alleles and mutations showed that pathways such as zinc ion transport and cell membrane synthesis could play certain roles in phage resistance. Remarkably, the combination of zinc acetate and P21 showed increased bactericidal effect on Ev5-WHG. Significantly also, we showed that P21 completely prevented the growth of wildtype WHG40004 in the presence of antibiotics (meropenem and imipenem). The results from this study indicate that the analysis of phage resistance signatures during adaptation of bacteria to a lytic phage can inform choice of agents to work cooperatively with phage to limit and/or reverse resistance. This approach could be important for guiding future successful phage therapy. Importance Bacteriophages have proven very useful as alternative therapeutic agents in combating multidrug-resistant bacterial infections, however, bacterial resistance to phages threatens their use. In this study, we showed a new strategy of leveraging on genetic signatures that accompany phage resistance in bacteria to predict agents that can be used with lytic phages to combat multidrug-resistant Acinetobacter baumannii. Significantly, this approach was helpful in suggesting the use of zinc acetate to reduce resistance in phage-resistant bacteria, as well as the use of phage with antibiotics meropenem and imipenem to prevent resistance in wildtype strain of MDR A. baumannii. The approach of this study will be helpful for improving the outcome of phage therapy and in overcoming antimicrobial resistance.

Bacteriophages vB_Sen-TO17 and vB_Sen-E22, Newly Isolated Viruses from Chicken Feces, Specific for Several Salmonella enterica Strains

Two newly discovered bacteriophages, isolated from chicken feces and infecting Salmonella enterica strains, are described in this report. These phages have been named vB_Sen-TO17 and vB_Sen-E22, and we present their molecular and functional characterization. Both studied viruses are able to infect several S. enterica strains and develop lytically, but their specific host ranges differ significantly. Electron microscopic analyses of virions have been performed, and full genome sequences were determined and characterized, along with molecular phylogenetic studies. Genomes of vB_Sen-TO17 (ds DNA of 41,658 bp) and vB_Sen-E22 (dsDNA of 108,987 bp) are devoid of homologs of any known or putative gene coding for toxins or any other proteins potentially deleterious for eukaryotic cells. Both phages adsorbed efficiently (>95% adsorbed virions) within 10 min at 42 °C (resembling chicken body temperature) on cells of most tested host strains. Kinetics of lytic development of vB_Sen-TO17 and vB_Sen-E22, determined in one-step growth experiments, indicated that development is complete within 30-40 min at 42 °C, whereas burst sizes vary from 9 to 79 progeny phages per cell for vB_Sen-TO17 and from 18 to 64 for vB_Sen-E22, depending on the host strain. Virions of both phages were relatively stable (from several percent to almost 100% survivability) under various conditions, including acidic and alkaline pH values (from 3 to 12), temperatures from -80 °C to 60 °C, 70% ethanol, chloroform, and 10% DMSO. These characteristics of vB_Sen-TO17 and vB_Sen-E22 indicate that these phages might be considered in further studies on phage therapy, particularly in attempts to eliminate S. enterica from chicken intestine.

Mutant and Recombinant Phages Selected from In Vitro Coevolution Conditions Overcome Phage-Resistant Listeria monocytogenes

Bacteriophages (phages) are currently available for use by the food industry to control the foodborne pathogen Listeria monocytogenes Although phage biocontrols are effective under specific conditions, their use can select for phage-resistant bacteria that repopulate phage-treated environments. Here, we performed short-term coevolution experiments to investigate the impact of single phages and a two-phage cocktail on the regrowth of phage-resistant L. monocytogenes and the adaptation of the phages to overcome this resistance. We used whole-genome sequencing to identify mutations in the target host that confer phage resistance and in the phages that alter host range. We found that infections with Listeria phages LP-048, LP-125, or a combination of both select for different populations of phage-resistant L. monocytogenes bacteria with different regrowth times. Phages isolated from the end of the coevolution experiments were found to have gained the ability to infect phage-resistant mutants of L. monocytogenes and L. monocytogenes strains previously found to be broadly resistant to phage infection. Phages isolated from coinfected cultures were identified as recombinants of LP-048 and LP-125. Interestingly, recombination events occurred twice independently in a locus encoding two proteins putatively involved in DNA binding. We show that short-term coevolution of phages and their hosts can be utilized to obtain mutant and recombinant phages with adapted host ranges. These laboratory-evolved phages may be useful for limiting the emergence of phage resistance and for targeting strains that show general resistance to wild-type (WT) phages.IMPORTANCE Listeria monocytogenes is a life-threatening bacterial foodborne pathogen that can persist in food processing facilities for years. Phages can be used to control L. monocytogenes in food production, but phage-resistant bacterial subpopulations can regrow in phage-treated environments. Coevolution experiments were conducted on a Listeria phage-host system to provide insight into the genetic variation that emerges in both the phage and bacterial host under reciprocal selective pressure. As expected, mutations were identified in both phage and host, but additionally, recombination events were shown to have repeatedly occurred between closely related phages that coinfected L. monocytogenes This study demonstrates that in vitro evolution of phages can be utilized to expand the host range and improve the long-term efficacy of phage-based control of L. monocytogenes This approach may also be applied to other phage-host systems for applications in biocontrol, detection, and phage therapy.

Characteristics of a Series of Three Bacteriophages Infecting Salmonella enterica Strains

Molecular and functional characterization of a series of three bacteriophages, vB_SenM-1, vB_SenM-2, and vB_SenS-3, infecting various Salmonella enterica serovars and strains is presented. All these phages were able to develop lytically while not forming prophages. Moreover, they were able to survive at pH 3. The phages revealed different host ranges within serovars and strains of S. enterica, different adsorption rates on host cells, and different lytic growth kinetics at various temperatures (in the range of 25 to 42 °C). They efficiently reduced the number of cells in the bacterial biofilm and decreased the biofilm mass. Whole genome sequences of these phages have been determined and analyzed, including their phylogenetic relationships. In conclusion, we have demonstrated detailed characterization of a series of three bacteriophages, vB_SenM-1, vB_SenM-2, and vB_SenS-3, which reveal favorable features in light of their potential use in phage therapy of humans and animals, as well as for food protection purposes.

Paving the Way to Unveil the Diversity and Evolution of Phage Genomes

Phage biology has been developing for the last hundred years, and the potential of phages as tools and treatments has been known since their early discovery. However, the lack of knowledge of the molecular mechanisms coded in phage genomes hindered the development of the field. With current molecular methods, the last decade has been a resurgence of the field. The Special Issue on “Diversity and Evolution of Phage Genomes” is a great example with its 17 manuscripts published. It covers some of the latest methods to sample and characterize environmental and host associated viromes, considering experimental biases and computational developments. Furthermore, the use of molecular tools coupled with traditional methods has allowed to isolate and characterize viruses from different hosts and environments with such diversity that even a new viral class is being proposed. The viruses described cover all different phage families and lifestyles. However, is not only about diversity; the molecular evolution is studied in a set of manuscripts looking at phage-host interactions and their capacity to uncover the frequency and type of mutations behind the bacterial resistance mechanisms and viral pathogenesis, and such methods are opening new ways into identifying potential receptors and characterizing the bacterial host range.

Modeling Phage-Bacteria Dynamics

Phage-bacteria interaction is a classic example of competitive coevolution in nature. Mathematical modeling of such interactions furnishes new insight into the dynamics of phage and bacteria. Besides its intrinsic value, a somewhat underutilized aspect of such insight is that it can provide beneficial inputs toward better experimental design. In this chapter, we discuss several modeling techniques that can be used to study the dynamics between phages and their host bacteria. Monte Carlo simulations and differential equations (both ordinary and delay differential equations) can be used to successfully model phage-bacteria dynamics in well-mixed populations. The presence of spatial restrictions in the interaction media significantly affects the dynamics of phage-bacteria interactions. For such cases, techniques like cellular automata and reaction-diffusion equations can be used to capture these effects adequately. We discuss details of the modeling techniques with specific examples.

Biological challenges of phage therapy and proposed solutions: a literature review

Introduction: In light of the emergence of antibiotic-resistant bacteria, phage (bacteriophage) therapy has been recognized as a potential alternative or addition to antibiotics in Western medicine for use in humans.Areas covered: This review assessed the scientific literature on phage therapy published between 1 January 2007 and 21 October 2019, with a focus on the successes and challenges of this prospective therapeutic.Expert opinion: Efficacy has been shown in animal models and experimental findings suggest promise for the safety of human phagotherapy. Significant challenges remain to be addressed prior to the standardization of phage therapy in the West, including the development of phage-resistant bacteria; the pharmacokinetic complexities of phage; and any potential human immune response incited by phagotherapy.

Two Phages of the Genera Felixounavirus Subjected to 12 Hour Challenge on Salmonella Infantis Showed Distinct Genotypic and Phenotypic Changes

Salmonella Infantis is considered in recent years an emerging Salmonella serovar, as it has been associated with several outbreaks and multidrug resistance phenotypes. Phages appear as a possible alternative strategy to control Salmonella Infantis (SI). The aims of this work were to characterize two phages of the Felixounavirus genus, isolated using the same strain of SI, and to expose them to interact in challenge assays to identify genetic and phenotypic changes generated from these interactions. These two phages have a shared nucleotide identity of 97% and are differentiated by their host range: one phage has a wide host range (lysing 14 serovars), and the other has a narrow host range (lysing 6 serovars). During the 12 h challenge we compared: (1) optical density of SI, (2) proportion of SI survivors from phage-infected cultures, and (3) phage titer. Isolates obtained through the assays were evaluated by efficiency of plating (EOP) and by host-range characterization. Genomic modifications were characterized by evaluation of single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs). The optical density (600 nm) of phage-infected SI decreased, as compared to the uninfected control, by an average of 0.7 for SI infected with the wide-host-range (WHR) phage and by 0.3 for SI infected with the narrow-host-range (NHR) phage. WHR phage reached higher phage titer (7 × 1011 PFU/mL), and a lower proportion of SI survivor was obtained from the challenge assay. In SI that interacted with phages, we identified SNPs in two genes (rfaK and rfaB), which are both involved in lipopolysaccharide (LPS) polymerization. Therefore, mutations that could impact potential phage receptors on the host surface were selected by lytic phage exposure. This work demonstrates that the interaction of Salmonella phages (WHR and NHR) with SI for 12 h in vitro leads to emergence of new phenotypic and genotypic traits in both phage and host. This information is crucial for the rational design of phage-based control strategies.