In Vitro Evaluation of Ozonated Water Treatment on the Viability of Eimeria Oocysts and Giardia Cysts from Water Buffaloes: A Proof-of-Concept Study

Aqueous Ozone Exposure Inhibits Sporulation in the Cyclospora cayetanensis Surrogate Eimeria acervulina

Ozone is a potent disinfecting agent used to treat potable water and wastewater, effectively clearing protozoa such as Giardia and Cryptosporidium spp. It is unclear whether ozone treatment of water or fresh produce can reduce the spread of the emerging parasite Cyclospora cayetanensis, which causes cyclosporiasis in humans. Obtaining viable C. cayetanensis oocysts to evaluate inactivation methods is challenging because we lack the means to propagate them in vitro, because of delays in case reporting, and because health departments typically add inactivating fixatives to clinical specimens. Research in various surrogate organisms has sought to bolster understanding of the biology of C. cayetanensis. Among these surrogates is the poultry parasite Eimeria acervulina, a closely related and easily cultured parasite of economic significance. We used this surrogate to evaluate the consequences of ozone treatment, using the sporulation state as an indicator of infectious potential. Treating with ozonated water acidified with citric acid reduced sporulation ability in a dose-dependent manner; treatment with up to 4.93 mg/L initial concentration of ozone resulted in a 93% inactivation of sporulation by 7 days posttreatment. This developmental arrest was accompanied by transcriptional changes in genes involved in regulating the response to reactive oxygen species (ROS) in a time course that is consistent with the production of oxygen free radicals. This study shows that ozone is highly effective in preventing sporulation of E. acervulina, a model coccidian used as a surrogate for Cyclospora. Furthermore, ozone exposure induced molecular responses to general oxidative stress, documented with several well-characterized antioxidant enzymes.

Deterministic and stochastic survival models of injured ozonated Giardia cysts

Giardia cysts exposed to short sublethal ozonation in lake waters continue to die-off well after the ozone complete dissipation. This delayed inactivation can be the manifestation of injured cysts' mortality, which the traditional Chick-Watson-Hom type models of disinfection do not account for. But it can be described by a slightly modified version of a general microbial survival model adapted for injured cysts or other targeted microorganisms surviving disinfection. The downward concavity of the cysts' semi-logarithmic survival ratio vs. time relationships suggests that the cysts' deaths had unimodal temporal distribution. Indeed, the cumulative (CDF) forms of the Weibull and lognormal distribution functions both had excellent fit to the experimental survival data. Such a survival pattern can also be described by a fully probabilistic model devised from the injured cysts' Markov chain, where the mortality's probability rate rises linearly with time. The stochastic model explains the ubiquitous observation that microbial survival curves become increasingly irregular and irreproducible as the number of survivors dwindles, regardless of their concavity degree and direction. Although based on ozonated Giardia cyst data, the concept should be applicable to the delayed mortality of other microorganisms surviving sublethal treatments of other kinds but unable to recover and/or multiply. KEY POINTS: • Deterministic and stochastic survival models can describe delayed inactivation. • The Weibull and lognormal distributions can describe cysts' times to mortality. • Stochastic model explains the progressively growing scatter in survival curves.