A Meta-Analysis of the Impact of the Two-Layer Method of Preservation on Human Pancreatic Islet Transplantation

Reanimating Pancreatic Grafts Subjected to Prolonged Cold Ischemic Injury Using Normothermic Ex Vivo Perfusion

Background

Pancreas transplant volumes are limited because of poor utilization of "extended criteria grafts." Prolonged cold ischemia is a risk factor associated with poor allograft survival. We aimed to establish the feasibility of transplantation using grafts subjected to prolonged cold ischemia and determine whether these grafts could be optimized using normothermic ex vivo perfusion (NEVP) in a porcine model.

Methods

The study population consisted of 35 to 40 kg male Yorkshire pigs in an allotransplantation model with a 3-d survival plan for recipients. Control grafts were subjected to cold storage (CS) in a University of Wisconsin solution for 21 to 24 h (n = 6), whereas the test group received an additional 3 h NEVP after CS of 21 h (n = 5).

Results

The 3-d survival was 60% in the NEVP arm versus 0% in the control arm (P = 0.008; log rank). Graft parenchyma was 60% to 70% preserved in the NEVP arm at necropsy on gross appearance. In addition, the islet function was well preserved, and both the pancreas (including the islets) and the duodenal morphology were maintained histologically. The intravenous glucose tolerance test on the day of euthanasia was in the normoglycemic range for 80% of cases in the NEVP arm.

Conclusions

Optimization of pancreas grafts exposed to extended CS with NEVP seems promising at rescuing and reanimating these grafts for transplantation, resulting in significantly improved survival in a porcine pancreas transplant model.

Pancreatic islet transplantation: toward definitive treatment for diabetes mellitus

Since the late 20th century, advances in pancreatic islet transplantation have targeted improved glycemic control and fewer hypoglycemic events in patients with type 1 diabetes, and some important milestones have been reached. Following the Edmonton group's success in achieving insulin independence in all transplanted patients with type 1 diabetes, clinical islet transplantation is now performed worldwide. β cell replacement therapy for type 1 diabetes was established based on the favorable outcomes of a phase 3, prospective, open-label, single-arm, clinical study conducted at 8 centers in North America, in which 42 of 48 patients who underwent islet transplantation from 2008 to 2011 achieved HbA1c < 7.0% (53 mmol/mol) at day 365, which was maintained at 2 years in 34 patients. In Japan, a phase 2 multicenter clinical trial of islet transplantation for type 1 diabetes patients is currently ongoing and will end soon, but the interim results have already led to positive changes, with allogeneic islet transplantation being covered by the national health insurance system since April 2020. Current efforts are being made to solve the problem of donor shortage by studying alternative donor sources, such as porcine islets and pancreatic progenitor cells derived from pluripotent stem cells. The results of clinical trials in this area are eagerly awaited. It is hoped that they will contribute to establishing alternative sources for insulin-producing β cells in the near future.

Inflammatory biomarkers in the blood and pancreatic tissue of organ donors that predict human islet isolation success and function

The pancreas of brain-dead donors is the primary source of islets for transplantation. However, brain death mediates systemic inflammation, which may affect the quantity and quality of isolated islets. Our aim was to identify inflammatory biomarkers in donor blood and/or pancreatic tissue capable of predicting islet isolation success. Blood samples were collected from 21 pancreas donors and 14 healthy volunteers. Pancreatic tissue samples were also collected from the corresponding donor during organ procurement. Six serum cytokines were measured by a fluorescent bead-based immunoassay, and the expression of fifteen inflammatory target genes was quantified by quantitative reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-qPCR). There was no correlation between serum inflammatory cytokines and mRNA expression of the corresponding genes in peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) or pancreatic tissue. The IL6 expression in pancreatic tissue correlated negatively with post-isolation islet yield. Islets isolated from donors highly expressing IFNG in PBMCs and MAC1 in pancreatic tissue functioned poorly in vivo when transplanted in diabetic NODscid mice. Furthermore, the increased MAC1 in pancreatic tissue was positively correlated with donor hospitalization time. Brain death duration positively correlated with higher expression of IL1B in PBMCs and TNF in both PBMCs and pancreatic tissue but failed to show a significant correlation with islet yield and in vivo function. The study indicates that the increased inflammatory genes in donor pancreatic tissues may be considered as biomarkers associated with poor islet isolation outcome.

Oxygenated UW Solution Decreases ATP Decay and Improves Survival After Transplantation of DCD Liver Grafts

BACKGROUND

Donation after circulatory death (DCD) liver grafts are known to be predisposed to primary nonfunction and ischemic cholangiopathy. Many DCD grafts are discarded because of older donor age or long warm ischemia times. Thus, it is critical to improve the quality of DCD liver grafts. Here, we have tested whether an enriched oxygen carrier added to the preservation solution can prolong graft survival and reduce biliary damage.

METHODS

We assessed the adenosine triphosphate (ATP) content decay of mouse liver grafts after cold ischemia, warm ischemia, and combined warm+cold ischemia. In addition, we used a rat model of liver transplantation to compare survival of DCD grafts preserved in high-oxygen solution (preoxygenated perfluorocarbon [PFC] + University of Wisconsin [UW] solution) versus lower oxygen solution (preoxygenated UW solution).

RESULTS

Adenosine triphosphate levels under UW preservation fall to less than 10% after 30 minutes of warm ischemia. Preoxygenated UW solution with PFC reached a significantly higher PaO2. After 45 minutes of warm ischemia in oxygenated UW + PFC solution, grafts showed 63% higher levels of ATP (P = 0.011). In addition, this was associated with better preservation of morphology when compared to grafts stored in standard UW solution. Animals that received DCD grafts preserved in higher oxygenation solution showed improved survival: 4 out of 6 animals survived long-term whereas all control group animals died within 24 hours.

CONCLUSIONS

The additional oxygen provided by PFC during static cold preservation of DCD livers can better sustain ATP levels, and thereby reduce the severity of ischemic tissue damage. PFC-based preservation solution extends the tolerance to warm ischemia, and may reduce the rate of ischemic cholangiopathy.

Impact of Oxygen on Pancreatic Islet Survival

Pancreatic islet transplantation is a promising treatment option for individuals with type 1 diabetes; however, maintaining islet function after transplantation remains a large challenge. Multiple factors, including hypoxia associated events, trigger pretransplant and posttransplant loss of islet function. In fact, islets are easily damaged in hypoxic conditions before transplantation including the preparation steps of pancreas procurement, islet isolation, and culture. Furthermore, after transplantation, islets are also exposed to the hypoxic environment of the transplant site until they are vascularized and engrafted. Because islets are exposed to such drastic environmental changes, protective measures are important to maintain islet viability and function. Many studies have demonstrated that the prevention of hypoxia contributes to maintaining islet quality. In this review, we summarize the latest oxygen-related islet physiology, including computational simulation. Furthermore, we review recent advances in oxygen-associated treatment options used as part of the transplant process, including up-to-date oxygen generating biomaterials as well as a classical oxygen inhalation therapy.

Utilization of organs from donors after circulatory death for vascularized pancreas and islet of Langerhans transplantation: recommendations from an expert group

Donation after circulatory death (DCD) donors are increasingly being used as a source of pancreas allografts for vascularized organ and islet transplantation. We provide practice guidelines aiming to increase DCD pancreas utilization. We review risk assessment and donor selection criteria. We report suggested factors in donor and recipient clinical management and provide an overview of the activities and outcomes of vascularized pancreas and islet transplantation.

Influence of the Two-Layer Preservation Method on Human Pancreatic Islet Isolation: A Meta-Analysis

Introduction

There has been continuous debate on whether the Two-Layer Method (TLM) is superior to the University of Wisconsin solution (UW) for preserving human pancreas prior to islet isolation. The objective of the current meta-analysis is to assess which method is superior.

Methods

We searched electronic databases (MEDLINE, EMBASE, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials) for relevant human trials published in the English language from January 2000 to October 2013. Data on donor characteristics and islet isolation outcomes were extracted.

Results

14 articles containing 18 human studies were included in this meta-analysis. In comparison to UW alone, TLM alone produced a significantly higher islet yield (weighted mean difference, 776.32; 95% confidence interval; 370.82-1181.82; P = .0002). TLM alone also yielded higher proportion of transplantable preparations (odds ratio, 1.60; 95% confidence interval; 1.15-2.23; P = .005). The following measures did not differ: islet viability (weighted mean difference, 2.10; −2.41-6.60; P = .360), purity (weighted mean difference, −0.92; −3.75-1.91; P = .520) and function assessed by measuring the stimulation index (weighted mean difference, 0.17; −0.21-0.55; P = .380). When comparing TLM following UW storage with UW alone, the results were similar to the previous ones.

Conclusions

This data indicates that the TLM can improve islet yield and increase the opportunities of human pancreatic islet transplantation. Therefore, the TLM should be recommended for preserving human pancreas prior to islet isolation.

Effects of Donor-, Pancreas-, and Isolation-Related Variables on Human Islet Isolation Outcome: A Systematic Review

Different factors have been reported to influence islet isolation outcome, but their importance varies between studies and are hampered by the small sample sizes in most studies. The purpose of this study was to perform a systematic review to assess the impact of donor-, pancreas-, and isolation-related variables on successful human islet isolation outcome. PubMed, Embase, and Web of Science were searched electronically in April 2009. All studies reporting on donor-, pancreas-, and isolation-related factors relating to prepurification and postpurification islet isolation yield and proportion of successful islet isolations were selected. Seventy-four retrospective studies had sufficient data and were included in the analyses. Higher pre- and postpurification islet yields and a higher proportion of successful islet isolations were obtained when pancreata were preserved with the two-layer method rather than University of Wisconsin solution in donors with shorter cold ischemia times (CITs) [1 h longer CIT resulted in an average decline of prepurification and postpurification yields and proportion of successful isolations of 59 islet equivalents (IEQs)/g, 54 IEQs/g, and 21%, respectively]. Higher prepurification yields and higher percentage of successful islet isolations were found in younger donors with higher body mass index. Lower yields were found in donation after brain death donors compared to donation after cardiac death donors. Higher postpurification yields were found for isolation with Serva collagenase. This review identified donor-, pancreas-, and isolation-related factors that influence islet isolation yield. Standardized reports of these factors in all future studies may improve the power and identify additional factors and thereby contribute to improving islet isolation yield.

Current state of pancreas preservation and implications for DCD pancreas transplantation

One of the main factors limiting potential uptake of pancreas transplantation, particularly in the United Kingdom, is the shortage of grafts. There has therefore been a recent expansion, particularly in the United Kingdom, in the utilization of grafts from donation after cardiac death (DCD) donors. These grafts are subjected to a greater ischemic insult and are arguably at higher risk of poor functional outcome. Although conventional preservation techniques may be adequate for donation after brain death (DBD) and low-risk DCD pancreases, as the number of DCD pancreas transplants increase and the threshold for rejecting organs decreases, the importance of optimal preservation techniques is going to increase. Over recent years, there have been significant advances in preservation techniques for DCD kidneys, improving the outcome of these marginal grafts. However, the use of such techniques for pancreas preservation is extremely limited and mainly historical. This overview describes the background and results of the established method of pancreas preservation for DBD, namely, cold static storage, and describes the use of the two-layer method. It also reviews pulsatile machine perfusion and normothermic perfusion for pancreas preservation techniques, which have shown promise in the preservation of DCD kidney grafts. The use of these techniques in pancreas preservation is predominantly historical but warrants reevaluation as to the feasibility of applying these techniques to DCD pancreas grafts not only for preservation but also for viability assessment. Further areas for development of pancreas preservation are discussed.

Improved pancreatic islet isolation outcome in autologous transplantation for chronic pancreatitis

Total or partial pancreatectomy followed by autologous islet transplantation is a therapeutic option for the treatment of refractory chronic pancreatitis (CP). Maximization of islet yields from fibrotic and inflamed organs is crucial for prevention of posttransplant diabetes. We adapted technical advancements developed for islet allotransplantation toward islet autotransplantation. Eight patients (two men, six women; ages 24-58 years) underwent total (n = 7) or partial (n = 1) pancreatectomy for the treatment of CP refractory to maximal medical management. Pancreata were preserved in UW solution (UW group) in initial three cases and the last five pancreata were preserved with pancreatic ductal injection followed by ET-Kyoto/oxygenated PFC solutions (DI+TLM group). Islets were isolated by modified Ricordi method and were purified only in one case. All islet infusions were performed under general anesthesia via direct vein injection into the portal venous system with pressure monitoring. Total islet yields (129,314 ± 51,627 vs. 572,841 ± 116,934 IEQ, p < 0.04), islet yield/pancreas weight (1,233 ± 359 vs. 6,848 ± 847 IEQ/g, p < 0.003), and islet yield/patient body weight (1,951 ± 762 vs. 7,305 ± 1,531 IEQ/kg, p < 0.05) were significantly higher in the DI+TLM group when compared to the UW group. Pellet size was also higher (5.3 ± 0.3 vs. 13.5 ± 3.4 ml) in the DI+TLM group, suggesting that this method of preservation effectively protected pancreatic tissue against autolysis. First month posttransplant basal C-peptide and the secretory unit of islet transplant objects (SUITO) index were also higher in the DI+TLM group when compared to the UW group (2.0 ± 0.3 vs. 1.4 ± 0.4 ng/ml and 42.6 ± 12.7 vs. 14.6 ± 5.6, respectively). There were no technical complications related to the infusion. Our results suggest that higher islet yields can be achieved even from chronically inflamed and fibrotic organs using DI+TLM. The techniques applied for islet isolations from normal pancreata are showing promise for fibrotic pancreata from CP patients.

Persufflation (or gaseous oxygen perfusion) as a method of organ preservation

Improved preservation techniques have the potential to improve transplant outcomes by better maintaining donor organ quality and by making more organs available for allotransplantation. Persufflation, (PSF, gaseous oxygen perfusion) is potentially one such technique that has been studied for over a century in a variety of tissues, but has yet to gain wide acceptance for a number of reasons. A principal barrier is the perception that ex vivo PSF will cause in vivo embolization post-transplant. This review summarizes the extensive published work on heart, liver, kidney, small intestine and pancreas PSF, discusses the differences between anterograde and retrograde PSF, and between PSF and other conventional methods of organ preservation (static cold storage, hypothermic machine perfusion). Prospective implications of PSF within the broader field of organ transplantation, and in the specific application with pancreatic islet isolation and transplant are also discussed. Finally, key issues that need to be addressed before PSF becomes a more widely utilized preservation strategy are summarized and discussed.

31-Phosphorus magnetic resonance spectroscopy for dynamic assessment of adenosine triphosphate levels in pancreas preserved by the two-layer method

Cold preservation injury influences islet graft function. Reliable tools for real-time assessment of pancreas viability before islet isolation are lacking. Phosphorus magnetic resonance spectroscopy ((31)P-MRS) was used immediately after organ harvest to study rat pancreases at 4 °C to 6 °C in five randomized preservation groups: Marshall's solution, static two-layer method (TLM), continuous TLM with oxygen perfused at 0.5 L/min, and static TLM or continuous TLM both the latter following 30 minutes of warm ischemia (WI). (31)P spectra were analyzed for phosphomonoesters, inorganic phosphate (Pi) and α-, β-and γ-nucleotide triphosphate. Intergroup rates of change of [γ-adenosine triphosphate (ATP)]/[Pi] and [β-ATP]/[Pi] throughout preservation period were significantly different. For continuous TLM there was an increase relative to baseline (0.043 (SD0.033) h(-1) and 0.029 (0.029) h(-1), respectively) but a decrease for both static TLM (-0.023 (0.016) h(-1) and 0.015 (0.026), P < .001 and < .05, respectively) and Marshall's (-0.049 (0.025) h(-1) and -0.036 (0.019) h(-1), respectively, both P < .001) with respect to continuous TLM. Rate of decrease was similar for the Marshall's and static TLM groups. [γ-ATP]/[Pi] and [β-ATP]/[Pi] increased with WI continuous TLM (0.008 [0.009] h(-1) and 0.007 [0.008] hr(-1), respectively) but decreased for WI static TLM (-0.018 (0.008) h(-1) and -0.014 (0.004) hr(-1), respectively, P < .001). (31)P-MRS is an effective tool for noninvasive assessment of pancreas bioenergetics. Continuous TLM preserves cellular bioenergetics and is superior to current non-perfluorocar bone based solutions for pancreas preservation.

Islet transplantation: factors in short-term islet survival

Islet transplantation has the potential to cure type 1 diabetes. In recent years, the proportion of patients achieving initial insulin independence has improved, but longer term outcomes remain poor compared to those for whole pancreas transplants. This review article will discuss factors affecting islet yield and viability leading up to transplantation and in the immediate post-transplant period.

A Meta-Analysis for Comparison of the Two-Layer and University of Wisconsin Pancreas Preservation Methods in Islet Transplantation

Conflicting results have been reported on the effectiveness of the two-layer method (TLM) compared with the University of Wisconsin (UW) method for preserving pancreata. The objective of this study was to compile the evidence for or against any difference in human islet yield and viability between these two. PubMed (January 2000 to May 2008) and Cochran Library searches were performed and 17 studies were included for the meta-analysis. Data on donor characteristics, preservation time, and outcomes were abstracted. Studies were subgrouped based on how TLM was used (UW + TLM or TLM alone), on mean cold ischemic time (CIT) (>20 h or <20 h), and on whether special chemical was used (yes or no). Meta-analysis of all studies and subgroups was performed and the pooled standardized mean differences (SMD) with 95% confidence intervals (CI) were reported. Overall, the use of TLM significantly increased islet yield [SMD, 0.74 (0.44–1.04)] and viability [SMD, 0.63 (0.14–1.12)]. The beneficial effects of TLM on islet yield were more evident when TLM was used following UW storage or when prolonged CIT was used. TLM used alone, shorter CIT, and no chemical use all resulted in similar islet viability between TLM and UW groups. Beneficial effects of TLM on islet viability were demonstrated only when TLM was used following UW storage, or with prolonged CIT, or with chemical use. In conclusion, the TLM was beneficial for prolonged pancreas preservation before human islet isolation; however, benefit of the TLM for short-term preservation was not clear.

Limited Penetration of Perfluorocarbon in Porcine Pancreas Preserved by Two-Layer Method with 19Fluorine Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy and Headspace Gas Chromatography

The mechanism of the two-layer method (TLM) of pancreas preservation is unclear. Facilitating oxygen diffusion into preserved pancreas has been suggested, but direct measurements of tissue pO2 have yielded conflicting results. The degree of penetration of perfluorocarbon (PFC) into the pancreas during TLM storage is unknown. Segments of porcine pancreas (7.5 cm in length) were preserved either in University of Wisconsin solution (UW) alone ( n = 6) or in TLM for 24 h ( n = 6). Pancreatic samples were analyzed using Varian INOVA 9.4T MR scanner. External PFC standard was introduced for quantification. Four consecutive transverse images of 4 mm thickness were obtained using a spin-echo sequence. 19Fluorine magnetic resonance spectroscopy (19F MRS) was performed with the same parameters except with more averages. MR data were confirmed by headspace chromatography. PFC standard was readily detected in 19F MR images. There was no signal from pancreas in 19F MR images following either UW or TLM storage. 19F MR spectra typical of PFC were not obtained from either UW- or TLM-preserved pancreas with nonlocalized 19F MRS. Mean concentration of PFC in TLM pancreas measured by head space chromatography was 0.011 nl/g (SD ±0.006), not significantly different from background concentration (0.012 nl/g, SD ±0.006) in UW pancreas ( p = 0.42). There was no evidence of penetration of PFC into pancreas tissues investigated either by MR or chromatography in organs preserved at hypothermia by TLM, and mechanisms of TLM remain speculative.

Donor intervention and organ preservation: where is the science and what are the obstacles?

The organ shortage is widely acknowledged as the most critical factor hindering the full realization of success for solid organ transplantation. Innovation in the areas of donor management and organ preservation offers the most realistic hope to improve both the quality and size of the current organ supply. Although the basic science dissecting the complex processes of brain death and ischemia/reperfusion injury is replete with exciting discoveries, the clinical science investigating donor management and organ preservation is sparse in contrast. This review will survey the current landscape of trials to mitigate organ injury through interventions administered to donors in vivo or organs ex vivo. Consideration will then be given to the scientific, logistical and ethical obstacles that impede the transformation of laboratory breakthroughs into innovative treatments that simultaneously improve organ quality and supply.

Multicenter analysis of novel and established variables associated with successful human islet isolation outcomes

Islet transplantation is a promising therapy used to achieve glycometabolic control in a select subgroup of individuals with type I diabetes. However, features that characterize human islet isolation success prior to transplantation are not standardized and lack validation. We conducted a retrospective analysis of 806 isolation records from 14 pancreas-processing laboratories, considering variables from relevant studies in the last 15 years. The outcome was defined as post-purification islet equivalent count, dichotomized into yields > or =315 000 or < or =220 000. Univariate analysis showed that donor cause of death and use of hormonal medications negatively influenced outcome. Conversely, pancreata from heavier donors and those containing elevated levels of surface fat positively influence outcome, as did heavier pancreata and donors with normal amylase levels. Multivariable logistic regression analysis identified the positive impact on outcome of surgically intact pancreata and donors with normal liver function, and confirmed that younger donors, increased body mass index, shorter cold ischemia times, no administration of fluid/electrolyte medications, absence of organ edema, use of University of Wisconsin preservation solution and a fatty pancreas improves outcome. In conclusion, this multicenter analysis highlights the importance of carefully reviewing all donor, pancreas and processing parameters prior to isolation and transplantation.