The technique of cemented total hip replacement

Outcomes of Charnley total hip arthroplasty using improved cementing with so-called second- and third-generation techniques

BACKGROUND

Techniques of cemented total hip arthroplasty have developed over time. We present the outcomes of Charnley total hip arthroplasty performed using improved second- and third-generation cementing techniques.

METHODS

We reviewed the radiologic results of 91 Charnley total hip arthroplasties performed using second- and third-generation cementing techniques. Second-generation techniques involved making multiple anchor holes, a double-cementing method on the acetabular side and an intramedullary plug, and retrograde filling with a cement gun on the femoral side in 57 hips. Third-generation techniques involved additional vacuum mixing and cement pressurization in 34 hips.

RESULTS

Joint survival rates at 20 years when using second-generation techniques were 89% for the socket and 94% for the stem with aseptic loosening as the end point; the survival rates at 10 years when using third-generation techniques were 97 and 100%, respectively. According to our radiographic evaluation system for the clear zone at 5 years, there was less clear zone in the acetabular side with the third-generation techniques than with second-generation techniques. In the femoral side, there was very little development of the clear zone, but the difference between generations was not significant.

CONCLUSIONS

Second- and third-generation cementing techniques showed excellent survivorship. The clear zone scores at 5 years indicated that third-generation techniques were effective, especially in the acetabular side, and may produce better long-term results than second-generation techniques.

Large-diameter metal-on-metal cementless total hip arthroplasty in the elderly

To evaluate the clinical effectiveness and complications of large-diameter metal-on-metal prostheses, particularly in the elderly, we performed cementless total hip arthroplasty (THA) using metal-on-metal prostheses with large-diameter femoral heads (mean, 45 mm) in 59 patients (average age, 75.1 years) between January 2004 and December 2005. All procedures were performed using a posterolateral approach and spinal anesthesia. Average follow-up was 65 months. Pre- and postoperative Harris Hip Scores and SF-36 questionnaire results were recorded for all patients to evaluate the level of pain relief, improvement in physical function, and changes in quality of life. Postoperative radiographic images were used to document areas of osteolysis and probable aseptic loosening. Average preoperative Harris Hip Score was 36.1±5.7, compared to 69.4±8.3 at last follow-up (P<.01). Average preoperative SF-36 score was 33.6±7.4, compared to 71.8±6.4 at last follow-up (P<.01). There were no dislocations, aseptic loosening, or revisions. Our findings suggest that metal-on-metal cementless prostheses with large-diameter femoral heads in THA can produce satisfactory results with good durability, a low rate of dislocation and aseptic loosening, and a low incidence of revisions in the short term. The benefits of this technique for elderly patients, especially those with weak muscle power and reduced cognitive function, include avoidance of severe cement-injection complications and early functional recovery.

Effect of stem preheating on the fatigue behaviour of bone cement around hip prostheses

Tensile fatigue behaviour of bone cement specimens obtained from cement mantles moulded in vitro, simulating the surgical scenario, was investigated. The effect of stem preheating, before its insertion into the cement dough, on specimen fatigue life was studied. A commercial bone cement was selected for this study. Bone cement mixing was conducted in air, following the manufacturer's instructions, and injected simulating the clinical practice. Two conditions were considered: stem maintained at the surgical room temperature (23 degrees C), and stem preheated to 45 degrees C. Four repetitions of the whole procedure were performed for each condition obtaining a total of 32 specimens. All specimens underwent fatigue testing (stress ratio, 0; maximum tensile stress, 15 MPa) until failure. Both two-parameter and three-parameter Weibull distributions were initially used to analyse the fatigue life data set. However, the two-parameter distribution was chosen for both groups on the basis of the coefficient of determination used to test the goodness of fit. Stem preheating seems to have a negligible effect on fatigue behaviour of the studied bone cement in the low range of fatigue lives (up to 10(4)). However, above this number of cycles, stem preheating seems to reduce the probability of failure. These findings are discussed in the text.

Radiologic evaluation of the cement mantle in the femoral shaft. A comparative study using a fast-set or a standard-set cement

INTRODUCTION

At present a wide spectrum of cement types are available for cemented total hip arthroplasty (CTHA). All types have the same objective, i.e. to prolong the life of the implant for as long as possible. The purpose of this study was to compare the radiologic cement mantle of CTHA using cement with fast or standard setting characteristics.

METHOD

A prospective comparative study of patients who underwent CTHA was performed: the first group received fast setting cement (Cemex System Fast), the second group received standard setting cement (Cemex System). A radiologic evaluation of the cement mantle was done using Barrack's classification. In order to give the study clinical relevance we assembled Barrack's classification in two groups: 1) Low risk group (Types A and B); 2) High risk group (Types C and D). According to ISO 5833:2002, the international standard was used to perform physico-chemical (polymerization temperature, setting time) and mechanical testing (compression strength, bending strength and bending modulus).

RESULTS

The fast setting cement showed a shorter setting time and a higher polymerization temperature. The mechanical performances of both cements met the ISO limits. At a mean follow-up of 23 months (11-37 months) no statistically significant radiological difference was found in the radiologic cement mantle between the two groups either in the post-operative X-ray evaluation (p=0.32) or in the last follow-up (p=0.72). Statistical evaluation was done comparing the two sub-groups, i.e. low risk and high risk.

CONCLUSIONS

The use of fast or standard setting cement does not produce any difference in the quality of the radiologic cement mantle in the short-term. Both cements comply with ISO 5833 requirements.

Uncompromised quality of the cement mantle in Exeter femoral components implanted through a minimally-invasive direct anterior approach

A complete cement mantle is important for the longevity of a total hip replacement. In the minimally-invasive direct anterior approach used at the Innsbruck University hospital, the femoral component has to be inserted into the femoral canal by an angulated movement. In a cadaver study, the quality and the extent of the cement mantle surrounding 13 Exeter femoral components implanted straight through a standard anterolateral transgluteal approach were compared with those of 13 similar femoral components implanted in an angulated fashion through a direct anterior approach. A third-generation cementing technique was used. The inner and outer contours of the cement mantles was traced from CT scans and the thickness and cross-sectional area determined.

In no case was the cement mantle incomplete. The total mean thickness of the cement mantle was 3.62 mm (95% confidence interval 3.59 to 3.65). The mean thickness in the group using the minimally-invasive approach was 0.16 mm less than that in the anterolateral group. The distribution of the thickness was similar in the two groups. The mean thickness was less on the anteromedial and anterolateral aspect than on the posterior aspect of the femur.

There is no evidence that the angulated introduction of Exeter femoral components in the direct anterior approach in cadavers compromises the quality, extent or thickness of the cement mantle.