Development of a Clinical Judgment Measurement Model-Based Simulation Module for Ileus: A Mixed-Methods Study

A concept analysis of clinical judgment in undergraduate nursing students

AIM

To offer a clear understanding of the definition, attributes, antecedents, and consequences of undergraduate nursing students' clinical judgment in the nursing education context.

BACKGROUND

Clinical judgment is a concept with broad uses among healthcare professionals. Its definitions and attributes vary across contexts. There is no established understanding of clinical judgment in nursing students.

DESIGN

This concept analysis was performed using the eight steps of Walker and Avant's framework.

DATA SOURCES

A literature search was conducted using search engines and included peer-reviewed articles related to clinical judgment in nursing students.

RESULTS

Clinical judgment in nursing students was defined as the cognitive process exhibited via a nursing action by observation, patient assessment, interpreting, and prioritizing data that lead to responding using the appropriate nursing practice with the patient. Reflection was used to evaluate nursing students' clinical judgment to revise nursing practice. Antecedents included nursing education curriculum, student's knowledge, previous clinical experience, critical thinking, and clinical reasoning. The consequences of clinical judgment were clinical judgment ability, safe nursing practice, nursing care quality, and patient safety.

CONCLUSIONS

This concept analysis gives clear insights into the definition, attributes, antecedents, and consequences of undergraduate nursing student's clinical judgment.

Communication and Competencies Across Undergraduate BSN Programs and Curricula

BACKGROUND

An investigation was conducted to assess for and describe health communication instruction in entry-level baccalaureate (BSN) programs.

METHOD

This cross-sectional descriptive study examined entry-level baccalaureate degree nursing programs in the United States. A three-step process was used: (1) online survey of directors of BSN programs, (2) online survey of simulation directors, and (3) analysis of course titles and descriptions.

RESULTS

Communication instruction remains primarily knowledge-based rather than skills-based. The findings of this study confirm there is ambiguity in defining the scope of communication instruction across curricula, as well as radical differences in the inclusion of communication in course descriptions and content.

CONCLUSION

There is a need for clear definition of the scope of health communication skill development across BSN programs for communication behaviors to be measured and competency to be determined. A knowledge-building approach to communication instruction does not align with new plans for competency-based nursing education. [J Nurs Educ. 2021;60(11):618-624.].

Clinical judgment model-based nursing simulation scenario for patients with upper gastrointestinal bleeding: A mixed methods study

Assisting patients with upper gastrointestinal bleeding is a crucial role for nurses, and as future nurses, students should demonstrate sound clinical judgment. Well-structured, high-quality simulations are useful alternatives to prepare students for clinical practice. However, nursing simulation scenarios focused on enhancing clinical judgment in managing upper gastrointestinal bleeding are limited. This study aims to develop, apply, and evaluate an effective nursing simulation scenario for patients with upper gastrointestinal bleeding based on Tanner’s clinical judgment model using a mixed methods study design. A high-fidelity patient simulation was conducted among 80 undergraduate nursing students divided into a simulated control group (n = 39) and an experimental group (n = 41). Subsequent student performance evaluations used questionnaires and video recordings. After scenario simulations, the students showed a statistically significant increase in theoretical knowledge (p = 0.001) and clinical performance skills (p < 0.001), but there was no significant increase in self-confidence (p = 0.291). According to the video analysis, the “noticing” clinical judgment phase was the most frequently observed phase, while “reflection” was the least frequently observed phase. Additionally, “education” was the most frequently observed nursing domain, and “anxiety” was the least frequently observed domain. Although further simulation repetitions are required to reinforce students’ self-confidence when caring for patients with upper gastrointestinal bleeding, the scenario was deemed effective. Moreover, emphasis should be placed on developing various scenarios to strengthen students’ clinical judgment skills, especially “reflecting” and “emotional care.”