Biomechanical Impact of Localized Corneal Cross-linking Beyond the Irradiated Treatment Area

Use of Nanoindentation in Determination of Regional Biomechanical Properties of Rabbit Cornea After UVA Cross-Linking

Purpose

To evaluate the regional effects of different corneal cross-linking (CXL) protocols on corneal biomechanical properties.

Methods

The study involved both eyes of 50 rabbits, and the left eyes were randomized to the five intervention groups, which included the standard CXL group (SCXL), which was exposed to 3-mW/cm2 irradiation, and three accelerated CXL groups (ACXL1-3), which were exposed to ultraviolet-A at irradiations of 9 mW/cm2, 18 mW/cm2, and 30 mW/cm2, respectively, but with the same total dose (5.4 J/cm2). A control (CO) group was not exposed to ultraviolet-A. No surgery was done on the contralateral eyes. The corneas of each group were evaluated by the effective elastic modulus (Eeff) and the hydraulic conductivity (K) within a 7.5-mm radius using nanoindentation measurements.

Results

Compared with the CO group, Eeff (in regions with radii of 0-1.5 mm, 1.5-3.0 mm, and 3.0-4.5 mm) significantly increased by 309%, 276%, and 226%, respectively, with SCXL; by 222%, 209%, and 173%, respectively, with ACXL1; by 111%, 109%, and 94%, respectively, with ACXL2; and by 59%, 41%, and 37%, respectively, with ACXL3 (all P < 0.05). K was also significantly reduced by 84%, 81%, and 78%, respectively, with SCXL; by 75%, 74%, and 70%, respectively, with ACXL1; by 64%, 62%, and 61%, respectively, with ACXL2; and by 33%, 36%, and 32%, respectively, with ACXL3 (all P < 0.05). For the other regions(with radii between 4.5 and 7.5 mm), the SCXL and ACXL1 groups (but not the ACXL2 and ACXL3 groups) still showed significant changes in Eeff and K.

Conclusions

CXL had a significant effect on corneal biomechanics in both standard and accelerated procedures that may go beyond the irradiated area. The effect of CXL in stiffening the tissue and reducing permeability consistently decreased with reducing the irradiance duration.

Corneal Biomechanics Losses Caused by Refractive Surgery

Recent advances, specifically in the understanding of the biomechanical properties of the cornea and its response to diseases and surgical interventions, have significantly improved the safety and surgical outcomes of corneal refractive surgery, whose popularity and demand continue to grow worldwide. However, iatrogenic keratectasia resulting from the deterioration in corneal biomechanics caused by surgical interventions, although rare, remains a global concern. On one hand, in vivo biomechanical evaluation, enabled by clinical imaging systems such as the ORA and the Corvis ST, has significantly improved the risk profiling of patients for iatrogenic keratectasia. That is despite the fact the biomechanical metrics provided by these systems are considered indicators of the cornea's overall stiffness rather than its intrinsic material properties. On the other hand, new surgical modalities including SMILE were introduced to offer superior biomechanical performance to LASIK, but this superiority could not be proven clinically, creating more myths than answers. The literature also includes sound evidence that tPRK provided the highest preservation of corneal biomechanics when compared to both LASIK and SMILE. The aim of this review is twofold; to discuss the importance of corneal biomechanical evaluation prior to refractive surgery, and to assess the current understanding of cornea's biomechanical deterioration caused by mainstream corneal refractive surgeries. The review has led to an observation that new imaging techniques, parameters and evaluation systems may be needed to reflect the true advantages of specific refractive techniques and when these advantages are significant enough to offer better protection against post-surgery complications.

In Vivo Corneal Stiffness Mapping by the Stress-Strain Index Maps and Brillouin Microscopy

The study of corneal stiffness in vivo has numerous clinical applications such as the measurement of intraocular pressure, the preoperative screening for iatrogenic ectasia after laser vision correction surgery and the diagnosis and treatment of corneal ectatic diseases such as keratoconus. The localised aspect of the microstructure deterioration in keratoconus leading to local biomechanical softening, corneal bulging, irregular astigmatism and ultimately loss of vision boosted the need to map the corneal stiffness to identify the regional biomechanical failure. Currently, two methods to map the corneal stiffness in vivo are integrated into devices that are either already commercially available or about to be commercialised: the stress-strain index (SSI) maps and the Brillouin Microscopy (BM). The former method produces 2D map of stiffness across the corneal surface, developed through numerical simulations using the corneal shape, its microstructure content, and the deformation behaviour under air-puff excitation. It estimates the whole stress-strain behaviour, making it possible to obtain the material tangent modulus under different intraocular pressure levels. On the other hand, BM produces a 3D map of the corneal longitudinal modulus across the corneal surface and thickness. It uses a low-power near-infrared laser beam and through a spectral analysis of the returned signal, it assesses the mechanical compressibility of the tissue as measured by the longitudinal modulus. In this paper, these two techniques are reviewed, and their advantages and limitations discussed.

Comparison of two annular photorefractive intrastromal cross-linking protocols in high oxygen for low-grade myopia through 24-month follow-up

PURPOSE

To compare two annular epithelium-on (epi-on) high oxygen photorefractive intrastromal cross-linking (PiXL) illuminations protocols for treatment of low-grade myopia.

METHODS

In this randomized, single-masked, intra-individually comparative study, healthy individuals with bilateral low-grade myopia (manifest refractive spherical equivalent (MRSE) -0.75 diopters (D) to -2.50 D) were treated with high oxygen epi-on PiXL. One eye was randomized to receive pulsed accelerated 365-nm ultraviolet-A illumination in a central annular zone of 4.0 mm (1 second on, 1 second off; 30 mW/cm² ), and the fellow eye in a 3.5 mm annular zone (0.5 second on, 1 second off; 45 mW/cm² ). Uncorrected distance visual acuity (UDVA), MRSE, low-contrast visual acuity (LCVA), best spectacle corrected visual acuity (BSCVA), endothelial cell count (ECC) and Scheimpflug light scattering depths were assessed through 24-month follow-up.

RESULTS

Twenty-seven participants (54 eyes) were included. The 3.5 mm protocol rendered less subjective ocular discomfort posttreatment and a larger improvement than the 4.0 mm protocol in UDVA: -0.52 (-0.72, -0.32) logMAR (medians and interquartile ranges, IQR) and -0.38 (-0.50, -0.22), p = 0.003 and MRSE: +1.25 D (0.75, 1.50) and +1.0 (0.75, 1.0), p = 0.037. The transient reduction in LCVA was larger with the 3.5 mm protocol (p < 0.01). No adverse events, and no reductions in ECC or BSCVA were noted.

CONCLUSION

Epi-on PiXL in high oxygen reduces myopia in healthy eyes. A larger reduction of myopia and less early posttreatment subjective ocular discomfort can be seen with a smaller treatment zone, but likely at the expense of a transient decrease in low-contrast visual acuity.

Treatment effect with 2 photorefractive intrastromal cross-linking protocols in low-grade myopia through 24-month follow-up

PURPOSE

To assess the effect of two high-oxygen epi-on PiXL treatments for low-grade myopia.

METHODS

This prospective, randomized, intra-individually comparing, single-masked study included 23 healthy volunteers (46 eyes) aged 18-35 years with mild myopia, -0.75 to -2.50 D manifest refractive spherical equivalent (MRSE). One eye was randomized to a 4.0-mm homogenous treatment zone and the fellow eye to a 4.0-mm annular zone (16:40 min at 30 mW/cm² , fluence 15 J/cm² ). Uncorrected distance visual acuity (UDVA), MRSE, best spectacle-corrected visual acuity (BSCVA), Scheimpflug light scattering depths, mean keratometry (K_mean ) and endothelial cell count (ECC) were assessed through 24 months.

RESULTS

Similar improvements in UDVA were seen for the homogeneous and annular protocols at 1 month: -0.52 (-0.59, -0.39) and -0.49 (-0.59, -0.39) logMAR, respectively (medians and interquartile ranges, IQR), p = 0.91, and MRSE: +1.0 D (0.94, 1.31) and +1.0 D (0.69, 1.25), p = 0.17. Light scattering depths were 496 (465, 527) and 349 (247, 378) µm, respectively, and the reduction in mean keratometry was -0.8 D (-1.1, -0.7) and 0 D (-0.1, 0.1), p < 0.001. The treatment effect remained stable throughout 24 months. At 1 week, the participants reported less ocular discomfort with the annular protocol. No reductions were seen in BSCVA or ECC. No adverse events were reported.

CONCLUSION

PiXL can reduce low-grade myopia and improve uncorrected vision in healthy eyes. The initial ocular discomfort may be reduced with an annular treatment zone. Further studies are needed to optimize PiXL treatment parameters.

Advances in Imaging Technology of Anterior Segment of the Eye

Advances in imaging technology and computer science have allowed the development of newer assessment of the anterior segment, including Corvis ST, Brillouin microscopy, ultrahigh-resolution optical coherence tomography, and artificial intelligence. They enable accurate and precise assessment of structural and biomechanical alterations associated with anterior segment disorders. This review will focus on these 4 new techniques, and a brief overview of these modalities will be introduced. The authors will also discuss the recent advances in research regarding these techniques and potential application of these techniques in clinical practice. Many studies on these modalities have reported promising results, indicating the potential for more detailed comprehensive understanding of the anterior segment tissues.

Changes in Collagen Structure and Permeability of Rat and Human Sclera After Crosslinking

Purpose

To use second harmonic generation imaging and fluorescence recovery after photobleaching to demonstrate alterations in scleral collagen structure and permeability after crosslinking in rat and human eyes.

Methods

Excised rat and human scleras were imaged ex vivo with an inverted two-photon excitation fluorescence microscope before and after photochemical crosslinking using riboflavin and 405-nm laser light. Fluorescence recovery after photobleaching was applied to measure the diffusion of fluorescein isothiocyanate–dextran across the sclera.

Results

Crosslinking caused scleral collagen fibers to become wavier and more densely packed, with surface collagen being more affected than deeper collagen fibers. Crosslinked sclera showed significantly decreased permeability in the irradiation zone and also extended as far as 250 µm outside the irradiation zone.

Conclusions

Photochemical crosslinking induced changes in scleral structure and permeability that extended to tissue even outside the irradiation zone.

Translational Relevance

Ultrastructural changes associated with the emerging clinical technique of photochemical scleral crosslinking have not been well characterized. We demonstrate not only changes in scleral collagen by second harmonic generation imaging but also the associated functional changes in tissue permeability by fluorescence recovery after photobleaching. We report the novel finding of reduced permeability extending well beyond the direct irradiation zone. This has implications for control in the clinical setting.

A review of imaging modalities for detecting early keratoconus

OBJECTIVES

Early identification of keratoconus is imperative for preventing iatrogenic corneal ectasia and allowing for early corneal collagen cross-linking treatments to potentially halt progression and decrease transplant burden. However, early diagnosis of keratoconus is currently a diagnostic challenge as there is no uniform screening criteria. We performed a review of the current literature to assess imaging modalities that can be used to help identify subclinical keratoconus.

METHODS

A Pubmed database search was conducted. We included primary and empirical studies for evaluating different modalities of screening for subclinical keratoconus.

RESULTS

A combination of multiple imaging tools, including corneal topography, tomography, Scheimpflug imaging, anterior segment optical coherence tomography, and in vivo confocal microscopy will allow for enhanced determination of subclinical keratoconus. In patients who are diagnostically borderline using a single screening criteria, use of additional imaging techniques can assist in diagnosis. Modalities that show promise but need further research include polarization-sensitive optical coherence tomography, Brillouin microscopy, and atomic force microscopy.

CONCLUSIONS

Recognition of early keratoconus can reduce risk of post-refractive ectasia and reduce transplantation burden. Though there are no current uniform screening criterion, multiple imaging modalities have shown promise in assisting with the early detection of keratoconus.

Corneal Collagen Ordering After In Vivo Rose Bengal and Riboflavin Cross-Linking

Purpose

Photoactivated cornea collagen cross-linking (CXL) increases corneal stiffness by initiating formation of covalent bonds between stromal proteins. Because CXL depends on diffusion to distribute the photoinitiator, a gradient of CXL efficiency with depth is expected that may affect the degree of stromal collagen organization. We used second harmonic generation (SHG) microscopy to investigate the differences in stromal collagen organization in rabbit eyes after corneal CXL in vivo as a function of depth and time after surgery.

Methods

Rabbit corneas were treated in vivo with either riboflavin/UV radiation (UVX) or Rose Bengal/green light (RGX) and evaluated 1 and 2 months after CXL. Collagen fibers were imaged with a custom-built SHG scanning microscope through the central cornea (350 µm depth, 225 × 225 µm en face images). The order coefficient (OC), a metric for collagen organization, and total SHG signal were computed for each depth and compared between treatments.

Results

OC values of CXL-treated corneas were larger than untreated corneas by 27% and 20% after 1 month and 38% and 33% after 2 months for the RGX and UVX, respectively. RGX OC values were larger than UVX OC values by 3% and 5% at 1 and 2 months. The SHG signal was higher in CXL corneas than untreated corneas, both at 1 and 2 months after surgery, by 18% and 26% and 1% and 10% for RGX and UVX, respectively.

Conclusions

Increased OC corresponded with increased collagen fiber organization in CXL corneas. Changes in collagen organization parallel reported temporal changes in cornea stiffness after CXL and also, surprisingly, are detected deeper in the stroma than the regions stiffened by collagen cross-links.

Detecting Mechanical Anisotropy of the Cornea Using Brillouin Microscopy

Purpose

The purpose of this study was to detect the mechanical anisotropy of the cornea using Brillouin microscopy along different perturbation directions.

Methods

Brillouin frequency shift of both whole globes (n = 10) and cornea punches (n = 10) were measured at different angles to the incident laser, thereby probing corneal longitudinal modulus of elasticity along different directions. Frequency shift of virgin (n = 26) versus cross-linked corneas (n = 15) over a large range of hydration conditions were compared in order to differentiate the contributions to Brillouin shift due to hydration from those due to stromal tissue.

Results

We detected mechanical anisotropy of corneas, with an average frequency shift increase of 53 MHz and 96 MHz when the instrument probed from 0° to 15° and 30° along the direction of the stromal fibers. Brillouin microscopy did not lose sensitivity to mechanical anisotropy up to 96% water content. We experimentally measured and theoretically modeled how mechanical changes independent of hydration affect frequency shift as a result of corneal cross-linking by isolating an approximately 100 MHz increase in frequency shift following a cross-linking procedure purely due to changes of stromal tissue mechanics.

Conclusions

Brillouin microscopy is sensitive to mechanical anisotropy of the stroma even in highly hydrated corneas. The agreement between model and experimental data suggested a quantitative relationship between Brillouin frequency shift, hydration state of the cornea, and stromal tissue stiffness.

Translational Relevance

The protocol and model validated throughout this study offer a path for comprehensive measurements of corneal mechanics within the clinic; allowing for improved evaluation of the long-term mechanical efficacy of cross-linking procedures.

Multifunctional synthetic Bowman's membrane-stromal biomimetic for corneal reconstruction

As the outermost layer of the eye, the cornea is vulnerable to physical and chemical trauma, which can result in loss of transparency and lead to corneal blindness. Given the global corneal donor shortage, there is an unmet need for biocompatible corneal substitutes that have high transparency, mechanical integrity and regenerative potentials. Herein we engineered a dual-layered collagen vitrigel containing biomimetic synthetic Bowman's membrane (sBM) and stromal layer (sSL). The sBM supported rapid epithelial cell migration, maturation and multilayer formation, and the sSL containing tissue-derived extracellular matrix (ECM) microparticles presented a biomimetic lamellar ultrastructure mimicking the native corneal stroma. The incorporation of tissue-derived microparticles in sSL layer significantly enhanced the mechanical properties and suturability of the implant without compromising the transparency after vitrification. In vivo performance of the vitrigel in a rabbit anterior lamellar keratoplasty model showed full re-epithelialization within 14 days and integration of the vitrigel with the host tissue stroma by day 30. The migrated epithelial cells formed functional multilayer with limbal stem cell marker p63 K14 expressed in the lower layer, epithelial marker K3 and K12 expressed through the layers and tight junction protein ZO-1 expressed by the multilayers. Corneal fibroblasts migrated into the implants to facilitate host/implant integration and corneal stromal regeneration. In summary, these results suggest that the multi-functional layers of this novel collagen vitrigel exhibited significantly improved biological performance as corneal substitute by harnessing a fast re-epithelialization and stromal regeneration potential.

Optical coherence elastography by ambient pressure modulation for high-resolution strain mapping applied to patterned cross-linking

The purpose of this study was to develop a novel non-contact optical coherence elastography (OCE) approach to measure laterally and axially highly resolved corneal strain distribution at different stages of patterned corneal cross-linking (CXL). Freshly enucleated rat eyes were obtained and prepared for accelerated patterned CXL treatment with distinct ultraviolet (UV) patterns (central, peripheral, bow-tie irradiation). Each cornea was measured repeatedly, in three different conditions: (i) virgin, (ii) after epithelial debridement and 0.5% hypo-osmolar riboflavin instillation for 30 min, and (iii) after patterned CXL at 9 mW cm-2 for 10 min. For biomechanical assessment, the corneal deformation response to an ambient pressure variation of -2 mmHg was recorded by OCE. Strain maps were obtained from phase and magnitude changes in the complex optical coherence tomography signal. Virgin corneas presented negative strain (-2.7 ± 1.1‰) in the anterior cornea and positive strain (1.9 ± 1.3‰) in the posterior cornea. A pronounced shift towards positive strains in the anterior cornea (particularly in UV-irradiated regions) was observed after CXL. Patterned UV irradiation induced localized strain alterations closely matching the geometry of the irradiation pattern. This study demonstrates the possibility of non-contact OCE by ambient pressure modulation, which could substantially improve the early diagnosis of corneal degeneration, advance research in small-animal eyes and refine in vitro mechanical investigation.

Application of optical coherence tomography and optical path length method for monitoring corneal thickness and refractive index change during corneal cross-linking

Corneal cross-linking (CXL) using UVA irradiation with a riboflavin photosensitizer has emerged as a new treatment paradigm for corneal ectatic disorders. The thickness threshold for protection of intraocular structures has often been challenged with ongoing developments, and corneal thinning becomes an important safety concern, especially for patients with thin corneas. In this study with an ex vivo bovine eye model, we monitored corneal thinning and corneal refractive index changes using optical coherence tomography (OCT) integrated with an adaptation of the optical path length method. CXL experiments were performed based on the standard protocol that includes removal of the corneal epithelium to facilitate diffusion of riboflavin into the stroma. The corneal stromal thickness and group refractive index were measured by a 1310 nm Fourier-domain OCT imaging system at three critical points of the procedure: immediately after epithelial removal, after 30 min riboflavin instillation, and after 30 min UVA irradiation with continuing instillation. We found that the refractive index of the bovine cornea changed significantly from epithelial removal to riboflavin instillation and UVA irradiation, increasing from 1.377±0.005 (mean±standard deviation) after de-epithelization to 1.387±0.003 after 30 min instillation and 1.388±0.008 after subsequent irradiation. The corneas also underwent a considerable decrease (10%-20%) in stromal thickness with thinning of 95±29  μm (mean±standard deviation) after riboflavin instillation and a further decrease (∼5%) with thinning of 42±19  μm after UVA irradiation. Our study highlights the importance of corneal thickness monitoring during CXL, especially after riboflavin instillation when the decrease is the largest, to avoid delivering endothelial cytotoxic doses. An increase in refractive index heightens the concern for corneal thinning and the need for careful monitoring as a safety precaution.

Delayed-Onset Transient Light Sensitivity Syndrome after Corneal Collagen Cross-Linking: A Case Series

In this case series, we report a potentially novel association of corneal collagen crosslinking (CCL) with the development of photophobia symptoms in a series of patients at a tertiary ophthalmology clinic and describe their clinical course. Photosensitivity is a rare and seemingly unpredictable complication of refractive surgery but can present as a disabling, bilateral ocular pain that requires immediate treatment. This complication, termed transient light-sensitivity syndrome (TLSS), can have a substantially delayed presentation after ocular procedures and is associated with inflammation of structures in the anterior chamber that can be imperceptible on slit-lamp examination. Traditionally, exposure to high-energy femtosecond lasers is hypothesized to create stromal gas bubbles powering postoperative inflammatory reactions. TLSS-like symptoms after CCL may be due to a secondary inflammatory response involving activated keratocytes and cytokine release. However, free radical damage from the interaction of riboflavin and ultraviolet in CCL may also drive this inflammatory process.