Effects of immunosuppressants after penetrating keratoplasty: meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials

Outcomes following tacrolimus systemic immunosuppression for penetrating keratoplasty in infants and young children

OBJECTIVE

To report outcomes of tacrolimus immunosuppression after penetrating keratoplasty (PK) in very young children.

METHODS

Retrospective, consecutive, cohort study of children undergoing PK at a tertiary children's hospital between 2005 and 2016. Oral tacrolimus immunosuppression was given for 2 years, followed by topical tacrolimus.

RESULTS

Fourteen children (20 eyes) had 24 PKs; nineteen eyes had primary PKs, five eyes had repeat PKs. Mean age at primary graft was 95 days (3.1 months) for anterior segment dysgenesis (ASD), 430 days (14.3 months) for non-ASD children. Eleven children (15 eyes) had ASD. Three children (five eyes) had non-ASD: two children (three eyes) had glaucoma-related corneal opacity and one child (two eyes) had congenital hereditary endothelial dystrophy (CHED). One-year rejection-free survival rates following primary PK was 80% for ASD (n = 15) and 100% for non-ASD (n = 4). At final review, 5/15 of primary grafts for ASD were clear. 10/15 failed after a mean of 19 months, specifically attributable to infection (n = 2), rejection (n = 2) and glaucoma (n = 2). 4/4 primary non-ASD grafts are clear at final review (mean follow-up = 77 months). All repeat grafts (n = 5), failed after a mean of 38.25 months. Considering all grafts, 15/24 (62.5%) failed: 5/15 due to infection, 2/15 due to rejection, 8/15 due to glaucoma, phthisis, perforation or vascularised with no rejection. At last review (mean = 58.1 months, range 28-84), overall cohort survival is 37.5%. Final visual acuities range between 0.86 and 2.4 LogMAR.

CONCLUSION

We compare our results to published literature: 1-year graft survival was higher than previously reported, with lower failure due to rejection. Overall infection rates did not increase, however, proportionally, severe infections were higher. Overall graft survival is at least comparable to reported literature.

High-risk corneal allografts: A therapeutic challenge

Corneal transplantation is the most common surgical procedure amongst solid organ transplants with a high survival rate of 86% at 1-year post-grafting. This high success rate has been attributed to the immune privilege of the eye. However, mechanisms originally thought to promote immune privilege, such as the lack of antigen presenting cells and vessels in the cornea, are challenged by recent studies. Nevertheless, the immunological and physiological features of the cornea promoting a relatively weak alloimmune response is likely responsible for the high survival rate in “low-risk” settings. Furthermore, although corneal graft survival in “low-risk” recipients is favourable, the prognosis in “high-risk” recipients for corneal graft is poor. In “high-risk” grafts, the process of indirect allorecognition is accelerated by the enhanced innate and adaptive immune responses due to pre-existing inflammation and neovascularization of the host bed. This leads to the irreversible rejection of the allograft and ultimately graft failure. Many therapeutic measures are being tested in pre-clinical and clinical studies to counter the immunological challenge of “high-risk” recipients. Despite the prevailing dogma, recent data suggest that tissue matching together with use of systemic immunosuppression may increase the likelihood of graft acceptance in “high-risk” recipients. However, immunosuppressive drugs are accompanied with intolerance/side effects and toxicity, and therefore, novel cell-based therapies are in development which target host immune cells and restore immune homeostasis without significant side effect of treatment. In addition, developments in regenerative medicine may be able to solve both important short comings of allotransplantation: (1) graft rejection and ultimate graft failure; and (2) the lack of suitable donor corneas. The advances in technology and research indicate that wider therapeutic choices for patients may be available to address the worldwide problem of corneal blindness in both “low-risk” and “high-risk” hosts.

Systemic immunosuppression with mycophenolate mofetil to prevent corneal graft rejection after high-risk penetrating keratoplasty: a 2-year follow-up study

Purpose

In this study, we aimed to evaluate the efficacy and safety of systemic immunosuppression with mycophenolate mofetil (MMF) to prevent corneal graft rejection after high-risk penetrating keratoplasty.

Methods

One hundred and ninety-six consecutive patients who underwent high-risk penetrating keratoplasty defined as the presence of deep vascularization in more than two quadrants, keratouveitis, emergency keratoplasties, and retransplantations were enrolled in the study. Ninety-eight prospectively followed up patients were treated with MMF [with dose adjustment based on mycophenolic acid (MPA) serum concentration], and 98 patients were in the non–MMF-treated retrospectively assessed control group.

Results

During a mean of 24 months of observation, immune reactions occurred in eight cases (8 %) and graft rejection with subsequent graft failure occurred in three cases (3 %) in the MMF group. In the control group, graft rejection occurred in 76 cases (78 %) and failure due to graft rejection occurred in 30 cases (31 %). Kaplan–Meier analysis demonstrated that 93 % of the grafts in the MMF-treated group and 47 % in the control group showed no immune rejection (p < 0.01, log-rank test) after a year. Cox regression analysis proved that MMF treatment decreased the risk of graft rejection 11 times (RR = 11, 95.0 % CI 4.8–25, p < 0.0001). Among 98 MMF-treated patients, 13 had gastric discomfort, three developed leucopenia, and two had anemia that resolved after MMF dose reduction.

Conclusions

MMF treatment after high risk penetrating keratoplasty is safe and reduces the incidence of immune graft rejection and graft failure. Side effects were rare and reversible in all but one case.