The effect of implant diameter on strain around implants retaining a mandibular overdenture with Locator attachments: An in vitro study

A modal analysis of implant-supported overdentures installed on differently positioned sets of dental implants

This study evaluated the three vibration characteristics, namely, natural frequency, damping ratio, and natural mode, together with maximum displacement of a two-implant-supported overdenture (IOD) at different locator attachment positions using experimental modal analysis (EMA). Edentulous mandibular models with a gingival thickness of 1 mm or 3 mm were prepared, into which dental implants were placed using a fully guided surgical template designed with simulation software, the locator abutments were fastened, and the IODs were then fabricated. The implant positions were bilaterally marked at the lateral incisor, first premolar, and first molar regions. EMA was performed by hammering the test structures to measure the impulse response and obtain the vibration characteristics (n = 5). The Kruskal-Wallis test was performed for natural frequency and maximum displacement, and the Games-Howell test for damping ratio. The significance level was set at α = 0.05. The study indicated that the gingival thickness had a significant effect on the vibration characteristics. Moreover, the natural frequency and damping ratio results showed that the vibration subsided faster when the attachment was placed on the molar implants in the thick gingival model. Furthermore, according to the effect of lateral force on IODs, the difference in maximum displacement between the anterior and posterior regions of the IOD was smaller when the attachments were designed on the pair of lateral incisors. Thus, within the limits of this experiment, our results suggested that two anterior implant-supported IODs are preferable treatment designs in terms of vibration engineering, especially when the gingiva is thick; the molar attachment design could be considered for thin gingival conditions. The differences in gingival thickness and abutment position affected the vibration characteristics of the IOD. Further in vivo studies would be necessary to validate the implant positions and their IOD designs for the mandibular edentulous shapes and the occlusal relationship.

In vitro study of the effect of implant position and attachment type on stress distribution of implant-assisted removable partial dentures

Background/purpose

Implant assisted removable partial dentures (IARPDs) improved biomechanical behavior of removable partial dentures (RPDs), but information of the effect of attachment type and implant position is limited. This study aimed to investigate the effect of implant position and attachment type on the stress distribution of IARPDs.

Material and methods

Four implants, 10 mm in length and 4.1 mm in diameter, were bilaterally placed close to first premolar and second molar regions of a mandibular Kennedy class I model having artificial dentition from canine to canine, vertical to the occlusal plane. Five IARPDs were fabricated to accommodate locator and magnetic attachments. Strain gauges were placed on the model surface to measure the strain around implants during loading. Unilateral vertical loading was applied to the right first molar area with magnitude of 120 N and crosshead speed of 10 mm/min. Measurements were recorded under following conditions: premolar IARPDs with locator or magnetic attachments, molar IARPDs with locator or magnetic attachments. Two-way multiple analysis of variance was performed to compare the maximum principal strain (MPS) around the implants with a significance level of 0.05.

Results

Implant position had significant effect on the MPS of IARPD on loading and nonloading sides while attachment type only significant on nonloading side. Molar implants showed larger MPS than premolar implants with both locator and magnetic attachments during unilateral loading.

Conclusion

The stress distribution of the IARPD is significantly affected by implant position wherein anteriorly placed implants exhibit lower MPS than relatively posteriorly placed implants.

Preliminary study of clinical outcomes for single implant-retained mandibular overdentures

This study evaluated marginal bone loss and prosthetic complications associated with single implant-retained mandibular overdentures (1-IODs) with locator attachments. The 1-IOD was placed in the mandibular midline by using a conventional loading protocol in 22 patients with an edentulous mandible. Marginal bone loss at the start of loading and 12 months postoperatively was assessed by radiographic and crestal bone evaluation. The crestal bone was defined as the distance between the customized abutment shoulder and the top of the bone, as indicated by probing. In addition, implant stability quotient and prosthetic complications were recorded. The cumulative implant survival rate was 95.5%. Median implant stability quotient remained greater than 80, and median radiographic bone loss was 0.56 mm. Crestal measurement showed a median crestal bone loss of 0.16, 0.43, 0.39, and 0.52 mm on the buccal, right, lingual, and left sides, respectively. Both radiographic and crestal bone loss values significantly differed between the start of implant loading and 12 months postoperatively (except on the buccal and lingual sides; P < 0.05). The need to replace the nylon insert was the most common complication. Conventional loading of a 1-IOD with a locator attachment resulted in a high survival rate, good implant stability, and acceptable marginal bone loss.