Effect of fluid contamination on reverse torque values in implant-abutment connections under oral conditions

The effect of contaminating media on the static and dynamic mechanical resilience of dental implant abutments' screws: In vitro study

INTRODUCTION

This in vitro study aims to biomechanically evaluate the influence of medium contamination for example, saliva, blood, chlorhexidine (liquid and gel), and fluoride mouthwash on the biomechanical behavior of implant abutments' screws under static and dynamic loading.

METHODS

Forty five Ti6Al4V commercial dental implants and abutments were tested in this study. Two main mechanical tests were carried out in the selected media. The first, static, aimed to evaluate the torque loss after the first tightening. The second, dynamic, involved a random cyclic load range between 0 and 200 N to evaluate torque loss due to mastication. In addition, metallographic longitudinal and cross-sections of the abutment-implant apparatus were examined to evaluate the abutment screw-abutment-implant interface.

RESULTS

The static torque test showed that irrespective of the media, no statistical difference in static torque loss was found prior to dynamic loading. For the dynamic tests, torque-angle evolution analysis during tightening to 30 Ncm and after the spectrum loading, showed the same global mechanical behavior for all media, but the statistical analysis indicated a difference between the groups in reverse torque values (RTV) and in the torque loss due to dynamic loading. The medium groups CHX, CHX-gel, and Fluoride mouthwash, showed a meaningful torque loss due to loading, but the medium groups, control (no medium), blood and saliva showed an opposite trend and required a higher torque to open the abutment screws. The microstructural analysis revealed clear signs of cold-welding/galling, post-dynamic loading in these latter groups.

CONCLUSIONS

The presence of lubrication/contamination media (CHX mouthwash/CHX-gel/Fluoride mouthwash) reduces the preload generated due to tightening but prevents damage due to galling. The observed reduction of RTV clearly emphasizes the need for frequent abutment screw retightening for implant-supported prosthetic long-term stability.

Bacterial Detection, Deformation, and Torque Loss on Dental Implants with Different Tapered Connections Compared with External Hexagon Connection after Thermomechanical Cycling

The relationship between bacterial infiltration and internal conical Implant-Abutment Interfaces (IAIs) with different conicities still requires investigations that can offer valuable information in the clinical understanding of peri-implant health. The present study aimed to verify the bacterial infiltration of two internal conical connections with an angulation of 11.5° and 16° with the external hexagonal connection as a comparative after thermomechanical cycling using saliva as a contaminant. Test (n = 10) and control (n = 3) groups were set up. Evaluations were made on torque loss, Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM), and Micro Computerized Tomography (MicroCT) after performing 2 × 10⁶ mechanical cycles (120 N) and 600 thermal cycles (5°-55° C) with 2 mm lateral displacement. The contents of the IAI were collected for microbiological analysis. There was a difference (p < 0.05) in torque loss of the groups tested; groups from the 16° IAI obtained a lower percentage of torque loss. All groups presented contamination and the analysis of the results shows that the microbiological profile of the IAI differs qualitatively from the profile found in the saliva used for contamination. The mechanical loading affects the microbiological profile found in the IAIs (p < 0.05). In conclusion, the IAI environment may favor a microbiological profile different from that of saliva and the thermocycling condition may alter the microbial profile found in the IAI.

Effects of Blood Contamination and Decontamination Protocol on Reverse Torque Value of Abutment Screws in Dental Implants: An In Vitro Study

Background and Objective: Loosening of abutment screws in dental implants is a mechanical complication that affects prosthetic treatments and hence, patient satisfaction. Blood contamination of abutment screws may play a role in this phenomenon. However, only limited research attention has been given to this issue. In the present study, we determined the effect of blood contamination and decontamination protocol on the reverse torque value (RTV) of abutment screws. Materials and Methods: A questionnaire-based survey was sent to 210 implantologists requesting feedback on their attitude to the blood contamination issue and the decontamination protocols used. The survey responses were used in a selection of the decontamination solutions that were used in the subsequent in vitro study on the effects of blood decontamination protocol on the RTV of abutment screws. Thus, three study groups were used (n = 20 abutment screws in each group): Group 1 (control group; blood-contaminated screws); Group 2 (screws decontaminated with 5.25% sodium hypochlorite (NaOCl) solution); and Group 3 (screws decontaminated with normal saline solution (0.9%)). Then, each of the connections were subjected to thermocycling, and RTVs of the screw were measured using a digital torque meter. Intragroup and intergroup RTVs were analyzed for significance using analysis of variance (ANOVA) and Tukey's honestly significant difference (HSD) tests. Results: 48% of the implantologists responded to the survey; 80% of them were concerned with blood contamination in the implant connection, especially before abutment loading and 85% of them used either chlorhexidine solution or normal saline solution as the decontamination agent. The mean RTV for Group 2 screws (30.27 ± 2.8 N.cm) was significantly greater than that for Group 3 screws (26.02 ± 1.99 N.cm) which, in turn, was significantly greater than that for Group 1 screws (23.64 ± 1.84 N.cm). Conclusion: Decontamination of blood-covered connections using 5.25% NaOCl solution or normal saline solution restores the RTV of abutment screws. This finding may have clinical relevance in that the decontaminated screws may contribute to the low incidence of screw loosening and, ultimately, improved patient satisfaction.

Evaluation the loosening of abutment screws in fluid contamination: an in vitro study

Screw loosening is one of the most common clinical problems of dental implants. Research on the influencing factors of screw loosening is very important to prevent screw loosening. The purpose of this in vitro study was to evaluate the influence of liquid contamination on the screw loosening. According to the contamination condition, forty-five abutment screws were divided into three groups (n = 15): no contamination, artificial saliva contamination, and mouthwash contamination. The preload and friction coefficient of the abutment screws were recorded. Then, the reverse torque values (RTVs) and settlement were measured after 3.0 × 10⁵ and 6.0 × 10⁵ cycles. The surface wear of the screws was analyzed. Finally, the stress distribution of the abutment screws was calculated by finite element analysis (FEA). The results showed that fluid contamination reduced the friction coefficient, increased the preload, decrease the settlement, improved resistance to screw loosening, and reduced wear on the thread surface. Appropriate antimicrobial lubrication may improve the anti-loosening performance of abutment screws and prevent excessive wear on the threaded surface.

The effect of the digital manufacturing technique of cantilevered implant-supported frameworks on abutment screw preload

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to investigate the misfit and screw preload at the implant abutment connection of implant supported fixed dental prosthesis with cantilever (ICFDP) manufactured using different digital manufacturing techniques and to compare the screw preload before and after cyclic loading.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Mandibular jaw model with four intra-foraminal implants was scanned using digital scanner. Stereolithography file was used to design a framework with nonengaging (NE) abutments and 10 mm cantilever distal to one terminal implant. Five frameworks were constructed using combined digital-conventional techniques (CAD-cast), and five frameworks were constructed using three-dimensional printing (3DP). Additional CAD-cast framework was constructed in a way that ensures passive fit (PF) to use as control. Scanning electron microscope (SEM) measured the implant abutment connection misfit. Sixty screws were used on the corresponding frameworks. Screws were torqued and pre-cyclic loading reverse torque value (RTV) was recorded. Frameworks were subjected to 200,000 loading cycles with a loading point 9 mm from the center of terminal implants adjacent to the cantilever and post-cyclic loading RTVs were recorded.

RESULTS

Microscopic readings showed significant differences between frameworks. PF demonstrated the lowest measurements of 16.04 (2.6) µm while CAD-cast demonstrated the highest measurements of 29.2 (3.1) µm. In all groups, RTVs were significantly lower than the applied torque. Post-cyclic loading RTV was significantly lower than pre-cyclic loading RTV in PF and 3DP frameworks. Differences in RTVs between the three manufacturing techniques were insignificant.

CONCLUSION

Although CAD-cast and three-dimensionally printed (3DP) both produce frameworks with clinically acceptable misfit, 3DP might not be the technique of choice for maintaining screw’s preload stability under an aggressive loading situation.