Expansion of tumor-T cell pairs from fine needle aspirates of melanoma metastases

Lack of B and T cell reactivity towards IDH1R132H in blood and tumor tissue from LGG patients

Purpose

Mutations in the isocitrate dehydrogenase-1 gene (IDH1) occur at high frequency in grade II–III gliomas (LGGs). IDH1 mutations are somatic, missense and heterozygous affecting codon 132 in the catalytic pocket of the enzyme. In LGG, most mutations (90%) result in an arginine to histidine substitution (IDH1^R132H) providing a neo-epitope that is expressed in all tumor cells. To assess the immunogenic nature of this epitope, and its potential use to develop T cell treatments, we measured IDH1^R132H-specific B and T cell reactivity in blood and tumor tissue of LGG patients.

Methods

Sera from IDH1^R132H-mutated LGG patients (n = 27) were assayed for the presence of a neo-specific antibody response using ELISA. In addition, PBMCs (n = 36) and tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes (TILs, n = 10) were measured for T cell activation markers and IFN-γ production by flow cytometry and ELISA. In some assays, frequencies of CD4 T cells specific for mutated peptide presented by HLA-DR were enriched prior to T cell monitoring assays.

Results

Despite high sensitivity of our assay, we failed to detect IDH1^R132H-specific IgG in sera of LGG patients. Similarly, we did not observe CD4 T cell reactivity towards IDH1^R132H in blood, neither did we observe such reactivity following pre-enrichment of frequencies of IDH1^R132H-specific CD4 T cells. Finally, we did not detect IDH1^R132H-specific CD4 T cells among TILs.

Conclusions

The absence of both humoral and cellular responses in blood and tumors of LGG patients indicates that IDH1^R132H is not sufficiently immunogenic and devaluates its further therapeutic exploitation, at least in the majority of LGG patients.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (10.1007/s11060-019-03228-6) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Selection of Tumor-Specific Cytotoxic T Lymphocytes in Acute Myeloid Leukemia Patients Through the Identification of T-Cells Capable to Establish Stable Interactions With the Leukemic Cells: "Doublet Technology"

The relevance of the immune system in cancer has long been studied. Autologous adoptive T cell therapies, based on the use of tumor infiltrating lymphocytes (TILs), have made great progress in recent years for the treatment of solid tumors, especially melanoma. However, further work is needed to isolate tumor-reactive T cells among patients diagnosed with hematologic malignancies. The dynamics of the interaction between T cells and antigen presenting cells (APC) dictate the quality of the immune responses. While stable joints between target cells and T lymphocytes lead to the induction of T cell activation and immune response, brief contacts contribute to the induction of immune-tolerance. Taking advantage of the strong interaction between target cell and activated T-cells, we show the feasibility to identify and isolate tumor-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) from acute myeloid leukemia (AML) patients by flow cytometry. Using this technology, CTLs bound through T cell receptor (TCR) to tumor cells can be identified in peripheral blood and bone marrow and subsequently selected and isolated by FACS-based cell sorting. These CTLs display higher percentage of effector cells and marked cytotoxic activity against AML blasts. In conclusion, we have developed a new procedure to identify and select specific cytotoxic T cells in patients diagnosed with acute myeloid leukemia.

Tumor Microenvironment: What have we Learned Studying the Immune Response in this Puzzling Battlefield?

Recent developments hallmark the progress in the understanding of tumor immunology and related therapeutic strategies. The administration of interleukin-2 (IL-2) to patients with cancer has shown that immune manipulation can mediate the regression of established cancers. The identification of the genes encoding cancer antigens and the development of means for effectively immunizing against these antigens has opened new avenues for the development of active immunization of patients with cancer. However, an efficient immune response against tumor comprises an intricate molecular network still poorly understood. Only when the code governing immune responsiveness of cancer will be deciphered, new therapeutic strategies could be designed to fit biologically defined mechanisms of immune rejection of cancer.

In this review, we propose that the mechanisms regulating tumor rejection in response to vaccination will be more efficiently identified by following the evolution of treatment induced events within the tumor microenvironment taking advantage of recently developed technological tools. As a model, we will discuss the observed immune response to tumor antigen -specific immunization and its relationship with the systemic administration of IL-2.

Whole Body Melanoma Transcriptome Response in Medaka

The incidence of malignant melanoma continues to increase each year with poor prognosis for survival in many relapse cases. To reverse this trend, whole body response measures are needed to discover collaborative paths to primary and secondary malignancy. Several species of fish provide excellent melanoma models because fish and human melanocytes both appear in the epidermis, and fish and human pigment cell tumors share conserved gene expression signatures. For the first time, we have examined the whole body transcriptome response to invasive melanoma as a prelude to using transcriptome profiling to screen for drugs in a medaka (Oryzias latipes) model. We generated RNA-seq data from whole body RNA isolates for controls and melanoma fish. After testing for differential expression, 396 genes had significantly different expression (adjusted p-value <0.02) in the whole body transcriptome between melanoma and control fish; 379 of these genes were matched to human orthologs with 233 having annotated human gene symbols and 14 matched genes that contain putative deleterious variants in human melanoma at varying levels of recurrence. A detailed canonical pathway evaluation for significant enrichment showed the top scoring pathway to be antigen presentation but also included the expected melanocyte development and pigmentation signaling pathway. Results revealed a profound down-regulation of genes involved in the immune response, especially the innate immune system. We hypothesize that the developing melanoma actively suppresses the immune system responses of the body in reacting to the invasive malignancy, and that this mal-adaptive response contributes to disease progression, a result that suggests our whole-body transcriptomic approach merits further use. In these findings, we also observed novel genes not yet identified in human melanoma expression studies and uncovered known and new candidate drug targets for further testing in this malignant melanoma medaka model.

Direct T cell-tumour interaction triggers TH1 phenotype activation through the modification of the mesenchymal stromal cells transcriptional programme

BACKGROUND

Mesenchymal stromal cells (MSCs) are heterogeneous cells with immunoregulatory and wound-healing properties. In cancer, they are known to be an essential part of the tumour microenvironment. However, their role in tumour growth and rejection remains unclear. To investigate this, we co-cultured human MSCs, tumour infiltrating lymphocytes (TIL), and melanoma cells to investigate the role of MSCs in the tumour environment.

METHODS

Mesenchymal stromal cells were co-cultured with melanoma antigen-specific TIL that were stimulated either with HLA-A*0201(+) melanoma cells or with a corresponding clone that had lost HLA-A*0201 expression.

RESULTS

Activated TIL induced profound pro-inflammatory gene expression signature in MSCs. Analysis of culture supernatant found that MSCs secreted pro-inflammatory cytokines, including TH1 cytokines that have been previously associated with immune-mediated antitumor responses. In addition, immunohistochemical analysis on selected markers revealed that the same activated MSCs secreted both the TH1 cytokine (interleukin-12) and indoleamine 2,3 dioxygenase (IDO), a classical immunosuppressive factor.

CONCLUSIONS

This study reflected that the plasticity of MSCs is highly dependent upon microenvironment conditions. Tumour-activated TIL induced TH1 phenotype change in MSCs that is qualitatively similar to the previously described immunologic constant of rejection signature observed during immune-mediated, tissue-specific destruction. This response may be responsible for the in loco amplification of antigen-specific anti-cancer immune response.

Effector CD4 and CD8 T cells and their role in the tumor microenvironment

T cells in tumors—the so-called tumor infiltrating lymphocytes (TIL) have been studied intensively over the past years. Compelling evidence point to a clinical relevance for high numbers of T cells at the tumor site with CD8 memory T cells as a key denominator for overall survival (OS) in patients with colo-rectal cancer (CRC), and also for others solid cancers. These data goes hand in hand with studies of clonality of TIL showing the T cells among TIL are expanded clonally, and also that tumor specific T cells of CD4 as well as CD8 type are enriched at the tumor site. The tumor microenvironment is hostile to T cell function e.g., due to expression of enzymes that depletes the amino acids tryptophan and arginine, high concentration of tumor secreted lactate, and presence innate cells or regulatory T cells both with suppressive activity. Analyses of the specificity of TILs in melanoma demonstrate that quite few known antigens are in fact recognized by these cultures underscoring patient unique and/or mutated antigens may represent important target for recognition.

Dissection of T-cell antigen specificity in human melanoma

Tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes (TIL) isolated from melanoma patients and expanded in vitro by interleukin (IL)-2 treatment can elicit therapeutic response after adoptive transfer, but the antigen specificities of the T cells transferred have not been determined. By compiling all known melanoma-associated antigens and applying a novel technology for high-throughput analysis of T-cell responses, we dissected the composition of melanoma-restricted T-cell responses in 63 TIL cultures. T-cell reactivity screens against 175 melanoma-associated epitopes detected 90 responses against 18 different epitopes predominantly from differentiation and cancer-testis antigens. Notably, the majority of these responses were of low frequency and tumor-specific T-cell frequencies decreased during rapid expansion. A further notable observation was a large variation in the T-cell specificities detected in cultures established from different fragments of resected melanoma lesions. In summary, our findings provide an initial definition of T-cell populations contributing to tumor recognition in TILs although the specificity of many tumor-reactive TILs remains undefined.

Comparison of three culture media for the establishment of melanoma cell lines

Melanoma cell lines are useful tools for the analysis of tumor-specific lymphocytes which are injected to patients treated by adoptive immunotherapy. So they have been established previously (with an efficacy of 47%) in Roswell Park Memorial Institute (RPMI) medium enriched with fetal calf serum (FCS). In order to improve the probability of establishing melanoma cell lines, we compared two FCS-free media with the original FCS medium. Ten melanoma-invaded lymph nodes were tested for their ability to grow in three different culture media: RPMI with FCS; RPMI with human serum (HS); serum-free X-vivo 15 (X15). For each medium, we compared the following criteria: percentage of lines obtained; period of establishment; cell morphology; expression of melanoma-associated antigens and surface molecules. More cell lines were obtained with HS and X15 media compared to FCS medium (7/10, 5/10 and 4/10, respectively). The time period to establish a stable line was similar for the three media. No morphological differences were observed in cells derived from the same tumor sample in the different media. With the X15 medium, cells generally expressed lower levels of melanocytic differentiation antigens and surface molecules. The growth of melanoma cell lines in FCS-free culture media appears possible and advantageous, with an increased probability of obtaining autologous tumor cell lines. Furthermore the cells obtained could be used as multiple antigenic sources in active or adoptive immunotherapy protocols.

Generation and characterization of non-small-cell lung cancer cell lines and clones for use in the study of immunotherapy

The in vitro study of cancer has been made easier by the use of stable tumor cell (TC) lines derived from patients to study antigen expression, immunogenicity, and response to both experimental and conventional therapeutic agents. However, the routine generation of these cell lines in some tumor histologies such as non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC) is difficult. In many cases, colonies of TCs do not survive, most likely due to a lack of critical growth factors in cell culture medium. Other times, TC colonies are overgrown by fibroblasts, which appear to have less stringent growth requirements. In some cases, cultures are overgrown by bacteria or mold contained in the biopsy arriving from the surgical or pathology suite. This study presents the characteristics of three new NSCLC cell lines and associated autologous clones generated from both adenocarcinoma and squamous cell carcinoma tissue. Different culture media and variable techniques were used to generate these stable TC lines. Limiting dilution analysis resulted in numerous clones, some of which displayed heterogeneity in terms of growth, antigen expression, and the ability to release cytokines. The successes and failures associated with generating TC lines are discussed in this article. Both parental cultures and related clones serve as critical reagents for the continued study of the cellular immune response to NSCLC.

Capture of tumor cell membranes by trogocytosis facilitates detection and isolation of tumor-specific functional CTLs

The success of adoptive cell transfer in the treatment of metastatic cancer in humans is dependent on the selection of highly active tumor-specific cytotoxic T cells. We report here that CTLs capture membrane fragments from their targets while exerting cytotoxic activity and thus gain a detectable functional signature by which they can be identified. Fluorochrome labeling or biotinylation was used to tag tumor cells. CD8(+) T cells were coincubated with the tagged targets, sorted, and functionally evaluated. Our results show that membrane capture by CD8(+) lymphocytes is T-cell receptor dependent, epitope specific, and preferentially associated with highly cytotoxic clonal subsets. CTLs that captured membranes from unmodified melanoma exhibited enhanced cytotoxic activity against tumor cell lines and autologous melanoma. In a human melanoma in vivo model, adoptive transfer of membrane-capturing, peptide-specific T cells, but not noncapturing or bulk CD8(+) T cells, inhibits tumor progression. Membrane capture is therefore a signature of antigen-specific CTLs endowed with high functional avidity and may have direct relevance in the clinical application of adoptive immunotherapy.

Signatures associated with rejection or recurrence in HER-2/neu-positive mammary tumors

We have previously shown T-cell-mediated rejection of the neu-overexpressing mammary carcinoma cells (MMC) in wild-type FVB mice. However, following rejection of primary tumors, a fraction of animals experienced a recurrence of a neu antigen-negative variant (ANV) of MMC (tumor evasion model) after a long latency period. In the present study, we determined that T cells derived from wild-type FVB mice can specifically recognize MMC by secreting IFN-gamma and can induce apoptosis of MMC in vitro. Neu transgenic (FVBN202) mice develop spontaneous tumors and cannot reject it (tumor tolerance model). To dissect the mechanisms associated with rejection or tolerance of MMC tumors, we compared transcriptional patterns within the tumor microenvironment of MMC undergoing rejection with those that resisted it either because of tumor evasion/antigen loss recurrence (ANV tumors) or because of intrinsic tolerance mechanisms displayed by the transgenic mice. Gene profiling confirmed that immune rejection is primarily mediated through activation of IFN-stimulated genes and T-cell effector mechanisms. The tumor evasion model showed combined activation of Th1 and Th2 with a deviation toward Th2 and humoral immune responses that failed to achieve rejection likely because of lack of target antigen. Interestingly, the tumor tolerance model instead displayed immune suppression pathways through activation of regulatory mechanisms that included in particular the overexpression of interleukin-10 (IL-10), IL-10 receptor, and suppressor of cytokine signaling (SOCS)-1 and SOCS-3. These data provide a road map for the identification of novel biomarkers of immune responsiveness in clinical trials.

Tumour immunity: effector response to tumour and role of the microenvironment

Substantial evidence shows that inflammation promotes oncogenesis and, occasionally, participates in cancer rejection. This paradox can be accounted for by a dynamic switch from chronic smouldering inflammation promoting cancer-cell survival to florid, tissue-disruptive inflammatory reactions that trigger cancer-cell destruction. Clinical and experimental observations suggest that the mechanism of this switch recapitulates the events associated with pathogen infection, which stimulate immune cells to recognise danger signals and activate immune effector functions. Generally, cancers do not have danger signals and, therefore, they cannot elicit strong immune reactions. Synthetic molecules have been developed that mimic pathogen invasion at the tumour site. These compounds activate dendritic cells to produce proinflammatory cytokines, which in turn trigger cytotoxic mechanisms leading to cancer death. Simultaneously, dendritic cells capture antigen shed by dying cancer cells, undergo activation, and stimulate antigen-specific T and B cells. This process results in massive amplification of the antineoplastic inflammatory process. Thus, although anti-inflammatory drugs can prevent onset of some malignant diseases, induction of T cells specific for tumour antigen by active immunisation, combined with powerful activation signals within the cancer microenvironment, might yield the best strategy for treatment of established cancers.

Overview of melanoma vaccines and promising approaches

It is difficult to envision anything better than melanoma vaccines to exemplify the effectiveness of modern biotechnology in developing biologically rational therapeutics. Melanoma vaccines can reproducibly induce cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) responses better than any other anticancer therapy. Anticancer vaccines have been labeled by some as ineffective for the simple reason that they only rarely lead to cancer regression. This oxymoron stems from the naïve expectation that CTLs are all that is needed to reject cancer. Little is known about requirements for CTL localization and effector function within the tumor microenvironment. In the future, more attention should be given to events downstream of immunization (afferent arm of immune response) to identify combination therapies likely to facilitate localization and activation of CTL at the receiving end (efferent arm).

Immune monitoring

A wide array of immunologic tests are available for immune monitoring in cancer vaccine trials, and the number of novel assays and technical modifications continues to burgeon. Because only a small fraction of all proposed vaccine trials tested in phase I-II trials, for practical reasons, will ultimately move forward to be tested in phase III trials, there must be a system of establishing the most promising immunization strategies. This evaluation of cancer vaccine will require standardization of the immune assays and statistical methods used in immunologic monitoring. Furthermore, the use of a systematic approach to evaluating and adopting novel technologies for immunologic assessment would likely lead to timely implementation of more reliable, practical and cost-effective methods of immune. It should be the goal and expectation that this rational approach to immune monitoring will allow the critical appraisal of the most promising vaccine candidates in the context of pivotal, multi-center trials.

Sequential gene profiling of basal cell carcinomas treated with imiquimod in a placebo-controlled study defines the requirements for tissue rejection

An analysis of basal cell carcinoma subjected to local application of imiquimod revealed that most transcripts stimulated by imiquimod involve the activation of cellular innate and adaptive immune-effector mechanisms.

Background

Imiquimod is a Toll-like receptor-7 agonist capable of inducing complete clearance of basal cell carcinoma (BCC) and other cutaneous malignancies. We hypothesized that the characterization of the early transcriptional events induced by imiquimod may provide insights about immunological events preceding acute tissue and/or tumor rejection.

Results

We report a paired analysis of adjacent punch biopsies obtained pre- and post-treatment from 36 patients with BCC subjected to local application of imiquimod (n = 22) or vehicle cream (n = 14) in a blinded, randomized protocol. Four treatments were assessed (q12 applications for 2 or 4 days, or q24 hours for 4 or 8 days). RNA was amplified and hybridized to 17.5 K cDNA arrays. All treatment schedules similarly affected the transcriptional profile of BCC; however, the q12 × 4 days regimen, associated with highest effectiveness, induced the most changes, with 637 genes unequivocally stimulated by imiquimod. A minority of transcripts (98 genes) confirmed previous reports of interferon-α involvement. The remaining 539 genes portrayed additional immunological functions predominantly involving the activation of cellular innate and adaptive immune-effector mechanisms. Importantly, these effector signatures recapitulate previous observations of tissue rejection in the context of cancer immunotherapy, acute allograft rejection and autoimmunity.

Conclusion

This study, based on a powerful and reproducible model of cancer eradication by innate immune mechanisms, provides the first insights in humans into the early transcriptional events associated with immune rejection. This model is likely representative of constant immunological pathways through which innate and adaptive immune responses combine to induce tissue destruction.

Immunobiology of the sentinel lymph node and its potential role for antitumour immunity

The sentinel lymph node (SLN) is thought to be an important lymphoid organ for protecting against metastasis and is thought to play a crucial part in provoking antitumour immunity. Because SLN biopsy is undertaken for various types of cancers, such as malignant melanoma and breast cancer, SLN mapping has become a standard procedure, thereby eliminating unnecessary lymph-node resection in patients who do not have affected nodes. The immune surveillance activities of the SLN in melanoma and breast cancer are thought to be suppressed, whereas in cancers of gastrointestinal-tract, the presence of T cells in the SLN has not been shown to suppress the host's immune function. Furthermore, cell death after primary systemic chemotherapy for solid tumours can provoke an antigen-specific immunity in the tumour, which affects tumour response to treatment and, therefore, survival in patients. This review discusses the immunobiology of the SLN and potential strategies for activation of antitumour immunity by primary systemic chemotherapy and other modalities, in terms of tumour-size reduction and survival benefit.

Functional roles of immature dendritic cells in impaired immunity of solid tumour and their targeted strategies for provoking tumour immunity

Dendritic cells play a crucial role in initiating tumour immunity as well as in the immune response for invading foreign pathogens such as bacteria and viruses. For bacterial and viral infections, the immature dendritic cells (iDCs) residing in peripheral tissues are efficiently activated and matured by pathogen signals for performing the immune response. In contrast, for self-antigens, the naive T cells are not activated by iDCs but proceed to anergy/deletion, and the generation of regulatory T cells for immune tolerance. The induction of immune response and tolerance is regulated strictly by iDCs as the sensor for homeostasis of immune response in the host. Despite the identification of some tumour antigens, tumour immunity is not provoked successfully. Even though there are some critical obstacles to inhibit effective tumour immunity, tumour cells are able to exploit the functional roles of iDCs for tumour progression, which are induced by tumour-derived soluble factors such as vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) and functionally modulated in the microenvironment. The iDCs still remain as the critical target for provoking tumour immunity. In this review, the functional roles of tumour-associated iDCs and the strategy for targeting iDCs in effective tumour immunity for the cancer patient are discussed.

Autologous tumor rejection in humans: trimming the myths

There is overwhelming evidence that the human immune system can keep in check the growth of autologous tumors. Yet, this phenomenon is rare and most often tumors survive striking a balance with the host's immune system. The well-documented coexistence of immune cells that can recognize cancer and their targets within the same host is reminiscent of chronic allograft rejection well-controlled by immune suppression or of a lingering tissue-specific autoimmune reaction. In this review, we argue that autologous tumor rejection represents a distinct form of tissue-specific rejection similar to acute allograft rejection or to flares of autoimmunity. Here we discuss similarities within the biology of these phenomena that may converge into a common immunological constant of rejection. The purpose is to simplify the basis of immune rejection to its bare bones critically dissecting the significance of those components proposed by experimental models as harbingers of this final outcome.

Adoptive T-Cell Therapy of Cancer

Adoptive therapy involves the transfer of ex vivo expanded immune effector cells to patients as a means of augmenting the antitumor immune response. In general, this transfer is accomplished by harvesting cells from the peripheral blood, tumor sites, or draining lymph nodes and expanding effector cells in a specific or nonspecific fashion for adoptive transfer. This article describes the rationale for adoptive T-cell therapy, the developments that have led to the translational application of this strategy for the treatment of cancer, the challenges that have been addressed, and future approaches to the development of adoptive therapy as a treatment modality.

The effects of gp100 and tyrosinase peptide vaccinations on nevi in melanoma patients

BACKGROUND

A new approach to prevent disease recurrence in high-risk melanoma patients involves immunization with gp100 and tyrosinase peptides. This is the first study to examine the effects of such treatments on nevi.

DESIGN

We studied biopsies of 'clinically atypical' nevi from 10 patients before and after peptide vaccination. All had a cutaneous melanoma measuring at least 1.5 mm in depth, satellite metastases, or at least one positive lymph node. We performed immunohistochemical stains for CD3, CD4, CD8, MHC-I, MHC-II, CD1a, HMB-45, MART-1, tyrosinase, bcl-2, p53, and Ki-67 (mib-1).

RESULTS

Immunohistochemistry showed no differences in staining due to vaccination in either the immunologic or melanocytic markers. However, there was a significant increase in both p53 and bcl-2 staining, and a trend toward decreased Ki-67 staining, in the nevi post-treatment.

DISCUSSION

The primary goal of peptide vaccinations with gp100 and tyrosinase is to activate melanoma-specific T cells in order to prevent melanoma recurrence. Nevi were studied in order to assess the effects on benign melanocytes. No significant changes in lymphocytes, langerhans cells, expression of MHC antigens, or melanocytic markers were found. The increase in p53 and bcl-2 raises the possibility that vaccination with melanocytic antigens stimulates a response in benign melanocytes.

Definition of an Immunologic Response Using the Major Histocompatibility Complex Tetramer and Enzyme-Linked Immunospot Assays

PURPOSE

Define an immunologic response using the tetramer and enzyme-linked immunospot (ELISPOT) assays.

EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN

Ten healthy subjects and 21 patients with melanoma (all HLA-A*0201) donated a total of 121 blood samples to determine the lower limit of detection (LLD), analytic coefficient of variation (aCV), and physiologic CV (pCV) of the tetramer and ELISPOT assays. The mean, SD, and reference change value (RCV) were calculated to define changes beyond the assay imprecision, and its application was tested in the monitoring of T-cell expansion after CTLA4 blockade with ticilimumab (CP-675,206).

RESULTS

The LLD for the tetramer assay was 0.038% CD8+ cells and seven spots per 10(5) peripheral blood mononuclear cells for the ELISPOT assay. The aCV of the tetramer assay was <10% and was higher for the ELISPOT (24.69-36.32%). There was marked between-subject variability on baseline homeostatic values, which was correlated to prior antigen exposure. An immunologic response was defined as an increase beyond the mean + 3 SD in antigen-specific cells for subjects with baseline levels below the LLD, or beyond the assay RCV for baseline levels above the LLD. In four patients receiving ticilimumab, expansions of antigen-specific T cells beyond the assay variability were noted for EBV and MART1 antigens.

CONCLUSIONS

A combined approach of change from negative (below the LLD) to positive (above the LLD) and a percentage change beyond the assay variability using the RCV score can be computed to define which change in circulating antigen-specific T cells represents a response to immunotherapy.

Melanocyte-specific, cytotoxic T cell responses in vitiligo: the effective variant of melanoma immunity?

Vitiligo is a relatively common progressive depigmentary condition that is believed to be due to the autoimmune-mediated loss of epidermal melanocytes. An interesting aspect of vitiligo is its relation to melanoma: cytotoxic T lymphocytes directed to self-antigens shared by normal melanocytes and melanoma cells are found in both conditions and might prove important in melanocyte destruction, yet the resulting immune reactions are completely different. From this standpoint, the selective destruction of pigment cells that occurs in cases of vitiligo is the therapeutic goal sought in melanoma research. In the present article, we will address these issues by reviewing current literature on the subject as well as by posing some speculations.

Active Antigen-specific Immunotherapy of Melanoma: from Basic Science to Clinical Investigation

Advanced-stage melanoma here dismal prognosis, and novel therapeutic approaches are urgently required. The possibility of taking advantage of the immune response of patients for its treatment has been an appealing concept for almost a century. Only during the last decade, however, has the molecular identification of tumor-associated antigens (TAAs) offered the possibility of vaccinating patients (e.g., active induction of TAA-specific immune responses). Active antigen-specific immunotherapy (AASIT) is currently being investigated in a number of clinical centers as a treatment option for advanced-stage melanoma. A large number of melanoma TAAs have been molecularly characterized and are being used in vaccination trials in various molecular forms and according to various immunization protocols. Here we provide a short overview on melanoma TAAs, the technologies currently in use to induce specific cytotoxic T-lymphocyte (CTL) responses in vivo, and their monitoring. We also propose a tentative AASIT agenda for the next few years, aiming at improving the capacity to induce and monitor TAA-specific immune responses and to verify their clinical effectiveness.

Vaccination with T cell-defined antigens

Tumour immunology encompasses a broad array of biological phenomena including interactions between neoplastic cells and the innate and adaptive immune response. Among immune cells, T cells have taken the centre stage because they can be easily demonstrated to specifically recognise autologous cancer cells. As most tumour-associated antigens are intracellular proteins, T cells appear to be the most suitable tool for cancer-specific attack, as antibodies do not cross the cell membrane and the innate immune response lacks the same level of specificity. Finally, the relative ease in which T cells can be educated through antigen-specific immunisation to recognise cancer cells has elevated them to an even higher stature. In this review, it will be argued that T cells represent a unique anticancer agent, characterised by absolute specificity. Although other therapeutic modalities (antibody-based) have been effectively implemented, a comparison of T cell-based approaches with other modalities goes beyond the purposes of this review and will not be included in the discussion. However, it is obvious that the role of the T cell is limited and other components of the immune response (effector mononuclear phagocytes, natural killer cells, cytokines, chemokines, soluble factors), genetic background and tumour heterogeneity are likely to be necessary for the completion of cancer rejection.

Understanding the response to immunotherapy in humans

Whether the efforts of the last decade aimed at the development of vaccines against tumor-specific antigens encountered success or failure is a matter of expectations. On the bright side, we could optimistically observe that anti-cancer-vaccines stand as an outstanding example of the successful implementation of modern biotechnology tools for the development of biologically sound therapeutics. In particular, vaccines against melanoma (the prototype model of tumor immunology in humans) can reproducibly induce cytotoxic T cell (CTL) responses exquisitely specific for cancer cells. This achievement trespasses the specificity of any other anti-cancer therapy. The skeptics, on the other end, might point out that immunization only rarely leads to cancer regression, labeling, therefore, this approach is ineffective. In our opinion this judgment stems from the naïve expectation that CTL induction is sufficient for an effective immune response. Here we propose that more needs to be understood about the mechanisms required for the induction of a therapeutically relevant immune response in humans. In particular, we will discuss the variables related to cancer heterogeneity, the weight of individual patients' polymorphism(s), the role of the T cell activation and differentiation and, finally, the complex relationship between immune and cancer cells within the tumor microenvironment.

T-cell-based immunotherapy of melanoma: what have we learned and how can we improve?

The lack of effective treatment for advanced stage melanoma by conventional therapies, such as radiation and chemotherapy, has highlighted the need to develop alternative therapeutic strategies. Among them, immunotherapy has attracted much attention because of the potential role played by immunological events in the clinical course of melanoma and the availability of well-characterized melanoma antigens to target melanoma lesions with immunological effector mechanisms. In recent years, T-cell-based immunotherapy has been emphasized, in part because of the disappointing results of the antibody-based trials conducted in the early 1980s, and in part because of the postulated major role played by T-cells in tumor growth control. In this review, the characteristics of antibody and T-cell-defined melanoma antigens will first be described, with emphasis on those used in clinical trials. Following a review of the current immunization and immunomonitoring strategies, the results from the T-cell-based immunotherapy clinical trials conducted to date will be reviewed.

Dynamic changes of specific T cell responses to melanoma correlate with IL-2 administration

Interleukin 2 (IL-2) is a promising immunotherapeutic agent for the treatment of metastatic melanoma and renal cell carcinoma. Systemic administration of high dose IL-2 produces objective responses in up to 25% of melanoma patients, and a low but significant proportion of these patients experience durable responses. Nevertheless, the cells and molecules responsible for induction of tumor regression over the course of IL-2 treatment remain unknown. New strategies in tumor immunotherapy have evolved over the past decade as a consequence of significant progress in the field, in particular with respect to the characterization of peptide epitopes derived from tumor associated antigens, and the role of antigen presenting cells in the initiation of cellular immune responses. Alongside with these factual as well as conceptual advances, new methods have been developed to monitor and characterize anti-tumor T cell responses in cancer patients. Application of these tools to dissect anti-tumor responses has demonstrated that various immune therapeutic approaches can induce powerful systemic anti-tumor cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) responses. However, only limited efforts have been made to use present days tool to analyze anti-tumor immune responses in patients treated with IL-2 based immunotherapy. We have examined CTL responses against known tumor antigens in melanoma patients over the course of IL-2 based immunotherapy (electrochemotherapy). Surprisingly, anti-tumor CTL responses significantly declined upon initiation of therapy, but reappeared when IL-2 administration was paused. Molecular analyses of the clonotypic composition of responding T cells demonstrated that new clones emerged over the course of treatment, and that tumor-specific T cells that had left the peripheral blood could subsequently be detected at the tumor site. These data provide new insight into the biological actions of IL-2 and highlight the difficulties associated with the monitoring of anti-tumor immune responses. This underlines the importance of frequent sampling of blood and tumor biopsies to be analyzed with a combination of state of the art technologies in order to gain detailed information on the interactions between cancer cells and cells of the immune system.

Dissecting tumor responsiveness to immunotherapy: the experience of peptide-based melanoma vaccines

Recent years have witnessed important breakthroughs in our understanding of tumor immunology. A variety of immunotherapeutic strategies has shown that immune manipulation can induce the regression of established cancer in humans. The identification of the genes encoding tumor-associated antigens (TAA) and the development of means for immunizing against these antigens have opened new avenues for the development of an effective anticancer immunotherapy. However, an efficient immune response against tumor requires an intricate cross-talk between cancer and immune system cells, which is still poorly understood. Only when the molecular basis underlying tumor susceptibility to an immune response is deciphered could new therapeutic strategies be designed to fit biologically defined mechanisms of cancer immune rejection. In this article, we address some of the critical issues that have been identified in cancer immunotherapy, in part from our own studies on immune therapies in melanoma patients treated with peptide-based vaccination regimens. This is not meant to be a comprehensive overview of the immunological phenomena accompanying cancer patient vaccination but rather emphasizes some emergent findings, puzzling controversies and unanswered questions that characterize this complex field of oncology. In addition to reviewing the main immunological concepts underlying peptide-based vaccination, we also review the available data regarding naturally occurring and therapeutically induced anticancer immune response, both at the peripheral and intratumoral level. The hypothesized role of innate immunity in predetermining tumor responsiveness to immunotherapeutic manipulation is also discussed.

Active-specific immunization against melanoma: Is the problem at the receiving end?

The recent progress in tumor immunology is a striking example of the successful application of modern biotechnology to understand the complex phenomenon of immune-mediated cancer rejection. Tumor antigens were identified and successfully utilized in active immunization trials to induce tumor antigen-specific T cells. This achievement has left, however, clinicians and researchers perplexed by the paradoxical observation that immunization-induced T cells can recognize tumor cells in standard assays but cannot induce tumor regression. A closer look at T cell physiology and tumor biology suggests that this observation is not so surprising. Here, we argue that successful immunization is one of several steps required for tumor clearance while more needs to be understood about how T cells localize and are effective within a tumor microenvironment impervious to the execution of their effector function.

Tumors as elusive targets of T-cell-based active immunotherapy

The understanding of tumor-host interactions remains elusive despite significant progress in the identification of tumor antigens (TAs) recognized by autologous T cells. In particular, most human tumors do not regress and continue to grow in spite of spontaneous or immunization-induced immune responses demonstrated in circulating lymphocytes. Indeed, systemic immune responses might insufficiently address the complexity of tumor-host interactions because of factors, such as (1) the lack of productive T-cell receptor (TCR) engagement with epitope owing to qualitative and/or quantitative defects in the generation and maintenance of the immune response, (2) insufficient costimulation provided by the host, (3) the lack of localization of the immune response in target tissues and (4) the complexity of tumor-host interactions within the tumor microenvironment caused by temporal changes in tumor phenotypes and an array of immune mediators expressed in the tumor microenvironment. Here, we will review current knowledge of the different 'levels' of immune response that might be necessary for immunotherapy to be effective in the treatment of cancer. Furthermore, we will discuss the information still required in order to understand the mechanism(s) governing tumor rejection by the immune system in response to TA-specific immunization.

Identification of human tumor antigens recognized by T-cells and their use for immunotherapy

Identification of human tumor antigens led to development of new immunotherapies for patients with cancer. Identification of T-cell epitopes allowed us to monitor antitumor T-cell responses quantitatively and qualitatively during immunotherapy as well as to develop more efficient immunotherapies with sufficient amounts of antigens in more immunogenic forms. Various immunotherapies, passive immunotherapies, including adoptive transfer of tumor reactive T-cells or allogeneic antigen-specific donor T-cells, and active immunization with identified tumor antigens or dendritic cells pulsed with tumor antigens are being evaluated in clinical trials. Although tumor regression has been observed in some patients, further improvement is required.

The role of ultrasound in detection and management of regional disease in melanoma patients

Melanoma follow-up programs are directed towards early detection of tumor recurrence. Because the majority of first relapses occur in the regional lymph node area, special focus is placed on this region using various techniques in addition to physical examination. During the last several years, particularly ultrasound B-scan has evolved as a technique of major importance for detection of such regional melanoma recurrences. The technique shows high sensitivity and specificity, discriminating regional or subcutaneous melanoma metastases from nonspecific nodes. Furthermore, suspicious findings can be evaluated quickly and reliably by the minimally invasive technique of ultrasound-guided fine-needle aspiration cytology (FNAC). For regional metastases located deeply or close to vulnerable structures, the new method of ultrasound-guided anchor-wire-marking facilitates subsequent surgery. In summary, ultrasound B-scan has become an essential technique in the follow-up of melanoma patients.

Quantitative real-time RT-PCR as a method for monitoring T lymphocyte reactivity to full-length tyrosinase protein in vaccinated melanoma patients

The major goal of therapeutic cancer vaccine trials is to mediate tumor regression. However, it is critically important to devise in vitro immunological assays that correlate with clinical outcome, for use as surrogate markers of vaccine efficacy. To date, clinical emphasis has been placed on peptide vaccines, but trends towards the use of more complex immunogens such as whole proteins require the development of efficient and sensitive methods for monitoring their immunological effects. In the context of a vaccination trial using full-length tyrosinase (Ty) to immunize patients with metastatic melanoma, a monitoring technique was developed in which autologous dendritic cells (DC) infected with a recombinant adenovirus encoding the Ty protein were used to assess the Ty-specific reactivity of fresh peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) collected from patients at different intervals during therapy. Quantitative real-time RT-PCR (qRT-PCR) was used to measure the production of cytokine mRNA by T cells following a 2.5-h incubation with Ty-expressing DC. Two out of ten patients studied demonstrated Ty protein-specific reactivity that increased during and after the period of vaccination. While one of these patients also reacted to an HLA-A1-compatible Ty peptide, the second did not recognize any of the known Ty epitopes, highlighting the importance of this technique for monitoring the effects of complex vaccines.

Functional heterogeneity of vaccine-induced CD8(+) T cells

The functional status of circulating vaccine-induced, tumor-specific T cells has been questioned to explain their paradoxical inability to inhibit tumor growth. We enumerated with HLA-A*0201/peptide tetramers (tHLA) vaccine-elicited CD8(+) T cell precursor frequency among PBMC in 13 patients with melanoma undergoing vaccination with the HLA-A*0201-associated gp100:209-217(210 M) epitope. T cell precursor frequency increased from undetectable to 12,400 +/- 3,600 x 10(6) CD8(+) T cells after vaccination and appeared heterogeneous according to previously described functional subtypes: CD45RA(+)CD27(+) (14 +/- 2.6% of tHLA-staining T cells), naive; CD45RA(-)CD27(+) (14 +/- 3.2%), memory; CD45RA(+)CD27(-) (43 +/- 6%), effector; and CD45RA(-)CD27(-) (30 +/- 4.1%), memory/effector. The majority of tHLA(+)CD8(+) T cells displayed an effector, CD27(-) phenotype (73%). However, few expressed perforin (17%). Epitope-specific in vitro stimulation (IVS) followed by 10-day expansion in IL-2 reversed this phenotype by increasing the number of perforin(+) (84 +/- 3.6%; by paired t test, p < 0.001) and CD27(+) (from 28 to 67%; by paired t test, p = 0.01) tHLA(+) T cells. This conversion probably represented a change in the functional status of tHLA(+) T cells rather than a preferential expansion of a CD27(+) (naive and/or memory) PBMC, because it was reproduced after IVS of a T cell clone bearing a classic effector phenotype (CD45RA(+)CD27(-)). These findings suggest that circulating vaccine-elicited T cells are not as functionally active as inferred by characterization of IVS-induced CTL. In addition, CD45RA/CD27 expression may be more informative about the status of activation of circulating T cells than their status of differentiation.

Gene-expression profiling of the response of peripheral blood mononuclear cells and melanoma metastases to systemic IL-2 administration

BACKGROUND

Interleukin-2 (IL-2) has direct pluripotent effects on cells with immune and inflammatory function. Which of these effects has a critical role in mediating tumor regression remains enigmatic. In this study, we compared early changes in transcriptional profiles of circulating mononuclear cells with those occurring within the microenvironment of melanoma metastases following systemic IL-2 administration.

RESULTS

The results suggest that the immediate effects of IL-2 administration on the tumor microenvironment is transcriptional activation of genes predominantly associated with monocyte cell function; minimal effects were noted on migration, activation and proliferation of T cells. However, production of chemokines and markers of adhesion and migration within few hours of IL-2 administration may be responsible for a secondary recruitment of immune cells to the tumor site later.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results suggest that IL-2 induces inflammation at tumor sites with three predominant secondary effects: activation of antigen-presenting monocytes; massive production of chemoattractants that may recruit other immune cells to the tumor (including MIG and PARC, which are specific for T cells); and activation of cytolytic mechanisms in monocytes (calgranulin, grancalcin) and NK cells (NKG5, NK4).

Intensity of the vaccine-elicited immune response determines tumor clearance

Tumor Ag-specific vaccines used for cancer immunotherapy can generate specific CD8 responses detectable in PBMCs and in tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes. However, human studies have shown that detection of a systemic vaccine-induced response does not necessarily correlate with the occasional instances of tumor rejection. Because this discrepancy might partially be attributable to the genetic heterogeneity of human cancers, as well as to the immunosuppressive effects of previous treatments, we turned to a mouse model in which these variables could be controlled to determine whether a relationship exists between the strength of vaccine-induced immune responses and tumor rejection. We challenged mice with the beta-galactosidase (beta-gal)-expressing tumor cells, C25.F6, vaccinated them with beta-gal-carrying viral vectors, and used quantitative RT-PCR to measure the vaccine-induced immune response of splenocytes directly ex vivo. We found that the strength of the response increased with increasing doses of beta-gal-carrying vector and/or upon boosting with a heterologous beta-gal-carrying virus. Most importantly, we found that the strength of the detected immune response against this foreign Ag strongly correlated with reduction in the number of lung metastases. The results from this mouse model have major implications for the implementation of tumor vaccines in humans.

Sentinel node mapping identifies vaccine-draining lymph nodes with tumor-specific immunological activity

BACKGROUND

Adoptive immunotherapy (AIT) with 4T07-IL2 vaccine-draining lymph node (DLN) cells induced regression of established 4T07 mammary carcinomas, but contralateral non-DLN were inactive. These experiments were performed to determine whether mapping with isosulfan blue (IB), as described for identification of sentinel nodes, would identify vaccine-DLN with antitumor activity.

METHODS

Ten days after vaccination with 4T07-IL-2, .1 ml of 1% IB was injected into the vaccination site (footpads or flanks). After 3 minutes, mice were euthanized, and the blue-stained nodes were collected. With flank vaccination, IB identified both an inguinal and an axillary node. We also collected DLNs blindly in mice not receiving IB dye. DLN cell suspensions were then activated with bryostatin 1, ionomycin, and IL-2, expanded in culture, and adoptively transferred to mice bearing established 4T07 flank tumors.

RESULTS

Complete tumor regression occurred in nearly all mice treated with popliteal or inguinal DLNs collected with or without IB. IB-stained axillary DLNs cured 100% of tumor-bearing mice, whereas none of the mice treated with blindly collected axillary DLNs were cured.

CONCLUSION

We have shown that IB identifies immunologically active DLNs, does not interfere with expansion of lymphocytes in vitro, and, more importantly, has no detrimental effect on the ability of lymphocytes to induce tumor regression in vivo. For axillary DLNs, use of IB mapping identified immunologically active lymph nodes that could not otherwise be found.

Dendritic cells and their emerging clinical applications

Dendritic cells (DC) are now recognised as a unique leukocyte type, consisting of two or more subsets. The origins and functional inter-relationships of these cells are the subject of intense basic scientific investigation. They play important roles in initiating and directing immune responses, defending the host from pathogens and maintaining self tolerance. Fundamental studies are defining new molecules and mechanisms associated with DC function. The first methods for counting these rare blood cell populations are already providing interesting new clinical data. Indeed, abnormal DC function may contribute to deficiencies in the immune response against malignancies. Phase I trial data suggests that DC-based cancer vaccination protocols may contribute an important new biological approach to cancer therapy. Manipulation of DC to facilitate allogeneic transplantation and even to manage autoimmune disease are likely developments.

Short-term kinetics of tumor antigen expression in response to vaccination

The melanoma patient's immune response to tumor has been extensively studied. Yet, the frequently observed coexistence of tumor-associated Ag (TAA)-specific T cells with their target cells in vivo remains unexplained. Loss of TAA expression might contribute to this paradox. We studied TAA expression in metastases by obtaining fine-needle aspirations from 52 tumor lesions in 30 patients with melanoma before and soon after immunotherapy. Limitations due to low amounts of starting material were overcome with a high fidelity antisense RNA amplification method. TAA expression was measured by quantitative real-time PCR of anti-sense RNA. Decrease in gp100/Pmel-17 TAA preceded tumor disappearance in several instances and could be best explained by immune selection because most patients had received gp100/Pmel-17-specific vaccination. Conversely, immune selection was absent in nonregressing lesions. These observations suggest that vaccination, when successful, triggers a broad inflammatory reaction that can lead to tumor destruction despite immune selection. Additionally, lack of clinical response might be attributed to lack of this initiating event rather than immune escape. This study provides an insight into the natural history of tumors and defines a strategy for the characterization of gene expression in tumors during therapy.

Kinetics of cytokine expression in melanoma metastases classifies immune responsiveness

Production of cytokines (CKs) in the tumor micro-environment may modulate tumor-host interactions. However, pre-clinical models often provide conflicting data and there is no established role for CKs as modulators of the natural or treatment-related behavior of tumors. Serial sampling by fine-needle aspirates (FNAs) of identical metastases from patients affected with metastatic melanoma and undergoing IL-2-based vaccination allowed prospective measurement of IL-10, TGF-beta1, TGF-beta2 and IFN-gamma transcriptional levels assessed by quantitative real-time PCR. Thus, it was possible to prospectively document the expression of markers relevant to a given treatment and follow at the same time the clinical outcome of the lesions left in place. Eight of 27 metastatic lesions completely regressed in response to the treatment and 1 demonstrated >50% shrinkage. These regressions occurred after the follow-up FNA had been obtained. IL-10 transcript was differentially expressed in pre-treatment FNA of responding lesions (t-test p(2) = 0.002). During treatment, INF-gamma transcript levels significantly increased in regressing compared to non-regressing lesions (t-test p(2) = 0.03). These data suggest that the pre-treatment CK profile of the tumor micro-environment may determine clinical responsiveness to immune therapy. Furthermore, temporal changes in CK expression during treatment might describe the biological characteristics of an effective immune response.

Ex vivo analysis of tumor antigen specific CD8+ T cell responses using MHC/peptide tetramers in cancer patients

The development of soluble tetrameric MHC/peptide complexes has opened the possibility to directly identify and monitor antigen-specific CD8+ T cells in different clinical situations. This represents a technological breakthrough for the field of cell-mediated immunity. For example, the direct identification and enumeration of tumor-specific CD8+ T cells at the tumor site and in blood has recently provided compelling evidence that strong anti-tumoral responses naturally occur in some cancer patients. Moreover, the use of tetramers plays an essential role in the design of vaccination protocols aimed at inducing a strong and protective CD8+ T cell-mediated anti-tumoral response in cancer patients. The monitoring of antigen-specific T cell responses elicited by various peptide-based vaccines tested in phase I clinical trials clearly indicates that tumor-specific CD8+ T cells can be activated effectively at least in some cancer patients. Thus, multiparameter monitoring of antigen-specific T cell responses that combines ex vivo tetramer staining with various phenotyping and functional assays provides a novel approach to assess the functional potential of tumor-specific T lymphocytes and may also facilitate the optimization of vaccination protocols.

Dendritic cells: On the move from bench to bedside

As dendritic cells increasingly become the adjuvant of choice in new approaches to cancer immunotherapy, a degree of protocol standardization is required to aid future large-scale clinical trials.