Autoimmunity to DNA and nucleosomes in binary tetracycline-regulated polyomavirus T-Ag transgenic mice

The greatest contribution to medical science is the transformation from studying symptoms to studying their causes-the unrelenting legacy of Robert Koch and Louis Pasteur-and a causality perspective to approach a definition of SLE

The basic initiative related to this study is derived from the fact that systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is a unique and fertile system science subject. We are, however, still far from understanding its nature. It may be fair to indicate that we are spending more time and resources on studying the complexity of classified SLE than studying the validity of classification criteria. This study represents a theoretical analysis of current instinctual SLE classification criteria based on "the causality principle." The discussion has its basis on the radical scientific traditions introduced by Robert Koch and Louis Pasteur. They announced significant changes in our thinking of disease etiology through the implementation of the modern version of "the causality principle." They influenced all aspects of today's medical concepts and research: the transformation of medical science from studies of symptoms to study their causes, relevant for monosymptomatic diseases as for syndromes. Their studies focused on bacteria as causes of infectious diseases and on how the immune system adapts to control and prevent contagious spreading. This is the most significant paradigm shift in the modern history of medicine and resulted in radical changes in our view of the immune system. They described acquired post-infection immunity and active immunization by antigen-specific vaccines. The paradigm "transformation" has a great theoretical impact also on current studies of autoimmune diseases like SLE: symptoms and their cause(s). In this study, the evolution of SLE classification and diagnostic criteria is discussed from "the causality principle" perspective, and if contemporary SLE classification criteria are as useful as believed today for SLE research. This skepticism is based on the fact that classification criteria are not selected based on cogent causal strategies. The SLE classification criteria do not harmonize with Koch's and Pasteur's causality principle paradigms and not with Witebsky's Koch-derived postulates for autoimmune and infectious diseases. It is not established whether the classification criteria can separate SLE as a "one disease entity" from "SLE-like non-SLE disorders"-the latter in terms of SLE imitations. This is discussed here in terms of weight, rank, and impact of the classification criteria: Do they all originate from "one basic causal etiology"? Probably not.

Lupus nephritis: low urinary DNase I levels reflect loss of renal DNase I and may be utilized as a biomarker of disease progression

Renal DNase I is lost in advanced stages of lupus nephritis. Here, we determined if loss of renal DNase I reflects a concurrent loss of urinary DNase I, and whether absence of urinary DNase I predicts disease progression. Mouse and human DNase I protein and DNase I endonuclease activity levels were determined by western blot, gel, and radial activity assays at different stages of the murine and human forms of the disease. Cellular localization of DNase I was analyzed by immunohistochemistry, immunofluorescence, confocal microscopy, and immunoelectron microscopy. We further compared DNase I levels in human native and transplanted kidneys to determine if the disease depended on autologous renal genes, or whether the nephritic process proceeded also in transplanted kidneys. The data indicate that reduced renal DNase I expression level relates to serious progression of lupus nephritis in murine, human native, and transplanted kidneys. Notably, silencing of renal DNase I correlated with loss of DNase I endonuclease activity in the urine samples. Thus, urinary DNase I levels may therefore be used as a marker of lupus nephritis disease progression and reduce the need for renal biopsies.

Systemic Lupus Erythematosus: Definitions, Contexts, Conflicts, Enigmas

Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is an inadequately defined syndrome. Etiology and pathogenesis remain largely unknown. SLE is on the other hand a seminal syndrome that has challenged immunologists, biologists, genetics, and clinicians to solve its nature. The syndrome is characterized by multiple, etiologically unlinked manifestations. Unexpectedly, they seem to occur in different stochastically linked clusters, although single gene defects may promote a smaller spectrum of symptoms/criteria typical for SLE. There is no known inner coherence of parameters (criteria) making up the disease. These parameters are, nevertheless, implemented in The American College of Rheumatology (ACR) and The Systemic Lupus Collaborating Clinics (SLICC) criteria to classify SLE. Still, SLE is an abstraction since the ACR or SLICC criteria allow us to define hundreds of different clinical SLE phenotypes. This is a major point of the present discussion and uses "The anti-dsDNA antibody" as an example related to the problematic search for biomarkers for SLE. The following discussion will show how problematic this is: the disease is defined through non-coherent classification criteria, its complexity is recognized and accepted, its pathogenesis is plural and poorly understood. Therapy is focused on dominant symptoms or organ manifestations, and not on the syndrome itself. From basic scientific evidences, we can add substantial amount of data that are not sufficiently considered in clinical medicine, which may change the paradigms linked to what "The Anti-DNA antibody" is-and is not-in context of the imperfectly defined syndrome SLE.

Impact of the tumor necrosis factor receptor-associated protein 1 (Trap1) on renal DNaseI shutdown and on progression of murine and human lupus nephritis

Recent findings show that transformation of mild glomerulonephritis into end-stage disease coincides with shutdown of renal DNaseI expression in (NZBxNZW)F1 mice. Down-regulation of DNaseI results in reduced chromatin fragmentation and deposition of extracellular chromatin fragments in glomerular basement membranes where they appear in complex with IgG antibodies. Here, we implicate the anti-apoptotic and survival protein, tumor necrosis factor receptor-associated protein 1 (Trap1) in the disease process, based on the observation that annotated transcripts from this gene overlap with transcripts from the DNaseI gene. Furthermore, we translate these observations to human lupus nephritis. In this study, mouse and human DNaseI and Trap1 mRNA levels were determined by real-time quantitative PCR and compared with protein expression levels and clinical data. Cellular localization was analyzed by immune electron microscopy, IHC, and in situ hybridization. Data indicate that silencing of DNaseI gene expression correlates inversely with expression of the Trap1 gene. Our observations suggest that the mouse model is relevant for the aspects of disease progression in human lupus nephritis. Acquired silencing of the renal DNaseI gene has been shown to be important for progression of disease in both the murine and human forms of lupus nephritis. Early mesangial nephritis initiates a cascade of inflammatory signals that lead to up-regulation of Trap1 and a consequent down-regulation of renal DNaseI by transcriptional interference.

Precise conditional immortalization of mouse cells using tetracycline-regulated SV40 large T-antigen

Cellular immortalization provides a way for expansion and subsequent molecular characterization of rare cell types. Ideally, immortalization can be achieved by the reversible expression of immortalizing proteins. Here, we describe the use of conditional immortalization based on a modified tetracycline-regulated system for the expression of SV40 large T-antigen in embryonic stem (ES) cells and mice. The modified system relies on a codon improved reverse tetracycline transactivator (irtTA) fused to the ligand-binding domain (LBD) of the androgen receptor (irtTA-ABD) or of a mutated glucocorticoid receptor (irtTA-GBD*). Induction of T-antigen is conferred only after addition of two ligands, one to activate the LBD (mibolerone for irtTA-ABD or dexamethasone for irtTA-GBD*) and one to activate the tetracycline transactivator (doxycycline). In ES cells, changes in gene expression upon large T induction were limited and reversible upon deinduction. Similarly, expression of T-antigen was very tightly regulated in mice. We have isolated and expanded bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells that could be genetically manipulated and maintained their differentiation properties after several passages of expansion under conditions that induce the expression of large T-antigen.

Nuclease deficiencies promote end-stage lupus nephritis but not nephritogenic autoimmunity in (NZB × NZW) F1 mice

New information has profoundly improved our insight into the processes that account for lupus nephritis. This review summarizes the data proving that secondary necrotic chromatin fragments are generated and retained in kidneys at time-points when the major renal nuclease Dnase-1 is selectively and severely downregulated. Second, we discuss data, which may indicate that nuclease deficiencies are not associated with autoimmunity to chromatin. Secondary to downregulation of renal Dnase-1, large chromatin fragment-immunoglobulin G complexes are accumulated in glomerular basement membranes of patients producing anti-chromatin autoantibodies. Exposure of chromatin in situ in glomeruli is the factor that renders anti-chromatin (anti-dsDNA and anti-nucleosome) antibodies nephritogenic. Without exposed chromatin, they circulate as non-pathogenic antibodies. This shows that acquired loss of renal Dnase-1 enzyme activity is a dominant event responsible for the progression of lupus nephritis into end-stage disease. Before the loss of Dnase-1, lupus-prone (NZB × NZW) F1 mice develop mild or silent nephritis with mesangial immune complex deposits, which correlates solely with onset of anti-dsDNA antibody production. The principal cellular and molecular requirements needed to produce these autoantibodies have been explained experimentally, but the mechanism(s) accounting for them in vivo in context of lupus nephritis have not yet been determined. However, published data show that defects in nucleases operational in apoptotic or necrotic cell death are not associated with the induction of nephritogenic anti-dsDNA autoantibodies. The data discussed in this study explain how an unusual exposure of chromatin may be a central factor in the evolution of lupus nephritis in (NZB x NZW) F1 mice, but not in promoting nephritogenic chromatin-specific autoimmunity.

Pure anti-dsDNA mAbs need chromatin structures to promote glomerular mesangial deposits in BALB/c mice

The glomerular targets for nephritogenic antibodies have been identified as membrane-associated chromatin fragments. The processes responsible for their deposition are poorly understood. To determine early events in antibody-mediated nephritis, we injected highly pure anti-dsDNA mAbs into BALB/c mice. Mice receiving one dose of anti-dsDNA mAbs were sacrificed 6 or 24 h later. No direct binding of mAbs to glomerular membranes or to the mesangial matrix was observed by immune electron microscopy. In contrast, repeated injections of the same antibodies over 4 weeks resulted in deposition of electron dense structures predominantly in the mesangial matrix. These structures contained mAbs and chromatin fragments as determined by co-localization immune electron microscopy. Biotinylated anti-dsDNA mAbs, injected into nephritic (NZB x NZW)F1 or MRL(lpr/lpr) mice were detected in newly formed electron dense structures within glomerular capillary membranes. There were no correlation between mAb affinity for DNA, as determined by surface plasmon resonance analyses, and ability to bind chromatin fragments in vivo. No direct binding of mAbs to inherent membrane antigens was observed. Quantification of DNA in sera before and after one single injection of antibodies revealed increased DNA levels at 6 h after injection of anti-dsDNA mAb, and lower levels after 24 h. Repeated injections of anti-dsDNA caused an increase in circulating DNA. These results indicate that availability of chromatin fragments, presumable in circulation, is important for glomerular mesangial matrix deposition of anti-dsDNA antibody-containing immune complexes in context of lupus nephritis.

The danger model in deciphering autoimmunity

Autoimmunity has been a topic of intensive research for several decades, yet amazingly, no uniform hypothesis exists to explain the basis for the spectrum of autoantibody specificities seen in autoimmune diseases. It therefore seems appropriate to consider whether our current framework for understanding tolerance, and thus the mechanisms controlling the initiation and perpetuation of autoimmunity, may be faulty. Adapting the paradigm of Matzinger-the 'danger model', a case can be made for a perspective that appreciates the fundamental role of the tissues in controlling immune response, favouring a shift of focus in studies on the initiation of autoimmunity. Applying the elements of this model, I set forth a number of scenarios for how autoreactivity could emerge, with emphasis on the likely sources of the involved autoantigens and the functional basis of their appearance. The emerging picture is one in which disruption of tissue homeostasis takes centre stage, with the antigen-presenting cells as the key players.

Increased prevalence of polyomavirus BK viruria that correlates with thrombocytopenia in patients with systemic lupus erythematosus on intensive immunosuppressive therapy

The prevalence of polyomavirus BK (BKV) reactivation is high in patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) on long-term immunosuppressants compared to normal population. However, only a few studies are available for the possible correlation of BKV reactivation and clinical manifestations in SLE patients. In the present study, we tried to correlate BKV viruria, clinical manifestations, laboratory findings, and medications in patients with SLE. The urine BKV viral DNA copies were detected from 95 patients with SLE and 32 healthy volunteers by real-time PCR. We found that the prevalence rate of BKV viruria in SLE patients was significantly higher than normal group (71.6% vs. 18.6%, p < 0.001) as well as the urine BKV DNA viral load (4.74 +/- 3.17 vs. 1.08 +/- 2.33 by log scale, p < 0.001). Interestingly, BKV viruria (+) SLE patients had more thrombocytopenic events than BKV viruria ( - ) group (32.4% vs. 3.7%, p = 0.008 after adjustment by age and sex). The patients with BKV viruria DNA copy number >3,200,000/ml exhibited more thrombocytopenia risk than BKV viruria <==3,200,000 copy number/ml or BKV viruria ( - ). The use of potent immunosuppressants may increase BKV viruria. In a refractory thrombocytoponeic case, the add-on of anti-BKV medication, leflunomide 20 mg/day rapidly decreased BKV viruria and recovered platelet counts. In conclusion, our study demonstrated that patients with SLE had higher prevalence rate of BKV reactivation that is correlated with thrombocytopenic episode. Intensive immunosuppressive therapy in SLE may increase the risk of BKV viruria.

Circulating chromatin-anti-chromatin antibody complexes bind with high affinity to dermo-epidermal structures in murine and human lupus nephritis

Murine and human lupus nephritis are characterized by glomerular deposits of electron-dense structures (EDS). Dominant components of EDS are chromatin fragments and IgG antibodies. Whether glomerular EDS predispose for similar deposits in skin is unknown. We analysed (i) whether dermo-epidermal immune complex deposits have similar molecular composition as glomerular deposits, (ii) whether chromatin fragments bind dermo-epidermal structures, and (iii) whether deposits in nephritic glomeruli predispose for accumulation of similar deposits in skin. Paired skin and kidney biopsies from nephritic (NZBxNZW)F1 and MRL-lpr/lpr mice and from five patients with lupus nephritis were analysed by immunofluorescence, immune electron microscopy (IEM) and co-localization TUNEL IEM. Affinity of chromatin fragments for membrane structures was determined by surface plasmon resonance. Results demonstrated (i) presence of EDS containing chromatin fragments and IgG in both organs in nephritic patients, (ii) chromatin fragments possessed high affinity for dermo-epidermal laminins and collagens, (iii) glomerular immune complex deposits did not predict similar interstitial deposits in skin, although such complexes were present in capillary lumina in glomeruli and skin of all nephritic individuals. Thus, chromatin-IgG complexes accounting for lupus nephritis seem to reach skin through circulation, but other undetermined factors are required for these complexes to deposit within skin membranes.

Renal expression of polyomavirus large T antigen is associated with nephritis in human systemic lupus erythematosus

We have demonstrated that glomerular expression of polyomavirus large T antigen (T-ag) in a binary tetracycline-regulated T-ag transgenic mouse model (i) terminated tolerance for nucleosomes, (ii) released complexes of nucleosomes and T-ag to the microenvironment from dead cells, and (iii) that these complexes bound induced anti-nucleosome antibodies and finally (iv) that they associated with glomerular membranes as immune complexes. This process may be relevant for human lupus nephritis, since productive polyomavirus infection is associated with this organ manifestation. Here, we compare nephritis in the T-ag transgenic mouse with nephritis in human SLE. Glomerular sections were analysed by transmission electron microscopy, immune electron microscopy (IEM) and by co-localization IEM and TUNEL IEM assays to compare morphological changes, composition of immune complexes and formation of nucleosome-T-ag complexes. Affinity of nucleosome-T-ag complexes for glomerular collagen IV and laminin was determined by surface plasmon resonance (SPR). Analyses revealed electron dense structures in both human and murine kidney samples. These EDS were shown to contain T-ag, DNA and histones, indicating that extra-cellular chromatin may originate from polyomavirus infected cells in human kidneys. SPR analyses demonstrated high affinity of nucleosomes and nucleosome-T-ag complexes for collagen IV and laminin. Complexes of nucleosomes, T-ag and anti-T-ag and anti-dsDNA antibodies bind glomerular membranes and contribute to the evolution of lupus nephritis in human SLE.

Lupus nephritis: the central role of nucleosomes revealed

Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is an autoimmune syndrome characterized by autoantibodies to nuclear constituents. Some of these antibodies are diagnostically important, whereas others act as disease-modifying factors. One clinically important factor is autoantibodies against dsDNA and nucleosomes, which have overlapping diagnostic and nephritogenic impact in SLE. Although a scientific focus for 5 decades, the molecular and cellular origin of these antibodies, and why they are associated with lupus nephritis, is still not fully understood. A consensus has, however, evolved that antibodies to dsDNA and nucleosomes are central pathogenic factors in the development of lupus nephritis. In contrast, no agreement has been reached as to which glomerular structures are bound by nephritogenic anti-nucleosome antibodies in vivo. Mutually contradictory paradigms and models have evolved simply because we still lack precise and conclusive data to provide definitive insight into how autoantibodies induce lupus nephritis and which specificity is critical in the nephritic process(es). In this review, data demonstrating the central role of nucleosomes in inducing and binding potentially nephritogenic antibodies to DNA and nucleosomes are presented and discussed. These autoimmune-inducing processes are discussed in the context of Matzinger's danger model (Matzinger P: Friendly and dangerous signals: is the tissue in control? Nat Immunol 2007, 8:11-13; Matzinger P: The danger model: a renewed sense of self. Science 2002, 296:301-305; Matzinger P: Tolerance, danger, and the extended family. Annu Rev Immunol 1994, 12:991-1045) and Medzhitov's and Janeway's (Medzhitov R, Janeway CA Jr: Decoding the patterns of self and nonself by the innate immune system. Science 2002, 296:298-300; Medzhitov R, Janeway CA Jr: How does the immune system distinguish self from nonself? Semin Immunol 2000, 12:185-188; Janeway CA Jr, Medzhitov R: Innate immune recognition. Annu Rev Immunol 2002, 20:197-216) distinction of noninfectious self (NIS) and infectious nonself (INS). The mechanisms leading to production of potentially nephritogenic anti-nucleosome antibodies and to overt lupus nephritis are interpreted in the context of these paradigms.

Glomerular expression of large polyomavirus T antigen in binary tet-off regulated transgenic mice induces apoptosis, release of chromatin and initiates a lupus-like nephritis

Binary tetracycline-regulated polyomavirus large T antigen transgenic mice were generated to study immunological tolerance for nucleosomes. Expression of T antigen resulted in binding of the protein to chromatin, and released T antigen-nucleosome complexes from dying cells maintained anti-dsDNA and anti-nucleosome antibody-production by activating autoimmune nucleosome-specific B cells and CD4+ and CD8+ T antigen specific T cells. Glomerular T antigen expression was observed in these mice. Here, we demonstrate that this expression was linked to glomerular cell apoptosis, release of nucleosomes and association of nucleosomes with glomerulus basement membranes, detected as electron dense structures. Immune electron microscopy (IEM) revealed that these structures were glomerular targets for induced anti-dsDNA and anti-T antigen antibodies. Co-localization IEM demonstrated that in vivo-bound auto-antibodies co-localized with experimental monoclonal antibodies to dsDNA and to T antigen. A comparative analysis of glomeruli from nephritic (NZWxNZB)F1 and T antigen expressing transgenic mice revealed deposition of nucleosomes in glomerular capillary and mesangial matrix membranes and binding of anti-nucleosome antibodies in both mice strains. A controlled experimental model that may elucidate the initial events accounting for nucleosome-mediated nephritis has not been available. The transgenic mouse may be important to describe early immunological and cellular events accounting for the enigmatic lupus nephritis.

Nucleosomes possess a high affinity for glomerular laminin and collagen IV and bind nephritogenic antibodies in murine lupus-like nephritis

AIM

Lupus nephritis is closely associated with in vivo autoantibody-binding to glomerular membrane-associated electron-dense structures (EDS). The biochemical nature and cellular origin of EDS are controversial, and definitive characterisation needs to be performed.

METHODS

By using the terminal transferase biotin-dUTP nick end-labelling (TUNEL) assay at the electron microscopic level, we have traced extracellular chromatin within the glomerular basement membranes of nephritic (NZBxNZW)F1 mice. The TUNEL assay was subsequently used in combination with standard immune electron microscopy (IEM). To analyse why chromatin particles associate with membranes, we determined the affinity of nucleosomes and DNA for glomerular laminin, collagen IV and the mesangial matrix proteoglycan perlecan by surface plasmon resonance.

RESULTS

This intra-assay colocalisation TUNEL IEM demonstrated that autoantibodies fully colocalised with extracellular TUNEL-positive chromatin observed as EDS in glomerular membranes, similar to results obtained by the same technique applied to human lupus nephritis. Most importantly, these data validate the murine variant of lupus nephritis as a model to study origin of extracellular chromatin as a key element in human lupus nephritis. Kinetic analyses demonstrated that nucleosomes had a high affinity for collagen IV and laminin, but not for perlecan.

CONCLUSION

Collectively, these results provide firm evidence that dominant target structures for nephritogenic autoantibodies are constituted by TUNEL-positive chromatin associated with glomerular capillary and mesangial matrix membranes at high affinity.

Glomerular apoptotic nucleosomes are central target structures for nephritogenic antibodies in human SLE nephritis

Antibodies to double-stranded (dsDNA) are associated with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) and directly involved in human lupus nephritis. Information about their glomerular target antigens is inconsistent, and whether availability of target antigens, antibody specificity or avidity are nephritogenic parameters, is not determined. In this study, we analyzed renal tissue from anti-dsDNA antibody-positive lupus patients with nephritis by morphological and immunological assays, including immune electron microscopy (IEM) and colocalization IEM, an EM-based confocal microscopy assay. IEM demonstrated that antibody deposits were confined to electron dense structures (EDS) in glomerular membranes. These autoantibodies colocalized with nucleosome-binding anti-dsDNA/-histone/-transcription factor antibodies. To confirm the colocalization IEM-data, we developed a colocalization terminal deoxynucleotidyl-transferase (TdT) biotin-dUTP nicked end-labeled (TUNEL) IEM assay where extracellular DNA was traced by TdT-mediated introduction of biotinylated nucleotides and autoantibodies by IEM. Results consistently demonstrated that DNA colocalized with autoantibodies in glomerular membrane-associated EDS. The colocalization IEM and colocalization TUNEL IEM assays thus demonstrate that intra-glomerular membrane-associated nucleosomes are targeted by anti-dsDNA autoantibodies in human lupus nephritis. The data provide a new approach to understand basic molecular and immunological processes accounting for antibody-mediated nephritis in human SLE.

[Systemic lupus erythematosus and nucleosome]

The property of nucleosome in systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is reviewed. Nucleosome, complex of histone and DNA, is thought to have a pivotal role in pathogenesis of SLE. It is formed during apoptosis that is increased in peripheral lymphocytes of SLE. The concentration of nucleosome is elevated in SLE, probably related with disease activity. Nucleosome is speculated that the clearance from peripheral blood is decreased and that is modified by viral infection to become more immunogenic. Anti-nucleosome antibody is highly positive in majority of SLE, and is very specific for SLE except scleroderma and mixed connective tissue disease. This antibody is thought as a diagnostic marker and probably an activity marker for SLE. Anti-nucleosome antibody forms immune complex with nucleosome. As histone has strong positive charge, it is demonstrated that this nucleosome/anti-nucleosome complex is bound to negatively charged heparan sulfate of glomerular basement membrane in kidney. Then, complements bind to this antibody to generate lupus glomerulonephritis. Although main site of apoptosis in SLE is considered as lymphocytes, we experienced a case with SLE who had liver dysfunction with elevated soluble Fas ligand (sFasL) and apoptosis in her hepatocytes in the active stage of SLE. We measured serum sFasL, and found the relation of sFasL and liver involvement in active SLE. As major source of nucleosome should be apoptosis of lymphocytes in SLE, hepatocytes could be another candidate of apoptosis in some SLE.

Nephritogenic lupus antibodies recognize glomerular basement membrane-associated chromatin fragments released from apoptotic intraglomerular cells

Antibodies to dsDNA represent a classification criterion for systemic lupus erythematosus. Subpopulations of these antibodies are involved in lupus nephritis. No known marker separates nephritogenic from non-nephritogenic anti-dsDNA antibodies. It is not clear whether specificity for glomerular target antigens or intrinsic antibody-affinity for dsDNA or nucleosomes is a critical parameter. Furthermore, it is still controversial whether glomerular target antigen(s) is constituted by nucleosomes or by non-nucleosomal glomerular structures. Previously, we have demonstrated that antibodies eluted from murine nephritic kidneys recognize nucleosomes, but not other glomerular antigens. In this study, we determined the structures that bind nephritogenic autoantibodies in vivo by transmission electron microscopy, immune electron microscopy, and colocalization immune electron microscopy using experimental antibodies to dsDNA, to histones and transcription factors, or to laminin. The data obtained are consistent and point at glomerular basement membrane-associated nucleosomes as target structures for the nephritogenic autoantibodies. Terminal deoxynucleotidyl-transferase-mediated dUTP nick end-labeling or caspase-3 assays demonstrate that lupus nephritis is linked to intraglomerular cell apoptosis. The data suggest that nucleosomes are released by apoptosis and associate with glomerulus basement membranes, which may then be targeted by pathogenic anti-nucleosome antibodies. Thus, apoptotic nucleosomes may represent both inducer and target structures for nephritogenic autoantibodies in systemic lupus erythematosus.

Critical comparative analyses of anti-alpha-actinin and glomerulus-bound antibodies in human and murine lupus nephritis

OBJECTIVE

Although anti-double-stranded DNA (anti-dsDNA) antibodies are important in lupus nephritis, the question regarding which glomerular structures (alpha-actinin, nucleosomes, or others) are recognized by nephritogenic anti-dsDNA antibodies is still controversial. In this study, we determined which glomerular structures are recognized by monoclonal and in vivo-bound nephritogenic antibodies.

METHODS

Western blotting was used to analyze the ability of nephritogenic anti-dsDNA antibodies to recognize glomerular and nucleosomal structures. Sera from patients with lupus nephritis, sera from random antinuclear antibody-positive patients, and paired antibodies from sera and kidney eluates from nephritic (NZB x NZW)F(1) mice were analyzed for activity against proteins identified by monoclonal nephritogenic antibodies, and against alpha-actinin, dsDNA, nucleosomes, histone H1, heparan sulfate, DNase I, and type IV collagen. Immunoelectron microscopy was used to determine the glomerular localization of alpha-actinin and in vivo-bound autoantibodies in nephritic (NZB x NZW)F1 mouse kidneys.

RESULTS

Anti-alpha-actinin antibodies were observed in human and murine lupus nephritis sera and in sera from patients without systemic lupus erythematosus and were not detected in kidney eluates from nephritic mice. Antibodies to dsDNA and histone H1 were detected in all eluates. Western blot analyses revealed that nephritogenic anti-dsDNA antibodies recognized a 32-kd band, identified as histone H1. Competitive enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay demonstrated that nephritogenic monoclonal antibodies, and dominant antibodies eluted from nephritic kidneys, cross-reacted with dsDNA and H1. This cross-reactive anti-H1 specificity was largely absent in sera from those mice. Immunoelectron microscopic analysis of nephritic (NZB x NZW)F1 mouse kidneys revealed that antibodies eluted from kidneys, but not anti-alpha-actinin antibodies, bound to distinct nephritis-associated electron-dense structures linked to glomerular basement membranes.

CONCLUSION

Cross-reactive anti-dsDNA/anti-histone H1 antibodies, but not anti-alpha-actinin antibodies, are central among those deposited in nephritic glomeruli.