Evolution of Transcriptional Control of theIgHLocus: Characterization, Expression, and Function of TF12/HEB Homologs of the Catfish

The Concerted Action of E2-2 and HEB Is Critical for Early Lymphoid Specification

The apparition of adaptive immunity in Gnathostomata correlates with the expansion of the E-protein family to encompass E2-2, HEB, and E2A. Within the family, E2-2 and HEB are more closely evolutionarily related but their concerted action in hematopoiesis remains to be explored. Here we show that the combined disruption of E2-2 and HEB results in failure to express the early lymphoid program in Common lymphoid precursors (CLPs) and a near complete block in B-cell development. In the thymus, Early T-cell progenitors (ETPs) were reduced and T-cell development perturbed, resulting in reduced CD4 T- and increased γδ T-cell numbers. In contrast, hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs), erythro-myeloid progenitors, and innate immune cells were unaffected showing that E2-2 and HEB are dispensable for the ancestral hematopoietic lineages. Taken together, this E-protein dependence suggests that the appearance of the full Gnathostomata E-protein repertoire was critical to reinforce the gene regulatory circuits that drove the emergence and expansion of the lineages constituting humoral immunity.

Activation-induced cytidine deaminase structure and functions: a species comparative view

In the ten years since the discovery of activation-induced cytidine deaminase (AID) there has been considerable effort to understand the mechanisms behind this enzyme's ability to target and modify immunoglobulin genes leading to somatic hypermutation and class switch recombination. While the majority of research has focused on mouse and human models of AID function, work on other species, from lamprey to rabbit and sheep, has taught us much about the scope of functions of the AID mutator. This review takes a species-comparative approach to what has been learned about the AID mutator enzyme and its role in humoral immunity.

Immunoglobulin genes and their transcriptional control in teleosts

Immunoglobulin (Ig), which exists only in jawed vertebrates, is one of the most important molecules in adaptive immunity. In the last two decades, many teleost Ig genes have been identified by in silico data mining from the enormous gene and EST databases of many fish species. In this review, the organization of Ig gene segments, the expressed Ig isotypes and their transcriptional controls are discussed. The Ig heavy chain (IgH) locus in teleosts encodes the variable (V), the diversity (D), the joining (J) segments and three different isotypic constant (C) regions including Cμ, Cδ, and Cζ/τ genes, and is organized as a "translocon" type like the IgH loci of higher vertebrates. In contrast, the Ig light (L) chain locus is arranged in a "multicluster" or repeating set of VL, JL, and CL segments. The IgL chains have four isotypes; two κ L1/G and L3/F), σ (L2) and λ. The transcription of IgH genes in teleosts is regulated by a VH promoter and the Eμ3' enhancer, which both function in a B cell-specific manner. The location of the IgH locus, structure and transcriptional function of the Eμ3' enhancer are important to our understanding of the evolutional changes that have occurred in the IgH gene locus.

The zebrafish IgH locus contains multiple transcriptional regulatory regions

Many fish have, in addition to IgM and IgD, a third isotype called IgZ or IgT. The ζ-chain locus is embedded among the Ig heavy chain V-, D- and J-elements in a manner reminiscent of the TcR δ/α locus. Isotype selection thus occurs during VDJ recombination, a process that is facilitated by intralocus transcription. Using in silico analyses and enhancer reporter vectors we identified 3 new regions within the zebrafish IgH locus through which transcription can be activated in catfish B-cell lines. Two of these, termed Eζi (Jζ to Cζ1 intronic) and Eζ3' regions flank the ζ-chain constant domain exons. A third region, Eδ3', resides downstream of the δ-chain exons. All regions contain predicted binding sites for transcription factors that contribute to B-cell specific transcription in fish and mammals. Each region also has proximal matrix attachment regions, which may further contribute to transcriptional activation and chromatin remodeling. We discuss possible roles for these regions during VDJ recombination.

The IgH locus 3' regulatory region: pulling the strings from behind

Antigen receptor gene loci are among the most complex in mammals. The IgH locus, encoding the immunoglobulin heavy chain (IgH) in B-lineage cells, undergoes major transcription-dependent DNA remodeling events, namely V(D)J recombination, Ig class-switch recombination (CSR), and somatic hypermutation (SHM). Various cis-regulatory elements (encompassing promoters, enhancers, and chromatin insulators) recruit multiple nuclear factors in order to ensure IgH locus regulation by tightly orchestrated physical and/or functional interactions. Among major IgH cis-acting regions, the large 3' regulatory region (3'RR) located at the 3' boundary of the locus includes several enhancers and harbors an intriguing quasi-palindromic structure. In this review, we report progress insights made over the past decade in order to describe in more details the structure and functions of IgH 3'RRs in mouse and human. Generation of multiple cellular, transgenic and knock-out models helped out to decipher the function of the IgH 3' regulatory elements in the context of normal and pathologic B cells. Beside its interest in physiology, the challenge of elucidating the locus-wide cross talk between distant cis-regulatory elements might provide useful insights into the mechanisms that mediate oncogene deregulation after chromosomal translocations onto the IgH locus.

BOB.1 of the channel catfish, Ictalurus punctatus: not a transcriptional coactivator?

Expression of the immunoglobulin heavy chain (IGH) locus of the channel catfish (Ictalurus punctatus) is driven by the Emu3' enhancer, whose core region contains two octamer motifs and a muE5 site. Orthologues of the Oct1 and Oct2 transcription factors have been cloned in the channel catfish and shown to bind to the octamer motifs within the core enhancer. While catfish Oct2 is an activator of transcription, catfish Oct1 failed to drive transcription and may act as a negative regulator of IGH transcription. In mammals, the Oct co-activator BOB.1 (B cell Oct-binding protein1, also known as OCA-B and OBF-1) greatly enhances the transcriptional activity of Oct factors and plays an important role in the development of the immune system. An orthologue of BOB.1 has been cloned in the catfish, and its function characterized. The POU binding domain of the catfish BOB.1 was found to be 95% identical at the amino acid level with the binding domain of human BOB.1, and all the residues directly involved in binding to the Oct-DNA complex were conserved. Despite this conservation, catfish BOB.1 failed to enhance transcriptional activation mediated by endogenous or co-transfected catfish Oct2, and failed to rescue the activity of the inactive catfish Oct1. Electrophoretic mobility shift assays showed that catfish BOB.1 was capable of binding both catfish Oct1 and Oct2 when they formed a complex with the Oct motif. Analysis of recombinant chimeric catfish and human BOB.1 proteins demonstrated that the failure to drive transcription was due to the lack of a functional activation domain within the catfish BOB.1.

Interaction between E-protein and Oct transcription factors in the function of the catfish IGH enhancer

Transcriptional control of the immunoglobulin heavy chain (IGH) locus in the channel catfish, Ictalurus punctatus, is incompletely understood. It is, however, known that 2 variant octamer motifs and a microE5 motif in the core region of the enhancer (Emicro3') are important in driving transcription, and it has been suggested that interaction between transcription factors (Oct factors and E-proteins) bound to these sites contributes to enhancer function. In this study, the functional relationships between the microE5 motif, the proximal octamer motif, and the factors that bind them have been examined. The results of mutational analysis of these motifs showed that their interaction is important to driving transcription from the enhancer. Furthermore, the catfish Oct transcription factors were capable of a physical interaction with the catfish E-proteins. These results support a role for interaction between transcription factors bound to the octamer and microE5 motifs in the function of the Emicro3' enhancer.

Function of E-protein dimers expressed in catfish lymphocytes

E-proteins are essential class I bHLH transcription factors that play a role in lymphocyte development. In catfish lymphocytes the predominant E-proteins expressed are CFEB (a homologue of HEB) and E2A1, which both strongly drive transcription. In this study the role of homodimerization versus heterodimerization in the function of these catfish E-proteins was addressed through the use of expression constructs encoding forced dimers. Constructs expressing homo- and heterodimers were transfected into catfish B cells and shown to drive transcription from the catfish IGH enhancer. Expression from an artificial promoter containing a trimer of muE5 motifs clearly demonstrated that the homodimer of E2A1 drove transcription more strongly (by a factor of 10-25) than the CFEB homodimer in catfish B and T cells, while the heterodimer showed intermediate levels of transcriptional activation. Both CFEB1 and E2A1 proteins dimerized in vitro, and the heterodimer CFEB1-E2A1 was shown to bind the canonical muE5 motif.

Characterization of an Oct1 orthologue in the channel catfish, Ictalurus punctatus: a negative regulator of immunoglobulin gene transcription?

BACKGROUND

The enhancer (Emu3') of the immunoglobulin heavy chain locus (IGH) of the channel catfish (Ictalurus punctatus) has been well characterized. The functional core region consists of two variant Oct transcription factor binding octamer motifs and one E-protein binding muE5 site. An orthologue to the Oct2 transcription factor has previously been cloned in catfish and is a functionally active transcription factor. This study was undertaken to clone and characterize the Oct1 transcription factor, which has also been shown to be important in driving immunoglobulin gene transcription in mammals.

RESULTS

An orthologue of Oct1, a POU family transcription factor, was cloned from a catfish macrophage cDNA library. The inferred amino acid sequence of the catfish Oct1, when aligned with other vertebrate Oct1 sequences, revealed clear conservation of structure, with the POU specific subdomain of catfish Oct1 showing 96% identity to that of mouse Oct1. Expression of Oct1 was observed in clonal T and B cell lines and in all tissues examined. Catfish Oct1, when transfected into both mammalian (mouse) and catfish B cell lines, unexpectedly failed to drive transcription from three different octamer-containing reporter constructs. These contained a trimer of octamer motifs, a fish VH promoter, and the core region of the catfish Emu3' IGH enhancer, respectively. This failure of catfish Oct1 to drive transcription was not rescued by human BOB.1, a co-activator of Oct transcription factors that stimulates transcription driven by catfish Oct2. When co-transfected with catfish Oct2, Oct1 reduced Oct2 driven transcriptional activation. Electrophoretic mobility shift assays showed that catfish Oct1 (native or expressed in vitro) bound both consensus and variant octamer motifs. Putative N- and C-terminal activation domains of Oct1, when fused to a Gal4 DNA binding domain and co-transfected with Gal4-dependent reporter constructs were transcriptionally inactive, which may be due in part to a lack of residues associated with activation domain function.

CONCLUSION

An orthologue to mammalian Oct1 has been found in the catfish. It is similar to mammalian Oct1 in structure and expression. However, these results indicate that the physiological functions of catfish Oct1 differ from those of mammalian Oct1 and include negative regulation of transcription.

Characterization of two POU transcription factor family members from the urochordate Oikopleura dioica

Three POU domain containing transcription factors have been cloned from the urochordate Oikopleura dioica. Phylogenetic analysis showed that two of these (OctA1 and OctA2) are closely related members of the class II POU domain family, and one (OctB) is a member of the class III POU domain family. All three transcription factors contained a highly conserved bipartite DNA-binding POU domain with POU specific and POU homeodomains, separated by a linker region. All three proteins were shown to bind specifically to the canonical octamer motif, ATGCAAAT. The ability of these factors to drive transcription from an octamer-containing reporter construct was assessed in vertebrate B lymphocyte cell lines. Both OctA1 and OctA2 drove transcription in murine and catfish B cell lines, however, OctB did not increase the level of transcription above background levels. It is concluded that Oct transcription factors capable of functioning in a similar fashion to vertebrate Oct1/2 were present at the phylogenetic level of the urochordates.

Regulation of the immunoglobulin heavy chain locus expression at the phylogenetic level of a bony fish: transcription factor interaction with two variant octamer motifs

Transcriptional control of the IGH locus in teleosts is not fully understood, but evidence from catfish and zebrafish indicates major roles for octamer-binding (Oct) and E-protein transcription factors. A pair of variant octamer motifs in the Emu3' enhancer of the catfish has been shown to be particularly important in driving expression, justifying detailed study of their function. These octamer motifs were examined to determine if they bound Oct2 POU domains in monomeric or dimeric (PORE and MORE) configurations. While catfish Oct2 was shown to be capable of binding PORE and MORE motifs in dimeric conformation, the two octamer motifs in Emu3' bound Oct2 POU domains only in monomeric configuration. Catfish Oct2, when bound in this monomeric conformation, was shown to bend the DNA helix. The relative position of the two octamer motifs in Emu3' affected the activity of the enhancer, and moving the octamer motifs closer together by 5 bp greatly reduced the activity of the enhancer. This effect was not due to steric hindrance preventing the binding of Oct transcription factors to the two motifs, but rather was shown to be due to the disruption of an additional transcription factor binding site lying between the two octamer motifs.

Conservation and divergence of the Eμ3′ enhancer in the IGH locus of teleosts

The core region of the Emicro3' transcriptional enhancer that drives the expression of the teleost IGH locus has been characterized functionally in two species, the catfish (Ictalurus punctatus) and the zebrafish (Danio rerio). These studies have suggested important differences: whereas the catfish enhancer acts through an E-box and two octamer motifs, the zebrafish enhancer exerts its major effects through two E-box motifs alone. In this study, the function of the catfish enhancer was reexamined in a broader comparative context within the teleosts. Electrophoretic mobility shift assays of motifs from catfish, zebrafish, and Fugu were conducted to determine their ability to bind catfish E-protein and Oct transcription factors. Transient expression assays were conducted using a region of the catfish core enhancer that includes a newly described hybrid octamer/E-box motif. Sequences homologous to the Emicro3' enhancer region from six teleosts were aligned to determine conserved regions ("phylogenetic footprinting"). These studies allowed the following conclusions to be drawn: (1) The important 3'E-box motif described in the zebrafish corresponds in the homologous region of the catfish enhancer to an Oct motif with a newly described negative regulatory function and (2) Comparison of the Emicro3' enhancer sequences of six teleosts indicates that while a variety of octamer and E-box motifs are found in this region, strict evolutionary conservation of the important functional elements of the teleost Emicro3' enhancer has not occurred.

Characterization of 23 CC chemokine genes and analysis of their expression in channel catfish (Ictalurus punctatus)

Chemokines are a large family of chemotactic cytokines playing crucial roles in the innate immune response. CC chemokines constitute the largest subfamily of chemokines, with 28 CC chemokines identified from mammalian species. However, the status of CC chemokines in teleosts is yet to be determined. We previously identified 26 catfish CC chemokine cDNAs from catfish. In this study, we isolated and sequenced 23 channel catfish CC chemokine genes amounting to a total of over 56 kb of genomic sequences. Genomic organization of the 23 CC chemokine genes was determined by comparing the generated genomic sequences with the previously identified cDNA sequences. Microsatellites were identified from 16 catfish CC chemokine genes allowing them to be utilized for genome mapping. Structural analysis indicated conservation of genomic organization of CC chemokine genes, which may facilitate the establishment of orthologies. Expression of all known catfish CC chemokine transcripts was assessed in nine important tissues. Of the 26 catfish CC chemokine genes, 14 were universally expressed, six were widely expressed in many tissues, while six were highly tissue-specific.

Evolution of vertebrate E protein transcription factors: comparative analysis of the E protein gene family in Takifugu rubripes and humans

E proteins are essential for B lymphocyte development and function, including immunoglobulin (Ig) gene rearrangement and expression. Previous studies of B cells in the channel catfish ( Ictalurus punctatus) identified E protein homologs that are capable of binding the μE5 motif and driving a strong transcriptional response. There are three E protein genes in mammals, HEB (TCF12), E2A (TCF3), and E2-2 (TCF4). The major expressed E proteins found in catfish B cells are homologs of HEB and of E2A. Here we sought to define the complete family of E protein genes in a teleost fish, Takifugu rubripes, taking advantage of the completed genome sequence. The catfish CFEB (HEB homolog) sequence identified homologous E-protein-encoding sequences in five scaffolds in the Takifugu genome database. Detailed comparative analysis with the human genome revealed the presence of five E protein homologs in Takifugu. Single genes orthologous to HEB and to E2-2 were identified. In contrast, two members of the E2A gene family were identified in Takifugu; one of these shows the alternative processing of transcripts that identifies it as the ortholog of the E12/E47-encoding mammalian E2A gene, whereas the second Takifugu E2A gene has no predicted alternative splice products. A novel fifth E protein gene (EX) was identified in Takifugu. Phylogenetic analysis revealed four E protein branches among vertebrates: EX, E2A, HEB, and E2-2.

Regulation of immunoglobulin gene transcription in a teleost fish: identification, expression and functional properties of E2A in the channel catfish

The function of the transcriptional enhancer, Emu3', of the IgH locus of the channel catfish, Ictalurus punctatus, involves the interaction of E-protein and Oct family transcription factors. The E-proteins [class I basic helix-loop-helix (bHLH) family] are encoded in mammals by three genes: E2A (of which E12/E47 are alternatively spliced products), HEB, and E2-2. An E2A homologue has been identified in a catfish B-cell cDNA library and contains regions homologous to the bHLH and activation domains of mammalian and other vertebrate E2A proteins. E2A message is widely expressed, being readily detected in catfish B cells, T cells, kidney, spleen, brain, and muscle. Its expression is lower than that previously observed for TF12/CFEB, the catfish homologue of HEB. E2A strongly activated transcription of a muE5 motif-dependent construct in catfish B cells, and also activated transcription from the core region of the catfish IgH enhancer (Emu3') in a manner dependent on the presence of the muE5 site. Catfish E2A, expressed in vitro, bound the muE5 motif present in the core region of Emu3'. These results document the conservation of structure and function in vertebrate E2A and suggest a potential role of E2A in driving expression of the IgH locus at the phylogenetic level of a teleost fish.

Evolution of transcriptional enhancers in the immunoglobulin heavy-chain gene: functional characteristics of the zebrafish Emu3' enhancer

Past studies of the channel catfish immunoglobulin heavy-chain (IgH) locus indicates that it lacks an Emu enhancer in the J(H)-Cmu1 intron but does have an enhancer, termed Emu3', in the mu-delta intergenic region. The positioning of the catfish enhancer downstream of the mu-chain exons is predicted to be unfavorable for antibody-affinity maturation in catfish, and would also have been an impediment to the evolution of class switch recombination, had it existed in early tetrapods. To determine if this downstream enhancer is a general feature of teleost fish, we have identified the location of the transcriptional enhancer in the zebrafish IgH locus. We find that zebrafish, like catfish, only have an Emu3'-like enhancer that has cross-species activity, but which is B-cell-specific in its activity. A 300-bp region of the zebrafish enhancer shares sequence homology with the core of the catfish Emu3', although there has been loss and gain of specific octamer enhancer motifs. Mutagenesis studies demonstrate that the zebrafish IgH enhancer depends on a pair of E-box motifs that are found in the enhancer core. Similarly spaced E-box motifs appear to exist in the Emu3' enhancer regions of other teleost fish, suggesting this is a common feature among fish IgH enhancers. We discuss how this distal positioning of the enhancer may influence affinity maturation in extant teleosts as well as the evolution of this process in the early tetrapods.