Bicondylar tibial fractures: Internal or external fixation?

A Novel Approach in the Management of Tibial Plateau Fractures with Compartment Syndrome

Background

Compartment syndrome in tibial plateau fractures presents a formidable challenge for treating orthopedic surgeons. The most common strategy is early fasciotomy and external fixation, followed by a second stage definitive fixation. We conducted a prospective study of tibial plateau fractures of Schatzker Type V and VI with impending compartment syndrome treated by single-stage double incision fasciotomy and dual internal fixation and Vacuum-Assisted Closure (VAC).

Materials and Methods

The study was between May 2014 and February 2019. 21 patients with impending compartment syndrome who underwent single-stage double incision fasciotomy and Open Reduction and Internal Fixation (ORIF) with dual plate were included in the study. The functional and radiological outcome was measured using the modified Rasmussen functional and radiological scoring and The Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Arthritis Index (WOMAC).

Results

The mean age of patients was 38.7 years (Standard deviation of ± 9.48). The mean follow-up period was 27 months (Standard deviation of ± 6.51). The mean functional and radiological modified Rasmussen score was 27.28 (range 21 to 29) & 8 (range 7 to 10), respectively. 4 patients had excellent outcomes, and 17 patients had good results. The mean WOMAC score was 8.04 (Standard deviation of ± 5.35). Five patients had a score of 0, 14 patients had a score of 1-10 and 2 had a score of 11-20.

Conclusions

The early double incision fasciotomy and definitive internal fixation with dual plate and VAC as single-stage surgery in patients with impending compartment syndrome help to obtain excellent to good functional outcomes with reduced complications.

Systematic Review of Current Approaches to Tibia Plateau: Best Clinical Evidence

If not treated adequately, tibia plateau fractures result in premature osteoarthritis and lifelong disability. The advent of newer implants and techniques to improve outcomes has necessitated the development of different surgical approaches. A Medline and EMBASE search (June 2020) was conducted to identify publications during the last 10 years that focused on surgical approaches for proximal tibia fractures/ tibia plateau management. A total of 2107123 and 2715399 articles were found related to fractures in this area with 133 and 103 review articles looking at the approach on MEDLINE and EMBASE, respectively. This article reviews the continued development of the surgical approaches to aid understanding for surgeons and identify areas for future research to help improve outcomes. Although the anterolateral approach is the most commonly applied surgical technique, having the knowledge of newer approaches (medial, posteromedial, posterolateral, or direct posterior) in the armamentarium is necessary to treat the vast array of fracture patterns. There has been a shift amongst trauma surgeons of using a combination of approaches for complex tibia plateau fractures. 

Treatment of C1.1 (AO‑41) tibial plateau fracture: A finite element analysis of single medial, lateral and dual plating

Bicondylar tibial plateau fractures pose many challenges in surgical treatment. The aim of the present study was to analyze three methods of reduction, single medial, single lateral, and dual plating, for the treatment of a bicondylar tibial plateau fracture, through finite element analysis (FEA). A simple metaphyseal fracture, type C1.1 (AO-41) was modeled on a CT-derived 3D model of the knee. Lateral and medial proximal tibial polyaxial plates with screws were modeled and placed accordingly for the three methods of reduction. Simulation of physiological type loading corresponding to the maximal weight acceptance phase during a slow walking gait cycle was performed using FEA. Values of stress and strain were recorded near the fracture lines. Dual plating provided a decrease of stress and strain in the tibial plateau area. However, the differences in the values among the three cases were small. The stress concentration areas were located in the vicinity of the fracture, predominantly in the area of the tibial plateau. Considering the limitations of the present study, the results revealed that dual plating leads to smaller stress and strain values near the fracture lines in the tibial plateau area. However, values obtained for single lateral plating are close in range. Considering the complexity of the surgical approach for dual plating, single lateral plating may be a solution for good reduction with fewer surgical risks and complications. Further studies on the C1.1 fracture (AO-41) are needed to analyze the complex issue of reducing and stabilizing such a fracture and to characterize the postoperative state while providing predictable parameters for an optimal result.

Challenges in the management of floating knee injuries: Results of treatment and outcomes of 224 consecutive cases in 10 years

INTRODUCTION

Floating knee is a flail knee joint resulting from fractures of the shafts or adjacent metaphyses of the femur and the ipsilateral tibia. It is usually associated with several complications and mortality. This study was designed to present our experience with the treatment of this injury.

MATERIAL AND METHOD

This study was performed between January 2004 and December 2014. 224 cases of floating knee injuries gathered from the 34,480 lower extremities trauma files were studied, and the target information recorded. The injuries most frequently occurred in subjects between 16 and 35 years of age (60.71%), and in male subjects (85.71%). The most frequent mechanism of injury was traffic accident (92.85%). External fixation was the common type of treatment (82.14%) in emergency or as a definitive treatment. The treatment was performed within 24 h of the trauma. We performed a 36-month follow up with clinical examination, radiographs, assessing the complications, and using the Modified Cincinnati Rating System Questionnaire (MCRSQ) and the Karlström/Olerud Score (KOS) to evaluate the progression of the outcomes.

RESULTS

Early complications included 8 cases of compartment syndrome, 60 open fractures and 24 partially amputated limbs. A total amputation was performed in 3 patients. The most common late complication was heterotopic calcifications of the knee (n = 68, 30.6%). Good scores for MCRSQ and KOS were obtained only after patients were sent to a reference center for knee surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

Our experience revealed that the complication rate associated with floatingknee injuries remains high, regardless of the performed treatment. Surgeons should focus on reducing complications while treating these severe injuries.

Establishment of Classification of Tibial Plateau Fracture Associated with Proximal Fibular Fracture

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this retrospective study was to determine the incidence of fibular fractures as an associated injury in tibial plateau fractures according to CT scan. We also attempt to introduce a new morphological sub-classification on this associated injury and to analyze the correlation between this classification and tibial plateau fractures.

METHODS

We selected cases with fibular fractures from all the tibial plateau fracture patients. The cases were further divided into 2 groups: unicondylar group and bicondylar group. On the basis of our new classification system of fibular fracture, all the included cases were divided into 5 subgroups.

RESULTS

Finally, a total of 150 cases associated with fibular fractures in 502 tibial plateau fracture cases were identified from our institution database. The incidence of fibular head fracture in tibial plateau fractures was 29.88% (150/502). Seventy-one cases (47.3%) were involved one condyle, and 79 cases (52.7%) involved both. It shows significant difference in the subgroup of avulsion fracture with horizontal fracture line (Type A) which is ratio of 16.9% in unicondylar group and 1.27% in bicondylar group.

CONCLUSION

A new classification of this associated injury describing the morphology of the fracture fragments may improve operative planning.

WITHDRAWN: Challenges in the management of floating knee injuries: Results of treatment and outcomes of 224 consecutive cases in 10 years

The Publisher regrets that this article is an accidental duplication of an article that has already been published in Injury, 50(2) (2019) 453–461, https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1016/j.injury.2018.12.009. The duplicate article has therefore been withdrawn. The full Elsevier Policy on Article Withdrawal can be found at https://www.elsevier.com/about/our-business/policies/article-withdrawal.

Severe tibial plateau fractures (Schatzker V-VI): open reduction and internal fixation versus hybrid external fixation

Tibial plateau fractures (TPF) are highly prone to complications and adverse effects. Their treatment has long been a matter of controversy, as fracture patterns and possible damage to soft tissues can easily aggravate complications. On the one hand, open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF) techniques provide a good approach to joint shape restoration and biomechanics, but they may also provoke a higher rate of soft-tissue complications. On the other, hybrid external fixation (HEF), although allowing little facility for reduction, may, theoretically, produce much less damage to the soft tissues. We present 93 cases of TPF classified as type V or VI that were followed up for at least 24 months. There were no statistical differences among them in relation to consolidation, secondary malalignment or range of motion, according to whether ORIF or HEF was employed. However, when external fixation followed open reduction, both superficial and deep-infection rates were higher.

Proximal tibial fractures with impending compartment syndrome managed by fasciotomy and internal fixation: A retrospective analysis of 15 cases

BACKGROUND

Proximal tibia fractures with compartment syndrome present a challenge for orthopedic surgeons. More often than not these patients are subjected to multiple surgeries and are complicated by infection osteomyelitis and poor rehabilitation. There is no consensus in the management of these fractures. Most common mode is to do early fasciotomy with external fixation, followed by second stage definitive fixation. We performed a retrospective study of proximal tibia fractures with impending compartment syndrome treated by single stage fasciotomy and internal fixation. Results in terms of early fracture union, minimum complications and early patient mobilization were very good.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Fifteen patients who were operated between July 2011 and June 2012 were selected for the study. All documents from their admission until the last followup in December 2013 were reviewed, data regarding complications collected and results were evaluated using Oxford Knee scoring system.

RESULTS

At the final outcome, there was anatomical or near anatomical alignment with no postoperative problems with range of motion of near complete flexion (>120) in all patients within 3 months. 13 patients started full weight bearing walking at 3 months. Delayed union in two patients and skin necrosis in one patient was observed.

CONCLUSIONS

Since the results are encouraging and the rehabilitation time is much less when compared to conventional approaches, it is recommended using this protocol to perform early fasciotomy with the definitive internal fixation as single stage surgery to obtain excellent followup results and to reduce rehabilitation time, secondary trauma, expense of treatment and infection rate.

Outcome of complex tibial plateau fractures treated with external fixator

BACKGROUND

Tibial plateau fractures are usually associated with communition and soft tissue injury. Percutaneous treatment of these complex fractures is intended to reduce soft issue complications and postoperative stiffness of the knee joint. We assessed the complications, clinical outcome scores, and postoperative knee range of movements, after fluoroscopic assisted closed reduction and external fixator application.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Seventy eight complex tibial plateau fractures in 78 patients were included in the study. All fractures were managed with closed reduction and external fixator application. In 28 cases with intraarticular split, we used percutaneous cancellous screw fixation for reduction and fixation of condylar parts. In nine open fractures, immediate debridement was done. In 16 cases, elevation of depressed segment and bone grafting was required, which was done from a very small incision. All patients were clinically and radiographically evaluated at a mean followup of 26.16 months (range 6-60 months).

RESULTS

Clinical results were evaluated according to the Rasmussen's criteria. Average healing time was 13.69 weeks (range 12- 28 weeks). Mean knee range of motion was 122.60° (range 110°-130°). Forty seven results were scored as excellent, 25 good, 2 fair, and 1 as poor.

CONCLUSION

We believe that minimally invasive treatment by percutaneous techniques and external fixation is a fairly reasonable treatment alternative, if near anatomical reduction of joint surface can be confirmed on fluoroscopy.