Reconstructive surgery for hypospadias: A systematic review of long-term patient satisfaction with cosmetic outcomes

What should be next in lifelong posterior hypospadias: Conclusions from the 2023 ERN eUROGEN and EJP-RD networking meeting

BACKGROUND

A congenital disease is for life. Posterior hypospadias, the severe form of hypospadias with a penoscrotal, scrotal, or perineal meatus, is a challenging condition with a major impact on lifelong quality of life.

AIM

Our network meeting is aimed to identify what is currently missing in the lifelong treatment of posterior hypospadias, to improve care, quality of life, and awareness for these patients.

METHODS

The network meeting "Lifelong Posterior Hypospadias" in Utrecht, The Netherlands was granted by the European Joint Programme on Rare Diseases-Networking Support Scheme. There was a combination of interactive sessions (hackathons) and lectures. This paper can be regarded as the last phase of the hackathon.

RESULTS

Surgery for hypospadias remains challenging and complications may occur until adulthood. Posterior hypospadias affects sexual function, fertility, and hormonal status. Transitional care from childhood into adulthood is currently insufficiently established. Patients should be more involved in defining desired treatment approach and outcome measures. For optimal outcome evaluation standardization of data collection and registration at European level is necessary. Tissue engineering may provide a solution to the shortage of healthy tissue in posterior hypospadias. For optimal results, cooperation between basic researchers from different centers, as well as involving clinicians and patients is necessary.

CONCLUSIONS

To improve outcomes for patients with posterior hypospadias, patient voices should be included and lifelong care by dedicated healthcare professionals guaranteed. Other requirements are joining forces at European level in uniform registration of outcome data and cooperation in basic research.

Sexual well-being and penile appearance in adolescents operated for distal hypospadias in childhood

BACKGROUND

The importance of patient-reported outcomes (PRO) in hypospadias is increasing. However, more knowledge is needed concerning genital self-perception on appearance and function in adolescents. The complication rates for distal hypospadias is different from that for severe hypospadias, and expected outcomes related to sexual well-being and cosmetics may also differ.

OBJECTIVE

To investigate 16-year-olds' self-reported outcomes on penile appearance, sexual well-being, and voiding function in distal hypospadias, and compare with that of healthy male adolescents and a surgeon's view.

STUDY DESIGN

Sixteen-year-old patients operated for distal hypospadias were included in this cross-sectional study and compared to a group of healthy adolescents. The assessment tools included the adolescents' self-perception on genital appearance and function measured by Pediatric Penile Perception Score (PPPS) and their responses to a structured interview. We also included information on clinical data from the electronic medical records, together with a physical examination and an uroflowmetry.

RESULTS

Seventy patients and 61 healthy adolescents participated. Patients and the comparison group reported no differences on sexual well-being. The patients were satisfied with penile appearance, however their overall PPPS was significantly lower (8.9), compared to the comparison group (9.6, p = 0.03). Thirty-nine percent of patients had complications leading to re-interventions and reported lower scores on genital self-perception on appearance and function compared to those who had not re-interventions. Voiding function was normal. The surgeon's score on appearance was comparable to the patients' score.

DISCUSSION

A key finding in our study is the patients' high satisfaction on sexual well-being, which was similar to healthy adolescents. The patients were also satisfied with penile appearance but scored significantly lower than the comparison group. Surgeons and patients had comparable scores on appearance; however, they seemed to emphasize different aspects of appearance. Our results on penile appearance and sexual well-being are comparable to those of other studies on distal hypospadias. In our study, re-interventions were associated with more negative genital self-perception on appearance and function, similar to findings in other studies.

CONCLUSION

Our results show overall positive satisfaction on sexual well-being, voiding function and penile appearance despite less satisfaction on penile appearance when compared with the comparison group. Satisfaction was reported to be good also in patients experiencing re-interventions.

Small Intestinal Submucosa for corporeal body grafting in patients with proximal hypospadias and severe chordee: Long term follow-up assessing erectile function and genital self-perception

BACKGROUND

Proximal hypospadias and severe ventral chordee are often challenging to repair. To preserve penile length in chordee repair, Small Intestinal Submucosa (SIS) corporal grafting is often performed with potential long-term complications including recurrent curvature and erectile dysfunction (ED). There is a paucity of data evaluating sexual function in mid, late and post-pubertal patients.

OBJECTIVE

We aimed to assess long-term outcomes of genital self-perception and erectile function in mid, late and post-pubertal patients who underwent single-layer (1-ply) SIS corporal body grafting for correction of severe chordee.

STUDY DESIGN

Patients with proximal hypospadias who underwent correction of severe chordee using SIS grafting between 2001 and 2015 were retrospectively identified. Patients were evaluated for erectile and sexual function using the modified erection hardness score (mEHS) and the modified sexual health inventory for men (mSHIM). Perceived function and straightness were measured with Hypospadias Objective Scoring Evaluation (HOSE). Penile self-perception was assessed using the Pediatric Penile Perception Score (PPPS). Results were compared to an age-matched healthy control group. Categorical variables were analyzed using Fisher's exact test, and continuous variables using paired and unpaired t-test and ANOVA.

RESULTS

Nineteen patients with proximal hypospadias who underwent correction of severe chordee using SIS grafting and 18 controls participated in the study with a median age of 17 years for both groups. In the mEHS, 12 (63.2%) hypospadias-patients and 14 (87.5%) controls rated their erections as completely hard and very rigid. In the mSHIM, 1 (5.2%) hypospadias-patient was classified as having moderate ED. A total of 16 hypospadias-patients (84%) and 16 controls (88.9%) reported being very satisfied or satisfied with the straightness of their penis. No significant difference was observed in the mEHS, mSHIM and PPPS between groups (p < 0.05). The straightness of the erection was rated lower by participants, than by the pediatric urologist. In the HOSE, 12 (63.2%) hypospadias-patients and 16 (88.9%) controls obtained an acceptable score.

DISCUSSION

Our findings indicate favorable long-term outcomes in ED and genital self-perception; only 5% of our population reported having a mild-moderate to moderate presentation of ED, and there were no reports of severe ED. The overall PPPS satisfaction rates were statistically similar for the control and hypospadias groups. The small sample population limits the significance of our findings.

CONCLUSION

Corporal body grafting with 1-ply SIS suggests positive long-term outcomes in genital self-perception and erectile function, with mid, late and post-pubertal patients who underwent hypospadias repair having comparable results to age-matched healthy controls.

An Objective Assessment and Comparison of the Cosmetic Outcome: Parental Perspective after Tubularized Incised Plate Urethroplasty with Foreskin Reconstruction and Circumcision

Aim

We aimed to evaluate the parents' view of the cosmetic outcome after hypospadias surgery.

Materials and Methods

Between January 2017 and December 2020, 70 patients aged between 2 and 7 years underwent surgical correction of hypospadias. Group 1 had 35 patients (coronal: 6, distal: 19, and mid-penile: 10) assigned for tubularized incised plate urethroplasty (TIPU) with modified foreskin reconstruction. Group 2 had 35 patients (coronal: 4, distal: 22, and mid-penile: 9) assigned for TIPU and circumcision. Parents were assessed with the Pediatric Penile Perception Score (PPPS).

Results

Parent satisfaction for the position and shape of the urethral opening, shape of the glans, penile skin, and length exhibited no statistically relevant difference between the group. Parent satisfaction with the appearance of the genitals in Group 1 was relatively high 2.60 ± 0.55, as compared to Group 2 1.77 ± 0.49 which is statistically significant (P < 0.00028).

Conclusion

Our experience shows good early cosmetic results of foreskin reconstruction and high parental satisfaction. Foreskin reconstruction should constitute a key element of the final result to restore a penis with an appearance as normal as possible.

Post-Hypospadias Repair Penile Score in Follow-Up Patients of Urethroplasty

Background: Hypospadias is described as the abnormal location of the urethral meatus upon the ventral surface of the penis with variable association with the abnormal development of the urethral spongiosum, ventral prepuce, and penile chordee. Numerous studies have utilized techniques like "Penile Perception Score (PPPS)," "Hypospadias Objective Scoring System (HOSE)," and "Hypospadias Objective Penile Evaluation Score (HOPE)" to evaluate the outcome after hypospadias repair, but there is a lack of evidence analyzing the utility of "Post-Hypospadias Repair Penile Score (PHRPS)." This study was carried out to assess PHRPS in children undergoing hypospadias repair.

Methodology: A prospective cohort study was conducted at the department of pediatric surgery, uni-II, The Children’s Hospital and University of Child Health Sciences, Lahore, Pakistan from November 2020 to December 2021. All male children aged up to 12 years and planning to undergo hypospadias repair during the study period were included. The PHRPS system was used to assess the outcomes of hypospadias repair. Qualitative data were represented as frequency and percentage, while mean and standard deviation (SD) were calculated for quantitative data.

Results: During this period, a total of 37 children were treated for hypospadias. The mean age of the patients at the time of repair was 8.2±3.6 years, ranging between 1.5 years and 12 years. Out of 37 patients, 14 (37.8%) had penoscrotal hypospadias, while 12 (32.4%) had distal penile hypospadias. In terms of acute post-surgery complications, edema was reported in 9 (24.3%), bleeding 1 (2.7%), and surgical site infection 1 (2.7), while all of these were successfully managed conservatively. Seven patients were lost to follow-up, so they were excluded from the final analysis. On the basis of PHRPS scoring, 17 (56.7%) patients had excellent outcomes, 2 (6.7%) had good outcomes, 8 (26.7%) had acceptable outcomes, and 3 (10.0%) had poor outcomes.

Conclusion: The PHRPS is a new but simple objective tool, facilitating surgical audit and balanced evaluation of the outcomes of traditional and innovative procedures. The outcome of hypospadias repair was generally found to be good.

Hypospadias: clinical approach, surgical technique and long-term outcome

Background

Hypospadias is one of the most common congenital abnormalities in male newborn. There is no universal approach to hypospadias surgical repair, with more than 300 corrective procedures described in current literature. The reoperation rate within 6–12 months of the initial surgery is most frequently used as an outcome measure. These short-term outcomes may not reflect those encountered in adolescence and adult life. This study aims to identify the long-term cosmetic, functional and psychosexual outcomes.

Methods

Medical records of boys who had undergone surgical repair of hypospadias by a single surgical team led by the same surgeon at a single centre between August 2001 and December 2017 were reviewed. Families were contacted by telephone and invited to participate. Surgical outcome was assessed by combination of clinical examination, a life-related interview and 3 validated questionnaires (the Penile Perception Score-PPS, the Hypospadias Objective Score Evaluation-HOSE, the International Index of Erectile Function-5-IIEF5). Outcomes were compared according to age, severity of hypospadias, and respondent (child, parent and surgeon).

Results

187 children and their families agreed to participate in the study. 46 patients (24.6%) presented at least one complication after the repair, with a median elapsed time of 11.5 months (6.5–22.5). Longitudinal differences in surgical corrective procedures (p < 0.01), clinical approach (p < 0.01), hospitalisation after surgery (p < 0.01) were found. Cosmetic data from the PPS were similar among children and parents, with no significant differences in child’s age or the type of hypospadias: 83% of children and 87% of parents were satisfied with the cosmetic result. A significant difference in functional outcome related to the type of hypospadias was reflected responses to HOSE amongst all groups of respondents: children (p < 0.001), parents (p=0.02) and surgeon (p < 0.01). The child’s HOSE total score was consistently lower than the surgeon (p < 0.01). The HOSE satisfaction rate on functional outcome was 89% for child and 92% for parent respondents.

Conclusion

Surgeons and clinicians should be cognizant of the long-term outcomes following hypospadias surgical repair and this should be reflected in a demand for a standardised approach to repair and follow-up.

Coronal sulcus–based ventral mucosal flap to help penile coverage in severe concealed penis

Introduction

There are many techniques to treat congenital concealed penis (CP). Skin resurfacing is the most difficult step in severe cases. We aim to show medium-term results of coronal sulcus–based triangular ventral mucosal flap (CBVMF) as a treatment of prepubertal severe CP, a recently reported technique. We aim to determine whether results are durable and if the technique is associated with persistent mucosal redundancy or with a permanent unequal penile color pattern.

Methods

CP cases reconstructed with CBVMF were reviewed. Preoperative complaints, degree of motivation of the child/parent to surgery, satisfaction of parent/child with results, and surgical complications were described.

Results

Seven patients (6 months to 6 years old) were treated with CBVMP. Two patients showed megaprepuce and another was submitted to a limited postectomy 3 years before. One family was not fully satisfied (expected “bigger penis”), but acknowledged that the penis was now well exposed. No child talked about the problem preoperatively, but all of the boys were fully satisfied with the results of the surgery and verbalized this in the interviews. Flap edema resolved after 3 months in all but one patient. The flaps assumed the color of penile skin in the medium term.

Conclusions

CBMVP results were satisfactory. Serious complications did not occur. Flap edema does not persist in the medium term, and redundancy was not a problem. The color of the flap tended to evolve into a pattern similar to the penile skin.

High satisfaction on genital self-perception and sexual function in healthy Norwegian male adolescents

BACKGROUND

Genital self-perception and self-reported outcome on sexual function represent important information in studies focusing on male adolescents born with a genital malformation. Normal data from an age-matched control group are essential for comparison and more knowledge is needed concerning age after puberty and before entering adulthood.

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the self-reported outcome on genital perception and sexual outcome of healthy male adolescents aged 16 and 17 years.

STUDY DESIGN

Sixty-one individuals were included in this cross-sectional study. The assessment tools included the adolescents' self-report on genital perception and sexual function measured by the Pediatric Penile Perception Score (PPPS) and their responses to a semi-structured interview. In addition, we added information on mental health and psychosocial functioning measured by the Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire, and health-related quality of life (HRQoL) measured by the Pediatric Quality of Life Inventory. Body satisfaction and self-esteem were also measured by the Global Self-Worth and Physical Appearance subscales of the revised version of the Self-Perception Profile for Adolescents (SPPA).

RESULTS

Of the 73 individuals invited, a total of 61 participated. The adolescents reported high satisfaction on genital self-perception and sexual function with a score close to 10 on the overall PPPS score (maximum overall score is 12). Participants who were dissatisfied with their genitals reported penile length, alongside foreskin, as their main concern. More than 90% reported satisfaction on sexual function, concerning erection, masturbation, ejaculation, and orgasm. Results showed a higher score on body satisfaction, self-esteem, mental health and psychosocial functioning and a lower score on HRQoL compared to the normative Norwegian data. The small numbers of individuals that scored more negatively on genital self-perception and sexual function also scored more negatively in all items studied.

DISCUSSION

A key finding in our study was their high satisfaction on the overall PPPS score and reported sexual function. The results are comparable to other studies related to healthy male adolescents and the sample studied deviate little from a representative Norwegian sample. A comparison group of age-matched adolescents from the normative population is important to determine long-term outcomes on genital appearance and sexual function of patients born with a genital malformation and operated on in early childhood. Limitations of this study are the small sample-size and the lack of information on non-participants.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results show generally positive genital self-perception and sexual function in a healthy group of Norwegian male adolescents, aged 16 and 17.

Sexual functions and fertility outcomes after hypospadias repair

Hypospadias is a common abnormality of the urogenital tract with a wide range of variety in its presentation and severity. The primary aim to correct hypospadias is to restore normal penile function and appearance. Although it can be corrected at any age, early correction between the 6 and 18 months of life is recommended. The functional and cosmetic outcomes have been very-well presented in the literature, although the aspects of sexuality and fertility of hypospadias repair in the long term are vague. In this narrative review, we aimed to gather the data around the sexuality and fertility outcomes of hypospadias repair and acknowledge urologists and parents of boys with hypospadias who will have a correction surgery about future sexual and fertility concerns.

Comparison of Outcome and Success Rate of Onlay Island Flap and Dorsal Inlay Graft in Hypospadias Reconstruction: A Prospective Study

Background

Chordee correction, urethroplasty, and tissue reconstruction are performed to correct and retain standard functionality of the penis in hypospadias. Conventional reconstruction techniques, such as onlay island flap and the dorsal inlay graft, can be performed based on the classification of hypospadias. However, the outcomes and complication rates have not been widely studied. Thus, we aimed to provide preliminary evidence regarding the efficacy and safety of both approaches in hypospadias reconstruction.

Patients and Methods

A prospective study with two time evaluations of 14 and 180 days post-operatively was performed at the Urology outpatient clinic from October 2014 to September 2019. A proportion comparison of success rate, time to the complication, operation time, catheterization duration, uroflowmetry parameter post-surgery, and mean scores comparison of PPPS were measured as the intended outcomes.

Results

In a total of 59 pediatric hypospadias, patients who had undergone reconstruction are included in this study. Higher subjects’ age and severe chordee severity were more common in the dorsal inlay graft group (age=7.50 [1–26] months; severe chordee 45.8%) compared to the onlay island flap group (age=4.0 [1–67] months; severe chordee 31.4%), both groups showed similar satisfaction regarding meatal shape and position (P=0.618), glands shape (P=0.324), penile skin shape (P=0.489), and general cosmetic appearance (P=0.526). Complication occurrence and time to complication duration of both groups were also not statistically significant (P=0.464 and P=0.413). There are no significant differences in Q_max, Q_mean, voided volume, and PVR of both groups (P=0.125, 0.136, 0.076, 0.260, respectively). Significant differences in operation times and catheterization duration are found in this study (P<0001).

Conclusion

Outcome evaluation regarding functional, complication and patient satisfaction comparing onlay flap and dorsal inlay graft for hypospadias patients is scarce. This study found that both procedures can be considered safe with comparable incidence of complications.

Cosmetic and functional outcome for the use of stitch by stitch technique in hypospadias surgery; results of 235 patients

INTRODUCTION

One of the essential goals of hypospadias surgery is to create a cosmetically and functionally accepted penis with a near-normal looking glans and external meatus.

AN OBJECTIVE

We developed our technique stitch by stitch to allow glans closure in a conical manner with centrally located external urethral meatus in hypospadias repair using onlay flap.

STUDY DESIGN (PATIENT AND METHODS)

A total of 235 hypospadias male patients (0.5-30 years old) were included in the study. All of them treated by flap urethroplasty techniques and meatoglanuloplasty using stitch by stitch technique. Operative technique (described in details by illustrations); starts with penile degloving, preparation of the flap (Site of hypospadic meatus is determined after degloving). Creation of a narrow strip of the urethral plate with wide glanular wings is done using bilateral incisions which are extended to the tip of the glans. The width of the urethral plate is about 3 mm then we suture the flap to the narrow urethral plate in two layers in continuous manner using vicryl 6/0 over a suitable plastic catheter. Triangular (V shape) area of the distal part of the flap is excised at the midline. After this we anastomose the flap to the tip of the glans. The glans appears opened in the midline as inverted V shape. Closure of the glans is finished in the midline using three mattress interrupted sutures with another three simple stitches are used in between.

RESULTS

From February 2007 to December 2016; 235 hypospadias patients fulfilled criteria and were included in our prospective cohort study table (1).

DISCUSSION

The meatoplasty technique and stitch-by-stitch glans closure were used in all patients. Excellent results were achieved with an overall degree of satisfaction of 87% in patients older than six years (based on the Pediatric Penile Perception Score), and 84% in patients younger than six years. The complication rate was low at 8.5% and was related to a failure of the flap technique. Many surgical techniques have been described for glans closure and meatoplasty with variable outcomes, but none of them fits all patients with hypospadias; each procedure has its limitations and demands specific selection criteria. Limitations of this study come from a relatively short follow-up, and a single surgeon experience that needs to be reproduced by other surgeons.

CONCLUSION

Meatoglanuloplasty using stitch-by-stitch technique provides satisfactory cosmetic and functional results in hypospadias patients.

Outcome of urethral mobilization and advancement after anterior hypospadias surgery

Background

In hypospadias surgery, despite continued refinement of various surgical procedures, there is no completely satisfactory technique in terms of complications and cosmesis. In recent literature, urethral mobilization and advancement (UMA) is gaining popularity in the management of distal penile hypospadias with no or very low complication rate as compared to all other techniques. The aim of this study is to share our results by using UMA in the management of anterior hypospadias with or without chordae.

Results

A total of 60 patients of anterior hypospadias having the mean age 57.15 ± 38.73 months were included. The mean length of hospital stay was 2.83 ± 1.33 days. The only peroperative complication was urethral injury during urethral mobilization seen in one patient. The most common postoperative complication was hematoma seen in five (8.3%) cases. Two patients (3.3%) had retraction of urethra. One patient had wound infection. Stenosis was labeled in four (6.6%). At 3 months follow-up, 93.3% patients had slit-like meatus and good urinary stream.

Conclusion

We found that UMA technique had good functional as well as excellent cosmetic outcome, so the technique can be adopted for anterior hypospadias correction.

Assessing quality of life of patients with hypospadias: A systematic review of validated patient-reported outcome instruments

BACKGROUND

Patient-reported outcomes have the potential to provide invaluable information for evaluation of hypospadias patients, aid in decision-making, performance assessment, and improvement in quality of care. To appropriately measure patient-relevant outcomes, well-developed and validated patient-reported outcome (PRO) instruments are essential.

OBJECTIVE

To identify and evaluate existing PRO instruments designed to measure quality of life and/or satisfaction of individuals with hypospadias that have been developed and validated in a hypospadias population.

METHODS

A systematic search of MEDLINE, EMBASE, PsycINFO, CINAHL and Health and Psychosocial Instruments was conducted in April 2016. Two reviewers independently assessed studies and identified PRO instruments for inclusion. Data were extracted on study characteristics, instrument development and validation, and content domains.

RESULTS

A total of 32 studies were included that used or described five PRO instruments: Hypospadias Objective Scoring Evaluation (HOSE), Pediatric Penile Perception Score (PPPS), Penile Perception Score (PPS), Genital Perception Scale (GPS) for adults, and GPS for children/adolescents. Instrument development and validation was limited. The majority of identified instruments focused on postoperative cosmetic satisfaction, with only one instrument considering urinary function, and no instruments evaluating sexual function and psychosocial sequelae.

CONCLUSIONS

While many hypospadias studies have acknowledged the necessity of a patient-reported element, few have used validated PRO instruments developed in a hypospadias population. Existing instruments to measure patient-reported outcomes in hypospadias require improvement in both the breadth of content and in their development and validation methodology.