Hot water epilepsy: Phenotype and single photon emission computed tomography observations

Clinical and Genetic Features in Patients With Reflex Bathing Epilepsy

Objective

To describe the clinical and genetic findings in a cohort of individuals with bathing epilepsy, a rare form of reflex epilepsy.

Methods

We investigated by Sanger and targeted resequencing the SYN1 gene in 12 individuals from 10 different families presenting with seizures triggered primarily by bathing or showering. An additional 12 individuals with hot-water epilepsy were also screened.

Results

In all families with bathing epilepsy, we identified 8 distinct pathogenic or likely pathogenic variants and 2 variants of unknown significance in SYN1, 9 of which are novel. Conversely, none of the individuals with hot-water epilepsy displayed SYN1 variants. In mutated individuals, seizures were typically triggered by showering or bathing regardless of the water temperature. Additional triggers included fingernail clipping, haircutting, or watching someone take a shower. Unprovoked seizures and a variable degree of developmental delay were also common.

Conclusion

Bathing epilepsy is genetically distinct reflex epilepsy caused mainly by SYN1 mutations.

A case report of sudden epileptic death linked to thermal water after mud therapy

We present the case of a 60-year-old male, with a long history of epilepsy, who was discovered submerged and unconscious in a small thermal whirlpool bath. The circumstances were forensically reviewed to include examination of clinical data and an autopsy with toxicological analysis. The conclusion was that “warm” hydro-therapy had contributed more than “hot” mud-therapy to the onset of epilepsy which led to accidental drowning, notwithstanding the deceased’s treatment with the long-lasting, poly-drug antiepileptic therapy. Further, we analysed the Italian medical indications of wellness centres for patients with epilepsy or other diseases.

Cortical-Subcortical morphometric signature of hot water epilepsy patients

BACKGROUND

Cortical and subcortical grey matter (GM) morphometric changes have been demonstrated Temporal Lobe Epilepsy (TLE) or Idiopathic Generalized Epilepsies (IGE). Hot Water Epilepsy (HWE) has not hitherto been studied in these perspectives.

PURPOSE

To investigate the cortical and subcortical grey matter in subjects with HWE in terms of thickness, volume, and surface area using Surface-Based Morphometry (SBM). To assess relationships of SBM-derived metrics with clinical variables.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Ninety-nine people with HWE and 50 age-matched healthy controls underwent high resolution volumetric MRI brain. These were processed with FreeSurfer to obtain SBM parameters i:e cortical thickness, cortical volume, and Cortical surface area. Volumes of seven subcortical GM structures (hippocampus, globus pallidus, nucleus ambiguous(NA), caudate nucleus, putamen, thalamus, and amygdala) were computed. Intergroup morphometric differences and their correlation with epilepsy-specific clinical variables were calculated.

RESULTS

SBM revealed a global reduction in bihemispheric cortical thickness and left hemispheric cortical volume. Besides, a regional difference in the morphometric measures was noted in temporo-limbic, parietal, pre-cuneus, and the cingulate region. Reduced volume of thalami and left caudate alongside an increased volume of the bilateral amygdala, bilateral nucleus ambiguous (NA), right caudate, and putamen was the other cardinal observation.

CONCLUSION

HWE subjects show alterations in the morphometry of the cortical ribbon and the subcortical grey matter. The temporal semiology, 'reflex nature' pathophysiology correlates involvement of temporo-limbic structures/somatosensory cortex, while the involvement of structures like pre-cuneus, posterior cingulate, and frontal regions are in agreement with functional networks related loss of awareness. That bilateral amygdala swelling occurs in HWE is a novel observation and may signal that it could be a distinct variant of Mesial TLE.

Reduced small world brain connectivity in probands with a family history of epilepsy

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

The role of inheritance in ascertaining susceptibility to epilepsy is well established, although the pathogenetic mechanisms are still not very clear. Interviewing for a positive family history is a popular epidemiological tool in the understanding of this susceptibility. Our aim was to visualize and localize network abnormalities that could be associated with a positive family history in a group of patients with hot water epilepsy (HWE) using resting-state functional magnetic resonance imaging (rsfMRI).

METHODS

Graph theory analysis of rsfMRI (clustering coefficient γ; path length λ; small worldness σ) in probands with a positive family history of epilepsy (FHE+, 25) were compared with probands without FHE (FHE-, 33). Whether a closer biological relationship was associated with a higher likelihood of network abnormalities was also ascertained.

RESULTS

A positive family history of epilepsy had decreased γ, increased λ and decreased σ in bilateral temporofrontal regions compared to FHE- (false discovery rate corrected P ≤ 0.0062). These changes were more pronounced in probands having first degree relatives and siblings with epilepsy. Probands with multiple types of epilepsy in the family showed decreased σ in comparison to only HWE in the family.

CONCLUSION

Graph theory analysis of the rsfMRI can be used to understand the neurobiology of diseases like genetic susceptibility in HWE. Reduced small worldness, proportional to the degree of relationship, is consistent with the current understanding that disease severity is higher in closer biological relations.

Reflex epileptic mechanisms in ictogenesis and therapeutic consequences

Recent studies of reflex epileptic mechanisms in human epilepsy using advanced methods of neurophysiology and functional neuroimaging have contributed much to elucidate pathophysiological processes of seizure generation. Whereas in lesional focal epilepsies reflex mechanisms usually relate directly to the anatomical focus, in system epilepsies they have helped to define which functional anatomical systems serving physiological function are recruited by the ictogenic mechanisms. Reflex epileptic seizures can often be prevented by avoidance or modification of triggers or by prophylactic benzodiazepine administration. Surgical options apply to focal cases. According to restricted experiences with pharmacotherapy, without controlled studies and little information on new AEDs, reflex seizures in system epilepsies appear to respond best to valproic acid and in focal epilepsies, to carbamazepine.

Reflex seizures, traits, and epilepsies: from physiology to pathology

Epileptic seizures are generally unpredictable and arise spontaneously. Patients often report non-specific triggers such as stress or sleep deprivation, but only rarely do seizures occur as a reflex event, in which they are objectively and consistently modulated, precipitated, or inhibited by external sensory stimuli or specific cognitive processes. The seizures triggered by such stimuli and processes in susceptible individuals can have different latencies. Once seizure-suppressing mechanisms fail and a critical mass (the so-called tipping point) of cortical activation is reached, reflex seizures stereotypically manifest with common motor features independent of the physiological network involved. The complexity of stimuli increases from simple sensory to complex cognitive-emotional with increasing age of onset. The topography of physiological networks involved follows the posterior-to-anterior trajectory of brain development, reflecting age-related changes in brain excitability. Reflex seizures and traits probably represent the extremes of a continuum, and understanding of their underlying mechanisms might help to elucidate the transition of normal physiological function to paroxysmal epileptic activity.