Immunohistochemistry-based comparative study in detection of Hirschsprung's disease in infants in a Tertiary Care Center

The Diagnostic Value of Immunohistochemistry Markers in Hirschsprung Disease; A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

Immunohistochemistry (IHC) markers are employed to improve the diagnostic yield when testing for Hirschsprung disease (HSCR). Yet, a superior test has not been identified.

OBJECTIVES

We aimed to determine the diagnostic test accuracy (DTA) of IHC markers.

METHODS

We conducted database search for studies reporting IHC staining on rectal biopsy investigating for HSCR. We constructed 2 × 2 contingency tables, and calculated DTA estimates in pooled and paired testing using random-effect model meta-analysis.

RESULTS

Twenty eight IHC markers from 107 studies were used to investigate for HSCR in 10891 children. In pooled analysis; calretinin sensitivity and specificity were superior to acetylcholinesterase, S100, and peripherin [98 % (CI; 0.95-0.99) & 99 % (CI; 0.97-0.99)], [94 % (CI; 0.86-0.97) & 99 % (CI; 0.96-0.99)], [92 % (CI; 0.85-0.96) & 97 % (CI; 0.89-0.99)] and [91.7 % (CI; 0.54-0.98) & 94.8 % (CI; 0.59-0.99)], respectively. In paired analysis calretinin diagnostic odds ratio was superior to hematoxylin and eosin (H&E), acetylcholinesterase and S100: [3349 (PI; 551.3-22667.2) vs 345.3 (PI; 54.9-2394.2)], [300.9 (PI; 13.3-4146.9) vs 34.6 (PI; 2.2-363.9)] and [696.9 (PI; 91.2-3401.7) vs 196.9 (PI; 29.8-890.5)], respectively. In biopsies labelled inadequate for H&E testing, calretinin specificity to rule out HSCR reached 92 % (CI; 0.288-0.998).

CONCLUSIONS

IHC provides additional diagnostic value over H&E. Calretinin appears to be, currently, a superior IHC marker. The available literature is of variable quality, cautious interpretation of the findings should be considered.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

III.

Rectal Biopsy for Hirschsprung's Disease: A Multicentre Study Involving Biopsy Technique, Pathology and Complications

BACKGROUND

The heterogeneity of rectal biopsy techniques has encouraged us to search for a surgical and pathological standardisation of this diagnostic technique to exclude Hirschsprung's disease. The different amounts of information on the anatomopathology report prompted us to compile a template for the anatomopathology report for diagnostic rectal biopsies for surgical colleagues and pathologists working on Hirschsprung's disease.

METHODS

We gathered the anonymous biopsy information and its pathology information from five hospitals for all patients in which rectal biopsies were taken to diagnose Hirschsprung's disease over two years (2020-2021).

RESULTS

Of the 82 biopsies, 20 suction (24.4%), 31 punch (37.8%) and 31 open biopsies (37.8%) were taken. Of all biopsies, 69 were conclusive (84.2%), 13 were not (15.8%). In the suction biopsy group, 60% were conclusive and 40% were not; for punch biopsy, the values were 87% and 13%, respectively and for open biopsy, 97% and 3%. Inconclusive results were due to insufficient submucosa in 6/8 suction biopsies, 4/4 punch biopsies and 0/1 open biopsies. An insufficient amount of submucosa was the reason for an inconclusive result in 6/20 cases (30%) after suction biopsy, 4/31 (12.9%) cases after punch biopsy and 0 cases (0%) after open biopsy. We had one case with major postoperative bleeding post suction biopsy; there were no further adverse effects after biopsy.

CONCLUSIONS

Diagnostic rectal biopsies in children are safe. Non-surgical biopsies are more likely to give inconclusive results due to smaller amounts of submucosa present in the specimen. Open biopsies are especially useful when previous non-surgical biopsies are inconclusive. An experienced pathologist is a key factor for the result. The anatomopathology report should specify the different layers present in the specimen, the presence of ganglion cells and hypertrophic nerve fibres, their description and a conclusion.

Diagnostic Algorithm in Hirschsprung's Disease: Focus on Immunohistochemistry Markers

BACKGROUND/AIM

Hirschsprung disease (HD) is caused by the congenital absence of ganglion cells in the distal bowel (aganglionosis). Rectal biopsy is considered important for its diagnosis. The aim of this study was to apply immunohistochemical staining using a minimal set of antibodies and develop an algorithm that will assist in the diagnosis of HD.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Rectal or colonic biopsies were performed in patients with HD (n=26) or patients treated for other bowel diseases (n=34). Immunohistochemical staining was performed for MAP1b, peripherin, S-100, calretinin, NSE, bcl-2 and CD56 proteins.

RESULTS

Staining for CD56, S-100, peripherin and calretinin facilitated the identification of ganglion cells. The use of CD56 and S-100 antibodies together resulted in the highest rate of ganglion cell staining intensity (94%).

CONCLUSION

We propose a practical diagnostic algorithm with the application of CD56 and S-100 antibodies that can be used in clinical practice in children suspected of Hirschsprung's disease.