Should cross-sex hormone treatment of transsexual subjects vary with ethnic group?

The efficacy of and user satisfaction with different antiandrogens in Chinese transgender women

Objective

Cyproterone acetate (CPA) and spironolactone (SPL) are different antiandrogens in gender-affirming hormone therapy (GAHT) for transgender women. Few studies have evaluated their efficacy and user satisfaction, especially among East Asians. This study aimed to evaluate these aspects in Chinese transgender women.

Methods

Data were collected retrospectively from transgender women visiting the Peking University Third Hospital from 2012 to 2021. From 639 people identified as transgender women, 151 of them (80 using CPA and 71 using SPL, 16 to 40-year-old) under stable GAHT ≥6 months were enrolled. Total testosterone levels and visual analogue scale (VAS)-based satisfaction scores were evaluated.

Results

No difference was observed in age between the CPA and SPL groups (median [IQR], 22 [20-24] years and 23 [20-26] years, respectively). The duration of GAHT was longer in CPA group than in SPL group (18 [10-32] months vs. 12 [8-21] months, p = 0.009). Total testosterone levels were significantly lower with CPA treatment (25 mg/d) than with SPL treatment (100 mg/d) (median [IQR]: 0.7 [0.7-2.1] nmol/L vs. 13.0 [6.0-17.8] nmol/L, p < 0.001). The proportion of total testosterone levels reaching the recommended range was significantly higher in CPA group than in SPL group (75.0% vs. 11.3%, p < 0.001). VAS-based satisfaction scores for erection decreased and figure feminization were higher in CPA group than in SPL group, which remained unchanged after adjusting for age, treatment duration, estradiol dose, and comorbid mental disorders (p < 0.05). The prolactin levels were higher in CPA group than in SPL group (18.9 [11.8-28.1] ng/ml vs. 11.8 [7.9-18.4] ng/ml, p < 0.001). No severe safety events were reported in both groups.

Conclusion

In Chinese transgender women, CPA was more effective than SPL in lowering testosterone levels. Additionally, VAS scores indicated greater satisfaction with erection decreased and figure feminization using CPA compared to SPL.

Endocrinology of Transgender Medicine

Gender-affirming treatment of transgender people requires a multidisciplinary approach in which endocrinologists play a crucial role. The aim of this paper is to review recent data on hormonal treatment of this population and its effect on physical, psychological, and mental health. The Endocrine Society guidelines for transgender women include estrogens in combination with androgen-lowering medications. Feminizing treatment with estrogens and antiandrogens has desired physical changes, such as enhanced breast growth, reduction of facial and body hair growth, and fat redistribution in a female pattern. Possible side effects should be discussed with patients, particularly those at risk for venous thromboembolism. The Endocrine Society guidelines for transgender men include testosterone therapy for virilization with deepening of the voice, cessation of menses, and increases of muscle mass and facial and body hair. Owing to the lack of evidence, treatment of gender nonbinary people should be individualized. Young people may receive pubertal suspension, consisting of GnRH analogs, later followed by sex steroids. Options for fertility preservation should be discussed before any hormonal intervention. Morbidity and cardiovascular risk with cross-sex hormones is unchanged among transgender men and unclear among transgender women. Sex steroid-related malignancies can occur but are rare. Mental health problems such as depression and anxiety have been found to reduce considerably following hormonal treatment. Future studies should aim to explore the long-term outcome of hormonal treatment in transgender people and provide evidence as to the effect of gender-affirming treatment in the nonbinary population.