Varicocelectomy in adolescents - Does it safeguard future fertility? A single centre experience

BACKGROUND

There is paucity of literature comparing varicocelectomy to observant management amongst adolescent boys with hormonal and semen abnormalities resulting from high grade unilateral varicoceles and consequent testicular volume loss. Furthermore, it is not known whether surgical correction in such adolescents improves paternity rates in future compared to their non-operated cohort.

OBJECTIVE

The primary objective was to compare adolescent boys with unilateral high grade varicocele with associated ipsilateral testicular volume loss who were operated versus those who were not, in relation to their fertility markers (hormonal, semen parameters, and testicular volume) over a 5 year follow up period. The secondary objective was to compare the paternity rates in the respective groups over long term.

STUDY DESIGN

This was a single center, retrospective study of a prospectively maintained database conducted from 2010 to 2020, based on a standardized protocol. All adolescent boys >15 years of age (middle and late adolescence), with grade II or III unilateral varicoceles with abnormal fertility markers, who were operated (Group A) and not operated (Group B) were included. The changes in hormonal assay, sonographic assessment, semen analysis at presentation, 1st year and the 5th year follow up amongst both the groups were collated and analysed. Primary paternity rates amongst both the groups was documented by telephonic or email conversations.

RESULTS

Of the 182 boys referred for varicocele management, 110 boys (Group A -70 boys and Group B - 40 boys) satisfied our inclusion criteria and were analysed. Mean age at presentation amongst Group A boys was 16.5 years (15-18 years) and Group B boys was 16 years (15-18 years). Grade III varicoceles were more predominant amongst both the groups. There was a significant improvement in all Group A boys (operated) in the fertility markers from the time at presentation to the 5th year follow up (p < 0.001). In Group B, (boys not operated) there was no significant improvement in the above parameters. The testicular catch up growth was 92% at the 5th year follow-up in Group A and 42% in Group B. At long term follow-up, the paternity rate was 80% and 36% in Group A and B respectively.

DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION

In adolescent boys in whom hormonal assay, testicular volumes and semen characteristics are negatively affected by high grade unilateral varicoceles, surgical correction could normalize these values, thereby safeguarding their fertility in the long term.

Magnification-assisted subinguinal varicocelectomy with testicular delivery in children: a preliminary report

PURPOSE

To evaluate the effectiveness of magnification-assisted subinguinal varicocelectomy (MASV) with testicular delivery in children with severe varicocele.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We retrospectively analyzed the clinical data of 23 children 15 years or younger (mean age, 12.3±1.8 years) who underwent MASV with testicular delivery and ligation of all collateral veins except arteries and deferential veins between January 2010 and January 2014. All patients had grade 3 varicocele on the left side. Varicocelectomy was decided upon due to scrotal hypotrophy (n=14, 60.9%), the existence of mass (n=6, 26.1%, including 1 recurrent case), and discomfort (n=3, 13.0%). The preservation of internal spermatic artery (ISA) was successful in 8 patients (34.8%). The mean follow-up time was 10.8±6.6 months.

RESULTS

The surgical success rate of varicocelectomy was 100%. The overall symptom resolution rate was 91.3%. The scrotal mass and discomfort disappeared, but testicular catch-up growth did not occur in 2 among 14 patients with scrotal hypotrophy. The left testis volume increased from 6.5±4.3 mL to 10.6±7.5 mL (p=0.003). There were no significant inter-group differences in terms of the surgical success rate, symptom resolution, and catch-up growth between the ISA preservation group and the ligation group. None of the subjects demonstrated testicular atrophy or hydrocele after surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

MASV with testicular delivery is an effective and safe method for children with severe varicocele.

Dilemma of adolescent varicocele: long-term outcome in patients managed surgically and in patients managed expectantly

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate outcomes of adolescent varicocele in the case of surgical versus conservative management.

METHODS

173 adolescent patients presenting with varicocele were evaluated clinically and sonographically to define varicocele grade and testicular volume. The patients were divided into 2 groups: A (53) with testicular size discrepancy >20% and bilateral varicoceles; B (120) unilaterally affected patients with testicular size discrepancy <20%, who were randomly allocated into 2 equal sub-groups (B1 & B2) of 60 patients. Group A & B1 patients underwent 3× loupe magnified inguinal varicocelectomy while B2 patients were conservatively managed.

RESULTS

Mean patient age was 14.3 years with mean testicular volume of 11.75 mL and 10.15 mL for right and left testicles, respectively. There were no significant differences between sub-groups B1 & B2 for age, mean testicular volume, size discrepancy and varicocele grade. Mean follow-up of group A & B1 patients was 78 months showing grade I varicocele recurrence (4 cases), catch-up growth in 70% of cases and normal semen analysis in all cases. Mean follow-up of group B2 patients was 79 months showing catch-up growth in 50% of cases and normal semen analysis in all but 1 case. Four cases were shifted to surgical treatment due to reduction of testicular size (2 cases), varicocele upgrade (1 case) and oligoasthenospermia (1 case). At the last follow-up, the mean testicular volume for groups A, B1 & B2 was 16.2, 16.45 & 16.3 mL for right testes and 14.7, 15.6 & 15.2 mL for left testes, respectively. There was significantly better catch-up growth in sub-group B1 compared to B2 but the testicular volume was not statistically different.

CONCLUSIONS

Although adolescent varicocelectomy was associated with a higher percentage of patients showing testicular catch-up growth, the mean testicular volume was not significantly different. Further studies are needed to report on paternity among those patients.

Clinical characteristics and surgical outcomes in adolescents and adults with varicocele

Purpose

To compare clinical characteristics and surgical results in adolescents and adults with varicocele.

Materials and Methods

We retrospectively analyzed the characteristics of 93 patients, 34 adolescents (mean age, 14.4±2.1 years) and 59 adults (mean age, 30.4±12.4 years), who underwent surgical repair of varicocele between 2006 and 2009. Median follow-up time in all patients was 18.7 months. The most bothersome symptoms, bilaterality, grades, surgical methods, artery-sparing rates, operation times, semen analysis, success rates, and recurrence-free period were compared between the two groups.

Results

The overall success rate of surgical repair was 92.5%. The most bothersome symptoms were scrotal mass, pain, and hypotrophy in adolescents and pain, scrotal mass, infertility, and hypotrophy in adults (p=0.008). There were no significant between-group differences in bilaterality, grades, surgical methods, operation times, pre- or postoperative semen analyses, success rates, or recurrence-free periods. Patients who underwent artery-sparing surgery had higher recurrence rates than did those who underwent surgery that did not spare arteries. In adults, semen density increased significantly after surgery, from 35.6 million/ml to 49.6 million/ml (p=0.046).

Conclusions

There were no significant differences in clinical characteristics or surgical results between adolescents and adults with varicocele, except for the most bothersome symptoms. Semen density increased after surgery in both groups.

Nationwide survey to evaluate the prevalence of varicoceles in South Korean middle school boys: a population based study

OBJECTIVE

We carried out a nationwide epidemiological study to evaluate the prevalence and effect of varicoceles on testicular volume in South Korean adolescents. We also investigated the correlation between varicoceles and body mass index (BMI).

METHODS

In this prospective study, physical examinations were carried out to assess the presence and severity of varicoceles in middle school boys from six regions of South Korea. Testicular volume, height and weight of all boys were measured. The prevalence of varicoceles was assessed. The associations between age, testicular volume, BMI, and the presence and severity of varicoceles were examined.

RESULTS

A total of 1938 boys with a mean age of 14.1 years (range 13-16 years) were screened. A varicocele was found on the left side in 295 (15.2%) boys and on the right side in 8 (0.4%) boys. Bilateral varicoceles were found in 17 (0.9%) individuals. Of the subjects with a left varicocele, 151 (51.2%), 80 (27.1%) and 64 (25.1%) boys had a grade 1, 2 or 3 varicocele, respectively. The prevalence of varicoceles did not increase with age. The proportion of boys with testicular size discrepancies increased with the severity of the varicocele. After adjusting for age, BMI had a negative correlation with the presence of varicoceles.

CONCLUSIONS

The prevalence of varicoceles in South Korean middle school boys is 16.5%. The presence of varicoceles seems to have a negative effect on testicular growth. BMI has a significant inverse relationship with the occurrence of varicoceles.