Designing HDAC-PROTACs: lessons learned so far

Slow-Binding and Covalent HDAC Inhibition: A New Paradigm?

The dysregulated post-translational modification of proteins is an established hallmark of human disease. Through Zn2+-dependent hydrolysis of acyl-lysine modifications, histone deacetylases (HDACs) are key regulators of disease-implicated signaling pathways and tractable drug targets in the clinic. Early targeting of this family of 11 enzymes (HDAC1-11) afforded a first generation of broadly acting inhibitors with medicinal applications in oncology, specifically in cutaneous and peripheral T-cell lymphomas and in multiple myeloma. However, first-generation HDAC inhibitors are often associated with weak-to-modest patient benefits, dose-limited efficacies, pharmacokinetic liabilities, and recurring clinical toxicities. Alternative inhibitor design to target single enzymes and avoid toxic Zn2+-binding moieties have not overcome these limitations. Instead, recent literature has seen a shift toward noncanonical mechanistic approaches focused on slow-binding and covalent inhibition. Such compounds hold the potential of improving the pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic profiles of HDAC inhibitors through the extension of the drug-target residence time. This perspective aims to capture this emerging paradigm and discuss its potential to improve the preclinical/clinical outlook of HDAC inhibitors in the coming years.

Unveiling the role of histone deacetylases in neurological diseases: focus on epilepsy

Epilepsy remains a prevalent chronic neurological disease that is featured by aberrant, recurrent and hypersynchronous discharge of neurons and poses a great challenge to healthcare systems. Although several therapeutic interventions are successfully utilized for treating epilepsy, they can merely provide symptom relief but cannot exert disease-modifying effect. Therefore, it is of urgent need to explore other potential mechanism to develop a novel approach to delay the epileptic progression. Since approximately 30 years ago, histone deacetylases (HDACs), the versatile epigenetic regulators responsible for gene transcription via binding histones or non-histone substrates, have grabbed considerable attention in drug discovery. There are also substantial evidences supporting that aberrant expressions and/activities of HDAC isoforms are reported in epilepsy and HDAC inhibitors (HDACi) have been successfully utilized for therapeutic purposes in this condition. However, the specific mechanisms underlying the role of HDACs in epileptic progression have not been fully understood. Herein, we reviewed the basic information of HDACs, summarized the recent findings associated with the roles of diverse HDAC subunits in epilepsy and discussed the potential regulatory mechanisms by which HDACs affected the development of epilepsy. Additionally, we also provided a brief discussion on the potential of HDACs as promising therapeutic targets for epilepsy treatment, serving as a valuable reference for basic study and clinical translation in epilepsy field.

PROTAC-Mediated HDAC7 Protein Degradation Unveils Its Deacetylase-Independent Proinflammatory Function in Macrophages

Class IIa histone deacetylases (Class IIa HDACs) play critical roles in regulating essential cellular metabolism and inflammatory pathways. However, dissecting the specific roles of each class IIa HDAC isoform is hindered by the pan-inhibitory effect of current inhibitors and a lack of tools to probe their functions beyond epigenetic regulation. In this study, a novel PROTAC-based compound B4 is developed, which selectively targets and degrades HDAC7, resulting in the effective attenuation of a specific set of proinflammatory cytokines in both lipopolysaccharide (LPS)-stimulated macrophages and a mouse model. By employing B4 as a molecular probe, evidence is found for a previously explored role of HDAC7 that surpasses its deacetylase function, suggesting broader implications in inflammatory processes. Mechanistic investigations reveal the critical involvement of HDAC7 in the Toll-like receptor 4 (TLR4) signaling pathway by directly interacting with the TNF receptor-associated factor 6 and TGFβ-activated kinase 1 (TRAF6-TAK1) complex, thereby initiating the activation of the downstream mitogen-activated protein kinase/nuclear factor-κB (MAPK/NF-κB) signaling cascade and subsequent gene transcription. This study expands the insight into HDAC7's role within intricate inflammatory networks and highlights its therapeutic potential as a novel target for anti-inflammatory treatments.

Fluorescence theranostic PROTACs for real-time visualization of ERα degradation

Proteolysis targeting chimera (PROTAC) technology, a groundbreaking strategy for degradation of pathogenic proteins by hijacking of the ubiquitin-proteasome-system has become a promising strategy in drug design. However, the real-time monitoring and visualization of protein degradation processes have been long-standing challenges in the realm of drug development. In this research, we sought to amalgamate the highly efficient protein-degrading capabilities of PROTAC technology with the visualization attributes of fluorescent probes, with the potential to pave the path for the design and development of a novel class of visual PROTACs. These novel PROTACs uniquely possess both fluorescence imaging and therapeutic characteristics, all with the goal of enabling real-time observations of protein degradation processes. Our approach involved the utilization of a high ER-targeting fluorescent probe, previously reported in our laboratory, which served as a warhead that specifically binds to the protein of interest (POI). Additionally, a VHL ligand for recruiting E3 ligase and linkers of various lengths were incorporated to synthesize a series of novel ER-inherent fluorescence PROTACs. Among them, compound A3 demonstrated remarkable efficiency in degrading ERα proteins (DC50 = 0.12 μM) and displaying exceptional anti-proliferative activity against MCF-7 cells (IC50 = 0.051 μM). Furthermore, it exhibited impressive fluorescence imaging performance, boasting an emission wavelength of up to 582 nm, a Stokes shift of 116 nm, and consistent optical properties. These attributes make it especially suitable for the real-time, in situ tracking of ERα protein degradation processes, thus may serve as a privileged visual theranostic PROTAC for ERα+ breast cancer. This study not only broadens the application spectrum of PROTAC technology but also introduces a novel approach for real-time visualization of protein degradation processes, ultimately enhancing the diagnostic and treatment efficacy of PROTACs.

HDAC-targeting epigenetic modulators for cancer immunotherapy

HDAC inhibitors, which can inhibit the activity of HDAC enzymes, have been extensively studied in tumor immunotherapy and have shown potential therapeutic effects in cancer immunotherapy. To date, numerous small molecule HDAC inhibitors have been identified, but many of them suffer from limited clinical efficacy and serious toxicity. Hence, HDAC inhibitor-based combination therapies, and other HDAC modulators (e.g. PROTAC degraders, dual-acting agents) have attracted great attention with significant advancements achieved in the past few years due to their superior efficacy compared to single-target HDAC inhibitors. In this review, we overviewed the recent progress on HDAC-based drug discovery with a focus on HDAC inhibitor-based drug combination therapy and other HDAC-targeting strategies (e.g. selective HDAC inhibitors, HDAC-based dual-target inhibitors, and PROTAC HDAC degraders) for cancer immunotherapy. In addition, we also summarized the reported co-crystal structures of HDAC inhibitors in complex with their target proteins and the binding interactions. Finally, the challenges and future directions for HDAC-based drug discovery in cancer immunotherapy are also discussed in detail.

Pan-cancer analyses of bromodomain containing 9 as a novel therapeutic target reveals its diagnostic, prognostic potential and biological mechanism in human tumours

BACKGROUND

Mutations in one or more genes responsible for encoding subunits within the SWItch/Sucrose Non-Fermentable (SWI/SNF) chromatin-remodelling complexes are found in approximately 25% of cancer patients. Bromodomain containing 9 (BRD9) is a more recently identified protein coding gene, which can encode SWI/SNF chromatin-remodelling complexes subunits. Although initial evaluations of the potential of BRD9-based targeted therapy have been explored in the clinical application of a small number of cancer types, more detailed study of the diagnostic and prognostic potential, as well as the detailed biological mechanism of BRD9 remains unreported.

METHODS

We used various bioinformatics tools to generate a comprehensive, pan-cancer analyses of BRD9 expression in multiple disease types described in The Cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA). Experimental validation was conducted in tissue microarrays and cell lines derived from lung and colon cancers.

RESULTS

Our study revealed that BRD9 exhibited elevated expression in a wide range of tumours. Analysis of survival data and DNA methylation for BRD9 indicated distinct conclusions for multiple tumours. mRNA splicing and molecular binding were involved in the functional mechanism of BRD9. BRD9 may affect cancer progression through different phosphorylation sites or N6 -methyladenosine site modifications. BRD9 could potentially serve as a novel biomarker for diagnosing different cancer types, especially could accurately forecast the prognosis of melanoma patients receiving anti-programmed cell death 1 immunotherapy. BRD9 has the potential to serve as a therapeutic target, when pairing with etoposide in patients with melanoma. The BRD9/SMARCD1 axis exhibited promising discriminative performance in forecasting the prognosis of patients afflicted with liver hepatocellular carcinoma (LIHC) and mesothelioma. Additionally, this axis appears to potentially influence the immune response in LIHC by regulating the programmed death-ligand 1 immune checkpoint. For experimental validation, high expression levels of BRD9 were observed in tumour tissue samples from both lung and colon cancer patients. Knocking down BRD9 led to the inhibition of lung and colon cancer development, likely via the Wnt/β-catenin signalling pathway.

CONCLUSIONS

These pan-cancer study revealed the diagnostic and prognostic potential, along with the biological mechanism of BRD9 as a novel therapeutic target in human tumours.

Targeting reversible post-translational modifications with PROTACs: a focus on enzymes modifying protein lysine and arginine residues

PROTACs represent an emerging field in medicinal chemistry, which has already led to the development of compounds that reached clinical studies. Posttranslational modifications contribute to the complexity of proteomes, with 2846 disease-associated sites. PROTAC field is very advanced in targeting kinases, while its use for enzymes mediating posttranslational modifications of the basic amino acid residues, started to be developed recently. Therefore, we bring together this less popular class of PROTACs, targeting lysine acetyltransferases/deacetylases, lysine and arginine methyltransferases, ADP-ribosyltransferases, E3 ligases, and ubiquitin-specific proteases. We put special emphasis on structural aspects of PROTAC elements to facilitate the lengthy experimental endeavours directed towards developing PROTACs. We will cover the period from the inception of the field, 2017, to April 2023.

Dietary γ-mangostin triggers immunogenic cell death and activates cGAS signaling in acute myeloid leukemia

Immunogenic cell death (ICD), one of cell-death types through release of damage-associated molecular patterns from dying tumor cells, activates tumor-specific immune response and elicits anti-tumor immunity by traditional radiotherapy and chemotherapy. However, whether natural products could induce ICD in leukemia is not elucidated. Here, we report dietary γ-mangostin eradicates murine primary leukemic cells and prolongs the survival of leukemic mice. As well, it restrains primary leukemic cells and CD34+ leukemic progenitor cells from leukemia patients. Strikingly, γ-mangostin attenuates leukemic cells by inducing ICD as characterized by expression of HSP90B1, ANXA1 and IL1B. Additionally, γ-mangostin accelerates cytoplasmic chromatin fragments generation, promoting DNA damage response, and enhances cGAS activation, leading to up-regulation of chemokines. Meanwhile, it induces HDAC4 degradation and acetylated histone H3 accumulation, which promotes chemokines transcription. Ultimately, CD8+ T cell is activated and recruited by γ-mangostin-induced chemokines in the microenvironment. Our study identifies γ-mangostin triggers ICD and activates cGAS signaling through DNA damage response and epigenetic modification. Therefore, dietary γ-mangostin would act as a potential agent to provoke anti-tumor immunity in the prevention and treatment of leukemia.

PROTAC chemical probes for histone deacetylase enzymes

Over the past three decades, we have witnessed the progression of small molecule chemical probes designed to inhibit the catalytic active site of histone deacetylase (HDAC) enzymes into FDA approved drugs. However, it is only in the past five years we have witnessed the emergence of proteolysis targeting chimeras (PROTACs) capable of promoting the proteasome mediated degradation of HDACs. This is a field still in its infancy, however given the current progress of PROTACs in clinical trials and the fact that FDA approved HDAC drugs are already in the clinic, there is significant potential in developing PROTACs to target HDACs as therapeutics. Beyond therapeutics, PROTACs also serve important applications as chemical probes to interrogate fundamental biology related to HDACs via their unique degradation mode of action. In this review, we highlight some of the key findings to date in the discovery of PROTACs targeting HDACs by HDAC class and HDAC isoenzyme, current gaps in PROTACs to target HDACs and future outlooks.

Discovery of highly potent HDAC8 PROTACs with anti-tumor activity

Various diseases are deeply associated with aberrations in HDAC8 functions. These aberrations can be assigned to either structural functions or catalytic functions of HDAC8. Therefore, development of HDAC8 degradation inducers might be more promising than HDAC8 inhibitors. We employed the proteolysis targeting chimera (PROTAC) strategy to develop a selective and potent HDAC8 degradation inducer CT-4 with single-digit nanomolar DC₅₀ values and over 95% D_max in both triple-negative breast cancer MDA-MB-231 cells and T-cell leukemia cells. Notably, CT-4 demonstrated potent anti-migration activity and limited anti-proliferative activity in MDA-MB-231 cells. In contrast, CT-4 effectively induced apototic cell death in Jurkat cells, as assessed by a caspase 3/7 activity assay and flow cytometry. Our findings suggest that the development of HDAC8 degradation inducers holds great potential for the treatment of HDAC8-related diseases.

HDACs as an emerging target in endocrine tumors: a comprehensive review

INTRODUCTION

The pathogenic role of deregulated histone (de-)acetylation by histone deacetyles (HDACs) has been demonstrated in several human cancers. While some HDAC inhibitors (HDACi) have been approved for individual entities, for endocrine tumors such translation into clinical practice has not yet been achieved.

AREAS COVERED

Relevant results identified by structured searches in PubMed as well as in reference lists are summarized in a narrative review to discuss the current knowledge of HDAC involvement and their therapeutic relevance in endocrine tumors. For thyroid, neuroendocrine, and adrenal tumors, various oncogenic mechanisms of HDAC deregulation and effects of HDAC inhibitors (HDACi) have been identified in preclinical studies including direct cancer cell toxicity and modification of differentiation status.

EXPERT OPINION

Based on positive pre-clinical results, the research on HDAC (inhibition) in the various endocrine tumors should be intensified - yet, it needs to be considered that i) HDACs' oncogenic actions might constitute only a part of epigenetic mechanisms driving cancer, ii) individual HDAC has different roles in different endocrine tumor entities, iii) inhibition of HDACs might be especially attractive in combination with conventional or other targeted therapies, and iv) new HDAC-inhibiting drugs with improved specificity or functionally modified HDACi might further improve their efficacy.

Comprehensive Transcriptomic Analysis of Novel Class I HDAC Proteolysis Targeting Chimeras (PROTACs)

The class I histone deacetylase (HDAC) enzymes;HDAC1,2 and 3 form the catalytic engine of at least seven structurally distinct multiprotein complexes in cells. These molecular machines play a vital role in the regulation of chromatin accessibility and gene activity via the removal of acetyl moieties from lysine residues within histone tails. Their inhibition via small molecule inhibitors has beneficial effects in a number of disease types, including the clinical treatment of hematological cancers. We have previously reported a library of proteolysis targeting chimeras (PROTACs) incorporating a benzamide-based HDAC ligand (from CI-994), with an alkyl linker and ligand for the von Hippel-Lindau (VHL) E3 ubiquitin ligase that degrade HDAC1-3 at submicromolar concentrations. Here we report the addition of two novel PROTACs (JPS026 and JPS027), which utilize a ligand for the cellular inhibitor of apoptosis (IAP) family of E3 ligases. We found that both VHL (JPS004)- and IAP (JPS026)-based PROTACs degrade HDAC1-3 and induce histone acetylation to a similar degree. However, JPS026 is significantly more potent at inducing cell death in HCT116 cells than is JPS004. RNA sequencing analysis of PROTAC-treated HCT116 cells showed a distinct gene expression signature in which cell cycle and DNA replication machinery are repressed. Components of the mTORC1 and -2 complexes were also reduced, leading to an increase in FOXO3 and downstream target genes that regulate autophagy and apoptosis. In summary, a novel combination of HDAC and IAP ligands generates a PROTAC with a potent ability to stimulate apoptosis and differential gene expression in human cancer cells.

An overview of PROTACs: a promising drug discovery paradigm

Proteolysis targeting chimeras (PROTACs) technology has emerged as a novel therapeutic paradigm in recent years. PROTACs are heterobifunctional molecules that degrade target proteins by hijacking the ubiquitin-proteasome system. Currently, about 20-25% of all protein targets are being studied, and most works focus on their enzymatic functions. Unlike small molecules, PROTACs inhibit the whole biological function of the target protein by binding to the target protein and inducing subsequent proteasomal degradation. PROTACs compensate for limitations that transcription factors, nuclear proteins, and other scaffolding proteins are difficult to handle with traditional small-molecule inhibitors. Currently, PROTACs have successfully degraded diverse proteins, such as BTK, BRD4, AR, ER, STAT3, IRAK4, tau, etc. And ARV-110 and ARV-471 exhibited excellent efficacy in clinical II trials. However, what targets are appropriate for PROTAC technology to achieve better benefits than small-molecule inhibitors are not fully understood. And how to rationally design an efficient PROTACs and optimize it to be orally effective poses big challenges for researchers. In this review, we summarize the features of PROTAC technology, analyze the detail of general principles for designing efficient PROTACs, and discuss the typical application of PROTACs targeting different protein categories. In addition, we also introduce the progress of relevant clinical trial results of representative PROTACs and assess the challenges and limitations that PROTACs may face. Collectively, our studies provide references for further application of PROTACs.

PROTAC: targeted drug strategy. Principles and limitations

The PROTAC (PROteolysis TArgeting Chimera) technology is a method of targeting intracellular proteins previously considered undruggable. This technology utilizes the ubiquitin-proteasome system in cells to specifically degrade target proteins, thereby offering significant advantages over conventional small-molecule inhibitors of the enzymatic function. Preclinical and preliminary clinical trials of PROTAC-based compounds (degraders) are presented. The review considers the general principles of the design of degraders. Advances and challenges of the PROTAC technology are discussed.

Developing HDAC4-Selective Protein Degraders To Investigate the Role of HDAC4 in Huntington's Disease Pathology

Huntington's disease (HD) is a lethal autosomal dominant neurodegenerative disorder resulting from a CAG repeat expansion in the huntingtin (HTT) gene. The product of translation of this gene is a highly aggregation-prone protein containing a polyglutamine tract >35 repeats (mHTT) that has been shown to colocalize with histone deacetylase 4 (HDAC4) in cytoplasmic inclusions in HD mouse models. Genetic reduction of HDAC4 in an HD mouse model resulted in delayed aggregation of mHTT, along with amelioration of neurological phenotypes and extended lifespan. To further investigate the role of HDAC4 in cellular models of HD, we have developed bifunctional degraders of the protein and report the first potent and selective degraders of HDAC4 that show an effect in multiple cell lines, including HD mouse model-derived cortical neurons. These degraders act via the ubiquitin-proteasomal pathway and selectively degrade HDAC4 over other class IIa HDAC isoforms (HDAC5, HDAC7, and HDAC9).

Development of the first non-hydroxamate selective HDAC6 degraders

The targeted degradation of histone deacetylase 6 (HDAC6) by heterobifunctional degraders constitutes a promising approach to treat HDAC6-driven diseases. Previous HDAC6 selective degraders utilised a hydroxamic acid as a zinc-binding group (ZBG) which features mutagenic and genotoxic potential. Here we report the development of a new class of selective HDAC6 degraders based on a difluoromethyl-1,3,4-oxadiazole warhead as ZBG.

Current trends in development of HDAC-based chemotherapeutics

BACKGROUND

Histone deacetylases (HDACs) are one of the essential epigenetic targets in cancer treatment. These enzymes play key roles in post-translation modification (PTM) and gene expression, and consequently, their inhibitors are about to find their place in pharmacotherapy. Most of the currently approved HDAC inhibitors (HDACIs) are wide-spectrum with poor clinical outcomes and numerous side effects. Therefore, new generations of HDAC-based chemotherapeutics with better clinical outcomes are emerging, e.g., isoform-selective inhibitors, multitargeted HDACIs, as well as HDAC degraders.

AIM

The review intended to introduce drug design approaches which were used for designing novel agents which can be beneficial in the process of finding new and more effective HDACI-based therapeutics.

METHODS

PubMed and other databases were searched for literature regarding the structure-function of HDAC isoforms, and strategies used to design HDAC inhibitors. Also, all clinical trials available from the ClinicalTrials site for years 2021-2022 were investigated.

KEY FINDINGS

It is expected that the future of drug discovery projects in HDAC field will concentrate mostly on issues such as isoform-selectivity, multitargeted HDAC inhibitors and HDAC degraders. Deeper knowledge of the 3D structure of HDACs complexed with inhibitors and extensive delineation of biological roles of HDACs are needed for efficient investigations leading to the discovery of novel potent inhibitors.

SIGNIFICANCE

Histone deacetylases (HDACs) are one of the important epigenetic targets in cancer treatment drug discovery. Comprehending the structure of HDAC isoforms along with applied drug design strategies can inspire new ideas.

HDAC Inhibitors for the Therapy of Triple Negative Breast Cancer

Triple negative breast cancer (TNBC) is an urgent as well as huge medical challenge, which is associated with poor prognosis and responsiveness to chemotherapies. Since epigenetic changes are highly implicated in TNBC tumorigenesis and development, inhibitors of histone deacetylases (HDACIs) could represent a promising therapeutic strategy. Although clinical trials involving single HDACIs showed disappointing results against TNBC, recent studies emphasize the high potential impact of HDACIs in controlling TNBC. In addition, encouraging results stem from new compounds designed to obtain isoform selectivity and/or polypharmacological HDAC approach. The present review provides a discussion of the HDACIs pharmacophoric models and of the structural modifications, leading to compounds with a potent activity against TNBC progression.

Targeting Histone Deacetylases: Opportunities for Cancer Treatment and Chemoprevention

The dysregulation of gene expression is a critical event involved in all steps of tumorigenesis. Aberrant histone and non-histone acetylation modifications of gene expression due to the abnormal activation of histone deacetylases (HDAC) have been reported in hematologic and solid types of cancer. In this sense, the cancer-associated epigenetic alterations are promising targets for anticancer therapy and chemoprevention. HDAC inhibitors (HDACi) induce histone hyperacetylation within target proteins, altering cell cycle and proliferation, cell differentiation, and the regulation of cell death programs. Over the last three decades, an increasing number of synthetic and naturally derived compounds, such as dietary-derived products, have been demonstrated to act as HDACi and have provided biological and molecular insights with regard to the role of HDAC in cancer. The first part of this review is focused on the biological roles of the Zinc-dependent HDAC family in malignant diseases. Accordingly, the small-molecules and natural products such as HDACi are described in terms of cancer therapy and chemoprevention. Furthermore, structural considerations are included to improve the HDACi selectivity and combinatory potential with other specific targeting agents in bifunctional inhibitors and proteolysis targeting chimeras. Additionally, clinical trials that combine HDACi with current therapies are discussed, which may open new avenues in terms of the feasibility of HDACi’s future clinical applications in precision cancer therapies.