Alignment-free detection of horizontal gene transfer between closely related bacterial genomes

Genetic Transfer in Action: Uncovering DNA Flow in an Extremophilic Microbial Community

Horizontal genetic transfer (HGT) is a significant driver of genomic novelty in all domains of life. HGT has been investigated in many studies however, the focus has been on conspicuous protein-coding DNA transfers that often prove to be adaptive in recipient organisms and are therefore fixed longer-term in lineages. These results comprise a subclass of HGTs and do not represent exhaustive (coding and non-coding) DNA transfer and its impact on ecology. Uncovering exhaustive HGT can provide key insights into the connectivity of genomes in communities and how these transfers may occur. In this study, we use the term frequency-inverse document frequency (TF-IDF) technique, that has been used successfully to mine DNA transfers within real and simulated high-quality prokaryote genomes, to search for exhaustive HGTs within an extremophilic microbial community. We establish a pipeline for validating transfers identified using this approach. We find that most DNA transfers are within-domain and involve non-coding DNA. A relatively high proportion of the predicted protein-coding HGTs appear to encode transposase activity, restriction-modification system components, and biofilm formation functions. Our study demonstrates the utility of the TF-IDF approach for HGT detection and provides insights into the mechanisms of recent DNA transfer.

Fast and compact matching statistics analytics

MOTIVATION

Fast, lightweight methods for comparing the sequence of ever larger assembled genomes from ever growing databases are increasingly needed in the era of accurate long reads and pan-genome initiatives. Matching statistics is a popular method for computing whole-genome phylogenies and for detecting structural rearrangements between two genomes, since it is amenable to fast implementations that require a minimal setup of data structures. However, current implementations use a single core, take too much memory to represent the result, and do not provide efficient ways to analyze the output in order to explore local similarities between the sequences.

RESULTS

We develop practical tools for computing matching statistics between large-scale strings, and for analyzing its values, faster and using less memory than the state-of-the-art. Specifically, we design a parallel algorithm for shared-memory machines that computes matching statistics 30 times faster with 48 cores in the cases that are most difficult to parallelize. We design a lossy compression scheme that shrinks the matching statistics array to a bitvector that takes from 0.8 to 0.2 bits per character, depending on the dataset and on the value of a threshold, and that achieves 0.04 bits per character in some variants. And we provide efficient implementations of range-maximum and range-sum queries that take a few tens of milliseconds while operating on our compact representations, and that allow computing key local statistics about the similarity between two strings. Our toolkit makes construction, storage and analysis of matching statistics arrays practical for multiple pairs of the largest genomes available today, possibly enabling new applications in comparative genomics.

AVAILABILITY AND IMPLEMENTATION

Our C/C++ code is available at https://github.com/odenas/indexed_ms under GPL-3.0. The data underlying this article are available in NCBI Genome at https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/genome and in the International Genome Sample Resource (IGSR) at https://www.internationalgenome.org.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION

Supplementary data are available at Bioinformatics online.

The statistical power of k-mer based aggregative statistics for alignment-free detection of horizontal gene transfer

Alignment-based database search and sequence comparison are commonly used to detect horizontal gene transfer (HGT). However, with the rapid increase of sequencing depth, hundreds of thousands of contigs are routinely assembled from metagenomics studies, which challenges alignment-based HGT analysis by overwhelming the known reference sequences. Detecting HGT by k-mer statistics thus becomes an attractive alternative. These alignment-free statistics have been demonstrated in high performance and efficiency in whole-genome and transcriptome comparisons. To adapt k-mer statistics for HGT detection, we developed two aggregative statistics TsumS and Tsum*, which subsample metagenome contigs by their representative regions, and summarize the regional D2S and D2* metrics by their upper bounds. We systematically studied the aggregative statistics’ power at different k-mer size using simulations. Our analysis showed that, in general, the power of TsumS and Tsum* increases with sequencing coverage, and reaches a maximum power >80% at k = 6, with 5% Type-I error and the coverage ratio >0.2x. The statistical power of TsumS and Tsum* was evaluated with realistic simulations of HGT mechanism, sequencing depth, read length, and base error. We expect these statistics to be useful distance metrics for identifying HGT in metagenomic studies.

Alignment-free sequence comparison: benefits, applications, and tools

Alignment-free sequence analyses have been applied to problems ranging from whole-genome phylogeny to the classification of protein families, identification of horizontally transferred genes, and detection of recombined sequences. The strength of these methods makes them particularly useful for next-generation sequencing data processing and analysis. However, many researchers are unclear about how these methods work, how they compare to alignment-based methods, and what their potential is for use for their research. We address these questions and provide a guide to the currently available alignment-free sequence analysis tools.

gmos: Rapid Detection of Genome Mosaicism over Short Evolutionary Distances

Prokaryotic and viral genomes are often altered by recombination and horizontal gene transfer. The existing methods for detecting recombination are primarily aimed at viral genomes or sets of loci, since the expensive computation of underlying statistical models often hinders the comparison of complete prokaryotic genomes. As an alternative, alignment-free solutions are more efficient, but cannot map (align) a query to subject genomes. To address this problem, we have developed gmos (Genome MOsaic Structure), a new program that determines the mosaic structure of query genomes when compared to a set of closely related subject genomes. The program first computes local alignments between query and subject genomes and then reconstructs the query mosaic structure by choosing the best local alignment for each query region. To accomplish the analysis quickly, the program mostly relies on pairwise alignments and constructs multiple sequence alignments over short overlapping subject regions only when necessary. This fine-tuned implementation achieves an efficiency comparable to an alignment-free tool. The program performs well for simulated and real data sets of closely related genomes and can be used for fast recombination detection; for instance, when a new prokaryotic pathogen is discovered. As an example, gmos was used to detect genome mosaicism in a pathogenic Enterococcus faecium strain compared to seven closely related genomes. The analysis took less than two minutes on a single 2.1 GHz processor. The output is available in fasta format and can be visualized using an accessory program, gmosDraw (freely available with gmos).

Exploring lateral genetic transfer among microbial genomes using TF-IDF

Many microbes can acquire genetic material from their environment and incorporate it into their genome, a process known as lateral genetic transfer (LGT). Computational approaches have been developed to detect genomic regions of lateral origin, but typically lack sensitivity, ability to distinguish donor from recipient, and scalability to very large datasets. To address these issues we have introduced an alignment-free method based on ideas from document analysis, term frequency-inverse document frequency (TF-IDF). Here we examine the performance of TF-IDF on three empirical datasets: 27 genomes of Escherichia coli and Shigella, 110 genomes of enteric bacteria, and 143 genomes across 12 bacterial and three archaeal phyla. We investigate the effect of k-mer size, gap size and delineation of groups on the inference of genomic regions of lateral origin, finding an interplay among these parameters and sequence divergence. Because TF-IDF identifies donor groups and delineates regions of lateral origin within recipient genomes, aggregating these regions by gene enables us to explore, for the first time, the mosaic nature of lateral genes including the multiplicity of biological sources, ancestry of transfer and over-writing by subsequent transfers. We carry out Gene Ontology enrichment tests to investigate which biological processes are potentially affected by LGT.

A novel alignment-free method for detection of lateral genetic transfer based on TF-IDF

Lateral genetic transfer (LGT) plays an important role in the evolution of microbes. Existing computational methods for detecting genomic regions of putative lateral origin scale poorly to large data. Here, we propose a novel method based on TF-IDF (Term Frequency-Inverse Document Frequency) statistics to detect not only regions of lateral origin, but also their origin and direction of transfer, in sets of hierarchically structured nucleotide or protein sequences. This approach is based on the frequency distributions of k-mers in the sequences. If a set of contiguous k-mers appears sufficiently more frequently in another phyletic group than in its own, we infer that they have been transferred from the first group to the second. We performed rigorous tests of TF-IDF using simulated and empirical datasets. With the simulated data, we tested our method under different parameter settings for sequence length, substitution rate between and within groups and post-LGT, deletion rate, length of transferred region and k size, and found that we can detect LGT events with high precision and recall. Our method performs better than an established method, ALFY, which has high recall but low precision. Our method is efficient, with runtime increasing approximately linearly with sequence length.

Ebolavirus classification based on natural vectors

According to the WHO, ebolaviruses have resulted in 8818 human deaths in West Africa as of January 2015. To better understand the evolutionary relationship of the ebolaviruses and infer virulence from the relationship, we applied the alignment-free natural vector method to classify the newest ebolaviruses. The dataset includes three new Guinea viruses as well as 99 viruses from Sierra Leone. For the viruses of the family of Filoviridae, both genus label classification and species label classification achieve an accuracy rate of 100%. We represented the relationships among Filoviridae viruses by Unweighted Pair Group Method with Arithmetic Mean (UPGMA) phylogenetic trees and found that the filoviruses can be separated well by three genera. We performed the phylogenetic analysis on the relationship among different species of Ebolavirus by their coding-complete genomes and seven viral protein genes (glycoprotein [GP], nucleoprotein [NP], VP24, VP30, VP35, VP40, and RNA polymerase [L]). The topology of the phylogenetic tree by the viral protein VP24 shows consistency with the variations of virulence of ebolaviruses. The result suggests that VP24 be a pharmaceutical target for treating or preventing ebolaviruses.

Integrating alignment-based and alignment-free sequence similarity measures for biological sequence classification

MOTIVATION

Alignment-based sequence similarity searches, while accurate for some type of sequences, can produce incorrect results when used on more divergent but functionally related sequences that have undergone the sequence rearrangements observed in many bacterial and viral genomes. Here, we propose a classification model that exploits the complementary nature of alignment-based and alignment-free similarity measures with the aim to improve the accuracy with which DNA and protein sequences are characterized.

RESULTS

Our model classifies sequences using a combined sequence similarity score calculated by adaptively weighting the contribution of different sequence similarity measures. Weights are determined independently for each sequence in the test set and reflect the discriminatory ability of individual similarity measures in the training set. Because the similarity between some sequences is determined more accurately with one type of measure rather than another, our classifier allows different sets of weights to be associated with different sequences. Using five different similarity measures, we show that our model significantly improves the classification accuracy over the current composition- and alignment-based models, when predicting the taxonomic lineage for both short viral sequence fragments and complete viral sequences. We also show that our model can be used effectively for the classification of reads from a real metagenome dataset as well as protein sequences.

AVAILABILITY AND IMPLEMENTATION

All the datasets and the code used in this study are freely available at https://collaborators.oicr.on.ca/vferretti/borozan_csss/csss.html.

CONTACT

ivan.borozan@gmail.com

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION

Supplementary data are available at Bioinformatics online.

Alignment-free genetic sequence comparisons: a review of recent approaches by word analysis

Modern sequencing and genome assembly technologies have provided a wealth of data, which will soon require an analysis by comparison for discovery. Sequence alignment, a fundamental task in bioinformatics research, may be used but with some caveats. Seminal techniques and methods from dynamic programming are proving ineffective for this work owing to their inherent computational expense when processing large amounts of sequence data. These methods are prone to giving misleading information because of genetic recombination, genetic shuffling and other inherent biological events. New approaches from information theory, frequency analysis and data compression are available and provide powerful alternatives to dynamic programming. These new methods are often preferred, as their algorithms are simpler and are not affected by synteny-related problems. In this review, we provide a detailed discussion of computational tools, which stem from alignment-free methods based on statistical analysis from word frequencies. We provide several clear examples to demonstrate applications and the interpretations over several different areas of alignment-free analysis such as base-base correlations, feature frequency profiles, compositional vectors, an improved string composition and the D2 statistic metric. Additionally, we provide detailed discussion and an example of analysis by Lempel-Ziv techniques from data compression.

Analysis of horizontal genetic transfer in red algae in the post-genomics age

The recently published genome of the unicellular red alga Porphyridium purpureum revealed a gene-rich, intron-poor species, which is surprising for a free-living mesophile. Of the 8,355 predicted protein-coding regions, up to 773 (9.3%) were implicated in horizontal genetic transfer (HGT) events involving other prokaryote and eukaryote lineages. A much smaller number, up to 174 (2.1%) showed unambiguous evidence of vertical inheritance. Together with other red algal genomes, nearly all published in 2013, these data provide an excellent platform for studying diverse aspects of algal biology and evolution. This novel information will help investigators test existing hypotheses about the impact of endosymbiosis and HGT on algal evolution and enable comparative analysis within a more-refined, hypothesis-driven framework that extends beyond HGT. Here we explore the impacts of this infusion of red algal genome data on addressing questions regarding the complex nature of algal evolution and highlight the need for scalable phylogenomic approaches to handle the forthcoming deluge of sequence information.

Next-generation phylogenomics

Thanks to advances in next-generation technologies, genome sequences are now being generated at breadth (e.g. across environments) and depth (thousands of closely related strains, individuals or samples) unimaginable only a few years ago. Phylogenomics--the study of evolutionary relationships based on comparative analysis of genome-scale data--has so far been developed as industrial-scale molecular phylogenetics, proceeding in the two classical steps: multiple alignment of homologous sequences, followed by inference of a tree (or multiple trees). However, the algorithms typically employed for these steps scale poorly with number of sequences, such that for an increasing number of problems, high-quality phylogenomic analysis is (or soon will be) computationally infeasible. Moreover, next-generation data are often incomplete and error-prone, and analysis may be further complicated by genome rearrangement, gene fusion and deletion, lateral genetic transfer, and transcript variation. Here we argue that next-generation data require next-generation phylogenomics, including so-called alignment-free approaches.

Alignment-free population genomics: an efficient estimator of sequence diversity

Comparative sequencing contributes critically to the functional annotation of genomes. One prerequisite for successful analysis of the increasingly abundant comparative sequencing data is the availability of efficient computational tools. We present here a strategy for comparing unaligned genomes based on a coalescent approach combined with advanced algorithms for indexing sequences. These algorithms are particularly efficient when analyzing large genomes, as their run time ideally grows only linearly with sequence length. Using this approach, we have derived and implemented a maximum-likelihood estimator of the average number of mismatches per site between two closely related sequences, π. By allowing for fluctuating coalescent times, we are able to improve a previously published alignment-free estimator of π. We show through simulation that our new estimator is fast and accurate even with moderate recombination (ρ ≤ π). To demonstrate its applicability to real data, we compare the unaligned genomes of Drosophila persimilis and D. pseudoobscura. In agreement with previous studies, our sliding window analysis locates the global divergence minimum between these two genomes to the pericentromeric region of chromosome 3.