Small duct primary sclerosing cholangitis: A discrete variant or a bridge to large duct disease, a practical review

Identifying a therapeutic window of opportunity for people living with primary sclerosing cholangitis: Embryology and the overlap of inflammatory bowel disease with immune-mediated liver injury

Primary sclerosing cholangitis (PSC) is a variably progressive, fibrosis-causing autoimmune disorder of the intrahepatic and extrahepatic bile ducts of unclear etiology. PSC is commonly (in 60%-90% of cases) associated with an inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) like PSC-IBD and less commonly with an autoimmune hepatitis (AIH) like PSC-AIH or AIH-overlap disorder. Hepatologists and Gastroenterologists often consider these combined conditions as distinctly different from the classical forms in isolation. Here, we review recent epidemiologic observations and highlight that PSC-IBD and PSC-AIH overlap appear to represent aspects of a common PSC clinico-pathological pathway and manifest in an age-of-presentation-dependent manner. Particularly from the pediatric experience, we hypothesize that all cases of PSC likely originate from a complex "Early PSC"-"IBD"-"AIH" overlap in which PSC defines the uniquely and variably associated "AIH" and "IBD" components along an individualized lifetime continuum. We speculate that a distinctly unique, "diverticular autoimmunity" against the embryonic cecal- and hepatic diverticulum-derived tissues may be the origin of this combined syndrome, where "AIH" and "IBD" variably commence then variably fade while PSC progresses with age. Our hypothesis provides an explanation for the age-dependent variation in the presentation and progression of PSC. This is critical for the optimal targeting of studies into PSC etiopathogenesis and emphasizes the concept of a "developmental window of opportunity for therapeutic mitigation" in what is currently recognized as an irreversible disease process. The discovery of such a window would be critically important for the targeting of interventions, both the administration of current therapies and therapeutic trial planning.

Comparative histologic features among liver biopsies with biliary-pattern injury and confirmed clinical diagnoses

Biliary-pattern injury in the liver (eg, duct injury, ductular reaction, cholestasis) can occur in several conditions, including primary biliary cholangitis (PBC), primary sclerosing cholangitis (PSC), large duct obstruction (LDO), and drug-induced liver injury (DILI). While the histologic changes in these conditions have been individually well described, distinguishing among them remains often challenging, particularly when biopsy samples are limited in size, robust clinical information is unavailable, and/or the pathologist does not feel confident in evaluating liver disease. This study evaluated histologic features that could aid the diagnosis of biliary-pattern injury on biopsy. We reviewed 121 liver biopsies from clinically confirmed cases of PBC, PSC, chronic LDO, or DILI for multiple clinical and histologic parameters. The rates of these histologic findings were then compared among different entities. Onion-skin fibrosis was seen in 14% of PSC in comparison to 0%, 5%, and 0% of PBC, DILI, and chronic LDO (P = 0.031). Florid duct lesions were identified in 21% of PBC compared to 2% of PSC and 0% of DILI and LDO (P = 0.0065). Similarly, 42% of PBC showed lobular granulomas, compared to 7% of PSC, 11% of DILI, and 33% of chronic LDO (P = 0.0001). Cholestasis was more commonly seen in DILI (42%) and chronic LDO (83%) than in PBC (4%) and PSC (16%) (P < 0.0001). Lobular chronic inflammation was found in a significantly higher percentage of PBC and LDO than of PSC and DILI (P = 0.0009). There were significantly fewer cases of PBC showing neutrophils in ductular reaction than PSC, DILI, and LDO (P = 0.0063). Histologic findings that can help suggest a diagnosis in liver biopsies with biliary-pattern injury include florid duct lesions, lobular granulomas, lack of neutrophils in ductular reaction, and lobular chronic inflammation in PBC; onion-skin fibrosis in PSC; cholestasis and feathery degeneration in DILI; and lobular granulomas, lobular chronic inflammation, cholestasis, and feathery degeneration in chronic LDO. These findings are likely most helpful when complicating factors interfere with biopsy interpretation.

Analysis of various ATP-binding cassette transporters revealed quantification of ABCB4 as a potential diagnostic tool in primary sclerosing cholangitis (PSC)

AIMS

ATP-binding cassette transporters are important proteins in regulating bile constituent transport between hepatocytes and the bile canalicular system. Dysfunctional transporters lead to accumulation of toxic bile components within hepatocytes or the biliary system, known as cholestasis, resulting in liver damage. It has been previously reported that two particular ATP-binding cassette transporters, ABCB4 and ABCB11, have altered expression in patients with primary sclerosing cholangitis (PSC). Interested in further analysis of expression patterns of ATP-binding cassette transporters in PSC patients, we investigated liver samples from 201 patients, including 43 patients with PSC and 51 patients with primary biliary cholangitis patients (PBC). In addition to ABCB4 and ABCB11, we also included other ATP-binding cassette transporters, to determine if upregulation of ABCB4 and ABCB11 is specifically found in the liver of patients with PSC.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Retrospectively, formalin-fixed and paraffin-embedded liver biopsies, resections, and explants were selected to investigate the expression of ABCB1, ABCB4, ABCB11, ABCG5/8, and FXR1 using nanoString nCounter and immunohistochemistry for validation of differently expressed transporters seen in PSC liver samples in comparison to non-PSC liver specimens. Strikingly, ABCB4 was the only ATP-binding cassette transporter showing increased gene and protein expression in hepatocytes of PSC livers when compared to non-PSC liver specimens. Furthermore, ABCB4 protein expression also correlated with disease stage in PSC.

CONCLUSION

Our study concluded that altered ABCB4 expression is specifically seen in liver specimens of PSC patients. Therefore, quantitative ABCB4 analysis may be an additional useful tool for the histopathological diagnosis of PSC to distinguish this entity from other cholangiopathies.

Morphological aspects of small-duct cholangiopathies: A minireview

The biliary system consists of intrahepatic and extrahepatic bile ducts lined by biliary epithelial cells (cholangiocytes). Bile ducts and cholangiocytes are affected by a variety of disorders called cholangiopathies, which differ in aetiology, pathogenesis, and morphology. Classification of cholangiopathies is complex and reflects pathogenic mechanisms (immune-mediated, genetic, drug- and toxin-induced, ischaemic, infectious, neoplastic), predominant morphological patterns of biliary injury (suppurative and non-suppurative cholangitis, cholangiopathy), and specific segments of the biliary tree affected by the disease process. While the involvement of large extrahepatic and intrahepatic bile ducts is typically visualised using radiology imaging, histopathological examination of liver tissue obtained by percutaneous liver biopsy still plays an important role in the diagnosis of cholangiopathies affecting the small intrahepatic bile ducts. To increase the diagnostic yield of a liver biopsy and determine the optimal therapeutic approach, the referring clinician is tasked with interpreting the results of histopathological examination. This requires knowledge and understanding of basic morphological patterns of hepatobiliary injury and an ability to correlate microscopic findings with results obtained by imaging and laboratory methods. This minireview describes the morphological aspects of small-duct cholangiopathies pertaining to the diagnostic process.