Comparison of Micro-ID and Minitek-Serology Systems for Rapid Identification of Salmonella

Identification of Enterobacteriaceae with the Minitek system

A total of 417 strains (361 Enterobacteriaceae, 56 Vibrionaceae) was examined in all the available Minitek system tests. The results were processed through four successive identification schemes devised by the manufacturer and the proportion of strains correctly identified, not identified or incorrectly identified determined for each scheme. From the results, a probability matrix was constructed incorporating all 35 Minitek tests. Test results for each strain were then processed through this matrix to determine its success in identification. From the matrix the order of separating value of the tests was determined. Forty-three of the strains were each tested three times to assess the level of test reproducibility; the corrected error rate was 0.85%.

Four hour identification of Enterobacteriaceae with the API Rapid 20E and Micro-ID systems

One hundred strains of Enterobacteriaceae were examined in parallel with the API Rapid 20E and Micro-ID commercial four hour identification systems. With the API Rapid 20E system 78% of the strains were correctly identified, 15% were not identified, and 7% were misidentified. The respective figures with the Micro-ID system were 74%, 11%, and 15%.