The effects of irrigation volume to the heat generation during implant surgery

Design modification of surgical drill bit for final osteotomy site preparation towards improved bone-implant contact

Implant stability significantly impacts accelerated osseointegration, leading to faster patient recovery. Both primary and secondary stability necessitates superior bone-implant contact influenced by the surgical tool required to prepare the final osteotomy site. Besides, excessive shearing and frictional forces generate heat causing local tissue necrosis. Hence, surgical procedure necessitates proper irrigation with water to minimize heat generation. Notably, the water irrigation system removes bone chips and osseous coagulums, which may help accelerate osseointegration and improve bone-implant contact. The inferior bone-implant contact and thermal necrosis at the osteotomy site are primarily responsible for poor osseointegration and eventual failure. Therefore, optimizing tool geometry is key to minimizing shear force, heat generation, and necrosis during final osteotomy site preparation. The present study explores modified drilling tool geometry, especially cutting edge for osteotomy site preparation. The mathematical modeling is used to find out ideal cutting-edge geometry that facilitates drilling under relatively less operational force (0.55-5.24 N) and torque (98.8-154.5 N-mm) with a significant reduction (28.78%-30.87%) in heat generation. Twenty-three conceivable designs were obtained using the mathematical model; however, only three have shown promising results in static structural FEM platforms. These drill bits are designed for the final drilling operation and need to be carried out during the final osteotomy site preparation.

Effect of low-speed drilling without irrigation on osseointegration: an experimental study in dogs

OBJECTIVE

To study the early phases of osseointegration at implants installed in sites prepared with either high rotational speed with irrigation or low rotational speed without irrigation.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

After 3 months from tooth extraction, two implants were installed in one side of the mandible of twelve dogs. The osteotomies were prepared either at 60 rpm without irrigation or at 750 rpm with refrigeration. Biopsies were obtained after 4 and 8 weeks of healing, six animals each period for histological analyses.

RESULTS

After 4 weeks of healing, new bone percentage in contact with the implant surface (BIC%) was 46.6 ± 7.3% and 43.1 ± 6.8% at the low- and high-speed sites, respectively (p = 0.345). After 8 weeks of healing, the fractions increased to 60.0 ± 11.1% and 60.2 ± 6.2%, respectively (p = 0.753).

CONCLUSIONS

Implants installed in sites prepared using either low-rotational drilling without irrigation or high speed with irrigation presented similar amounts of osseointegration.

Appraising efficiency of OpSite as coolant in drilling of bone

Background

During drilling of bone, which is common in clinical surgeries, heat generation increases local temperature in the drilling site. Transmission of excessive heat to the surrounding bone tissue can cause thermal osteonecrosis. Consequently, it may lead to failure of implants and fixation screws or delay in healing process. Using cooling is a method for limiting temperature elevation.

Materials and methods

In this study, through comparing three conditions of drilling without cooling, external cooling with normal saline, and external cooling with OpSite spray, the efficiency of OpSite as coolant is studied. In this regard, 2 drill bit diameters, 3 drilling speeds, and 3 drilling feed-rates are considered as drilling variables in the experiments.

Results

For the whole experiments, while cooling with normal saline resulted in lower maximum temperatures than without cooling condition, OpSite had even better results and limited the temperature elevation during drilling of bone efficiently.

Conclusion

OpSite spray, which has lower infection risks than normal saline on one hand and lower maximum temperature rise with all combinations of drilling parameters on the other hand, can be considered in clinical surgeries for cooling applications.

Healing at sites prepared using different drilling protocols. An experimental study in the tibiae of sheep

The aim of the experiment was to study the healing at implants installed in site prepared in bone type 1 using different rotation speeds and cooling strategies. The tibiae of twelve sheep were used as experimental sites. Two implant sites were prepared in each tibia using drills either at a high or a mixed speed under irrigation. At the mixed-speed sites, 60 rpm without irrigation were applied for the last drill, the countersink and during implant installation. Biopsies representing the healing after 1, 2, and 6 weeks were obtained and ground sections were prepared. At the histological analyses, after 1 week of healing, no new bone was found at both high- and mixed-speed sites. After 2 weeks of healing, small amounts of newly formed bone were observed in the cortical layer, reaching percentages of 3.6±3.0% at the mixed-speed sites, and of 2.2±1.5% at the high-speed sites. An irrelevant quantity of new bone was seen in the marrow compartments of a few specimens. After 6 weeks of healing, new bone was found in higher quantity, reaching in the cortical compartment 66.9±6.8% and 67.3±17.7% at the mixed- and high-speed sites, respectively. The respective percentages in the marrow compartment were 23.2±13.0% and 30.6±29.2%. No statistically significant differences between high- and mixed-speed groups were found. It was concluded that the use of the last drill and the installation of the implant with or without irrigation yielded similar bone healing and osseointegration.