Score reliability and construct validity of the Flinn Performance Screening Tool for adults with symptoms of carpal tunnel syndrome

Effective assessments to identify overuse injuries in unaffected limbs of persons with unilateral upper limb amputations

STUDY DESIGN

Cross-sectional study.

INTRODUCTION

Overuse injuries (OI) present major health problems and oftentimes, permanent disability. Persons with unilateral upper limb diagnoses, such as amputation, are at-risk for developing OI in their unaffected limbs. Measures to identify high-risk populations are needed.

PURPOSE OF THE STUDY

Scores on 6 OI-assessments were compared for persons with unilateral upper limb amputations (UULA) and healthy participants. Cutoff values were proposed.

METHODS

Sixty-two persons with UULA and 62 healthy controls completed this study. Scores for hand volume (HV), visual analogue scale (VAS), multi-site Semmes Weinstein Monofilament for median and ulnar nerves (SWM-M/SWM-U), torque range of motion for wrist/finger extension and flexion (TROM-E/TROM-F), intrinsic tightness (IT), and differential flexor tendon gliding (DFTG) were collected before and after 15 minutes of repetitive and resistive exercise. When analyzing collected data, descriptive statistics, and ANOVA were used to identify differences between groups. Receiver operating characteristic curves (ROC), area under the curve (AUC), sensitivity, and specificity were calculated to determine acceptable cutoff scores. Cutoff values with significant AUC ≥ 0.60 and sensitivity ≥ 0.80 were accepted.

RESULTS

Statistically significant differences were found between HV by gender in both pre-exercise and post-exercise conditions. Gain scores for whole sample HV, female HV, and TROM-E were statistically different although differences were small and not meaningful. Significant AUC and acceptable pre-exercise cutoff values included 375 ml. for female HV (sensitivity 89%, specificity 87%), 505 ml. for male HV (sensitivity 81%, specificity 70%), 82 degrees for TROM-E (sensitivity 92%, specificity 71%), and 73 degrees of TROM-F (sensitivity 90%, specificity 89%).

CONCLUSIONS

Potential at-risk OI-related populations, especially unaffected limbs of UULA persons, are best identified by pre-exercise cutoff values using HV by gender, TROM, and single-site SWM 2.83.

Systematic Review of Studies on Measurement Properties of Instruments for Adults Published in the American Journal of Occupational Therapy, 2009–2013

OBJECTIVE. We describe the methodological quality of recent studies on instrument development and testing published in the American Journal of Occupational Therapy (AJOT).

METHOD. We conducted a systematic review using the COnsensus-based Standards for the selection of health status Measurement INstruments (COSMIN) checklist to appraise 48 articles on measurement properties of assessments for adults published in AJOT between 2009 and 2013.

RESULTS. Most studies had adequate methodological quality in design and statistical analysis. Common methodological limitations included that methods used to examine internal consistency were not consistently linked to the theoretical constructs underpinning assessments; participants in some test–retest reliability studies were not stable during the interim period; and in several studies of reliability and convergent validity, sample sizes were inadequate.

CONCLUSION. AJOT’s dissemination of psychometric research evidence has made important contributions to moving the profession toward the American Occupational Therapy Association’s Centennial Vision. This study’s results provide a benchmark by which to evaluate future accomplishments.

Five years later: achieving professional effectiveness to move neurorehabilitation forward

The AOTA Centennial Vision outlined in 2007 challenged the occupational therapy profession to become a "powerful, widely recognized, science-driven, and evidence-based" profession that could adapt to changing societal and cultural needs and flourish well into the future. That challenge can be met by simply being effective at what we do; this will increase our value and validate our worth. Neurorehabilitation in occupational therapy can also thrive if we verify that the interventions we use and the strategies we implement are grounded in evidence. Professional effectiveness will emerge by (1) increasing the dissemination of research that supports the methods we use and informs others of the successful patient outcomes we achieve and (2) expanding development and validation of instruments that quantitatively and qualitatively measure functional outcomes. Occupational therapists can individually develop professional effectiveness by fostering greater academic-clinical alliances, objectifying evaluation and intervention methods, and preparing future practitioners appropriately for evidence-driven practice.