Shoulder pain in hemiplegia

A New Shoulder Orthosis to Dynamically Support Glenohumeral Subluxation

OBJECTIVE

In this paper we presented a novel shoulder subluxation support that aims to reduce the stress on the passive structures around the shoulder of patients with glenohumeral subluxation and glenohumeral-related shoulder pain. The device applies a force to the upper arm without impeding the functional range of motion of the arm. Our design contains a mechanism that statically balances the arm with two elastic bands.

METHODS

A technical evaluation study was conducted to assess the performance of the orthosis. Additionally, two patients evaluated the orthosis.

RESULTS

The results of the technical validation confirm the working of the balancing mechanism. The pilot study demonstrated that the shoulder support increased the feeling of stability of the shoulder joint and, to a lesser extent, decreased shoulder pain. Furthermore, both patients reported that the orthosis did not impede their range of motion.

CONCLUSION

In this research we developed a shoulder orthosis based on two statically balanced springs that support the shoulder of patients with glenohumeral subluxation that have residual shoulder muscle force. Compared to existing shoulder supports, our design does not impede the range of motion of the arm, and continues to provide a stabilizing force to the shoulder, even if the arm is moved away from the neutral position. Tests with two participants showed promising results.

SIGNIFICANCE

The device presented in this work could have a significant impact on the shoulder function which may improve rehabilitation outcome and improve the quality of life of patients suffering from glenohumeral subluxation and shoulder pain.

Treatment of Glenohumeral Subluxation: A Review of the Literature and Considerations for Pediatric Population

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this review was to identify treatment strategies in the research literature to inform all health professionals on best practice strategies when addressing glenohumeral subluxation.

DESIGN

Articles were identified by searching electronic databases. Two reviewers independently appraised the methodological quality of the selected studies. Discrepancies were resolved after corroboration of results.

RESULTS

Research literature pertaining to five major treatment strategies was found (n = 40 peer-reviewed publications), spanning evidence levels I-V. The greatest number of studies concerned neuromuscular electrical stimulation (n = 19), five of which were level I studies, followed by manual preventive strategies, such as slings (n = 20), three of which were level I studies.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings indicate that the most high-quality research supports using neuromuscular electrical stimulation or manual preventive studies, although no studies used direct comparison methods to ascertain relative merits of each type of intervention when compared with others. No evidence suggested that harm was done by using neuromuscular electrical stimulation or manual preventive methods. This literature review suggests that the identified treatment strategies should be considered by clinicians as the treatment of choice for GHS. No literature was identified that reviewed treatment strategies in a pediatric population; however, the authors considerations for treatment in the pediatric population were included.

An Aid for the Management of Shoulder Pain in Hemiplegia

This article describes the manufacture and use of a splint jacket which has proved to be of great value in the relief of severe shoulder pain in a hemiplegic person. It may be of use to others with this problem.

Effect of Intra-articular Hyaluronic Acid Injection on Hemiplegic Shoulder Pain After Stroke

Objective

To evaluate the efficacy of intra-articular hyaluronic acid (IAHA) injection for hemiplegic shoulder pain (HSP) after stroke.

Methods

Thirty-one patients with HSP and limited range of motion (ROM) without spasticity of upper extremity were recruited. All subjects were randomly allocated to group A (n=15) for three weekly IAHA injection or group B (n=16) for a single intra-articular steroid (IAS) injection. All injections were administered by an expert physician until the 8th week using a posterior ultrasonography-guided approach. Shoulder joint pain was measured using the Wong-Baker Scale (WBS), while passive ROM was measured in the supine position by an expert physician.

Results

There were no significant intergroup differences in WBS or ROM at the 8th week. Improvements in forward flexion and external rotation were observed from the 4th week in the IAHA group and the 8th week in the IAS group. Subjects experienced a statistically significant improvement in pain from the 1st week in the IAS and from the 8th week in IAHA group, respectively.

Conclusion

IAHA seems to have a less potent ability to reduce movement pain compared to steroid in the early period. However, there was no statistically significant intergroup difference in WBS and ROM improvements at the 8th week. IAHA might be a good alternative to steroid for managing HSP when the use of steroid is limited.

Hemiplegic shoulder pain: a study of two methods of physiotherapy treatment

A study was undertaken to examine the effectiveness of two methods of physiotherapy treatment for hemiplegic shoulder pain. Sixty-five patients were randomly allocated to receive either cryotherapy or the Bobath approach. Patients were assessed before and after a four-week period of treatment. The differences between the scores of the two groups on exit were not found to reach statistically significant levels for severity of pain at rest, on movement, or for reported distress; however the proportion of patients who reported no pain after the four weeks' treatment was greater in those who received the Bobath approach. The differences in reported frequency of occurrence of pain reached a significant level (p < .05), those in the Bobath group reporting less frequent pain. It is suggested that reasons forthe lack of expected differences in outcome between the two groups may be in part due to the diversity of underlying pathology, and to further trauma which occurred in the study period.

The difference between before and after ratings for all pain variables was significant; for reported severity and frequency p < .05, and for reported distress p < .001. These findings suggest that physiotherapy may have a role to play in the treatment and management of hemiplegic shoulder pain, but further investigations are needed. It may be appropriate to set up and monitor programmes of careful handling to see if shoulder pain can be avoided, and it is also suggested that those with severe pain at rest and on movement may be considered as a separate group for study.

Effects of Brain-Computer Interface-controlled Functional Electrical Stimulation Training on Shoulder Subluxation for Patients with Stroke: A Randomized Controlled Trial

The purpose of this study was to investigate the effects of brain-computer interface (BCI)-controlled functional electrical stimulation (FES) training on shoulder subluxation of patients with stroke. Twenty subjects were randomly divided into two groups: the BCI-FES group (n = 10) and the FES group (n = 10). Patients in the BCI-FES group were administered conventional therapy with the BCI-FES on the shoulder subluxation area of the paretic upper extremity, five times per week during 6 weeks, while the FES group received conventional therapy with FES only. All patients were assessed for shoulder subluxation (vertical distance, VD; horizontal distance, HD), pain (visual analogue scale, VAS) and the Manual Function Test (MFT) at the time of recruitment to the study and after 6 weeks of the intervention. The BCI-FES group demonstrated significant improvements in VD, HD, VAS and MFT after the intervention period, while the FES group demonstrated significant improvements in HD, VAS and MFT. There were also significant differences in the VD and two items (shoulder flexion and abduction) of the MFT between the two groups. The results of this study suggest that BCI-FES training may be effective in improving shoulder subluxation of patients with stroke by facilitating motor recovery. Copyright © 2016 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Effectiveness of the California Tri-Pull Taping method for shoulder subluxation poststroke: a single-subject ABA design

OBJECTIVE

I evaluated the effectiveness of the California Tri-Pull Taping method for clients with poststroke inferior shoulder subluxation of the glenohumeral joint.

METHOD

Ten participants were followed for 9 wk using an interrupted time series quasi-experimental single-subject ABA design to examine shoulder pain, activities of daily living (ADL) function, active range of motion, tape comfort, and subluxation.

RESULTS

The California Tri-Pull Taping method decreased inferior subluxation significantly from baseline to intervention but not at postintervention. Active range of motion was significantly increased in shoulder flexion and abduction between the baseline and intervention and the intervention and postintervention phases. Functional ADL scores were significant. The taping was reported to be comfortable. No significant difference in pain was found.

CONCLUSION

This intervention is a promising adjunct to the management of the hemiplegic subluxed shoulder that warrants further research.

Current and future interventions for glenohumeral subluxation in hemiplegia secondary to stroke

Poststroke shoulder pain is a common issue and can be caused by glenohumeral subluxation. This entity hinders function and quality of life and is caused by changes in tone and loss of fi ne control of the shoulder joints' supporting structures after a stroke. Current treatments are limited in number and effectiveness and have significant problems and limitations to their use. Furthermore, prior to percutaneous implantable neuromuscular electrical stimulation, there was no evidence for any treatment to provide relief for chronic hemiplegic shoulder pain from glenohumeral subluxation. This clinical review provides a comprehensive review of the anatomy, pathogenesis, clinical features, management, and clinical efficacy of current treatment modalities.

Underlying pathology and associated factors of hemiplegic shoulder pain

The prevalence of hemiplegic shoulder pain is approximately 22%-23% in the general population of stroke survivors and approximately 54%-55% among stroke patients in rehabilitation settings. Hemiplegic shoulder pain causes a reduced quality-of-life, poor functional recovery, depression, disturbed sleep, and prolonged hospitalization. Herein, we attempted to understand, based on a literature review and experts' opinion, the pathologic processes underlying hemiplegic shoulder pain and the major associated factors contributing to its development. The systematization of underlying pathologies was proposed, which might eventually enable a more constructive clinical approach in evaluating and treating patients with hemiplegic shoulder pain.

Use of calcitonin to prevent complex regional pain syndrome type I in severe hemiplegic patients after stroke

PURPOSE

To evaluate the effects of calcitonin in preventing complex regional pain syndrome type I (CRPS) in patients with severe hemiplegia following stroke.

METHODS

In this observer-blinded, controlled study comparison with historical controls between April 2003 and May 2004, subjects comprised consecutive patients with post-stroke hemiplegia admitted between June 2004 and September 2005, with any upper limb or finger graded as Brunnstrom stage (BrST) III or below. One group was administered intramuscular injection of 20 units of elcatonin (EL) (Asu(1-7) eel calcitonin) weekly from immediately after admission to discharge, together with rehabilitation therapy. The control group received rehabilitation therapy alone. Patients were observed during the in-hospital rehabilitation period. The main outcome measure was onset of CRPS.

RESULTS

Incidence of CRPS in all patients with post-stroke hemiplegia during the control period was about 8.2%, similar to recent studies. Limited to serious hemiplegic patients graded as BrST III or below, incidence of CRPS was significantly lower in the EL group (12.5%) than in controls (57.1%). No significant differences in patient background were seen between groups. CRPS was completely prevented when EL injection was started <or=4 weeks after stroke, but prophylactic effects were weak when EL was started >6 weeks after stroke.

CONCLUSION

Intramuscular calcitonin appears to suppress onset of CRPS after stroke, particularly when started early after stroke.

Effects of aromatherapy acupressure on hemiplegic shoulder pain and motor power in stroke patients: a pilot study

OBJECTIVES

The aim of this study was to determine if aromatherapy acupressure, compared to acupressure alone, was effective in reducing hemiplegic shoulder pain and improving motor power in stroke patients.

DESIGN

This work was a randomized, controlled trial.

SUBJECTS

Thirty (30) stroke patients with hemiplegic shoulder pain participated in this study.

INTERVENTION

Subjects were randomly assigned to either an aromatherapy acupressure group (N = 15) or an acupressure group ( N = 15), with aromatherapy acupressure using lavender, rosemary, and peppermint given only to the former group. Each acupressure session lasted 20 minutes and was performed twice-daily for 2 weeks.

OUTCOMES MEASURES

Shoulder pain and motor power were the outcome measures used in this study.

RESULTS

The pain scores were markedly reduced in both groups at post-treatment, compared to pretreatment (both aroma acupressure and acupressure group, p < 0.001). A nonparametric statistical analysis revealed that the pain score differed significantly between the 2 groups at post-treatment ( p < 0.01). The motor power significantly improved at post-treatment, compared to pretreatment, in both groups ( p < 0.005). However, there was no intergroup difference between two groups.

CONCLUSIONS

These results suggest that aromatherapy acupressure exerts positive effects on hemiplegic shoulder pain, compared to acupressure alone, in stroke patients.

Prevention and management of shoulder pain in the hemiplegic patient

OBJECTIVE

The objective of this review was to summarise the best available research related to the prevention and management of shoulder pain in the hemiplegic patient.

INCLUSION CRITERIA

This review considered all studies that included hemiplegic patients post-cerebral vascular accident (CVA). Interventions of interest were any treatments or programs used to manage or prevent shoulder pain secondary to hemiplegia. The primary outcomes of interest were those related to pain. This review considered any randomised controlled trials (RCT) that evaluated the effectiveness of interventions that addressed shoulder pain in hemiplegic patients. In the absence of RCT, other research designs such as non-randomised controlled trials, time series and case series were also considered for inclusion in a narrative summary.

SEARCH STRATEGY

The search sought to find both published and unpublished studies. Databases were searched up to February 2002 and included Medline, CINAHL, Current Contents, Cochrane Library, Expanded Academic Index, Electronic Collections Online, Turning Research Into Practice (TRIP), Dissertation Abstracts and Proceedings First. The reference lists of all studies identified were searched for additional studies.

ASSESSMENT OF METHODOLOGICAL QUALITY

All studies were checked for methodological quality by two reviewers and data was extracted using a data extraction tool.

RESULTS

Current research evaluating the effectiveness of treatment interventions on hemiplegic shoulder pain is very limited. The studies were very diverse in their nature of research. There has been no replication of studies, with the studies found using different populations, interventions or outcome measures. Not one study could be compared with another. Meta-analysis was unable to be performed not only because of inadequate reporting of results, but more often due to differences between the studies' participants and the range of interventions used. The diversity in interval post-CVA also makes it difficult to make any comparisons between studies. For this reason the review is in narrative form.

CONCLUSIONS

With this limited evidence, no single intervention has been identified that offers a dramatic effect in terms of treating pain in the hemiplegic shoulder. There is potential for some benefits for the patient's functional and comfort status, thereby improving their quality of life and maximising their social participation.Preventive interventions demonstrated that a shoulder positioning policy had no statistically significant effect on pain. Strapping within 48 h significantly delayed the onset of pain and current research evaluating exercise is not limited to just one area of exercise, but a diverse range, making it difficult to make any comparisons. Some studies did suggest evidence of improvement, albeit limited. However, some of the exercise techniques aggravated shoulder pain. Treatment interventions demonstrated that electromyogram biofeedback cannot be evaluated as a stand-alone therapy as it is used in conjunction with relaxation therapy. Intra-articular Triamcinolone Acetonide injections in a small RCT have not been proven to be beneficial, and are associated with a high incidence of side-effects. Different exercise techniques may aggravate shoulder pain more than others (e.g. Bobath technique compared to cryotherapy). The systematic review on the effectiveness of functional electrical stimulation was used for prevention and treatment and concluded that there is currently no evidence for effect.

Shoulder pain after stroke: a review of the evidence base to inform the development of an integrated care pathway

BACKGROUND

Shoulder pain is a common complication of stroke. It can impede rehabilitation and has been associated with poorer outcomes and prolonged hospital stay. This systematic review was undertaken to inform the development of an evidence-based integrated care pathway (ICP) for the management of hemiplegic shoulder pain (HSP).

AIMS AND OBJECTIVES

1) To provide a background understanding of the functional anatomy of the shoulder and its changes following stroke. 2) To review the literature describing incidence and causation of HSP and the evidence for factors contributing to its development. 3) To appraise the evidence for effectiveness of different interventions for HSP.

METHODS

Data sources comprised a computer-aided search of published studies on shoulder pain in stroke or hemiplegia and references to literature used in reviews (total references = 121).

MAIN FINDINGS

Although a complex variety of physical changes are associated with HSP, these broadly divide into 'flaccid' and 'spastic' presentations. Management should vary accordingly; each presentation requiring different approaches to handling, support and intervention. (1) In the flaccid stage, the shoulder is prone to inferior subluxation and vulnerable to soft-tissue damage. The arm should be supported at all times and functional electrical stimulation may reduce subluxation and enhance return of muscle activity. (2) In the spastic stage, movement is often severely limited. Relieving spasticity and maintaining range requires expert handling; overhead exercise pulleys should never be used. Local steroid injections should be avoided unless there is clear evidence of an inflammatory lesion.

CONCLUSIONS

HSP requires co-ordinated multidisciplinary management to minimize interference with rehabilitation and optimize outcome. Further research is needed to determine effective prophylaxis and document the therapeutic effect of different modalities in the various presentations. Development of an integrated care pathway provides a reasoned approach to management of this complex condition, thus providing a sound basis for prospective evaluation of different interventions in the future.

Management of shoulder pain in patients with stroke

Shoulder pain affects from 16% to 72% of patients after a cerebrovascular accident. Hemiplegic shoulder pain causes considerable distress and reduced activity and can markedly hinder rehabilitation. The aetiology of hemiplegic shoulder pain is probably multifactorial. The ideal management of hemiplegic stroke pain is prevention. For prophylaxis to be effective, it must begin immediately after the stroke. Awareness of potential injuries to the shoulder joint reduces the frequency of shoulder pain after stroke. The multidisciplinary team, patients, and carers should be provided with instructions on how to avoid injuries to the affected limb. Foam supports or shoulder strapping may be used to prevent shoulder pain. Overarm slings should be avoided. Treatment of shoulder pain after stroke should start with simple analgesics. If shoulder pain persists, treatment should include high intensity transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation or functional electrical stimulation. Intra-articular steroid injections may be used in resistant cases.

Functional electrical stimulation on chronic and acute hemiplegic shoulder subluxation

OBJECTIVE

The present study investigated and assessed the effectiveness of a functional electrical stimulation (FES) program in the management of acute and chronic shoulder subluxation.

DESIGN

By their postonset duration, hemiplegic subjects with subluxation participating in the study were placed into a short-duration group and a long-duration group. Subjects in each group were further assigned randomly to either a control subgroup or an experimental subgroup. The experimental subgroups of both short and long duration received FES therapy in which supraspinatus and posterior deltoid were induced to contract repetitively up to 6 hr/day for 6 wk. The duration of the FES session and muscle contraction/relaxation ratio were progressively increased as performance improved.

RESULTS

The experimental subgroup of short duration showed significant improvements in reducing subluxation as indicated by x-ray compared with the control subgroup of short duration after the first FES treatment. The same effect was not shown for the experimental subgroup of long duration. The second FES treatment program only resulted in an insignificant change of shoulder subluxation for both the short- and long-duration subgroups.

CONCLUSIONS

The present study suggests that hemiplegic subjects with short postonset duration are effectively trained for shoulder subluxation by the first FES treatment program. The same FES showed not to be effective when applied to the subjects with subluxation of > 1 yr.

Glenohumeral joint subluxation and reflex sympathetic dystrophy in hemiplegic patients

OBJECTIVE

To examine the relation between glenohumeral joint subluxation and reflex sympathetic dystrophy (RSD) in hemiplegic patients.

DESIGN

Case-control study.

SETTING

Inpatient rehabilitation hospital.

PATIENTS

Thirty-five hemiplegic patients with RSD (RSD group) and 35 hemiplegic patients without RSD (non-RSD group) were included in the study. Patients with rotator cuff rupture, brachial plexus injury, or spasticity greater than stage 2 on the Ashworth scale were excluded.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Both the RSD and non-RSD groups were assessed for presence and grade of subluxation from radiographs using a 5-point categorization. The degree of shoulder pain of the non-RSD group was assessed by a visual analogue scale of 10 points.

RESULTS

Glenohumeral subluxation was found in 74.3% of the RSD and 40% of the non-RSD group (p = .004). In the non-RSD group, 78.6% of the patients with subluxation and 38.1% of the patients without subluxation reported shoulder pain (p = .019). No correlation was found between the degree of shoulder pain and grade of subluxation in the non-RSD group (p = .152).

CONCLUSION

Findings from this study suggest that shoulder subluxation may be a causative factor for RSD. Therefore, prevention and appropriate treatment of glenohumeral joint subluxation should be included in rehabilitation of hemiplegic patients.

Shoulder supports revisited: a Canadian follow-up survey

This paper investigates the use of shoulder supports with stroke patients in Canada and compares the results of two survey questionnaires carried out in 1984 and 1994. It describes which shoulder supports therapists are using with stroke patients and which goals they hope to achieve with specific supports. The Lapboard, Cuff Type Sling, and Arm Trough Support were the most frequently used supports at both time periods. The most frequent goal chosen for each of these three most frequently chosen supports was the same at both time periods but were chosen significantly less frequently in 1994. There was a significant decrease in the use of the Bobath Axial Roll over the ten-year period. This follow up questionnaire documents the limited changes which have occurred in the last ten years in the management of the shoulder following stroke, raises some questions about this area of practice, and outlines some solutions including the need to base occupational therapy practice on more evidence.

Reduction in subluxation and improved muscle function of the hemiplegic shoulder joint after therapeutic electrical stimulation

Seventeen hemiplegic patients with chronic shoulder subluxation secondary to a cerebrovascular accident (CVA) were divided into three groups, two of which were subjected to 6 weeks of therapeutic electrical stimulation (TES) for 15 minutes twice a day, in order to assess the effectiveness of the treatment in reducing subluxation, and in improving shoulder abduction function. The third group was used as a control (C group). After 6 weeks of electrical stimulation of the supraspinatus (S group) and deltoid (D group), a significant (p<0.05) reduction in subluxation was observed in both groups when compared to the C group. The maximal force of shoulder abduction showed a tendency to increase in the S group (p<0.10). A significant increase in maximal force was also observed in the D group. In most of the TES-treated muscles, the interference pattern of EMG at maximum voluntary contraction increased. The amplitude of the EMG activity of the stimulated muscle also increased. Thus, we concluded that electrical stimulation therapy of the supraspinatus and the deltoid muscle is an effective treatment modality for shoulder subluxation and shoulder abduction function in hemiplegic patients.

Prediction of Reflex Sympathetic Dystrophy in Hemiplegic Patients by Electromyographic Study

Background and Purpose This study was designed to investigate the correlation between reflex sympathetic dystrophy syndrome (RSDS) in hemiplegic patients and spontaneous electromyographic (EMG) activity, as well as to determine the predictive value of spontaneous EMG activity in early diagnosis of RSDS.

Methods An EMG and nerve conduction velocity study of the weak upper limb was conducted on 70 hemiplegic patients at 3 to 4 weeks after cerebrovascular disease (either cerebral hemorrhage or infarction). Clinical assessment for development of the RSDS was done during the following 6 months. The correlation of RSDS development with the presence of spontaneous EMG activity and certain clinical parameters (including sex, age, side affected, cause of stroke, sensory impairment, spasticity, and shoulder subluxation) was analyzed statistically.

Results Of the 46 patients who exhibited spontaneous activity, 30 (65%) developed clinical RSDS in their hemiplegic upper extremity, whereas only 1 (4%) of the other 24 patients with no spontaneous EMG activity developed clinical RSDS within 6 months after the onset of hemiplegia ( P <.001). The correlation of RSDS development with the presence of shoulder subluxation and sensory impairment in the hemiplegic side was statistically significant. Neither age, sex, severity of spasticity, nor etiology of stroke had a significant correlation with the development of clinical RSDS.

Conclusions There is significant correlation between the presence of spontaneous EMG activity and the development of clinical RSDS in the hemiplegic upper extremity after stroke. It is concluded that spontaneous EMG activity in the hemiplegic hands of stroke patients might be a good predictor of the future development of clinical RSDS.

Transposition of coracoacromial ligament to humerus in treatment of vertical shoulder joint instability. Clinical applicability of experimental technique

Treatment of experimental distal subluxation in the shoulder joint was achieved by transposition of the coracoacromial ligament and its bony attachment from the acromion to the lesser tuberosity of the humerus. This transposition also reduced external rotation in the first 40 degrees of abduction. The method, which was applied in two clinical cases of distal subluxation, proves reasonable from a biomechanical point of view and yields satisfactory primary clinical results.