Gender Differences on Mental Health, Work-Family Conflicts and Alcohol Use in Response to Abusive Supervision

Is Burnout Primarily Linked to Work-Situated Factors? A Relative Weight Analytic Study

It has often been asserted that burnout is primarily linked to occupational-context factors, and only secondarily to individual-level (e.g., personality) and non-work (or general) factors. We evaluated the validity of this view by examining the links between burnout and an array of 22 work-situated (effort-reward imbalance, unreasonable work tasks, unnecessary work tasks, weekly working hours, job autonomy, skill development, performance feedback, and support in work life), work-unrelated (sentimental accomplishment, familial accomplishment, number of child[ren], leisure activities, residential satisfaction, environmental quality, security in daily life, and support in personal life), dispositional (neuroticism, sex, age, and physical condition), and intersecting (work–non-work conflict and non-work–work conflict) variables. The study involved schoolteachers from three different countries: France (N = 4,395), Spain (N = 611), and Switzerland (N = 514). Burnout was assessed with the Maslach Burnout Inventory for Educators. Most of our predictors were assessed based on widely used measures (e.g., neuroticism was assessed with the NEO-Five Factor Inventory). In order to assess sentimental accomplishment and familial accomplishment, we created two self-reported measures, namely, the Sentimental Accomplishment Inventory (SAI; 9 items) and the Familial Accomplishment Inventory (FAI; 9 items). The SAI and the FAI both showed strong reliability and high factorial validity. Exploratory structural equation modeling bifactor analysis and Mokken scaling suggested that both instruments could be considered essentially unidimensional. The study results showed that neuroticism, job strain, skill development, security in daily life, and work–non-work conflict were consistently associated with burnout across the three samples. Sample-specific predictors of burnout included sex, age, unreasonable work tasks, weekly working hours, job autonomy, support in work life, sentimental accomplishment, leisure activities, support in personal life, and non-work–work conflict. Relative weight analysis indicated that neuroticism was the best predictor of burnout in each sample. Our findings suggest that burnout’s nomological network may not be primarily job-related. We conclude that the tendency to de-emphasize individual-level and non-work factors in burnout research is unwise. This tendency may constitute a roadblock in the development of effective interventional strategies. The implications of our findings for burnout’s conceptual status are discussed. The neuroticism-burnout link should be further examined in longitudinal studies.

L'influence de l'identité professionnelle sur la détresse psychologique dans les métiers spécialisés des secteurs de la construction et manufacturier au Québec

OBJECTIVE

This study explores how the structure of professional identity and its undermining are associated with symptoms of psychological distress in the skilled trades, focusing on the construction and manufacturing sectors in Quebec. One limitation of the current research is its neglect of professional identity, even though this concept is important to explaining psychological distress symptoms.

METHODS

The sample includes 282 workers from four manufacturing and seven construction sites in Quebec. Data were collected for the years 2016 and 2017. Multilevel regression analysis was carried out with the statistical software Stata 13. Five variables were controlled in this study: sex, gender, age, type of team and occupational sector.

RESULTS

The results of multilevel regression models, addressing variations across 54 participating teams, suggested that a low skilled trades self-esteem, a higher professional identification, a low integration of differences, heavy demands at work, and job insecurity are associated with psychological distress, as are the factors of being a woman or being a younger worker.

CONCLUSION

Study results corroborate the importance of taking preventive actions on identity dimensions to reduce psychological distress symptoms. In particular, at the level of skilled trades culture, it would be beneficial to incorporate values based on a better inclusion of all workers and an open mind with regard to differences.