Venezia applicator with oblique needles improves clinical target volume coverage in distal parametrial tumor residue compared to parallel needles only

Comprehensive commissioning of a cone beam CT imaging ring for treatment of HDR GYN patients

PURPOSE

A new mobile cone beam computed tomography (CBCT) imaging ring (IRm, Elekta, v2.10.6, Veenendaal, Netherlands) has recently been proposed for brachytherapy to improve procedure efficiency. We describe the commissioning process and end-to-end tests for GYN HDR brachytherapy employing IRm CBCT imaging.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Commissioning included imaging isocenter test, 3D image quality, 2D imaging quality, image dose, and tube characteristics. CIRS HDR GYN phantom and Venezia CT/MR gynecological applicator were used to perform end-to-end (E2E) tests and optimize workflow. Venezia applicator and four interstitial needles were inserted into the phantom and IRm CBCT images were acquired. Phantom and applicator were scanned with CT scanner (Siemens SOMATOM go.Open Pro) using department's pelvis imaging protocol. MR imaging was performed using 0.35T MR Linac TRUFI pulse sequence. CBCT images were registered to CT and MR using rigid registration to assess image quality and applicator geometry fidelity.

RESULTS

All physics tests passed within acceptance tolerances. Registration of CBCT images to MR and CT scans was acceptable for applicator placement. Applicator registration of CBCT images to CT demonstrated excellent agreement of most distal source dwell position (<1 mm). Slice thickness was also measured to be 1.25 mm, within 0.5 mm of its nominal value.

CONCLUSION

Based on E2E and commissioning results, IRm is an appropriate tool for brachytherapy treatment planning. This study demonstrated good image quality in GYN phantom and Venezia applicator using the IRm. Distal source dwell position agreement between CBCT and CT was acceptable for clinical use.

Image-guided preplanning workflow for high-dose-rate interstitial brachytherapy for gynecological malignancies

PURPOSE

To demonstrate image-guided preplan workflows for high-dose-rate (HDR) brachytherapy for advanced gynecological malignancies.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Two different preplanning scenarios are presented: (1) CT- or MRI-based preplan with partial applicator in place; (2) Preplans generated from prior fractions. The first scenario can be applied to Syed-Neblett template-based implants or hybrid brachytherapy applicators, while the second scenario applies to hybrid applicators. Both scenarios use MRI or CT images acquired with the applicator in place to demonstrate tumor and applicator relative locations and therefore, provide the ability to show optimized suggested needle positions including the implant depths before the actual insertion.

RESULTS

The preplanning techniques have demonstrated feasibility and shown five areas of potential improvement: (1) shorter procedure time, (2) decreased number of total needles inserted, (3) shorter physician tumor contour time, (4) shorter planning time, and (5) evaluation of appropriateness for brachytherapy.

CONCLUSIONS

The use of image-guided brachytherapy preplanning improves clinical efficiency and is recommended for consideration for adaptation into clinical workflows for HDR interstitial and hybrid brachytherapy.

The Montreal split ring applicator: Towards highly adaptive gynecological brachytherapy using 3D-printed biocompatible patient-specific interstitial caps

Purpose

The addition of interstitial (IS) needles to intra-cavitary (IC) brachytherapy applicators is associated with improved outcomes in locally advanced cervical cancers involving parametrial tumor extensions. The purpose of this work was to validate a clinical workflow involving 3D-printed caps for a commercial IC split ring applicator that enable using IS needle trajectories tailored to each treatment.

Material and methods

A dedicated software module was developed in this work allowing users to design patient-specific IS caps without knowledge of computer-aided design (CAD) software. This software module was integrated to 3D Brachy, a commercial software developed by Adaptiiv Medical Technologies Inc. For validation of the workflow, CAD models of ground truth caps with five IS needle trajectories were designed with Fusion 360™, 3D-printed, assembled with a split ring applicator, and CT-scanned with radio-opaque markers. 3D Brachy was then applied to generate a replica based on trajectories reconstructed from the radio-opaque markers. A comparison between ground truth and replicated IS needle trajectories was done using intersection points with planes at the level of the cervix (z = 0 cm) and a representative needle depth (z = 3 cm).

Results

Prototypes of interstitial caps 3D-printed in both BioMed Amber and BioMed Clear SLA resins were tested to be functional both pre- and post-sterilization for IS needles with obliquity angles ≤ 45°. Distance-to-agreement at z = 0 cm and 3 cm as well as deviations in pitch and yaw angles of the five IS needle trajectories were found to have mean values of 3.3 ±2.1 mm, 7.3 ±2.0 mm, 2.9° ±2.3°, and 7.0° ±7.0°, respectively.

Conclusions

The clinical workflow for image-guided adaptive cervical cancer brachytherapy using the Montreal split ring applicator was validated.

Clinical outcomes using a 3D printed tandem-needle-template and the EMBRACE-II planning aims for image guided adaptive brachytherapy in locally advanced cervical cancer

BACKGROUND

Extensive local disease or narrow vagina may compromise brachytherapy (BT) in patients with cervical cancer. This is the first study to analyze long-term outcomes of using 3D printed vaginal tandem-needle templates (3DP TNT) for transvaginal insertion of needles in parallel (P) or parallel and oblique (P&O) direction to the tandem.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

All patients treated with BT using 3DP TNT from 2015-2020 were included. Decision to use a 3DP TNT and preplanning were made after 4-5 weeks of external beam radiotherapy, based on gynecological examination and MRI with a tandem-ring applicator in situ. The TNT was 3D-printed in house consisting of a circular template with P&O holes for guidance of plastic needles and a shaft fitting the uterine tandem. Thus, the radioactive source was never in direct contact with the 3DP TNT. The TNT was 3D printed in a standard or personalized configuration. Planning aims were based on the Embrace II protocol.

RESULTS

101 patients (median age of 63 years) were included: 49 with P needles only and 52 with P&O needles. Personalized TNT was used in 19 patients in the P&O group. Performance status (WHO) was > 0 in 48%. FIGO2018 stage III-IV was present in 77%. T-score at diagnosis and BT was 9.1 and 6.3 respectively, with a significantly higher T-score in the P&O compared to P group. The mean high-risk CTV D90 was 93 Gy with no significant difference between the two groups. Three-year local control rates were 85%, 95%, 75% for the overall, P- and P&O group respectively and 68%, 80% and 56% for cancer specific survival. Grade ≥3 treatment related complications were observed in 10 (10%) patients.

CONCLUSIONS

3DP TNT for BT in cervical cancer provides successful management of very extensive local disease and/or unfavorable anatomy with the possibility for treatment individualization.

Dosimetric impact of applicator displacement on three-dimensional image-guided high-dose-rate brachytherapy treatments for cervical cancer

Purpose

To determine the dosimetric impact of brachytherapy applicator displacement during intracavitary (IC) and combined intracavitary/interstitial (IC/IS) high-dose-rate brachytherapy in the treatment of cervical cancer.

Material and methods

Data from 27 consecutively treated patients undergoing IC or IC/IS high-dose-rate brachytherapy with tandem and ovoid-based applicators at a single academic medical center were analyzed. Virtual applicator displacements (a single shift of whole applicator with tandem/ovoid/associated needles) of 0 (clinical position), 2, 5, 7, and 10 mm in the inferior direction were modeled on treatment planning CT or MRI scans, with maintaining the same dwell times. Radiation dose to target volumes (D90 of high-risk clinical target volume) and organs at risk (OARs) (D0.1cc, D1cc, and D2cc of bladder, rectum, and sigmoid) were calculated for each virtual applicator shift, and significance of displacements was assessed using general linear model and Kruskal-Wallis test.

Results

Mean dose to high-risk clinical target volume (HR-CTV) D90 was 95.7%, 88.9%, 84.6%, and 77.1% of the prescribed dose in clinical position with displacements of 2, 5, 7, and 10 mm, respectively. Rectal D2cc significantly increased by 28% and 44% at displacement of 7 mm and 10 mm, respectively. IC/IS cases showed relatively greater dosimetric differences than IC cases, with HR-CTV D90 doses of 94.4%, 85.8%, 80.4%, and 72.4% at virtual displacements of 2, 5, 7, and 10 mm, respectively.

Conclusions

Applicator displacements of 5 mm or greater result in statistically significant and clinically meaningful decreases in radiation dose to HR-CTV during 3-dimensional high-dose-rate brachytherapy treatment planning, with corresponding increase in radiation dose to the rectum. IC/IS applicator displacements lead to relatively greater differences than those of IC applicators.

Efficacy and feasibility of 3D printed redesigned Venezia™ applicator for treating advanced cervix and recurrent endometrial cancer

PURPOSE

Venezia™ is an interstitial brachytherapy applicator for treating advanced cervical and vaginal vault recurrent cancer. However, there are limitations that lead to suboptimal target coverage. 3D printing introduction allows the redesign of Venezia™ for bulky and irregular-shaped tumors.

METHODS

This study first describes three new designs included: 1) add-on needles template allowed for an extra layer of straight and oblique needles, 2) redesigned vaginal cap so straight and oblique needles can be used together and 3) redesigned central tube allowed vaginal vault interstitial needle insertion. Drawbacks to original Venezia™ and rationale for using these new designs were discussed. Dosimetric analysis by comparing the original Venezia™ with new design for 10 cases in Oncentra treatment planning system v4.5 (Elekta, Stockholm, Sweden) to observe the dose differences in gross tumor volume (GTV), high risk clinical target volume (HRCTV), intermediate clinical target volume (IRCTV) and organs at risk.

RESULTS

For the dosimetric comparison, there were statistically significantly increased median minimal dose to 98% (D98%) of GTV, 90% (D90%) of HRCTV, and IRCTV for the new design with p-value of 0.008, 0.005 and 0.0018, respectively. Comparing the physical dose of D98% of GTV, D90% of HRCTV, and IRCTV when using the new design, it averagely increased by 11.7%, 8.0%, 19.4%, respectively per fraction.

CONCLUSIONS

Dosimetric comparison revealed the new designs increased the dose to GTV, HRCTV and IRCTV and fulfilled the dose constraints of bladder, rectum and sigmoid. The 3D printed new design is biocompatible, inexpensive and can be patient specific.

The Use of 3D Printing Technology in Gynaecological Brachytherapy-A Narrative Review

Radiation therapy, including image-guided adaptive brachytherapy based on magnetic resonance imaging, is the standard of care in locally advanced cervical and vaginal cancer and part of the treatment in other primary and recurrent gynaecological tumours. Tumour control probability increases with dose and brachytherapy is the optimal technique to increase the dose to the target volume while maintaining dose constraints to organs at risk. The use of interstitial needles is now one of the quality indicators for cervical cancer brachytherapy and needles should optimally be used in ≥60% of patients. Commercially available applicators sometimes cannot be used because of anatomical barriers or do not allow adequate target volume coverage due to tumour size or topography. Over the last five to ten years, 3D printing has been increasingly used for manufacturing of customised applicators in brachytherapy, with gynaecological tumours being the most common indication. We present the rationale, techniques and current clinical evidence for the use of 3D-printed applicators in gynaecological brachytherapy.

A novel approach for Venezia ovoid commissioning with a comprehensive analysis of source positions in high-dose-rate brachytherapy

PURPOSE

The lunar design of a Venezia ovoid makes commissioning of the applicator very challenging with traditional autoradiography. In this study, we propose a novel solution to ovoid commissioning and a quality assurance (QA) workflow to effectively assess the entire source path.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

A two-step commissioning process, using electron radiation and radiochromic films, was developed to verify the most distal source position. The ovoid was first attached to a film and was irradiated with a 12 MeV linac beam. This process was repeated on a separate, unexposed film, followed by irradiating it with a HDR source at the most distal position. Two lengths, including the ovoid thickness and the distance between the irradiated spot and the ovoid's outer surface, were obtained from the films' intensity maps. The offset value was calculated from the subtraction of the two measured lengths. Besides acquiring the offset, a source positional simulator (SPS) and a series of planar x-rays from two orthogonal orientations were used to characterize source movement within the ovoid.

RESULTS

Compared to x-ray-based autoradiography, the electron exposure significantly improved the ovoid's visibility on film. Our approach did not use surrogate, which further improved measurement outcomes by decreasing inherent uncertainties. The SPS results suggested the source movement was complex within the cervicovaginal area, but it was predictable with the proposed QA workflow.

CONCLUSION

We introduced a novel, surrogate-free method to commission the Venezia ovoid, which facilitated a manual applicator reconstruction. Additionally, we recommended QA multiple source positions to safely use the ovoid in clinical settings.

Dosimetric evaluation of the feasibility of utilizing a reduced number of interstitial needles in combined intracavitary and interstitial brachytherapy for cervical cancer

PURPOSE

To evaluate the ability of the Venezia advanced multichannel tandem and ring applicator to consistently produce dosimetrically comparable plans utilizing a reduced number of needle channels, to reduce the risk of secondary complications when boosting cervical cancer treatments with high dose rate (HDR) brachytherapy.

METHODS

We evaluated 26 fractions from 13 patients who were treated with HDR brachytherapy using the Venezia (Elekta) applicator. The original plans included a full load of 12-16 needles, including both parallel and 30-degree oblique needles. We replanned each original to nine new configurations, with a reduced number of two, three, four, or six needles. Comparisons included differences in percentage dose coverage to 90% of the high-risk clinical target volume, and percentage dose to 2 cm³ of the bladder, rectum, sigmoid, and bowel. We considered new plans "passing" if they remained within our standards (D90 > 100%; D2 cm³  < 85% bladder, <65% rectum, sigmoid, bowel) or did not perform worse than original.

RESULTS

Removing only the two most anterior or the two most posterior needles from both sides showed 80.8% and 61.5% overall passing rate. Removal of the most anterior and posterior four needles together showed 65.4% overall passing rate. Removing all oblique needles showed 19.2% overall passing rate. Removing only left-sided or only right-sided oblique needles showed 46.2% and 23.1% overall passing, respectively. Removing only right-sided or only left-sided parallel needles separately showed 19.2% and 34.6% overall passing, respectively. Removing all parallel needles showed 11.5% overall passing rate.

CONCLUSIONS

As only two replans required a full needle load to maintain dosimetric quality and 40 (76.9%), 36 (34.6%), 18 (69.2%), and 10 (19.2%) replans passed with 2, 3, 4, and 6 needles removed respectively, this indicates the potential for using a lesser number of interstitial needles during combined intracavitary and interstitial HDR brachytherapy while maintaining dosimetric quality.

The Kelowna template for combined intracavitary and interstitial brachytherapy for gynecologic malignancies: Design, application, treatment planning, dosimetric and treatment outcomes

PURPOSE

We report the feasibility, experience, and early outcomes of the combined intracavitary and interstitial dedicated applicator using the Kelowna GYN template (Varian, Palo Alto, CA).

METHODS AND MATERIALS

The Kelowna GYN template is CT compatible and used for the treatment of gynecologic cancers. In cases with patients that have an intact uterus, a modified applicator system using the Kelowna GYN template and a 3D printed adapter piece allows for compatibility with an intrautaerine tandem.

RESULTS

We reviewed the treatment course of 23 patients comprising of 86 fractions of HDR treatment. Median D90 for cervical tumors (n = 7) was 82.4 Gy (range 77.7-92.6); for postoperative cervical tumors (n = 2) was 73.9 Gy (range 72.0-5.8); for vaginal tumors (n = 4) was 85.8 Gy (range 79.8-88.1); for recurrent endometrial (n = 10) was 86.9 Gy (range 74.8-103.2). Median EQD2 D2cc for bladder was 72.4 Gy (range 47.7-99.4), for rectum was 61.2 Gy (range 52.4-80.6), and for sigmoid colon of 50.5 Gy (44.3-66.9). At a median follow-up of 12 months, 2 patients had a local recurrence. Two patients had distant recurrence: one with carcinomatosis at 6 months, and one with pulmonary metastases at 3 months. No patients had late grade three toxicities.

CONCLUSIONS

Our single institutional experience supports the use of the Kelowna template as a robust system as a combined IC-IS applicator resulting in versatile and reproducible implants for a variety of gynecologic malignancies.

Clinical outcome of combined intracavitary / interstitial brachytherapy using a hybrid applicator in locally advanced cervical cancer

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to evaluate the clinical outcome in locally advanced cervical cancer (LACC) after image-guided adaptive brachytherapy (IGABT) with combined intracavitary and interstitial (IC/IS) techniques using the hybrid Venezia applicator (Elekta AB, Sweden).

METHODS

LACC patients (UICC Stage IIB - IVB) treated with radiochemotherapy followed by IGABT with the hybrid IC/IS Venezia applicator at a single institution were retrospectively analyzed. Treatment comprised EBRT of the pelvis with 45 Gy and concomitant weekly cisplatin chemotherapy (40 mg/m²) followed by MRI-based IGABT. Dosimetry, oncological outcome and toxicity were investigated.

RESULTS

Forty-six patients underwent a total of 184 fractions of IGABT between 2017 and 2020. Median follow-up was 24 months. Combined IC/IS techniques were used in 40 patients (87%). The median HRCTV volume was 31.2 cm³ and the median HRCTV D_90% was 92.3 Gy (EQD2₁₀). The median D_2cm³ was 74.8 Gy for bladder, 57.9 Gy for rectum, 60.0 Gy for sigmoid and 52.2 Gy for bowel (EQD2₃). The 3-yr actuarial rates were 97.6% for local control, 97.6% for pelvic control, 59.9% for distant metastasis-free survival and 81.6% for overall survival. The crude rate for G2 and G3 late toxicity was 21.7% and 4.3%.

CONCLUSIONS

IGABT with the hybrid Venezia applicator and a pronounced use of a combined IC/IS technique achieved high target doses, while maintaining low doses to organs at risk, leading to excellent local control and overall survival rates with acceptable toxicity.