Histopathology and elastography discordance in evaluation of breast lesions with acoustic radiation force impulse elastography

An analytical model of full-field displacement and strain induced by amplitude-modulated focused ultrasound in harmonic motion imaging

The majority of disease processes involves changes in the micro-structure of the affected tissue, which can translate to changes in the mechanical properties of the corresponding tissue. Harmonic motion imaging (HMI) is an elasticity imaging technique that allows the study of the mechanical parameters of tissue by detecting the tissue response by a harmonic motion field, which is generated by oscillatory acoustic radiation force (ARF). HMI has been demonstrated in tumor detection and characterization as well as monitoring of ablation procedures. In this study, an analytical HMI model is demonstrated and compared with a finite element model (FEM), allowing rapid and accurate computation of the displacement, strain, and shear wave velocity (SWV) at any location in a homogeneous linear elastic material. Average absolute differences between the analytical model and the FEM were respectively 1.2 % for the displacements and 0.5 % for the strains for 41940 force voxels at 0.22 seconds per displacement evaluation. A convergence study showed that the average difference could be further decreased to 1.0 % and 0.15 % for the displacements and strains, respectively, if force resolution is increased. SWV fields, as calculated with the FEM and the analytical model, have regional differences in velocities up to 0.57 m/s with an average absolute difference of 0.11±0.07 m/s, primarily due to imperfections in the non-reflecting FEM boundary conditions. The apparent SWV differed from the commonly used plane-wave approximation by up to 1.2 m/s due to near and intermediate field effects. Maximum displacement amplitudes for a model with an inclusion stabilize within 10 % of the homogeneous model at an inclusion radius of 10 mm while the maximum strain reacts faster, stabilizing at an inclusion radius of 3 mm. In conclusion, an analytical model for HMI stiffness estimation is presented in this paper. The analytical model has advantages over FEM as the full-field displacements do not need to be calculated to evaluate the model at a single measurement point. This advantage, together with the computational speed, makes the analytical model useful for real-time imaging applications. However, the analytical model was found to have restrictive assumptions on tissue homogeneity and infinite dimensions, while the FEM approaches were shown adaptable to variable geometry and non-homogeneous properties.

Harmonic motion imaging of human breast masses: an in vivo clinical feasibility

Non-invasive diagnosis of breast cancer is still challenging due to the low specificity of the imaging modalities that calls for unnecessary biopsies. The diagnostic accuracy can be improved by assessing the breast tissue mechanical properties associated with pathological changes. Harmonic motion imaging (HMI) is an elasticity imaging technique that uses acoustic radiation force to evaluate the localized mechanical properties of the underlying tissue. Herein, we studied the in vivo feasibility of a clinical HMI system to differentiate breast tumors based on their relative HMI displacements, in human subjects. We performed HMI scans in 10 female subjects with breast masses: five benign and five malignant masses. Results revealed that both benign and malignant masses were stiffer than the surrounding tissues. However, malignant tumors underwent lower mean HMI displacement (1.1 ± 0.5 µm) compared to benign tumors (3.6 ± 1.5 µm) and the adjacent non-cancerous tissue (6.4 ± 2.5 µm), which allowed to differentiate between tumor types. Additionally, the excised breast specimens of the same patients (n = 5) were imaged post-surgically, where there was an excellent agreement between the in vivo and ex vivo findings, confirmed with histology. Higher displacement contrast between cancerous and non-cancerous tissue was found ex vivo, potentially due to the lower nonlinearity in the elastic properties of ex vivo tissue. This preliminary study lays the foundation for the potential complementary application of HMI in clinical practice in conjunction with the B-mode to classify suspicious breast masses.