Bioavailability of phenytoin from various pharmaceutical preparations in children

Prodrugs: My Initial Exploration and Where It Led

This review presents my early exploration in the area of prodrugs and specifically prodrugs of the anticonvulsant, phenytoin, also called diphenylhydantoin. My journey started in graduate school with an introduction to the prodrug concept and continued for much of my career as I remain fascinated by the topic/technique. I have also included some backstories that the reader might find noteworthy. Prodrug intervention is now recognized as one of the better tools for taking a challenging small molecule drug from un-developable to developable.

Recommendations of the Italian League Against Epilepsy Working Group on Generic Products of Antiepileptic Drugs

The availability of generic products of antiepileptic drugs (AEDs) has been increasing in recent years. In view of the importance of the issue, the Italian League against Epilepsy (LICE) set up an ad hoc working group whose task was to assess available evidence on the efficacy and safety of generic AEDs in the treatment of epilepsy and to produce recommendations on their use. A careful review of the literature revealed no adequately powered randomized controlled trials that assessed the risk/benefit ratio of generic substitution. Although there have been reports of loss or worsened seizure control, or appearance of adverse events, following the switch from brand products to generics, a critical assessment of the evidence generally does not allow us to establish a cause-effect relationship between the switch and a change in clinical status. Overall, the working group concluded that generic AEDs meeting current regulatory criteria for bioequivalence represent a valuable choice in the management of epilepsy by allowing a substantial reduction of treatment costs, particularly in patients initiating monotherapy or adjunctive treatment and in those with persistent seizures. The working group considered that in patients who achieved seizure freedom a modest change in plasma drug levels, which may occasionally occur even after substitution of products that meet bioequivalence criteria, could in rare cases lead to seizure breakthrough. Therefore, generic substitution is not recommended in patients who achieved seizure remission. Switches between a particular generic and another generic should also be preferably avoided. Finally, sustained-release AED formulations should not be used interchangeably with immediate-release brand or generic products. Patients need to be informed about the stringent criteria that currently govern the approval of generic products and about the implications of the use of generic AEDs, and their opinion should be taken into consideration at the time of prescribing.

Is generic prescribing acceptable in epilepsy?

There is considerable debate about the role of generic prescribing for people with epilepsy. The arguments go beyond simple considerations of cost on one hand and the possibility of toxicity or loss of seizure control on the other. The concepts of bioavailability and bioequivalence require further consideration. The measures that are currently used may not apply equally well to all situations. For example, additional measures may be needed for controlled-release preparations and in the other special cases. There is an extensive literature on the bioequivalence of various phenytoin preparations. This anticonvulsant drug is poorly soluble in water, has nonlinear kinetics and has a narrow therapeutic range, implying that problems with bioequivalence are likely to occur. This is borne out by clinical experience. There are a few published investigations on carbamazepine. The systematic studies, on the whole, fail to show major differences in bioequivalence between the various formulations. There is sparse information on the comparison between generic and proprietary formulations of other anticonvulsant drugs. Whatever arguments might be put forward supporting brand name or generic prescribing, there are strong reasons for recommending tight control on the consistency of anticonvulsant drugs, both generic and proprietary. There is also a strong case for ensuring that the physician who signs the prescription remains in control of the situation and that any decisions that the physician makes should be based on accurate and reliable information.

Effects of low-dose phenytoin administered to newborn mice on developing cerebellum

To examine correlations between dose levels of phenytoin (PHT) and neurotoxic effects on cerebellar development, we administered 10, 17.5, 25, and 35 mg/kg PHT suspended in sesame oil orally to newborn Jcl:ICR mice once a day during postnatal days 2-4 and determined plasma PHT concentrations during the administration period. Mortality rates were 12.5% and 35.2% in males and 15.3% and 33.3% in females for the 25 and 35 mg/kg PHT-treated groups during the PHT treatment, respectively. In the 25 and 35 mg/kg PHT-treated groups, total brain weight, the size of the cerebellum, and cerebellar weight were significantly reduced on postnatal day 21. However, in the 10 and 17.5 mg/kg PHT-treated groups, total brain weight and the size and weight of the cerebellum did not differ from those of the control group. Histologically, the number of pyknotic cells in the external granular layer (EGL) in the 25 and 35 mg/kg PHT-treated groups was increased on postnatal day 5, and the EGL was thicker than in the control group on postnatal day 14. Some of the Purkinje cells in the 35 mg/kg PHT-treated group showed degeneration. Plasma PHT levels were 10.7 +/- 2.2 and 24.6 +/- 2.6 micrograms/ml in the 25 and 35 mg/kg PHT groups on the third day of PHT treatment, respectively. In the 25 mg/kg PHT group, plasma PHT level was found to be in the therapeutic range for humans, 10-20 micrograms/ml. Accordingly, during pregnancy, epileptic women should be carefully given PHT at the lowest effective dose while plasma PHT levels are monitored properly. These findings emphasize the importance of pharmacokinetics in evaluating of phenytoin-induced developmental neurotoxicity.

Bioavailability and dissolution of proprietary and generic formulations of phenytoin

A comparative study of the bioavailability of seven formulations of phenytoin was carried out on 17 patients with epilepsy who were taking phenytoin regularly as part of their drug therapy. Three patients withdrew for personal reasons. No significant differences were found between Epanutin capsules and other generic formulations. However significant differences were noted between the generic products. Phenytoin BP tablets manufactured by Regent Laboratories (now withdrawn) had a relative bioavailability of only 76% compared with tablets manufactured by A H Cox and Company. In vitro dissolution tests requirements were met by all formulations of generic 100 mg tablets, and it was concluded that in vitro dissolution tests are not reliable indicators of biological equivalence. Significantly higher plasma levels were found with Epanutin Infatabs, but this was accounted for by their higher content of phenytoin, which is present in the acid form rather than the sodium salt.

Neurotoxicity of phenytoin administered to newborn mice on developing cerebellum

To examine the neurotoxic effects of phenytoin (PHT) on cerebellar development, we administered 50 mg/kg PHT suspended in sesame oil orally to newborn Jcl:ICR mice once a day during postnatal days 2-14 and determined plasma PHT concentrations at designated intervals during the administration period. In the treated group, walking reflex and negative geotaxis were poorly developed on postnatal day 14. Pyknotic cells in the external granular layer (EGL) significantly increased and were prominent in the vermis area compared with controls on postnatal day 14. Plasma PHT levels were 34-36 micrograms/ml on the 3rd day of PHT treatment and approached a steady-state situation. Total brain weight, size of the cerebellum, and cerebellar weight were significantly reduced in the treated group on postnatal day 56. Accordingly, oral administration of PHT in the neonatal period induced neurotoxic damage on the developing cerebellum.

Bio-availability and dissolution of three phenytoin preparations for children

A study of bio-availability of three drug companies' brands of phenytoin preparations (50mg capsule/tablets) was undertaken on 30 children with tonic-clonic or complex partial seizures. Eight children were excluded because of non-compliance and three because of abnormally high serum levels. Phenytoin capsules (Parke Davis) and tablets (Boots) produced significantly higher serum-level profiles than phenytoin tablets (Evans). Seizure frequencies did not differ significantly with the three brands of phenytoin. Dissolution of the three preparations tested in vitro was different. As a result of this study the authors recommend that children remain on the same manufacturer's brand of phenytoin throughout their treatment.

Phenytoin prodrugs III: water-soluble prodrugs for oral and/or parenteral use

Various bioreversible derivatives of phenytoin, a poorly water soluble and erratically absorbed drug after both oral and parenteral dosing, were synthesized. Initial evaluation of these expected prodrugs, i.e., their aqueous solubility, cleavage in the presence of various animal tissues, and anticonvulsant activity in mice, confirmed that a number of the derivatives did indeed behave as prodrugs. The more promising prodrugs were the disodium phosphate ester and various amino groups containing acyl esters of 3-(hydroxymethyl)-5,5-diphenylhydantoin.

Phenytoin Prodrugs V: In Vivo Evaluation of Some Water-Soluble Phenytoin Prodrugs in Dogs

Phenytoin bioavailability was evaluated in beagle dogs after oral and intravenous administrations of sodium phenytoin and two amino acyl esters and a disodium phosphate ester of 3-(hydroxymethyl)phenytoin (three prodrugs of phenytoin). Phenytoin displayed nonlinear pharmacokinetics in the dogs, complicating the determination of the absolute bioavailability of phenytoin from sodium phenytoin and the prodrugs. All three prodrugs essentially released phenytoin after intravenous administration in a quantitative manner, and all gave plasma levels of phenytoin after oral administration greater than those found after administration of sodium phenytoin. Based on the behavior in dogs and the earlier determination of the physicochemical properties of the prodrugs, it was concluded that one of the amino acyl esters, 3-(hydroxymethyl)-5,5-diphenylhydantoin N,N-dimethylglycine ester methanesulfonate, would be the most useful prodrug for oral administration, while 3-(hydroxymethyl)-5,5-diphenylhydantoin disodium phosphate ester would be the most useful for parenteral administration.

Comparison of serum phenytoin levels in epileptic patients who swallowed their phenytoin tablets with or without previous chewing

This cross-over study was conducted to compare serum phenytoin levels after chronic ingestion of phenytoin tablets with or without previous chewing. The phenytoin therapy was administered as 50 mg chewable Infatabs tablets in a single morning dose of 200 mg. There was no significant difference between the two modes of ingestion as regards serum phenytoin levels measured at various times after ingestion of the phenytoin tablets. Moreover, the area under the curve did not differ significantly during the 24 h interval. Minor changes between two Dilantin formulations, however, could influence drug availability.

Bioavailability of three phenytoin preparations in healthy subjects and in epileptics

Serum phenytoin concentrations have been studied in epileptic patients and healthy subjects taking tablets of phenytoin calcium (Desitin), A, phenytoin acid (Desitin), B, and phenytoin acid (Nordmark), C. Retrospective data and prospective investigation of hospitalized patients on long-term phenytoin treatment showed that significantly higher serum concentrations of phenytoin were produced by the phenytoin acid preparations B and C than by the phenytoin calcium preparation A. In a cross over study six volunteers received 200 mg/day of preparations A, B, and C for three weeks. In this study, too, higher phenytoin serum concentrations were produced by B and C than by A, although the differences were not statistically significant. The reasons for the discrepancies between the studies in healthy and epileptic subjects are discussed.