Investigating patients for bleeding disorders when most of the "usual" ones have been ruled out

A State of the Art lecture titled "Investigating Patients for Bleeding Disorders When Most of the Usual Ones Have Been Ruled Out" was presented at the International Society on Thrombosis and Haemostasis Congress in 2023. Mild to moderate bleeding disorders (MBDs) in patients in whom no diagnosis of an established disorder, such as platelet function defect, von Willebrand disease, or a coagulation factor deficiency, can be identified are classified as bleeding disorders of unknown cause (BDUCs). Prospective data from the Vienna Bleeding Biobank and other studies have revealed a high proportion of BDUCs of up to 70% among patients with MBD who have a similar bleeding phenotype as other MBDs. As BDUC is a diagnosis of exclusion, the accuracy of the diagnostic workup is essential. For example, repeated testing for von Willebrand disease should be considered if von Willebrand factor values are <80 IU/dL. Current evidence does not support the clinical use of global assays such as thromboelastography, platelet function analyzer, or thrombin generation potential. Rare and novel bleeding disorders due to genetic variants in fibrinolytic factors or natural anticoagulants are rare and should only be analyzed in patients with specific phenotypes and a clear family history. In BDUC, blood group O was identified as a risk factor for increased bleeding severity and bleeding risk after hemostatic challenges. Future studies should improve the phenotypical characterization and ideally identify novel risk factors in BDUC, as a multifactorial pathogenesis is suspected. Finally, we summarize relevant new data on this topic presented during the 2023 International Society on Thrombosis and Haemostasis Congress.

Health-related quality of life is impaired in bleeding disorders of unknown cause: results from the Vienna Bleeding Biobank

Background

Bleeding disorder of unknown cause (BDUC) is a diagnosis of exclusion after extensive investigation of coagulation and platelet function and is commonly seen among patients with mild-to-moderate bleeding disorders. Despite increasing awareness among treating physicians, little is known about the health-related quality of life (HrQoL) in BDUC.

Objectives

To investigate HrQoL in patients with BDUC in comparison to the general population and patients diagnosed with other established bleeding disorders.

Methods

Patients with mild-to-moderate bleeding disorders from the Vienna Bleeding Biobank, a prospective cohort study, were contacted via mail and phone to complete the 36-Item Health Survey Questionnaire form.

Results

In total, 333/657 (50.7%) patients completed the 36-Item Health Survey Questionnaire. Patients with BDUC (n = 207, 62%) had significantly impaired HrQoL both in physical (47.8 vs 49.2) and mental health parameters (42.9 vs 51.0) compared to the general population (n = 2914, 56% females), which remained after adjustment for sex and age in multivariable linear regression. The impairment in HrQoL, compared to patients with von Willebrand disease, platelet function defects, or mild clotting factor deficiencies, did not prevail after adjustment for age and sex. In patients with BDUC, age and the presence of at least 1 comorbidity were associated with impaired physical health but not sex or bleeding severity. Of all analyzed bleeding symptoms, only joint bleeding was associated with impaired physical health and gastrointestinal bleeding with mental health in BDUC.

Conclusion

The impairments in HrQoL in patients with BDUC emphasize the burden of BDUC on mental and physical well-being, encouraging early recognition and better counseling of patients with BDUC.

Bleeding of unknown cause and unclassified bleeding disorders; diagnosis, pathophysiology and management

Bleeding of unknown cause (BUC), also known as unclassified bleeding disorders (UBD), has been defined as a clear bleeding tendency in the presence of normal haemostatic tests. There are challenges in the diagnosis and management of these patients. BUC/UBD encompasses a heterogenous group of disorders which may include undiagnosed rare monogenic diseases, polygenic reasons for bleeding; and patients without a clear bleeding disorder but with a previous bleeding event. Nevertheless, these patients may have heavy menstrual bleeding or be at risk of bleeding when undergoing surgical procedures, or childbirth; optimizing haemostasis and establishing a mode of inheritance is important to minimize morbidity. The bleeding score has been used to clinically assess and describe these patients, but its value remains uncertain. In addition, accurate distinction between normal and pathological bleeding remains difficult. Several studies have investigated cohorts of these patients using research haemostasis tests, including thrombin generation and fibrinolytic assays, yet no clear characteristics have consistently emerged. Thus far, detailed genetic analysis of these patients has not been fruitful in unravelling the cause of bleeding. There is a need for standardization of diagnosis and management guidelines for these patients. This review gives an overview of this field with some suggestions for future research.

A Morphometric Analysis of Platelet Dense Granules of Patients with Unexplained Bleeding: A New Entity of Delta-Microgranular Storage Pool Deficiency

One thousand and eighty patients, having prolonged bleeding times, frequent epistaxis, menorrhagia or easy bruising or other bleeding manifestations, and excluding those with von Willebrand's disease, were evaluated for platelet dense granule deficiency. The mean diameter of platelet dense granules was determined for all patients using image analysis. Four hundred and ninety-nine had "classic" dense (delta) granule storage pool deficiency (δ-SPD). Five hundred and eighty-one individuals (53.8%) were found to have a normal mean number of dense granules, but for some of these patients, the dense granules were smaller than for the controls. Of the patients having a normal number of dense granules, 165 (28.4%) were found to have significantly smaller granules than the platelets obtained from the control subjects. Their average granule diameter was 123.35 ± 0.86 nm, that is more than three standard deviations below the mean of the control data. Total δ-granule storage pool volumes (TDGV)/platelet were calculated using these measurements. Individuals with δ-SPD had half the number of granules (2.25 ± 0.04 DG/PL) and storage pool volume (3.88 ± 1.06 × 106 nm3) when compared to our control data (4.64 ± 0.11 DG/PL; 10.79 × 106 nm3 ± 0.42). Individuals having a bleeding history but a normal average of small dense granules had a calculated storage pool volume statistically different than controls and essentially the same storage pool volume as patients with δ-SPD. We have identified a sub-classification of δ-SPD that we have defined as micro-granular storage pool deficiency (δ-MGSPD).

Investigation of patients with unclassified bleeding disorder and abnormal thrombin generation for physiological coagulation inhibitors reveals multiple abnormalities and a subset of patients with increased tissue factor pathway inhibitor activity

INTRODUCTION

We have routinely used thrombin generation to investigate patients with unclassified bleeding disorder (UBD).

AIMS

To investigate haemostatic abnormalities in patients with UBD that had abnormal thrombin generation on at least one occasion.

METHODS

Investigation of 13 known UBD patients with thrombin generation and detailed haemostatic testing was undertaken including TFPI assays but also thrombomodulin and fibrinogen-γ.

RESULTS

12 females and 1 male were included. No patient had a platelet function disorder or coagulation factor deficiency that explained the bleeding phenotype, though 2 patients had factor deficiencies; a factor X of 0.41 IU/mL and a factor XI of 0.51 IU/mL. ThromboGenomics revealed variants for these factors but no other abnormalities. Patients were included who previously had either prolonged lag time or decreased endogenous thrombin potential (ETP) via high dose tissue factor (5 pmol/L) or low dose tissue factor (1.5 pmol/L) with corn trypsin inhibitor (CTI). Tissue factor pathway inhibitor (TFPI) activity was significantly increased (P < .001; increased in 8 patients) compared with controls and abnormalities in soluble thrombomodulin (2 patients), fibrinogen-γ (1 patient) and tPA (4 patients for each) were seen. Total and free TFPI levels were not increased. Mixing studies of patient plasma with 50:50 normal plasma for thrombin generation via low dose tissue factor failed to correct the ETP consistent with ongoing inhibition. Addition of an anti-TFPI antibody partially corrected thrombin generation to normal levels. TFPI sequencing was unremarkable.

CONCLUSION

TFPI activity may be increased in a subset of UBD patients. Further research studies are warranted in UBD patients for coagulation inhibitor abnormalities.

Diagnostic work up of patients with increased bleeding tendency

Introduction

The diagnostic trajectory of patients with increased bleeding tendency can be very costly and time‐consuming. In addition, previous studies have shown that half of these patients remain without final diagnosis despite all efforts.

Aim

This study aimed to improve insight into the current diagnostic process of these patients.

Methods

A total of 117 adult patients, referred to an academic hospital because of being suspected to have an increased bleeding tendency, were included. Different parameters were compared between patients receiving final diagnosis, patients without final diagnosis but a high Tosetto bleeding assessment tool (BAT) score (classified as bleeding of unknown cause, or BUC) and a control group consisting of patients without final diagnosis and a low BAT score.

Results

The BAT score was significantly higher in patients in the BUC group as compared to patients reaching final diagnosis (8.1 vs 4.9). Interestingly, the two subcategories most prevalently increased were surgery and post‐partum haemorrhage‐associated bleeding (surgery: 2.1 vs 1.1; post‐partum haemorrhage: 0.7 vs 0.0). Laboratory screening results were more often abnormal in patients reaching final diagnosis compared to patients remaining without diagnosis and a high BAT score (n = 32 (78%) vs n = 14 (46%), 95% CI 1.5‐12), especially concerning the PFA (=27 (66%) vs n = 10 (33%), 95% CI 1.4‐10) and von Willebrand factor activity levels (n = 11 (27%) vs n = 1 (3%), 95% CI 1.3‐91).

Conclusion

Isolated high bleeding score on surgical or post‐partum bleeding correlates with a lower chance of receiving final diagnosis. Withholding extensive haemostatic testing should be considered. Better screening and confirmative haemostatic assays are still needed.

High proportion of patients with bleeding of unknown cause in persons with a mild-to-moderate bleeding tendency: Results from the Vienna Bleeding Biobank (VIBB)

INTRODUCTION

Data on clinical characteristics and the prevalence of underlying coagulopathies in patients with mild-to-moderate bleeding disorders (MBDs) are scarce.

AIM

We established the Vienna Bleeding Biobank (VIBB) to characterize and thoroughly investigate Austrian patients with MBDs.

RESULTS

Four hundred eighteen patients (female = 345, 82.5%) were included. A platelet function defect (PFD) was diagnosed in 26 (6.2%) and a possible PFD in 30 (7.2%) patients. Eight patients (1.9%) were diagnosed with von Willebrand disease (VWD) (type 1 n = 6; type 2 n = 2), and 29 patients had low VWF (30-50 IU/dL). Deficiencies in factor VIII, IX, XI or XIII were found in 11 (2.6%), 3 (0.7%), 3 (0.7%) and 1 patient(s), 2 patients had dysfibrinogenaemia, and further 2 had possible PFD and FXI deficiency. Probable causal mutations were detected in 8 of 11 patients with FVIII deficiency, 2 of 3 patients with FIX deficiency and 2 of 8 patients with VWD. Three hundred three patients (72.5%) had normal results in the coagulation assays and were categorized as patients with bleeding of unknown cause (BUC). The bleeding score did not differ between patients with and without established diagnosis. A diagnosis of a bleeding disorder was more frequently made in men than in women (49.3% vs 22.9%). Male sex (OR 3.55, 95% CI: 2.02-6.22; P < .001) and blood group 0 (OR 1.86, 95% CI: 1.17-2.94; P = .008) were independently associated with diagnosis of a bleeding disorder.

CONCLUSION

The high rate of patients with BUC despite in-depth haemostatic assessment underlines the incompleteness of available routine laboratory tests. Males with MBDs were more likely to be diagnosed with an established bleeding disorder than females.

Flow cytometry-based platelet function testing is predictive of symptom burden in a cohort of bleeders

Platelet function disorders (PFDs) are common in patients with mild bleeding disorders (MBDs), yet the significance of laboratory findings suggestive of a PFD remain unclear due to the lack of evidence for a clinical correlation between the test results and the patient phenotype. Herein, we present the results from a study evaluating the potential utility of platelet function testing using whole-blood flow cytometry in a cohort of 105 patients undergoing investigation for MBD. Subjects were evaluated with a test panel comprising two different activation markers (fibrinogen binding and P-selectin exposure) and four physiologically relevant platelet agonists (ADP, PAR1-AP, PAR4-AP, and CRP-XL). Abnormal test results were identified by comparison with reference ranges constructed from 24 healthy controls or with the fifth percentile of the entire patient cohort. We found that the abnormal test results are predictive of bleeding symptom severity, and that the greatest predictive strength was achieved using a subset of the panel, comparing measurements of fibrinogen binding after activation with all four agonists with the fifth percentile of the patient cohort (p = 0.00008, hazard ratio 8.7; 95% CI 2.5-40). Our results suggest that whole-blood flow cytometry-based platelet function testing could become a feasible alternative for the investigation of MBDs. We also show that platelet function testing using whole-blood flow cytometry could provide a clinically relevant quantitative assessment of platelet-related hemostasis.

Laboratory evaluation of patients with undiagnosed bleeding disorders

The evaluation of patients with a bleeding tendency represents a challenge as the routinely available tests for evaluating bleeding disorders are limited, complicating the laboratory determination of the clinically observed bleeding tendency. As a result, some bleeding disorders remain undiagnosed. The aim of the study was to evaluate whether global coagulation tests would contribute to the laboratory analysis of patients with undiagnosed bleeding disorders. Patients were evaluated for coagulation and fibrinolysis activities by thrombin generation test and euglobulin lysis time. In addition, plasma activity of factor XIII, plasminogen, α-2 antiplasmin, plasminogen activator inhibitor-1, and thrombin-activatable fibrinolysis inhibitor was also obtained. Forty-five patients were included. Eight per cent presented a mild bleeding disorder and 20% a moderate bleeding disorder. The thrombin generation test results were similar between patients and controls. Euglobulin lysis time results, however, were lower in patients than in controls, both before (median 175 vs. 250 min, respectively; P = 0.003) and after (median 145 vs. 115 min, respectively; P ≤ 0.001) arm constriction, suggesting that they were experiencing hyperfibrinolysis. Interestingly, patients' median thrombin-activatable fibrinolysis inhibitor activity was higher than in controls (21.2 vs. 19.46 μg/ml; P = 0.016). However, plasminogen, α-2 antiplasmin, plasminogen activator inhibitor-1, and factor XIII activities did not differ between the groups. Global coagulation and fibrinolysis tests proved to be limited in detecting the hemostatic disorders in some patients with a relevant bleeding tendency and may not be adequate to address their bleeding risk. Bleeding scores are currently the available medical approach for the evaluation of these patients.

Is my patient a bleeder? A diagnostic framework for mild bleeding disorders

Congenital mild bleeding disorders (MBDs) are very prevalent and are the source of frequent diagnostic problems. Most MBDs are categorized as disorders of primary hemostasis (ie, type 1 VWD and platelet function disorders), but mild or moderate deficiencies of clotting factors and some rare hyperfibrinolytic disorders are also included. These patients have abnormal bleeding from the skin and mucous membranes, menorrhagia, and disproportionate hemorrhages after trauma, invasive procedures, and surgery. This review addresses the main problems that physicians and hemostasis laboratories confront with the diagnosis of these patients, including: discerning normal/appropriate from pathological bleeding, the role and yield of screening tests, the lack of distinctive bleeding pattern among the different diseases, the inherent difficulties in the diagnosis of type 1 VWD and the most common platelet functional disorders, improvements in assays to measure platelet aggregation and secretion, and the evidence that most of the patients with MBDs end up without a definite diagnosis after exhaustive and repeated laboratory testing. Much research is needed to determine the pathogenesis of bleeding in MBD patients. Better standardization of current laboratory assays, progress in the knowledge of fibrinolytic mechanisms and their laboratory evaluation, and new understanding of the factors contributing to platelet-vessel wall interaction, along with the corresponding development of laboratory tools, should improve our capacity to diagnose a greater proportion of patients with MBDs.

Evaluation of low PAI-1 activity as a risk factor for hemorrhagic diathesis

BACKGROUND

Prospective studies of the epidemiology and clinical significance of low plasminogen activator inhibitor type 1 (PAI-1) activity are lacking.

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the prevalence of low PAI-1 activity in patients with a bleeding tendency in comparison with a normal population.

METHODS

In 586 consecutive patients, referred because of bleeding symptoms, we added analyses of PAI-1 activity and tissue plasminogen activator complex with PAI-1 (t-PA-PAI-1) to the routine investigation, consisting of platelet count, bleeding time, prothrombin time, activated partial thromboplastin time, fibrinogen, factor VIII, von Willebrand factor activity, and antigen. Controls were 100 blood donors and 100 age- and sex-matched healthy individuals. The latter were also evaluated regarding the previous bleeding episodes. The bleeding history was classified as clinically significant or not, and the criteria were fulfilled in 75% of the patients and 18% of the healthy controls.

RESULTS

The routine laboratory investigation of the patients was negative in 57%. Low PAI-1 activity, defined as <1.0 U mL(-1), was found in 23% of the patients and in 13% and 10% of the blood donors and healthy controls, respectively (odds ratio and 95% CI, 2.04; 1.11-3.77 and 2.75; 1.39-5.42, respectively). The difference remained statistically significant after the adjustment for body mass index, use of estrogens, sex and age (odds ratio for patients vs. healthy controls 3.23; 95% CI, 1.22-8.56, P = 0.019). The distribution of the 4G/5G genotypes in the patients was not different from that of two control populations. No specific symptom predicted for low PAI-1, which did not aggravate the clinical picture in association with the other hemostatic defects. Low tPA-PAI-1 was not associated with the increased bleeding tendency.

CONCLUSION

Low PAI-1 activity is common in patients with a bleeding diathesis, but it is a risk factor of minor clinical importance and not associated with specific bleeding manifestations.

vWf inhibitor detection by competitive ELISA

An inhibitor to von Willebrand factor (vWf) was detected in the plasma from two patients with histories of mild bleeding and one patient with a severe deficiency in the Factor VIII complex using a competitive enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) procedure. IgG antibodies from the patients' plasmas were shown to bind to vWf immobilised on polystyrene beads by flow cytometry. The inhibitor also potentiated a recently described platelet function assay based on stirring vWf immobilised on polystyrene beads with platelet rich plasma (PRP). Upon addition of mAb IV.3, potentiation of vWf bead-induced platelet activation was lost indicating that the enhancement of platelet activation was Fc receptor-dependent. Since the ELISA described can be used to quantitate vWf and to detect inhibitors to vWf in plasma samples, the method should prove useful in differentiating acquired vWd from congenital vWd.

On the value of menorrhagia as a predictor for coagulation disorders

The value of menorrhagia as a predictor for mild bleeding disorders has been very little studied and the results are divergent. In the present study on 30 women with objectively verified menorrhagia, we found a significantly increased prevalence of von Willebrand's disease (20%). By keeping a strict sampling and laboratory routine, and by restricting sampling to cycle days 5-7, we also obtained a very low interindividual variation of von Willebrand factor and coagulation factor VIII. We conclude that menorrhagia is a valuable predictor for coagulation and platelet disorders, and that time of sampling is of importance. This should be considered in the investigation of menorrhagia, and can be a guideline in looking for mild bleeding disorders.