Goitre in Australia

Effectiveness of hemi-thyroidectomy in relieving compressive symptoms in cases with large multi nodular goiter

Introduction and importance

This case series describe the efficacy of hemi-thyroidectomy to relieve the compressive symptoms of cases having large multi-nodular goiter with preservation of the thyroid gland function. It's considered as an education tool for surgeons to perform safe hemi thyroidectomy to patients indicated for total removal of the gland. Compressive symptoms like mild/severe dysphagia or dyspnea associated with both benign and malignant thyroid disease. Although total thyroidectomy is currently considered the standard of care, hemi thyroidectomy is another surgical option with more benefits.

Case presentation

This case series was performed in a tertiary university hospital in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. It included 35 females and 3 males above the age of 18 (mean age 42 years). All the operations were elective hemi-thyroidectomies performed by one surgeon, during 2019. Patients were complaining of; Voice Change, Neck Swelling, Dysphagia, Chocking, SOB, and Orthopnea. 20 of them were medically free and 18 patients had multiple associated comorbidities.

Clinical findings and investigations

Demographic data, baseline co-morbidities, TSH levels prior to surgery, thyroid gland size, FNA results and pre-operative symptoms were recorded. In addition, compressive symptomatology outcomes from two weeks to two years were recorded. Thirty-two of them (84%) had their symptoms resolve completely and did not need a completion surgery. Out of the 6 who had persistent symptoms, only two needed a completion surgery. Furthermore, only 34.2% required thyroid hormone replacement, 31.6% were euthyroid and 2.6% were hypothyroid preoperatively.

Interventions and outcome

Hemi thyroidectomy was chosen to avoid the risk of hormone replacement, and hypocalcemia. Our results revealed that compressive symptoms were effectively relieved in the majority of our patients. Only 2 patients had to undergo completion thyroidectomy due to compressive symptoms with no perioperative or postoperative complications.

Relevance and impact

We would recommend hemi thyroidectomy for cases of large multi nodular goiter due to its positive implication on patient outcome particularly if the patient refuse hormonal replacement.

•

Compressive symptoms were effectively relieved in the majority of our patients.

•

Only 2 patients had to undergo completion thyroidectomy due to compressive symptoms.

•

No perioperative or postoperative complications were witnessed during the primary or completion surgery.

•

The main drawback with hemithyroidectomy is recurrence.

•

Nevertheless, most recurrences post thyroid surgery are asymptomatic and are diagnosed on ultrasonography.

Total thyroidectomy for clinically benign disease of the thyroid gland

Background

The role of total thyroidectomy in the treatment of patients with benign thyroid disease remains controversial. However, this procedure may be appropriate when both thyroid lobes are involved and when the risk of recurrence is significant. This study is a review of a 15-year experience of total thyroidectomy for benign disease.

Methods

Between 1988 and 2002, 834 patients underwent total thyroidectomy for clinically benign disease at the Sydney Head and Neck Cancer Institute, Royal Prince Alfred Hospital. There were 128 men and 706 women with a mean age of 52 (range 16–91) years. Indications for surgery were euthyroid multinodular goitre (MNG), toxic MNG and Graves' disease in 730 (87·5 per cent), 57 (6·8 per cent) and 47 (5·6 per cent) respectively. A total of 74 patients had previously undergone partial thyroidectomy.

Results

The incidence of temporary recurrent laryngeal nerve palsy was 2·3 per cent and that of temporary hypoparathyroidism 14·4 per cent. Permanent recurrent laryngeal nerve palsy occurred in 1·1 per cent, and 2·4 per cent of patients had permanent hypoparathyroidism. Neither the initial clinical diagnosis nor a history of previous treatment significantly influenced the rate of complications. The incidence of malignancy, other than incidental microscopic papillary carcinoma, was 4·6 per cent.

Conclusion

Total thyroidectomy has an important role in the management of patients with benign disease when both lobes of the thyroid gland are involved. This approach avoids disease recurrence and the increased risk of morbidity associated with secondary operation.