Acute and cumulative benefits of Photobiomodulation for xerostomia: A systematic review and meta-analysis

The objective was to explore the effectiveness of photobiomodulation therapy for treating patients who suffer xerostomia and/or hyposalivation due to the most prevalent clinical diagnoses. We searched PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science, CINAHL and Cochrane Library for randomized or clinical controlled trials published until 31 October 2019. Risk of bias assessment and meta-analysis were conducted using the Cochrane tools. A total of 274 records were retrieved, and 11 met the inclusion criteria. Interventions whose parameters ranged between wavelengths of 790-830 nm (infrared), 30-120 mW of power and an energy density below 30 J/cm-2 were associated with improvements in xerostomia/hyposalivation. As for the assessment of methodological quality, 10 of the 11 articles included had a high risk of overall bias. Only 3 articles provided sufficient information to conduct a meta-analysis for quality of life, compared with placebo in patients with burning mouth syndrome, showing a standardized mean difference between groups from baseline of -0.90 (-1.48; -0.32). The present review and meta-analysis suggest that photobiomodulation therapy is an effective, non-invasive and safe approach in patients with xerostomia. However, despite the potential, it is not possible to reach a reliable consensus on the parameters to be used, and future studies should be conducted by standardizing intervention protocols.

Comparative Evaluation of Er:Cr:YSGG, Diode Laser and Alvogyl in the Management of Alveolar Osteitis: A Prospective Randomized Clinical Study

INTRODUCTION

Alveolar osteitis (AO) is a well-known complication following tooth extraction. Plethora of literature is available regarding its treatment modalities signifying that none of the treatment is as effective as any another treatment. LASER on the other hand, has been used to promote soft tissue healing.

MATERIAL AND METHOD

In order to evaluate the effects of laser on healing of AO we undertook a randomized clinical trial. In the trial, sixty patients diagnosed with AO were randomly divided into three groups viz: alvogyl, diode laser and Er:Cr:YSGG laser (erbium chromium yttrium scandium gallium garnet).

RESULTS

On analyzing the results, diode laser at 1.0 W power settings (energy: 20-25 J/cm²) in non-contact, continuous mode was found to be the most effective for both pain relief and healing improvement.

CONCLUSION

The diode laser is an acceptable and effective non-dressing treatment modality for alveolar osteitis, which is the most common painful complication following extraction.

Importance of pulsing illumination parameters in low-level-light therapy

The influence of emission parameters in low-level-light therapy on cellular responses is not yet fully understood. This study assessed the impact of various light delivery modes on collagen production in human primary fibroblast cultured in monolayers after three treatments with red light-emitting diode illumination (630 nm, 8 J/cm(2)). Human type I collagen was measured in cell culture supernatants with procollagen type I C-peptide enzyme immunoassay. Results demonstrated that, 72 h post-baseline, specific microsecond pulsing patterns had a more favorable impact on the ability of fibroblasts to produce collagen de novo than comparative conditions of continuous wave, pulsed 50% duty cycle, and millisecond pulsing domains. The cascade of events leading to collagen production by red illumination may be explained by the photodissociation of nitric oxide from cytochrome c oxidase. Short and intermittent light delivery might enhance this cellular event.

Pulsing influences photoradiation outcomes in cell culture

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Skin pigmentation can adversely affect phototherapy outcomes. Delivering pulsed light has been suggested as a means of enhancing efficacy. Suitable pulse frequencies remain indeterminate, often being selected empirically. This study was undertaken to determine whether pulsed light delivery mitigates the filtering effect of melanin pigment on photomodulation in vitro.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

Human HEP-2 cells were cultured in complete DMEM media. Photoradiation was delivered through 0.025% melanin filters at 670 nm (5.0 J/cm(2)/treatment/24 hours) for 72 hours at different pulse rates. Group A received no light treatment. Group B received treatments without pulsing. Groups C, D, E, F, and G received treatments at 6, 18, 36, 100, and 600 Hz. Cell proliferation was assessed by MTT assay and oxidative burst was measured using the 2.7 dichloro-fluorescein-diacetate assay.

RESULTS

Cell proliferation was maximally stimulated at 100 Hz at 48 and 72 hours (n = 4, P< or =0.05). Oxidative burst was maximally stimulated at 600 Hz (n = 4, P< or =0.05). All frequencies were stimulatory at 48 and 72 hours (n = 4, P< or =0.05).

CONCLUSION

This investigation suggests that light pulsing may improve outcomes by mitigating the filtration effects of cutaneous melanin. Further studies to further define these effects are warranted.

Photobiological Basis and Clinical Role of Low-Intensity Lasers in Biology and Medicine

The purpose of this article is to provide a comprehensive review on the clinical role of low intensity laser therapy (laser photostimulation) in biology and medicine. Studies on wound healing and pain relief are highlighted to show the clinical efficacy of laser therapy. Controversies about the use of low intensity laser as a therapeutic modality for wound healing and pain relief are presented and a brief explanation is provided to overcome these controversies. The importance of standard parameters is emphasized for the applications of low intensity lasers in biology and medicine. A justification has been made to warrant further research on the use of low intensity laser as a therapeutic modality. Although the therapeutic applications of low intensity laser are imminent, the heterogeneity in treatment protocols and study design calls for a vigilant interpretation of the findings.

Effects of low-level laser therapy (LLLT) of 810 nm upon in vitro growth of bacteria: relevance of irradiance and radiant exposure

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to investigate the irradiance-dependency of low-level laser therapy (LLLT) effects on bacterial growth.

BACKGROUND

LLLT is applied to open wounds to improve healing; however, its effect on wound bacteria is not well understood.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Escherichia coli, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, and Staphylococcus aureus were irradiated using a wavelength of 810 nm at irradiances of 0.015 W/cm2 (0-50 J/cm2) and 0.03 W/cm2 (0-80 J/cm2). Bacteria were counted after 20 h of incubation.

RESULTS

LLLT effects varied significantly with species. P.aeruginosa growth decreased overall dependent on an interaction of irradiance and radiant exposure; greatest inhibition was produced using high irradiance delivering radiant exposures in the range of 1-20 J/cm2 (p = 0.001-0.04). In contrast, E. coli growth increased overall (p = 0.01), regardless of irradiance; greatest effects were produced using low radiant exposures (1-20 J/cm2). There was a main effect for irradiance (p = 0.03) on S. aureus growth; however, growth was not different compared with controls. Additional analysis showed that there were differences in growth of P.aeruginosa when comparing samples that were matched by exposure times (66, 329, 658, 1316, 1974, and 2632 sec) rather than radiant exposure; this suggests that irradiance rather than exposure time was the significant factor in P. aeruginosa inhibition.

CONCLUSION

These findings have immediate relevancy in the use of LLLT for infected wounds. Exposure to 810-nm irradiation (0.03 W/cm2) could potentially benefit wounds infected with P. aeruginosa. However, increased E. coli growth could further delay recovery.

Effects of 810 nm laser irradiation on in vitro growth of bacteria: comparison of continuous wave and frequency modulated light

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Low intensity laser therapy may modify growth of wound bacteria, which could affect wound healing. This study compares the effects on bacteria of 810 nm laser using various delivery modes (continuous wave or frequency modulated light at 26, 292, 1000, or 3800 Hz).

STUDY DESIGN/MATERIALS AND METHODS

Staphylococcus (S.) aureus, Escherichia (E.) coli, and Pseudomonas (P.) aeruginosa were plated on agar and then irradiated (0.015 W/cm(2); 1-50 J/cm(2)) or used as controls (sham irradiated); growth was examined after 20 hours of incubation post exposure.

RESULTS

There were interactions of species and modulation frequency in the overall effects of irradiation (P = 0.0001), and in the radiant exposure mediated effects (P = 0.0001); thus individual frequencies and each bacterium were analysed separately. Bacteria increased following 3800 Hz (P = 0.0001) and 1000 Hz (P = 0.0001) pulsed irradiation; at particular radiant exposures P. aeruginosa proliferated significantly more than other bacteria. Pulsed laser at 292 and 26 Hz also produced species-dependent effects (P = 0.0001; P = 0.0005); however, the effects for different radiant exposures were not significant. Bacterial growth increased overall, independent of species, using continuous mode laser, significantly so at 1 J/cm(2) (P = 0.02). Analysis of individual species demonstrated that laser-mediated growth of S. aureus and E. coli was dependent on pulse frequency; for S. aureus, however, there was no effect for different radiant exposures. Further tests to examine the radiant exposure effects on E. coli showed that growth increased at a frequency of 1000 Hz (2 J/cm(2); P = 0.03). P. aeruginosa growth increased up to 192% using pulsed irradiation at 1000-3800 Hz; whereas 26-292 Hz laser produced only a growth trend.

CONCLUSIONS

The findings of this study point to the need for wound cultures prior to laser irradiation of infected wounds. Similar investigations using other common therapeutic wavelengths are recommended.

Laser modulation of angiogenic factor production by T-lymphocytes

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

In previous investigations, small variations in the energy densities of low level light therapy (LLLT) were found to produce significant differences in the proliferation of resting T-lymphocytes in vitro. Pulsing these cells with mitogen in addition to laser therapy produced inhibitory effects regardless of the amplitude of the energy density used. In the current study, the effect of LLLT on the production of angiogenic factor(s) by T-lymphocytes was investigated in vitro.

STUDY DESIGN/MATERIALS AND METHODS

Human T-cells isolated from peripheral blood were prepared in suspension either with or without addition of mitogen. Cell suspensions were irradiated with laser by using the following energy densities: 1.2, 3.6, 6.0, and 8.4 J/cm(2). Wavelength, pulsing frequency, and power output were kept constant at 820 nm, 5,000 Hz, and 50 mW, respectively. After either 3 or 5 days of incubation, lymphocyte supernatants were collected and added as conditioned media to cultured endothelial cells (ECs). The effect on the proliferation of these ECs was assessed over a 72-hour period by using a methylene blue assay.

RESULTS

Endothelial cell proliferation increased significantly when incubated with conditioned media collected from resting T-cells exposed to 1.2 and 3.6 J/cm(2). Day 5 conditioned media produced similar patterns of EC proliferation to that of day 3 but at lower magnitude. Pulsing of T-lymphocytes with mitogen in addition to laser irradiation significantly lessened their angiogenic capability. Conditioned media from 3.6 J/cm(2) laser-treated T-cells induced the maximal EC proliferation in all groups studied.

CONCLUSION

It would seem that laser therapy stimulates lymphocytes to produce factor(s) that can modulate EC proliferation in vitro; this effect on the lymphocytes is influenced by (1) the amplitude of energy density used for T-cell irradiation, (2) exposing T-cells to both mitogen and laser, and (3) the duration of T-cell incubation in culture.

The current status of low level laser therapy in dentistry. Part 1. Soft tissue applications

Despite more than 30 years of experience with low level laser therapy (LLLT) or 'biostimulation' in dentistry, concerns remain as to its effectiveness as a treatment modality. Controlled clinical studies have demonstrated that while LLLT is effective for some specific applications, it is not a panacea. This paper provides an outline of the biological basis of LLLT and summarizes the findings of controlled clinical studies of the use of LLLT for specific soft tissue applications in dentistry. Areas of controversy where there is a pressing need for further research are identified.

Effect of laser pulse repetition rate and pulse duration on mast cell number and degranulation

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Mast cell activation by low-level laser therapy (LLLT), leading to degranulation and the release of mediators, may be one of the mechanisms by which LLLT can accelerate tissue repair in mammals. The objective of this work, part of an investigation to determine the optimum parameters for increasing mast cell number and degranulation in injured skin, was to determine the effect of different pulsing frequencies of LLLT.

STUDY DESIGN/MATERIALS AND METHODS

Partial-thickness wounds in anaesthetized adult male Wistar rats were irradiated immediately after injury with monochromatic coherent light (wavelength 820 nm) pulsed at either 2.5, 20, 292, or 20,000 Hz at an average power density of 800 mW/cm2 for 27 seconds; the energy density was 21.6 J/cm2. The effects on mast cell number and degranulation were assessed 2 hours post-treatment by counting the numbers of intact and degranulated mast cells in Carnoy-fixed, toluidine blue-stained, sections of irradiated and sham-irradiated wounds.

RESULTS

The total number of mast cells was increased significantly (P < 0.05) by all the frequencies when compared to the sham-irradiated group, but there was no significant difference between frequencies (P > 0.05). However, although the number of degranulated mast cells was higher in all laser-treated wounds, in comparison with the sham-irradiated group, only the 20 Hz (pulse duration 45 ms) and 292 Hz (pulse duration 3 ms) frequencies were significantly effective (P < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

Increase in mast cell number is not pulsing frequency dependent, whereas degranulation is.