Effect of a Single Bout of Intermittent versus Continuous Walking on Perceptions of Fatigue in People with Multiple Sclerosis

The effect of intermittent vs. continuous walking on distance to fatigue in persons with multiple sclerosis

PURPOSE

Previous studies provided evidence that persons with Multiple Sclerosis (pwMS) who walk intermittently experience less fatigue and walk longer distances than when walking continuously. However, total distance pwMS can walk in either condition is unknown. We examined time and distance to fatigability in pwMS comparing intermittent walking (IW) to continuous walking (CW).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

18 pwMS, with Expanded Disability Status Scale median of 4.75 [range = 2-6.5, IQR = 2.5] participated in this randomized crossover study. The IW condition consisted of alternating 30 s treadmill walking and 30 s seated rests. The CW condition consisted of treadmill walking without breaks. Treadmill speed (TS) was determined by an overground 2-min walk test. Walking fatigability was determined by participants walking on the treadmill, until gait fatigue was noted by patient or examiners. Total time and distance to gait fatigue, and subjective fatigue as measured by the Visual analog scale of fatigue were recorded.

RESULTS

Participants had significantly longer duration and distance to fatigue in the IW condition than the CW condition (ps ≤ 0.037). No difference in VASF scores between the two conditions were noted.

CONCLUSION

In this sample, IW allowed pwMS to perform a greater volume of walking and can be an option to improve walking endurance in this population.IMPLICATIONS FOR REHABILITATIONMultiple sclerosis (MS) is a disease that progressively impacts walking, resulting in a decrease in the maximum distance that a person with MS can walk.Intermittent walking has been shown to improve 6-min walk test performance in persons with MS (pwMS) compared to continuous walking, but its effects on longer and shorter walks is not known.The use of distance to fatigue should be considered a viable option for measuring walking fatigability in pwMS as it does not exclude persons based on their ability to complete a 6-min walk, nor would it be too easy for persons with pwMS with mild disability.By using distance to fatigue as an outcome measure, this study provides evidence that intermittent walking results in less fatigability regardless of walking ability.PwMS, regardless of their walking ability, can walk longer distances intermittently than continuously, suggesting that clinical treatment of walking fatigability in pwMS should utilize intermittent rather than continuous walking training.

Combined effect of gender differences and fatiguing task on postural balance, functional mobility and fall risk in adults with multiple sclerosis: A preliminary study

AIM

To investigate the gender difference effect on postural balance, functional mobility, and fall risk after performing a fatiguing task in adults with multiple sclerosis (MS).

METHODS

Eleven women (30.91 ± 8.19 years) and seven men (30.29 ± 7.99 years) with relapsing-remitting MS performed a fatiguing task: three sets of the Five-repetition Sit-To-Stand Test (5-STST) were performed before and after the six-minute WalkTest (6MWT). Bipedal postural balance in eyes open and eyes closed conditions were assessed prefatigue (T0) and postfatigue (T3) using a force platform. Unipedal balance, functional mobility (Timed Up and Go Test), fall risk (Four Square Step Test) and fatigue [Visual Analogue Scale of Fatigue (VASF)] were assessed at T0 and T3. Heart rate (HR) and Rating of Perceived Exertion (RPE) were recorded before (only for HR), during and after the fatiguing task.

RESULTS

Compared to women, men showed an impairment of posturographic parameters [mean center of pressure (CoP) velocity (CoPVm) in both conditions (p < 0.05); CoP sway area (CoPAr) in both conditions (p < 0.01)], unipedal balance on the dominant leg (p <0.001), mobility (p<0.001) and an increased fall risk (p < 0.05). No gender differences were observed in 6MWT, 5-STST, HR, RPE, and VASF.

CONCLUSION

This preliminary study showed that fatiguing task negatively affected postural control, mobility and fall risk only in men. These gender differences were inconclusive but could be taken into account in postural balance rehabilitation programs for MS persons.

Effects of Nonconsecutive Sessions of Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation and Stationary Cycling on Walking Capacity in Individuals With Multiple Sclerosis

BACKGROUND

Exercise has been demonstrated to be safe and well-tolerated in individuals with multiple sclerosis (MS). Physical activity has been shown to enhance the therapeutic effects of transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS). This study aimed to determine the efficacy of intermittent tDCS combined with riding a stationary bicycle to improve walking capacity in individuals with MS.

METHODS

This double-blind randomized controlled trial enrolled 50 eligible participants. Thirty-nine participants completed the study: 21 in the active group and 18 in the control group. Participants were assigned randomly to exercise on a stationary bike in conjunction with anodal tDCS or to exercise combined with a sham tDCS protocol. Walking capacity tests (2-Minute Walk Test, 5-Meter Walk Test, Timed Up and Go test), manual muscle testing, the Fatigue Severity Scale, and the Multiple Sclerosis Quality of Life-54 were used to determine outcomes.

RESULTS

In terms of observed changes in 2-Minute Walk Test and 5-Meter Walk Test values, the exercise + tDCS group achieved significantly higher posttreatment values than the exercise + sham tDCS group. After the intervention and 1 month later, the intervention group's mean Timed Up and Go test value decreased significantly (P = .002) compared with that of the control group. There was no difference in Fatigue Severity Scale score, Multiple Sclerosis Quality of Life-54 score, or manual muscle testing improvement between the 2 groups.

CONCLUSIONS

Nonconsecutive sessions of anodal tDCS combined with stationary cycling may have a greater effect on the walking capacity of individuals with MS than exercise alone.

The clinical correlates of the chair sit to stand performance in people with multiple sclerosis

Objective: This study aimed to evaluate the motor and non-motor factors associated with sit-to-stand performance in people with Multiple Sclerosis (PwMS). Design: Observational cross-sectional study. Subjects: A total of 88 individuals with MS participated in this study. Main Measures: Standing performance was measured using the five-times-sit-to-stand test (FTSTS). The Berg Balance Scale to assess balance, the 10-Meter Walking Test (10-MWT) was used to assess walking speed; the Patient Determined Disease Steps (PDDS) was used to assess disability level. Furthermore, Brief International Cognitive Assessment for MS (BICAMS) was used to assess cognitive status, Hospital Anxiety and Depression scale (HADS) to assess depression and anxiety, and the Modified Fatigue Impact scale (MFIS) to evaluate fatigue. Spearman correlation coefficient was used to determine the relationship between all these variables and the FTSTS. Furthermore, multiple linear regression was conducted to determine predictive factors of the FTSTS. Results: FTSTS score was correlated significantly with BBS, PDDS, BICAMS, 10-MWT and MFIS (r ranged from 0.3 to 0.52; P < .05). However, there was no significant correlation observed between the FTSTS and HADS-depression or HADS-anxiety. Considering the multiple regression analysis, the following factors were significantly predictive of the FTSTS: 10-MWT, MFIS and the BICAMS-z score (R²: 0.433, P < .0001). Conclusion: The study concludes that sit to stand is multifactorial and is potentially associated with walking speed, cognitive function and fatigue. These factors should be considered by healthcare professionals in interpreting the sit-to-stand performance of PwMS and in designing rehabilitation interventions.

Self-efficacy training as an adjunct to exercise in a person with progressive multiple sclerosis: a case report

Background: Increasing self-efficacy to exercise and minimizing disease-related barriers has been shown to improve physical activity levels and quality of life (QOL) in persons with multiple sclerosis (MS). Currently, little research has examined exercise self-efficacy in persons with more advanced MS. Purpose: Explore the effects of a self-efficacy plus exercise intervention on physical activity endurance and level, QOL, and fatigue in an individual with advanced MS and low self-efficacy.Methods: The participant was a 60-year-old, severely disabled female with secondary progressive MS and an Expanded Disability Status Score (EDSS) of 8. The 8-week intervention consisted of weekly discussions and MS-related education; four one-on-one sessions with a MS "mentor;" daily journal to record sleep quality, fatigue level, and physical activity. Outcomes included a modified 5-meter walk test (5MWT), MS Impact Scale (MSIS-29), Exercise Self-Efficacy Scale (EX-ES), Modified Fatigue Impact Scale (MFIS), MS Self-Efficacy Scale (MS-SES), Patient Health Questionnaire-9 (PHQ-9), and daily physical activity monitoring. Outcomes were assessed at baseline (week 0), post-intervention (week 8), and 8 weeks post intervention (week 16). The participant continued her regular exercise routine independently throughout the study period.Results: There were notable improvements in EX-ES, MFIS, PHQ-9, MSIS-29 psychological subscale, sleep quality, and morning fatigue ratings post intervention, some of which were retained at follow up.Conclusion: The findings illustrate that an 8-week self-efficacy intervention increased exercise self-efficacy, QOL, and reduced perceived fatigue in a severely disabled individual with progressive MS. Future research should examine self-efficacy interventions in a larger sample size of persons with progressive MS.

Pilot trial of speed-intensive gait training on balance and walking in people with multiple sclerosis

Background/Aims

Diminished walking speed and endurance is commonly experienced by individuals with multiple sclerosis. Speed-intensive gait training has led to improvements in walking speed and endurance in other neurological populations; however, its effect in persons with multiple sclerosis is unknown. This pilot study examined the feasibility, safety and efficacy of speed-intensive gait training in a sample of people with multiple sclerosis.

Methods

A total of eight participants (five women, median Expanded Disability Status Scale 3.5) underwent a 6-week, twice weekly speed-intensive gait training programme. Walking speed and endurance, balance and fatigue were measured pre- and post-intervention.

Results

Speed-intensive gait training was feasible, with excellent adherence and safety. It proved effective, with improvements in walking speed (P=0.05), walking endurance (P=0.036) and balance (P=0.041) without an increase in fatigue.

Conclusions

The intermittent design of speed-intensive gait training may enable individuals with multiple sclerosis to achieve higher training volumes than traditional models. Although further study is warranted, rehabilitation clinicians should consider adding speed-intensive gait training as an intervention to improve walking and balance in this patient group.

Associations Between Self-Reported Symptoms and Gait Parameters Using In-Home Sensors in Persons With Multiple Sclerosis

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Multiple sclerosis (MS) is a progressive neurological disorder, characterized by exacerbations and remissions, often resulting in disability affecting multiple neurological functions. The purpose of this article was (1) to describe the frequencies of self-reported symptoms in a natural environment and (2) to determine characteristics and associations between self-reported symptoms and home gait parameters (speed, stride time, and stride length) at baseline and at 3 months in patients with MS.

METHODS

Participants completed the self-report MS-Related Symptom Scale to measure symptoms. A three-dimensional depth imaging system (Foresite Healthcare) was used to measure gait parameters in the home environment.

RESULTS

These data show significant correlations between the following symptoms: knee locking or collapsing, difficulty sleeping, depression, and anxiety with decreased number of average walks per day; however, the symptoms including trouble-making toilet: day and difficulty in starting urine were positively correlated with average walks per day. The symptom numbness was significantly correlated with decreased speed and decreased stride length.

DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS

Our findings suggest that certain groups of symptoms were more frequently reported with certain gait parameters (stride time/speed) in persons with MS. Rehabilitation nurses can provide optimal care to prevent future decline in symptoms and gait.

The effect of fatigue on balance performance in Parkinson's disease

Introduction

Balance loss and falls are a common and multifactorial finding in persons with Parkinson's Disease (pwPD). Objective fatigability is thought to contribute to falls in other neurologic conditions, but its impact on balance in pwPD is not known. The two-fold purpose of this study was to: 1) establish that a 6-minute walk (6MW_Fast) is a stimulus to subjective fatigue for pwPD; and, 2) determine if the Mini Balance Evaluation Systems Test (MBT) is sensitive to change that was induced by a fatiguing condition.

Methods

Using a randomized crossover design, 19 research participants performed a Mini Balance Evaluation Systems Test (MBT) before and after either a ‘fast’ 6-minute walk (6MW_Fast) to induce fatigue or a 6-minute rest.

Results

VASF scores increased after the 6MW_Fast. Total MBT scores in research participants with Modified Hoehn and Yahr (H&Y) scores of 3.0 and above differed significantly before and after the ‘fast’ 6-minute walk (p = .007, n = 9) while participants with H&Y scores of 1.5 to 2.5 (p = .084, n = 10) did not, suggesting that more disabled pwPD were more likely to experience fatigability that interfered with balance.

Conclusions

A 6MW_Fast is a sufficient stimulus to induce subjective fatigue in pwPD and to decrease total MBT scores for more disabled pwPD. Balance evaluations should occur when pwPD are in fatigued and unfatigued states to determine whether fatigue has an impact on balance performance.

•

Both subjective fatigue and objective fatigability can occur in Parkinsons Disease (PD).

•

Objective fatigability may be a factor in balance impairment in persons with PD.

•

Balance assessments in PD should be made with the patient in both a fatigued and non fatigued state.

Increases in fatigue do not change spasticity scores in persons with multiple sclerosis

AIM

Fatigue is a common finding in multiple sclerosis (MS) which may result in worsening of gait, function and other MS symptoms, like spasticity. Although the worsening of spasticity with fatigue has been reported by persons with MS, the effect of fatigue on spasticity has not been measured.

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to compare lower extremity Modified Ashworth Scale (MAS) scores of persons with mild-to-moderate MS symptoms before and after fatigued and unfatigued conditions.

METHODS

Using a randomized crossover design, MS subjects underwent 6-min walk to induce fatigue and 6-min supine rests, with lower extremity spasticity measured before and after each condition. Friedman tests gave paired comparisons of MAS before and after each condition.

RESULTS

16 subjects with mild-to-moderate MS completed the study (mean age = 56; standard deviation = 11.7). Friedman tests showed a significant decrease in mean rank for overall average MAS for both lower extremities (p = 0.031) when comparing fatigued to unfatigued conditions. This appeared to be driven by the right lower extremity average MAS (p = 0.002) and, more specifically, in post hoc pre to post-test comparisons for right knee flexor (p = 0.002 fatigued; p = 0.059 unfatigued) and right knee extensor (p = 0.001 fatigued; p = 0.020 unfatigued) MAS mean rank differences. Fatigue did not result in increased spasticity.

CONCLUSION

Spasticity in these subjects with MS was not worsened by fatigue suggesting that worsening of gait with fatigue may be due to causes other than spasticity.

Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation in treatment of post polio syndrome

BACKGROUND

Post polio syndrome is a rare disease that occurs decades after polio virus infection. Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) is a treatment option with proved effectiveness in drug resistant depression. Possibly it can be helpful in therapy of other neurological diseases including post polio syndrome.

OBJECTIVE

To describe a case of patient diagnosed with post polio syndrome who was treated with rTMS stimulation with a good effect.

METHODS

Patient had rTMS stimulation of left prefrontal cortex twice a week for an eight weeks. Patient's health status was evaluated before treatment, after last rTMS session and after three months from the end of the treatment.

RESULTS

Improvement of fatigue score, mood disturbances and motor functions was observed after treatment.

CONCLUSION

rTMS can be an effective method in treatment of post polio syndrome but further studies with larger group need to be done to confirm that data.

Orthotic and therapeutic effect of functional electrical stimulation on fatigue induced gait patterns in people with multiple sclerosis

PURPOSE

To assess the orthotic and therapeutic effects of prolonged use of functional electrical stimulation (FES) on fatigue induced gait patterns in people with Multiple Sclerosis (MS).

METHOD

Thirteen people with MS completed 3D gait analysis with FES off and on, before and after a fatiguing 6-minute walk, at baseline and after 8 weeks of use of FES.

RESULTS

Eleven participants completed all testing. An orthotic effect on gait was not evident on first use of FES. However, therapeutic effects on gait after 8 weeks use were generally positive, including increases in walking speed due to improved neuromuscular control and power generated at the hip and ankle of the more affected limb. The action of FES alone was not sufficient to overcome all fatigue related deficits in gait but there was evidence 8 weeks use of FES can ameliorate some fatigue effects on lower limb kinetics, including benefits to ankle mechanics involved in generating power around push-off during stance.

CONCLUSIONS

Eight-weeks of FES can benefit the gait pattern of people with MS under non-fatigued and fatigued conditions. Implications for rehabilitation In some people with MS prolonged use of FES may be necessary before observing positive orthotic effects. Improvements in the neuromuscular control of the more affected lower limb may develop with prolonged use of FES in people with MS. Only some therapeutic benefits of FES are maintained during fatigued walking in people with MS. FES may be considered as a gait retraining device as well as an orthotic intervention for people with MS.

Effects of Intermittent Versus Continuous Walking on Distance Walked and Fatigue in Persons With Multiple Sclerosis: A Randomized Crossover Trial

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Fatigue is a common, disabling symptom experienced by persons with multiple sclerosis (MS). Evidence shows that intermittent exercise is associated in improved performance and negligible fatigue. The purpose of this study was to examine whether subjects with MS walk greater distances with less fatigue under intermittent (INT) or continuous (CONT) walking condition.

METHODS

Twenty-seven subjects with MS (median Extended Disability Severity Scale 3.5, interquartile range 1.6) walked in the CONT (ie, 6 uninterrupted minutes) and INT (ie, three 2-minute walking bouts) conditions in a randomized crossover. Distance was measured for the entire 6-minute walking period and each 2-minute increment. Fatigue was measured as the difference in a visual analog scale of fatigue (ΔVAS-F) immediately preceding and following each trial.

RESULTS

Participants walked greater distances in the INT condition compared to the CONT condition (P = 0.005). There was a significant interaction of walking condition and time (P < 0.001), indicating that the distances walked in the INT condition changed across time. ΔVAS-F was significantly lower in the INT condition than in the CONT condition (P = 0.036).

DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION

Subjects with MS walked farther, and with less fatigue, when walking intermittently rather than continuously. Persons with MS may be able to tolerate a greater dose of walking training if the walking bouts are intermittent. Further study to determine the benefits of a walking exercise program using intermittent walking is recommended.Video Abstract available for additional insights from the authors (Supplemental Digital Content 1, http://links.lww.com/JNPT/A103).

Dorsiflexion assist orthosis reduces the physiological cost and mitigates deterioration in strength and balance associated with walking in people with multiple sclerosis

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the effect of wearing a dorsiflexion assist orthosis (DAO) on walking distance, physiological cost, fatigue, and strength and balance measures after a modified 6-minute walk test (6MWT) in people with multiple sclerosis (MS).

DESIGN

Randomized crossover trial.

SETTING

Hospital Movement Laboratory.

PARTICIPANTS

People with moderate MS and Expanded Disability Status Scale score of 3.7±0.7 (N=34; 26 women).

INTERVENTIONS

Modified 6MWT with and without a DAO worn on the weaker leg.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Distance walked, perceived fatigue, and the physiological cost of walking were compared between walking conditions. Pre- and postwalk changes in knee extensor and ankle dorsiflexor isometric strength and standing postural sway with eyes open and closed were compared between walking conditions.

RESULTS

There were no differences in distance walked or perceived fatigue between the 2 walking conditions. However, there was a reduced physiological cost of walking (P<.05), a smaller reduction in knee extensor strength (P<.05), and a smaller increase in standing postural sway with eyes open (P<.01) after walking while wearing the DAO compared with walking without wearing the DAO.

CONCLUSIONS

Despite not increasing walking distance or reducing perceived fatigue, the DAO reduced the physiological cost of walking and maintained knee strength and standing balance, which may have important implications for physical rehabilitation in people with MS. Further trials are required to determine whether the beneficial effects of wearing a DAO found here are maintained for longer periods.