Improving alcohol withdrawal outcomes in acute care

Assessment of a Hospital-Wide CIWA-Ar Protocol for Management of Alcohol Withdrawal Syndrome

Objective

To determine if a hospital-wide symptom-based alcohol withdrawal protocol may result in significant clinical improvements to patient outcomes, safety, and hospital efficiency.

Methods

Retrospective/prospective cohort study between January 1, 2016 and December 31, 2016 (pre-protocol), and between March 1, 2017 and August 7, July 2017 (post-protocol). Pre-protocol patients were identified retrospectively using International Classification of Diseases, 10^th revision codes (F10.1, F10.2, and Z71.4). Post-protocol patients were identified by the use of a unique alcohol withdrawal order set in their electronic medical record. The primary endpoint was average length of stay. Secondary outcomes included death, escalation of care as defined as requiring intensive care unit (ICU) consultation or the rapid response team, average ICU length of stay, respiratory failure, average benzodiazepine usage, and incidence of seizures.

Results

The study included 276 patients in the pre-protocol group and 145 patients in the post-protocol group. There was a significant reduction found in the primary endpoint of average length of stay (7.15 ± 6.5 days vs 5.7 ± 5.6 days; P=.02). There was a significant reduction in the average benzodiazepine use, use of adjunctive medications, need for ICU consultation or rapid response team, respiratory failure, average ICU length of stay, use of neurologic imaging, and the need for lumbar puncture.

Conclusion

Implementation of a Clinical Institute Withdrawal Assessment for Alcohol, Revised–based alcohol withdrawal protocol may significantly improve quality of care, patient safety, and treatment effectiveness in a large, mixed medical/surgical, urban community-based academic medical center.

Alcohol Withdrawal Syndrome: Improving Recognition and Treatment in the Emergency Department

Alcoholism continues to be a persistent health problem in the United States, accounting for up to 62% of emergency department (ED) visits. This quality improvement (QI) project examined whether identifying the benefit for early use of Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Test (AUDIT C) and Clinical Institute Withdrawal Assessment of Alcohol Scale, Revised (CIW-ar) in the ED would avoid escalation of care and offset poor outcomes of alcohol withdrawal syndrome (AWS). A preimplementation chart review (N = 99) showed an average of 12%-15% of patients requiring escalation of care at the project site. The QI project utilized a single-group, pre-/posttest design. The setting was a Southwest Veterans Affair tertiary care referral center. Thirty-five ED staff members were surveyed for baseline knowledge and attended education sessions, led by an advanced practice nurse, on the use of AUDIT-C and CIWA-ar. Posteducation, patients admitted to the hospital were screened with AUDIT-C and treated with CIWA-ar. Postimplementation, charts were reviewed for admitted patients (N = 42) on the use of AUDIT-C, CIWA-ar, length of stay (LOS), and area patient treated. Although the test scores after didactic education were statistically significant (p ≤ 0.050), there was no significant difference in the use of AUDIT-C or CIWA-ar in the ED, nor a significant decrease in LOS for those patients with CIWA-ar ordered. However, the potential for clinical benefit could not be disavowed. Barriers to implementation included survey fatigue, inability to embed AUDIT-C in the electronic medical record, inconsistency in completing AUDIT-C, interrater reliability, and patient fear of stigmatization. Advanced practice nurses provide an integral role to augment early identification and treatment of AWS in the ED.

Improving Nursing Knowledge of Alcohol Withdrawal: Second Generation Education Strategies

Christiana Care Health System implemented a Care Management Guideline for Alcohol Withdrawal Symptom Management, which provided direction for inpatient screening for alcohol withdrawal risk, assessment, and treatment. Nurses educated on its use expressed confusion with the use of the assessment tools, pharmacokinetics, and pathophysiology of alcohol withdrawal and delirium tremens. Reeducation was provided by nursing professional development specialists. Pre- and postsurveys revealed that nurses were more confident in caring for patients with alcohol withdrawal.