Diagnostic value of thallium-201 chloride single-photon emission computerized tomography in differentiating tumor recurrence from radiation injury after gamma knife surgery for metastatic brain tumors

OBJECT

The authors assessed the diagnostic value of 201Tl Cl single-photon emission computerized tomography (SPECT), performed after gamma knife surgery (GKS) for metastatic brain tumors in differentiating tumor recurrence from radiation injury.

METHODS

Of 6503 metastatic brain tumors treated with GKS, 201Tl SPECT was required in 72 to differentiate between tumor recurrence and radiation injury. When the Tl index was greater than 5, the lesion was diagnosed as a tumor recurrence. When the index was < 3.0 it was called radiation injury. In cases with a Tl index between 3 and 5, 201Tl SPECT was repeated once per month until the Tl index was greater than 5 or less than 3. If the Tl index fluctuated between 3 and 5 for 2 months, the lesion was diagnosed as radiation injury. The final diagnosis was based on histological examination or clinical course. The sensitivity of the method was 91%; thus 201Tl SPECT is effective for differentiating between tumor recurrence and radiation injury in metastatic brain tumors treated with GKS. Caution is necessary, however, for the following reasons: 1) simple interinstitutional comparisons of Tl indices are not possible because measurement methods are institute specific; 2) steroid administration decreases the Tl index to a variable degree; and 3) a severe radiation injury lesion, as is often seen after repeated GKS or very high dose GKS, may have a Tl index greater than 5.

CONCLUSIONS

Used with critical insight 201Tl Cl SPECT can be useful in distinguishing between tumor regrowth and radiation necrosis in patients with cerebral metastases.

Diagnostic value of thallium-201 chloride single-photon emission computerized tomography in differentiating tumor recurrence from radiation injury after gamma knife surgery for metastatic brain tumors

Object. The authors assessed the diagnostic value of 201Tl Cl single-photon emission computerized tomography (SPECT), performed after gamma knife surgery (GKS) for metastatic brain tumors in differentiating tumor recurrence from radiation injury.

Methods. Of 6503 metastatic brain tumors treated with GKS, 201Tl SPECT was required in 72 to differentiate between tumor recurrence and radiation injury. When the Tl index was greater than 5, the lesion was diagnosed as a tumor recurrence. When the index was < 3.0 it was called radiation injury. In cases with a Tl index between 3 and 5, 201Tl SPECT was repeated once per month until the Tl index was greater than 5 or less than 3. If the Tl index fluctuated between 3 and 5 for 2 months, the lesion was diagnosed as radiation injury. The final diagnosis was based on histological examination or clinical course.

The sensitivity of the method was 91%; thus 201Tl SPECT is effective for differentiating between tumor recurrence and radiation injury in metastatic brain tumors treated with GKS. Caution is necessary, however, for the following reasons: 1) simple interinstitutional comparisons of Tl indices are not possible because measurement methods are institute specific; 2) steroid administration decreases the Tl index to a variable degree; and 3) a severe radiation injury lesion, as is often seen after repeated GKS or very high dose GKS, may have a Tl index greater than 5.

Conclusions. Used with critical insight 201Tl Cl SPECT can be useful in distinguishing between tumor regrowth and radiation necrosis in patients with cerebral metastases.

Extraosseous accumulation of bone scanning agents in malignant brain tumors: comparison to semi-quantitative evaluation with 99mTc SPECT/201Tl SPECT and histological findings

Although 201Tl chloride (Tl) SPECT has been used in the differential diagnosis between recurrence of malignant brain tumor and necrosis after treatment, it is not generally recognized as a definite modality to distinguish them. We conducted a preliminary study using Tl SPECT and 99mTc-MDP or 99mTc-HMDP (Tc) SPECT because it has been said that extraosseous accumulation was caused by calcium deposits in necrotic tissues. In our study, for the purposes of clarifying the mechanism of extraosseous uptake and the correlation between extraosseous accumulation of bone-scanning agent and tumor viability in malignant brain tumors, we compared whether Tc uptake was correlated with the histopathological findings and further performed semi-quantitative evaluation between Tc SPECT and Tl SPECT. The correlation coefficients between the ratio of tumor to normal skull count obtained from Tc SPECT (Tc-T/N) and those of tumor to normal brain count (T/N) and to normal scalp count (T/S) both obtained from Tl SPECT were calculated. Using contrast enhanced CT (CE-CT) or contrast enhanced MRI (CE-MRI), 8 of 10 cases showed intensely ring-enhanced tumor with necrotic lesion. Histopathologically, 7 of 8 cases whose tumor had been resected before treatment had necrosis with increased vascularity or bleeding. Of the remaining 2 cases one case, malignant lymphoma had only hypervascularity by biopsy, while the other one was excluded for resection after treatment. Three of these 8 cases whose CE-CT or CE-MRI showed necrotic lesions exhibited Tc and Tl accumulations in the area corresponding to necrosis. In contrast, 2 showed no Tc nor Tl uptake. Tc-T/N had no significant correlation with any of early-, delayed-T/N or T/S. In conclusion, there was no significant correlation between Tc and Tl uptakes by malignant brain tumors in semi-quantitative evaluation.