Understanding Experiences of Moral Distress in End-of-Life Care Among US and UK Physician Trainees: a Comparative Qualitative Study

BACKGROUND

Moral distress is a state in which a clinician cannot act in accordance with their ethical beliefs because of external constraints. Physician trainees, who work within rigid hierarchies and who lack clinical experience, are particularly vulnerable to moral distress. We examined the dynamics of physician trainee moral distress in end-of-life care by comparing experiences in two different national cultures and healthcare systems.

OBJECTIVE

We investigated cultural factors in the US and the UK that may produce moral distress within their respective healthcare systems, as well as how these factors shape experiences of moral distress among physician trainees.

DESIGN

Semi-structured in-depth qualitative interviews about experiences of end-of-life care and moral distress.

PARTICIPANTS

Sixteen internal medicine residents in the US and fourteen junior doctors in the UK.

APPROACH

The work was analyzed using thematic analysis.

KEY RESULTS

Some drivers of moral distress were similar among US and UK trainees, including delivery of potentially inappropriate treatments, a poorly defined care trajectory, and involvement of multiple teams creating different care expectations. For UK trainees, healthcare team hierarchy was common, whereas for US trainees, pressure from families, a lack of guidelines for withholding inappropriate treatments, and distress around physically harming patients were frequently cited. US trainees described how patient autonomy and a fear of lawsuits contributed to moral distress, whereas UK trainees described how societal expectations around resource allocation mitigated it.

CONCLUSION

This research highlights how the differing experiences of moral distress among US and UK physician trainees are influenced by their countries' healthcare cultures. This research illustrates how experiences of moral distress reflect the broader culture in which it occurs and suggests how trainees may be particularly vulnerable to it. Clinicians and healthcare leaders in both countries can learn from each other about policies and practices that might decrease the moral distress trainees experience.

How individual ethical frameworks shape physician trainees' experiences providing end-of-life care: a qualitative study

OBJECTIVES

The end of life is an ethically challenging time requiring complex decision-making. This study describes ethical frameworks among physician trainees, explores how these frameworks manifest and relates these frameworks to experiences delivering end-of-life care.

DESIGN

We conducted semistructured in-depth exploratory qualitative interviews with physician trainees about experiences of end-of-life care and moral distress. We analysed the interviews using thematic analysis.

SETTING

Academic teaching hospitals in the United States and United Kingdom.

PARTICIPANTS

We interviewed 30 physician trainees. We purposefully sampled across three domains we expected to be associated with individual ethics (stage of training, gender and national healthcare context) in order to elicit a diversity of ethical and experiential perspectives.

RESULTS

Some trainees subscribed to a best interest ethical framework, characterised by offering recommendations consistent with the patient's goals and values, presenting only medically appropriate choices and supporting shared decision-making between the patient/family and medical team. Others endorsed an autonomy framework, characterised by presenting all technologically feasible choices, refraining from offering recommendations and prioritising the voice of patient/family as the decision-maker.

CONCLUSIONS

This study describes how physician trainees conceptualise their roles as being rooted in an autonomy or best interest framework. Physician trainees have limited clinical experience and decision-making autonomy and may have ethical frameworks that are dynamic and potentially highly influenced by experiences providing end-of-life care. A better understanding of how individual physicians' ethical frameworks influences the care they give provides opportunities to improve patient communication and advance the role of shared decision-making to ensure goal-aligned end-of-life care.

Assessing contributions of value-added medical student roles

Value-added student roles-defined as student activities that simultaneously teach physicianship and improve the healthcare system-have rapidly gained popularity in recent years. Though many agree that value-added medical student roles can contribute both to student learning and to patient outcomes, impact evaluation of these roles can pose a challenge. In this Personal View, we describe our quality improvement project at UC San Francisco aimed at reducing unnecessary physical therapist (PT) referrals. While our primary outcome measure remained unchanged, the project helped to galvanize safe mobilization efforts in the hospital and led to the establishment of a UCSF Health Safe Mobilization Committee, leading to broader and potentially more impactful institutional systems changes. How do we interpret success, and how do we appraise the potential impact students can have in a complex health system? While we agree with the importance of process-focused metrics that assess student participation in an interprofessional, data-driven quality improvement effort, we also see a role for an expanded assessment of student contributions to capture systems improvements that may occur downstream of student activities.

The rising cost of commonly used emergency department medications (2006-15)

OBJECTIVE

We determine how aggregate costs have changed for commonly used emergency department (ED) medications, and assess drivers of cost increases.

METHODS

Using the National Hospital Ambulatory Medical Care Survey (NHAMCS), we identified the top 150 ED medications administered and prescribed at discharge in 2015. We used average wholesale prices (AWP) for each year from 2006 to 15 from the Red Book (Truven Health Analytics Inc.). Average wholesale price per patient (AWPP) was calculated by dividing AWP by drug uses. This was then multiplied by the total drug administrations or prescriptions to estimate the total cost in a given the year. All prices were converted to 2015 dollars.

RESULTS

Aggregate costs of drugs administered in the ED increased from $688.7 million in 2006 to $882.4 million in 2015. For discharge prescriptions, aggregate costs increased from $2.031 billion in 2006 to $4.572 billion in 2015. AWPP for drugs administered in the ED in 2015 was 14.5% higher than in 2006 and 24.3% higher at discharge. The largest absolute increase in AWPP for drugs administered was for glucagon, which increased from $111 in 2006 to $235 in 2015. The largest AWPP increase at discharge was for epinephrine auto-injector, which increased from $124 in 2006 and to $481 in 2015.

CONCLUSION

Over the course of the study period, the aggregate costs of the most common medications administered in the ED increased by 28% while the costs of medications prescribed at discharge increased 125%.

"We Really Help, Taking Care of Each Other": Older Homeless Adults as Caregivers

Objectives:

Many older homeless adults maintain contact with family. We conducted a qualitative study examining the role of family caregiving for older homeless adults.

Method:

We conducted semi-structured qualitative interviews with a sample of 46 homeless participants who reported spending at least one night with a housed family member in the prior 6 months.

Results:

A total of 13 of 46 older adult participants provided caregiving. Themes included (a) the death of the care recipient led to the participant’s homelessness; (b) feeling a duty to act as caregivers; (c) providing care in exchange for housing; (d) caregivers’ ability to stay was tenuous; (e) providing care conflicted with the caregiver’s needs; and (f) resentment when family was ungrateful.

Discussion:

In a sample of older homeless adults in contact with family, many provided caregiving for housed family. For some, caregiving precipitated homelessness; for others, caregiving provided temporary respite from homelessness, and for others, caregiving continued during homelessness.