Comparison of actionable events detected in cancer genomes by whole-genome sequencing, in silico whole-exome and mutation panels

Background

Next-generation sequencing is used in cancer research to identify somatic and germline mutations, which can predict sensitivity or resistance to therapies, and may be a useful tool to reveal drug repurposing opportunities between tumour types. Multigene panels are used in clinical practice for detecting targetable mutations. However, the value of clinical whole-exome sequencing (WES) and whole-genome sequencing (WGS) for cancer care is less defined, specifically as the majority of variants found using these technologies are of uncertain significance.

Patients and methods

We used the Cancer Genome Interpreter and WGS in 726 tumours spanning 10 cancer types to identify drug repurposing opportunities. We compare the ability of WGS to detect actionable variants, tumour mutation burden (TMB) and microsatellite instability (MSI) by using in silico down-sampled data to mimic WES, a comprehensive sequencing panel and a hotspot mutation panel.

Results

We reveal drug repurposing opportunities as numerous biomarkers are shared across many solid tumour types. Comprehensive panels identify the majority of approved actionable mutations, with WGS detecting more candidate actionable mutations for biomarkers currently in clinical trials. Moreover, estimated values for TMB and MSI vary when calculated from WGS, WES and panel data, and are dependent on whether all mutations or only non-synonymous mutations were used. Our results suggest that TMB and MSI thresholds should not only be tumour-dependent, but also be sequencing platform-dependent.

Conclusions

There is a large opportunity to repurpose cancer drugs, and these data suggest that comprehensive sequencing is an invaluable source of information to guide clinical decisions by facilitating precision medicine and may provide a wealth of information for future studies. Furthermore, the sequencing and analysis approach used to estimate TMB may have clinical implications if a hard threshold is used to indicate which patients may respond to immunotherapy.

•

Genome analysis revealed that treatment biomarkers are shared across solid tumours, highlighting repurposing opportunities.

•

Comprehensive panels detect most known biomarkers; however, WGS detects more biomarkers for treatments in clinical trials.

•

TMB is well correlated between sequencing methods, but absolute values vary and are dependent on mutation types considered.

Whole-genome sequencing reveals clinically relevant insights into the aetiology of familial breast cancers

BACKGROUND

Whole-genome sequencing (WGS) is a powerful method for revealing the diversity and complexity of the somatic mutation burden of tumours. Here, we investigated the utility of tumour and matched germline WGS for understanding aetiology and treatment opportunities for high-risk individuals with familial breast cancer.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

We carried out WGS on 78 paired germline and tumour DNA samples from individuals carrying pathogenic variants in BRCA1 (n = 26) or BRCA2 (n = 22) or from non-carriers (non-BRCA1/2; n = 30).

RESULTS

Matched germline/tumour WGS and somatic mutational signature analysis revealed patients with unreported, dual pathogenic germline variants in cancer risk genes (BRCA1/BRCA2; BRCA1/MUTYH). The strategy identified that 100% of tumours from BRCA1 carriers and 91% of tumours from BRCA2 carriers exhibited biallelic inactivation of the respective gene, together with somatic mutational signatures suggestive of a functional deficiency in homologous recombination. A set of non-BRCA1/2 tumours also had somatic signatures indicative of BRCA-deficiency, including tumours with BRCA1 promoter methylation, and tumours from carriers of a PALB2 pathogenic germline variant and a BRCA2 variant of uncertain significance. A subset of 13 non-BRCA1/2 tumours from early onset cases were BRCA-proficient, yet displayed complex clustered structural rearrangements associated with the amplification of oncogenes and pathogenic germline variants in TP53, ATM and CHEK2.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study highlights the role that WGS of matched germline/tumour DNA and the somatic mutational signatures can play in the discovery of pathogenic germline variants and for providing supporting evidence for variant pathogenicity. WGS-derived signatures were more robust than germline status and other genomic predictors of homologous recombination deficiency, thus impacting the selection of platinum-based or PARP inhibitor therapy. In this first examination of non-BRCA1/2 tumours by WGS, we illustrate the considerable heterogeneity of these tumour genomes and highlight that complex genomic rearrangements may drive tumourigenesis in a subset of cases.

Abstract P5-10-01: Using whole genome sequencing and somatic mutation signatures to unravel insight into familial breast cancer aetiology

Approximately 10-15% of breast cancers are associated with a strong family history of disease. Pathogenic variants in BRCA1, BRCA2 or other moderate to highly penetrant susceptibility genes (e.g. TP53, ATM, CHEK2, PALB2 and PTEN) account for a number of breast cancer families. However, for over 50% of families the underlying genetic contribution to their risk remains unknown (termed here as non-BRCA1/2). This has a profound impact for how individuals and their families are managed in the clinic. We applied whole genome sequencing (WGS) to determine whether somatic mutation analysis can reveal insight into the aetiology of familial breast cancer. The full repertoire of somatic mutations was evaluated in 26 BRCA1, 22 BRCA2 and 32 non-BRCA1/2 tumours; including SNPs, indels, copy number changes and structural rearrangements, and mutational signatures. Genomes were also analysed using the HRD Index and HRDetect, as predictors of homologous recombination deficiency. BRCA1, BRCA2 and non-BRCA1/2 tumours exhibited a different burden of mutations, a different spectrum of mutational signatures and different telomere length. Based on collective patterns of mutation signatures, tumours were classified as 'BRCA1-like', 'BRCA2-like' or 'non-BRCA1/2-like' with a 15% rate of tumour re-classification from their original clinical BRCA status. The results demonstrate the power of WGS to differentiate between BRCA1 and BRCA2 driven tumours; in the identification of double-pathogenic germline mutation carriers based on the resulting somatic mutation signature; and in the interpretation of BRCA unclassified variants. WGS of tumour genomes reveals fascinating insights into tumour aetiology and could compliment current genetic testing of breast cancer families.

Citation Format: Simpson P, Nones K, Johnson J, Newell F, Patch A-M, Thorne H, Kazakoff S, De Luca X, Parsons M, Ferguson K, Reid L, McCart Reed A, Srihari S, Lakis V, Davidson A, Mukhopadhyay P, Holmes O, Xu Q, Wood S, Leonard C, Beasley J, Degasperi A, Nik-Zainal S, Ragan M, Spurdle A, Khanna KK, Lakhani S, Pearson J, Chenevix-Trench G, Waddell N. Using whole genome sequencing and somatic mutation signatures to unravel insight into familial breast cancer aetiology [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the 2018 San Antonio Breast Cancer Symposium; 2018 Dec 4-8; San Antonio, TX. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2019;79(4 Suppl):Abstract nr P5-10-01.

Novel GLIS3 mutations demonstrate an extended multisystem phenotype

INTRODUCTION

Mutations in the GLI-similar 3 (GLIS3) gene encoding the transcription factor GLIS3 are a rare cause of neonatal diabetes and congenital hypothyroidism with six affected cases from three families reported to date. Additional features, described previously, include congenital glaucoma, hepatic fibrosis, polycystic kidneys, developmental delay and facial dysmorphism.

SUBJECTS

We report two new cases from unrelated families with distinct novel homozygous partial GLIS3 deletions. Both patients presented with neonatal diabetes mellitus, severe resistant hypothyroidism in the presence of elevated thyroglobulin and normal thyroid anatomy, degenerative liver disease, cystic renal dysplasia, recurrent infections and facial dysmorphism. These novel mutations have also resulted in osteopenia, bilateral sensorineural deafness and pancreatic exocrine insufficiency, features that have not previously been associated with GLIS3 mutations. Gene dosage analysis showed that the parents were carriers of a deletion encompassing exons 1-2 (case 1) or exons 1-4 (case 2) of the 11 exon gene. Genome-wide SNP analysis did not reveal a common ancestral GLIS3 haplotype in patient 2.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results confirm partial gene deletions as the most common type of GLIS3 mutations, accounting for four of five families identified to date. We propose that mutations in GLIS3 lead to a wider clinical phenotype than previously recognised. We also report the first case of a recessive GLIS3 mutation causing neonatal diabetes and congenital hypothyroidism in a child from a non-consanguineous pedigree, highlighting the importance of molecular genetic testing in any patient with this phenotype.

Mutations in the ABCC8 gene encoding the SUR1 subunit of the KATP channel cause transient neonatal diabetes, permanent neonatal diabetes or permanent diabetes diagnosed outside the neonatal period

AIM

Mutations in the ABCC8 gene encoding the SUR1 subunit of the pancreatic ATP-sensitive potassium channel cause permanent neonatal diabetes mellitus (PNDM) and transient neonatal diabetes mellitus (TNDM). We reviewed the existing literature, extended the number of cases and explored genotype-phenotype correlations.

METHODS

Mutations were identified by sequencing in patients diagnosed with diabetes before 6 months without a KCNJ11 mutation.

RESULTS

We identified ABCC8 mutations in an additional nine probands (including five novel mutations L135P, R306H, R1314H, L438F and M1290V), bringing the total of reported families to 48. Both dominant and recessive mutations were observed with recessive inheritance more common in PNDM than TNDM (9 vs. 1; p < 0.01). The remainder of the PNDM probands (n = 12) had de novo mutations. Seventeen of twenty-five children with TNDM inherited their heterozygous mutation from a parent. Nine of these parents had permanent diabetes (median age at diagnosis: 27.5 years, range: 13-35 years). Recurrent mutations of residues R1183 and R1380 were found only in TNDM probands and dominant mutations causing PNDM clustered within exons 2-5.

CONCLUSIONS

ABCC8 mutations cause PNDM, TNDM or permanent diabetes diagnosed outside the neonatal period. There is some evidence that the location of the mutation is correlated with the clinical phenotype.

TRbase: a database relating tandem repeats to disease genes for the human genome

MOTIVATION

Tandem repeats are associated with disease genes, play an important role in evolution and are important in genomic organization and function. Although much research has been done on short perfect patterns of repeats, there has been less focus on imperfect repeats. Thus, there is an acute need for a tandem repeats database that provides reliable and up to date information on both perfect and imperfect tandem repeats in the human genome and relates these to disease genes.

RESULTS

This paper presents a web-accessible relational tandem repeats database that relates tandem repeats to gene locations and disease genes of the human genome. In contrast to other available databases, this database identifies both perfect and imperfect repeats of 1-2000 bp unit lengths. The utility of this database has been illustrated by analysing these repeats for their distribution and frequencies across chromosomes and genomic locations and between protein-coding and non-coding regions. The applicability of this database to identify diseases associated with previously uncharacterized tandem repeats is demonstrated.