The influence of ultrafiltration on red blood cell transfusion during cardiopulmonary bypass

Background:

Ultrafiltration during cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) reduces fluid overload and inflammatory mediators in open-heart surgery and is thought to reduce the risk of red blood cell (RBC) transfusion. We evaluated its effectiveness in reducing RBC transfusions in a large population undergoing cardiac surgery, among patients in general as well as by gender.

Methods:

We analyzed 40,650 propensity-matched adult cardiac surgery cases conducted over a 61-month period at 195 hospitals. We assessed the risk of intraoperative transfusion (⩾1 unit RBC) according to body surface area (BSA)-normalized ultrafiltration volume via mixed-effects binary logistic regression. Our statistical model controlled for 12 demographic and operative variables as well as for center level tendencies in ultrafiltration use and intraoperative RBC transfusion. In light of recent findings on gender and risk of transfusion, we also included an interaction effect between gender and ultrafiltration volume (UV).

Results:

Ultrafiltration was associated with an increased crude rate of RBC transfusion (32.1% vs. 28.1%, p<0.001), but equivalent crude median hematocrit change from first in operating room to nadir on bypass (−11% in both groups, p = 0.133). After controlling for patient, operative and site-level characteristics, we found no statistically significant effect on transfusion rate by volume of ultrafiltrate removed nor did we find statistical support for any gender-specific effect of ultrafiltration.

Conclusions:

Ultrafiltration is not associated with a reduction of risk of RBC transfusion during cardiac surgery. The use of ultrafiltration as a method for reducing intraoperative RBC transfusion warrants further study.

The effect of ultrafiltration on end-cardiopulmonary bypass hematocrit during cardiac surgery

OBJECTIVE

Ultrafiltration (UF) during cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) is a well-accepted method for hemoconcentration to reduce excess fluid and increase hematocrit, platelet count and plasma constituents. The efficacy of this technique may confer specific benefit to certain patients presenting with acquired cardiac defects. The purpose of this study was to retrospectively evaluate the effect of UF on end-CPB hematocrit by cardiac surgical procedure type.

METHODS

A review of 73,506 cardiac procedures from a national registry (SCOPE) was conducted between April 2012 and October 2016 at 197 institutions. Cases included in this analysis were those completed without intraoperative red blood cell transfusion and where zero-balance UF was not used. The primary end point was the last hematocrit reading taken before the end of CPB, with a secondary end point of urine output during CPB. In order to isolate the effect of the UF volume removed, we controlled for a number of confounding factors, including: first hematocrit on CPB, total asanguineous volume, estimated circulating blood volume, CPB urine output, total volume of crystalloid cardioplegia, total volume of other asanguineous fluids administered by both perfusion and anesthesia, type of cardiac procedure, acuity, gender, age and total time on CPB. Descriptive statistics were calculated among five subgroups according to the UF volume removed: no volume removed and quartiles across the range of UF volume removed. The effect of UF volume on primary and secondary end points was modeled using ordinary least squares and restricted cubic splines in order to assess possible non-linearity in the effect of the UF volume while controlling for the above-named confounding factors. An interaction term was included in each model to account for possible differences by procedure type.

RESULTS

The study found a statistically significant non-linear pattern in the relationship between the UF volume removed and the last hematocrit on bypass (X² = 172.5, df=24, p<0.001). For most procedure types, UF was most effective at increasing the last hematocrit on CPB, from 1 mL to approximately 2.5 L, with continued improvements in hematocrit coming more slowly as the UF volume was increased above 2.5 L. There were statistically significant interactions between UF and procedure type (X² = 78.5, df=24, p<0.0001) as well as UF and starting hematocrit on CPB (X² = 234.0, df=4, p<0.0001). In a secondary end-point model, there was a statistically significant relationship between the ultrafiltration volume removed and urine output on bypass (X² = 598.9, df=28, p<0.001).

CONCLUSION

The use of UF during CPB resulted in significant increases in end-hematocrit, with the greatest benefit shown when volumes were under 2.5 L. We saw a positive linear benefit up to 2.5 L removed and, thereafter, in most procedures, the benefit leveled off. However, of note is markedly decreased urine output on bypass as the ultrafiltration volumes increase.

Soluble fibrin monomer complex and cardiopulmonary bypass

Soluble fibrin monomer complexes (SFMCs) are precursors of fibrin polymer formation. Laboratory tests can be used to detect SFMCs in plasma. The purpose of this study was to determine whether a positive SFMC test is associated with pre-operative, intra-operative, and post-operative variables for patients that have undergone cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB). Pre-operative, operative, post-operative, and laboratory data from 120 consecutive adults patients (July 3, 2006 to June 29, 2007) that had undergone cardiac surgery with the use of CPB were obtained from a prospective quality control database. Two groups were created. Group 1 was all negative (NEG). This group had no SFMC test with a positive result (n=60) and no positive SFMCs (POS, n=60). Group 2 was any positive (POS). This group had at least one positive SFMC test (n=60). The POS group had more patients with endocarditis (11.7% vs. 3.3%, p < .001), chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) (18% vs. 8.3%, p = .005), longer CPB time (172 +/- 64 vs. 151 +/- 53 minutes, p = .047), and fewer minimally invasive procedures (31.7% vs. 51.7%, p = .002). The POS group required intraoperative (70.0% vs. 53.3%, p = .010) and post-operative (75.5% vs. 45.0%, p < .001) transfusions more frequently than the NEG group, despite similar amounts of blood loss. SFMC tests in CPB may be associated with patient pre-operative status and an increase in transfusion requirements.

Use of a multi-modality life support system

The purpose of this study was to describe the design and utilization of a multi-modality life support system (MMLSS), which is used to provide extracorporeal support for cases such as left heart bypass (LHB), extracorporeal life support (ECLS), veno-venous bypass, and hypothermic resuscitation. The design of the MMLSS consisted of a mobile cart outfitted with a centrifugal pump, heater cooler, an in-line blood gas monitor, oxygen blender/flow meter, and assorted safety devices (pressure sensors and level and bubble detectors). A single disposable circuit was used for all procedures and designed to be easily modifiable to support a variety of clinical scenarios, with and without the use of an oxygenator. The system was designed for rapid deployment throughout the hospital. From January 1, 2006 to December 31, 2007, the MMLSS has been used in three LHB procedures (63 +/- 72 minutes), four adult ECLS cases (57.2 +/- 56.9 hours), four veno-venous bypasses (72 +/- 35 minutes), and one hypothermic resuscitation (182 minutes). The MMLSS was designed to be used in patients > 20 kg and could achieve flows in the range of 1-5.5 L. There were no complications associated with the device. The MMLSS is a versatile system that can be used throughout the hospital with a single disposable circuit, accommodating a diverse caseload in a safe and reproducible manner.

Characteristics of uncontrolled hemorrhage in cardiac surgery

Patients with uncontrolled hemorrhage require massive transfusion therapy and consume a large fraction of blood bank resources. Institutional guidelines have been established for treatment, but early identification and prevention in susceptible patients remains challenging. Uncontrolled hemorrhage was defined as meeting institutional guidelines for recombinant FVIIa administration. Patients who received rFVIIa were compared with patients who did not require the therapy but who were operated on during the same time period. After institutional review board approval, demographic, operative, and transfusion data were analyzed from a prospective database. Patients receiving rFVIIa were more likely to undergo multiple procedures (2.6 +/- 0.8 vs. 1.8 +/- 0.8; p < .001); aortic surgery (59% vs. 11%; p < .005); have a higher Cleveland Clinic Clinical Severity score (7.8 +/- 2.7 vs. 5.5 +/- 4.0; p < .005); require longer bypass (265 +/- 92 min vs. 159 +/- 63 min; p < .001), cross-clamp (182 +/- 68 min vs. 112 +/- 56 min; p < .001), and circulatory arrest (15 +/- 24 min vs. 2 +/- 7 min; p < .05) times; and require more autotransfusion (2580 +/- 1847 mL vs. 690 +/- 380 mL; p < .05). Uncontrolled hemorrhage is associated with more complex surgery requiring longer bypass times and more autotransfusion.

Factors that influence the ability to perform autologous priming

The purpose of this study was to determine which factors impact the ability to perform autologous priming (AP) of the extracorporeal circuit. Second, the effects of differential AP on transfusion and volume requirements were evaluated. After institutional review board approval, demographic, operative, volumetric, and transfusion data were prospectively collected on 100 adult patients undergoing cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB). Two analyses were conducted: AP Taken and percent AP Given. For each analysis, three groups were created based on standard distribution. Group A included patients within less than mean--1 SD (< or = 500 mL AP Taken or > or = 90% AP Given back), group B included patients within mean +/- 1 SD (501-1299 mL AP Taken or 11%-89% AP Given back), and group C included patients greater than mean + 1 SD (> or = 1300 mL AP Taken or < or = 10% AP given back). Weight, pre-CPB hematocrit, clinical severity, and pre-CPB volume balance did not differ between the groups. Significant differences existed in AP Taken and percent AP Given between individual perfusionists. More AP was given back with higher urine output (group A: 846 +/- 700 mL, group B: 613 +/- 414 mL, group C: 384 +/- 272 mL; p = .004), more autotransfusion [group A: 0 (0,1300 mL), group B: 0 (0,500 mL), group C: 0 (0,250 mL); p = .008], and less AP Taken [group A: 800 (0,1300 mL), group B: 1000 (200,1600 mL), group C: 1000 (800,1600 mL); p = .001]. When more AP was taken, CPB hematocrit was higher (group A: 22.3% +/- 4.8%, group B: 25.6% +/- 4.7%, group C: 26.6% +/- 4.3%; p = .032), and fewer patients received red blood cells (group A: 64.3%, group B: 28.3%, group C:14.3%; p = .017). Some perfusionists were able to remove more AP before CPB. When more AP was taken, CPB hematocrit was higher, fewer patients received a transfusion, and less AP was given back. More AP was also given back with higher urine output and higher blood loss to the autotransfusion device.

A novel calculation to estimate blood volume and hematocrit during bypass

Patient blood volume impacts most facets of perfusion care, including volume management, transfusion practices, and pharmacologic interventions. Unfortunately, there is a wide variability in individual blood volumes, and experimental measurement is not practical in the clinical environment. The purpose of this study was to evaluate a mathematical algorithm for estimating individual blood volume. After institutional review board approval, volumetric and transfusion data were prospectively collected for 165 patients and applied to a series of calculations. The resultant blood volume estimate (BVE) was used to predict the first and last bypass hematocrit. The estimated hematocrits using both BVE and 65 mL/kg were compared with measured hematocrits using the Pearson moment correlation coefficient and the Bland Altman measures of accuracy and precision. There was a wide range of BVE (minimum, 35 mL/kg; mean +/- SD, 64 +/- 22 mL/kg; maximum, 129 mL/kg). Using BVE, the estimated hematocrit was similar to the measured first (24.7 +/- 6.4% vs. 24.5 +/- 6.2%, r = 0.9884, p > .05) and last (24.5 +/- 5.9% vs. 25.1 + 5.7%, r = 0.9001, p > .05) bypass hematocrit. Using 65 mL/kg resulted in a larger difference between estimated and measured hematocrits for the first (25.6 +/- 4.5% vs. 24.5 +/- 6.2%, r = 0.6885, p = .030) and last (23.8 +/- 3.6% vs. 25.1 +/-5.7%, r = 0.5990, p = .001) bypass hematocrits. Compared with using 65 mL/kg for blood volume, the BVE allowed for a more precise estimated hematocrit during CPB.

Chimeric pig hearts resist hyperacute rejection in ex vivo perfusion model

With surrogate tolerogenesis. the recipient immune system is engrafted within the donor pig before organ transplant. Chimeric pig hearts may resist hyperacute rejection by inducing accommodation. This hypothesis was tested using an ex vivo isolated piglet heart perfusion model. Processed sheep marrow was infused into fetal pigs at 45 days gestation. Heart explants from chimeric or nonchimeric pigs were suspended in a Langendorff apparatus and perfused with plasma from unsensitized sheep or sensitized sheep. Nonchimeric hearts perfused with plasma from unsensitized functioned for 240 min (N = 3). Nonchimeric hearts perfused with sensitized plasma deteriorated rapidly, functioning at 19+/-12 min (N = 6); Immunohistochemistry of heart graft revealed extensive deposition of IgG, IgM in the microvascular. In contrast, chimeric hearts perfused with sensitized plasma functioned for 183+/-46 min (N = 3)(p <.001); Deposition of IgG, IgM had substantially less. Heart grafts procured from chimeric pigs survived in the presence of antidonor IgG, IgM, and complement, demonstrating that chimeric pig hearts resist hyperacute rejection.

A retrospective study on perfusion incidents and safety devices

Despite the acceptance of extracorporeal circulation as an effective modality to facilitate cardiac surgery, patient outcomes can be negatively influenced by the occurrence of perfusion incidents. A perfusion survey was conducted to identify safety techniques and incidents related to cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB). An 80-question survey was mailed to chief perfusionists of all 1030 USA cardiac surgical centers using CPB. The survey was designed to examine practices and incidents that occurred during a 2-year period (July 1996 to July 1998). Five-hundred-and-fifty-two (54% response rate) surveys were returned, which accounted for 797 hospitals (79% of all cardiac centers) and 653,621 surgical procedures. Of the 27 identified CPB safety devices, the highest utilization was arterial line filters (98.5%) and the lowest arterial line bubble traps (3.4%). Of the reported cases, a CPB incident occurred once every 138 cases. The most common occurring incidents were protamine reactions (1:783), coagulation problems (1:771), and heater/cooler failures 11:1809). The rate of occurrence of an incident resulting in a serious injury or death was one for every 1453 procedures. Although techniques and safety devices create a relatively secure environment for CPB, lower incident rates may be achieved with further improvements in coagulation monitoring and incident reporting.

Hemostatic assessment of patients undergoing intraaortic balloon pump therapy

Patients undergoing intraaortic balloon pump (IABP) therapy are at risk for developing coagulopathies due to the adverse effects of prolonged exposure of the synthetic surface of the polyurethane balloon to blood components. Hemorrhagic risk has been attributed to a number of factors including thrombocytopenia, vascular injury, and/or platelet degranulation which increase the potential of receiving autogeneic blood transfusions. The present study is a prospective evaluation of coagulation using a viscoelastic monitor (Thrombelastograph--TEG) that measures functional aspects of clot development and stabilization in patients being treated with IABP therapy. Following Institutional Review Board approval, six patients undergoing IABP therapy for hemodynamic instability were enrolled in this study. Blood samples were taken prior to balloon insertion, at 8, 16, 24, 48, 72, and 96 hours on IABP therapy, and 24 hours following the removal of the balloon when applicable. Samples were incubated with heparinase to degrade heparin and TEG profiles were subsequently determined in duplicate. Measured parameters on the TEG included R-time, K-time, maximum amplitude, alpha angle, and lysis at 30 and 60 minutes with calculation of the TEG index. Mortality was 33% following IABP discontinuation. Transfusion of packed red blood cells occurred in 50% of the patients during their balloon pump therapy. Patients demonstrated a significant deviance in fibrinolytic potential from pre-IABP lysis (1.6% +/- 1.8) at both 24 hours (18.8% +/- 22.9) and 48 hours (21.9% +/- 28.5) of therapy (p < 0.05) which returned to baseline shortly after balloon removal. Activation of coagulation factors appeared evident by a steadily increasing alpha angle from pre-IABP data (3.1 +/- 9.2) throughout the duration of therapy and 24 hour recovery (53 +/- 14; p < .005), and by a steadily trending increase in the TEG index pre-IABP (.251 +/- 1.4) to post-IABP (2.6 +/- 1.7; p < 0.05). The results indicate that IABP therapy induces an increase in fibrinolytic potential at 24 to 48 hours of balloon pump therapy with a paradoxical trend toward increased coagulability, potentially predisposing the patient to hemorrhagic risk.