Structural Impact of Phosphorylation and Dielectric Constant Variation on Synaptotagmin's IDR

We used time-resolved Förster resonance energy transfer, circular dichroism, and molecular dynamics simulation to investigate the structural dependence of synaptotagmin 1's intrinsically disordered region (IDR) on phosphorylation and dielectric constant. We found that a peptide corresponding to the full-length IDR sequence, a ∼60-residue strong polyampholyte, can sample structurally collapsed states in aqueous solution, consistent with its κ-predicted behavior, where κ is a sequence-dependent parameter that is used to predict IDR compaction. In implicit solvent simulations of this same sequence, lowering the dielectric constant to more closely mimic the environment near a lipid bilayer surface promoted further sampling of collapsed structures. We then examined the structural tendencies of central region residues of the IDR in isolation. We found that the exocytosis-modulating phosphorylation of Thr¹¹² disrupts a local disorder-to-order transition induced by trifluoroethanol/water mixtures that decrease the solution dielectric constant and stabilize helical structure. Implicit solvent simulations on these same central region residues testing the impact of dielectric constant alone converge on a similar result, showing that helical structure is formed with higher probability at a reduced dielectric. In these helical conformers, lysine-aspartic acid salt bridges contribute to stabilization of transient secondary structure. In contrast, phosphorylation results in formation of salt bridges unsuitable for helix formation. Collectively, these results suggest a model in which phosphorylation and compaction of the IDR sequence regulate structural transitions that in turn modulate neuronal exocytosis.

Dynamics of Dystrophin's Actin-Binding Domain

We have used pulsed electron paramagnetic resonance, calorimetry, and molecular dynamics simulations to examine the structural mechanism of binding for dystrophin's N-terminal actin-binding domain (ABD1) and compare it to utrophin's ABD1. Like other members of the spectrin superfamily, dystrophin's ABD1 consists of two calponin-homology (CH) domains, CH1 and CH2. Several mutations within dystrophin's ABD1 are associated with the development of severe degenerative muscle disorders Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophies, highlighting the importance of understanding its structural biology. To investigate structural changes within dystrophin ABD1 upon binding to actin, we labeled the protein with spin probes and measured changes in inter-CH domain distance using double-electron electron resonance. Previous studies on the homologous protein utrophin showed that actin binding induces a complete structural opening of the CH domains, resulting in a highly ordered ABD1-actin complex. In this study, double-electron electron resonance shows that dystrophin ABD1 also undergoes a conformational opening upon binding F-actin, but this change is less complete and significantly more structurally disordered than observed for utrophin. Using molecular dynamics simulations, we identified a hinge in the linker region between the two CH domains that grants conformational flexibility to ABD1. The conformational dynamics of both dystrophin's and utrophin's ABD1 showed that compact conformations driven by hydrophobic interactions are preferred and that extended conformations are energetically accessible through a flat free-energy surface. Considering that the binding free energy of ABD1 to actin is on the order of 6-7 kcal/mole, our data are compatible with a mechanism in which binding to actin is largely dictated by specific interactions with CH1, but fine tuning of the binding affinity is achieved by the overlap between conformational ensembles of ABD1 free and bound to actin.

Enhanced synaptotagmin plasticity derived from pairing intrinsic disorder with synaptic vesicle lipids

Synaptotagmin 1 (Syt 1) is an integral membrane protein responsible for sensing the calcium ion (Ca²⁺) influx in neurons that triggers synaptic vesicle exocytosis. How Syt 1's intrinsically disordered region (IDR), a ∼60 residue sequence located between the protein's transmembrane helix and two Ca²⁺-sensing C2 domains, contributes to protein function is not well understood. The same is true of analogous IDRs located in the other synaptotagmin isoforms. Recently, we found that the Syt 1 IDR is structurally responsive to vesicles whose lipid composition mimics that of a synaptic vesicle organelle and that this sensitivity allosterically influences binding and folding behavior of the adjacent C2 domain. We believe these observations may be applicable to the study of other synaptotagmin isoforms and discuss generally how an IDR-membrane interaction could contribute to modulation of C2 domain function.

Synaptotagmin I's Intrinsically Disordered Region Interacts with Synaptic Vesicle Lipids and Exerts Allosteric Control over C2A

Synaptotagmin I (Syt I) is a vesicle-localized integral membrane protein that senses the calcium ion (Ca(2+)) influx to trigger fast synchronous release of neurotransmitter. How the cytosolic domains of Syt I allosterically communicate to propagate the Ca(2+) binding signal throughout the protein is not well understood. In particular, it is unclear whether the intrinsically disordered region (IDR) between Syt I's transmembrane helix and first C2 domain (C2A) plays an important role in allosteric modulation of Ca(2+) binding. Moreover, the structural propensity of this IDR with respect to membrane lipid composition is unknown. Using differential scanning and isothermal titration calorimetry, we found that inclusion of the IDR does indeed allosterically modulate Ca(2+) binding within the first C2 domain. Additionally through application of nuclear magnetic resonance, we found that Syt I's IDR interacts with membranes whose lipid composition mimics that of a synaptic vesicle. These findings not only indicate that Syt I's IDR plays a role in regulating Syt I's Ca(2+) sensing but also indicate the IDR is exquisitely sensitive to the underlying membrane lipids. The latter observation suggests the IDR is a key route for communication of lipid organization to the adjacent C2 domains.

Randomly organized lipids and marginally stable proteins: a coupling of weak interactions to optimize membrane signaling

Eukaryotic lipids in a bilayer are dominated by weak cooperative interactions. These interactions impart highly dynamic and pliable properties to the membrane. C2 domain-containing proteins in the membrane also interact weakly and cooperatively giving rise to a high degree of conformational plasticity. We propose that this feature of weak energetics and plasticity shared by lipids and C2 domain-containing proteins enhance a cell's ability to transduce information across the membrane. We explored this hypothesis using information theory to assess the information storage capacity of model and mast cell membranes, as well as differential scanning calorimetry, carboxyfluorescein release assays, and tryptophan fluorescence to assess protein and membrane stability. The distribution of lipids in mast cell membranes encoded 5.6-5.8bits of information. More information resided in the acyl chains than the head groups and in the inner leaflet of the plasma membrane than the outer leaflet. When the lipid composition and information content of model membranes were varied, the associated C2 domains underwent large changes in stability and denaturation profile. The C2 domain-containing proteins are therefore acutely sensitive to the composition and information content of their associated lipids. Together, these findings suggest that the maximum flow of signaling information through the membrane and into the cell is optimized by the cooperation of near-random distributions of membrane lipids and proteins. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Interfacially Active Peptides and Proteins. Guest Editors: William C. Wimley and Kalina Hristova.

Membrane modulates affinity for calcium ion to create an apparent cooperative binding response by annexin a5

Isothermal titration calorimetry was used to characterize the binding of calcium ion (Ca²⁺) and phospholipid to the peripheral membrane-binding protein annexin a5. The phospholipid was a binary mixture of a neutral and an acidic phospholipid, specifically phosphatidylcholine and phosphatidylserine in the form of large unilamellar vesicles. To stringently define the mode of binding, a global fit of data collected in the presence and absence of membrane concentrations exceeding protein saturation was performed. A partition function defined the contribution of all heat-evolving or heat-absorbing binding states. We find that annexin a5 binds Ca²⁺ in solution according to a simple independent-site model (solution-state affinity). In the presence of phosphatidylserine-containing liposomes, binding of Ca²⁺ differentiates into two classes of sites, both of which have higher affinity compared with the solution-state affinity. As in the solution-state scenario, the sites within each class were described with an independent-site model. Transitioning from a solution state with lower Ca²⁺ affinity to a membrane-associated, higher Ca²⁺ affinity state, results in cooperative binding. We discuss how weak membrane association of annexin a5 prior to Ca²⁺ influx is the basis for the cooperative response of annexin a5 toward Ca²⁺, and the role of membrane organization in this response.

Alternate splicing of dysferlin C2A confers Ca²⁺-dependent and Ca²⁺-independent binding for membrane repair

Dysferlin plays a critical role in the Ca²⁺-dependent repair of microlesions that occur in the muscle sarcolemma. Of the seven C2 domains in dysferlin, only C2A is reported to bind both Ca²⁺ and phospholipid, thus acting as a key sensor in membrane repair. Dysferlin C2A exists as two isoforms, the "canonical" C2A and C2A variant 1 (C2Av1). Interestingly, these isoforms have markedly different responses to Ca²⁺ and phospholipid. Structural and thermodynamic analyses are consistent with the canonical C2A domain as a Ca²⁺-dependent, phospholipid-binding domain, whereas C2Av1 would likely be Ca²⁺-independent under physiological conditions. Additionally, both isoforms display remarkably low free energies of stability, indicative of a highly flexible structure. The inverted ligand preference and flexibility for both C2A isoforms suggest the capability for both constitutive and Ca²⁺-regulated effector interactions, an activity that would be essential in its role as a mediator of membrane repair.

Allostery and instability in the functional plasticity of synaptotagmin I

Synaptotagmin I (Syt I) is the calcium ion sensor for regulated release of neurotransmitter. How Syt I mediates this cellular event has been a question of extensive study for decades and yet, a clear understanding of the protein’s diverse functionality has remained elusive. Using tools of thermodynamics, we have identified two intrinsic properties that may account for Syt I’s functional plasticity: marginal stability and negative coupling. These two intrinsic properties have the potential to provide great conformational flexibility and suggest that Syt I’s functional plasticity stems in part from subtle rearrangements in the protein’s conformational ensemble. This model for Syt I function is discussed within the context of the nervous system’s overall plasticity.

Mechanism for calcium ion sensing by the C2A domain of synaptotagmin I

The C2A domain is one of two calcium ion (Ca(2+))- and membrane-binding domains within synaptotagmin I (Syt I), the identified Ca(2+) sensor for regulated exocytosis of neurotransmitter. We propose that the mechanistic basis for C2A's response to Ca(2+) and cellular function stems from marginal stability and ligand-induced redistributions of protein conformers. To test this hypothesis, we used a combination of calorimetric and fluorescence techniques. We measured free energies of stability by globally fitting differential scanning calorimetry and fluorescence lifetime spectroscopy denaturation data, and found that C2A is weakly stable. Additionally, using partition functions in a fluorescence resonance energy transfer approach, we found that the Ca(2+)- and membrane-binding sites of C2A exhibit weak cooperative linkage. Lastly, a dye-release assay revealed that the Ca(2+)- and membrane-bound conformer subset of C2A promote membrane disruption. We discuss how these phenomena may lead to both cooperative and functional responses of Syt I.

Monte Carlo simulation of protein-induced lipid demixing in a membrane with interactions derived from experiment

Lipid domain formation induced by annexin was investigated in mixtures of phosphatidylcholine (PC), phosphatidylserine (PS), and cholesterol (Chol), which were selected to mimic the inner leaflet of a eukaryotic plasma membrane. Annexins are ubiquitous and abundant cytoplasmic, peripheral proteins, which bind to membranes containing PS in the presence of calcium ions (Ca(2+)), but whose function is unknown. Prompted by indications of interplay between the presence of cholesterol in PS/PC mixtures and the binding of annexins, we used Monte Carlo simulations to investigate protein and lipid domain formation in these mixtures. The set of interaction parameters between lipids and proteins was assigned by matching experimental observables to corresponding variables in the calculations. In the case of monounsaturated phospholipids, the PS-PC and PC-Chol interactions are weakly repulsive. The interaction between protein and PS was determined based on experiments of annexin binding to PC/PS mixtures in the presence of Ca(2+). Based on the proposal that PS and cholesterol form a complex in model membranes, a favorable PS-Chol interaction was postulated. Finally, protein-protein favorable interactions were also included, which are consistent with observations of large, two-dimensional, regular arrays of annexins on membranes. Those net interactions between pairs of lipids, proteins and lipids, and between proteins are all small, of the order of the average kinetic energy. We found that annexin a5 can induce formation of large PS domains, coincident with protein domains, but only if cholesterol is present.

Protein-lipid interactions role of membrane plasticity and lipid specificity on peripheral protein interactions

Lipid mixtures are inherently nonrandom as each lipid species differs slightly in its chemical structure. A protein associates not with a lipid but with a membrane comprised of lipids where the chemical activities of each lipid is determined by the composition of the mixture. There can be selectivity in this association because a protein can enhance the underlying tendency of lipids to be heterogeneously distributed. This is dependent on the protein having a preferential association of sufficient magnitude with some of the lipids within the membrane. To measure and model protein-lipid interactions, an understanding of the underlying lipid behavior is necessary to interpret their association constants. Methods to measure protein-lipid interactions are discussed within the context of using these techniques in modeling and a general framework is presented for the use of a signal arising from these interactions. The use of binding partition functions is presented as this allows the modeling of cooperative or independent (noncooperative) interactions of protein with lipids and of proteins with additional ligands as well as lipids. A model is also provided using the binding partition function formalism where protein dimerization, and by extension, oligomerization is enhanced at the membrane compared to in solution.

Peripheral protein organization and its influence on lipid diffusion in biomimetic membranes

Protein organization on biomembranes and their dynamics are essential for cellular function. It is not clear, however, how protein binding may influence the assembly of underlying lipids or how the membrane structure leads to functional protein organization. Toward this goal, we investigated the effects of annexin a5 binding to biomimetic membranes using fluorescence imaging and correlation spectroscopy. Annexin a5 (anx a5), a peripheral intracellular protein that plays a membrane remodeling role in addition to other functions, binds specifically and tightly to anionic (e.g., phosphatidylserine)-containing membranes in the presence of calcium ion. Our fluorescence microscopy reveals that annexin likely forms assemblies, along with a more dispersed population, upon binding to anionic biomembranes in the presence of calcium ion, which is reflected in its two-component Brownian motion. To investigate the effects of annexin binding on the underlying lipids, we used specific acyl chain labeled phospholipid analogues, NBD-phosphatidylcholine (NBD-PC) and NBD-phosphatidylserine (NBD-PS). We find that both NBD-labeled lipids cluster under anx a5 assemblies, as compared with when they are found under the dispersed annexin population, and NBD-PS exhibits two-component lateral diffusion under the annexin assemblies. In contrast, NBD-PC diffusion is slower by an order of magnitude under the annexin assemblies in contrast to its diffusion when not localized under anx a5 assemblies. Our results indicate that, upon binding to membranes, the peripheral protein annexin organizes the underlying lipids into domains, which may have functional implications in vivo.

Stability of protein-decorated mixed lipid membranes: The interplay of lipid-lipid, lipid-protein, and protein-protein interactions

Membrane-associated proteins are likely to contribute to the regulation of the phase behavior of mixed lipid membranes. To gain insight into the underlying mechanism, we study a thermodynamic model for the stability of a protein-decorated binary lipid layer. Here, proteins interact preferentially with one lipid species and thus locally sequester that species. We aim to specify conditions that lead to an additional macroscopic phase separation of the protein-decorated lipid membrane. Our model is based on a standard mean-field lattice-gas description for both the lipid mixture and the adsorbed protein layer. Besides accounting for the lipid-protein binding strength, we also include attractive lipid-lipid and protein-protein interactions. Our analysis characterizes the decrease in the membrane's critical interaction parameter as a function of the lipid-protein binding strength. For small and large binding strengths we provide analytical expressions; numerical results cover the intermediate range. Our results reiterate the crucial importance of the line tension associated with protein-induced compositional gradients and the presence of attractive lipid-lipid interactions within the membrane. Direct protein-protein attraction effectively increases the line tension and thus tends to further destabilize the membrane.

The cooperative response of synaptotagmin I C2A. A hypothesis for a Ca2+-driven molecular hammer

In the current understanding of exocytosis at the nerve terminal, the C2 domain of synaptotagmin (C2A) is presumed to bind Ca2+ and the membrane in a stepwise fashion: cation then membrane as cation increases the affinity of protein for membrane. Fluorescence spectroscopy data were gathered over a variety of lipid and Ca2+ concentrations, enabling the rigorous application of microscopic binding models derived from partition functions to differentiate between Ca2+ and phosphatidylserine contributions to binding. The data presented here are in variance with previously published models, which were based on the Hill approximation. Rather, the data are consistent with two forms of cooperativity that modulate the responsiveness of C2A: in Ca2+ binding to a network of three cation sites and in interaction with the membrane surface. We suggest synaptotagmin I C2A is preassociated with the synaptic vesicle membrane or nerve terminal. In this state, upon Ca2+ influx the protein will bind the three Ca2+ ions immediately and with high cooperativity. Thus, membrane association creates a high-affinity Ca2+ switch that is the basis for the role of synaptotagmin I in Ca2+-regulated exocytosis. Based on this model, we discuss the implications of protein-induced phosphatidylserine demixing to the exocytotic process.

Drug-membrane interactions studied in phospholipid monolayers adsorbed on nonporous alkylated microspheres

Characterization of interactions with phospholipids is an integral part of the in vitro profiling of drug candidates because of the roles the interactions play in tissue accumulation and passive diffusion. Currently used test systems may inadequately emulate the bilayer core solvation properties (immobilized artificial membranes [IAM]), suffer from potentially slow transport of some chemicals (liposomes in free or immobilized forms), and require a tedious separation (if used for free liposomes). Here the authors introduce a well-defined system overcoming these drawbacks: nonporous octadecylsilica particles coated with a self-assembled phospholipid monolayer. The coating mimics the structure of the headgroup region, as well as the thickness and properties of the hydrocarbon core, more closely than IAM. The monolayer has a similar transition temperature pattern as the corresponding bilayer. The particles can be separated by filtration or a mild centrifugation. The partitioning equilibria of 81 tested chemicals were dissected into the headgroup and core contributions, the latter using the alkane/water partition coefficients. The deconvolution allowed a successful prediction of the bilayer/water partition coefficients with the standard deviation of 0.26 log units. The plate-friendly assay is suitable for high-throughput profiling of drug candidates without sacrificing the quality of analysis or details of the drug-phospholipid interactions.

Purification of recombinant annexins without the use of phospholipids

Due to their involvement in a variety of physiological and pathological processes, different isoforms of annexins are being utilized as markers of some human diseases and bio-imaging of tissue injury (due to apoptosis), and have been proposed as drug delivery vehicles. These, in addition to extensive biophysical studies on the role of annexins in organizing lipid domains in biological membranes, have necessitated development of an efficient protocol for producing annexins in bulk quantities. In this paper, we report a one-step purification protocol for annexin a5 without using lipid vesicles or involving any column chromatographic step. Depending on the growth and expression condition, a fraction of recombinant annexin a5 (cloned in pET3d vector) was sequestered into inclusion bodies. When these inclusion bodies were dissolved in 6 M urea, subjected to a 10-fold snap dilution in the presence of 5 mM Ca(2+) and stored overnight at 4 degrees C, annexin a5 was precipitated as a homogenous protein as judged by SDS-PAGE. This one-step purification protocol produced about 35 mg of highly purified annexin a5 per liter of bacterial culture. The annexin a5 purified from inclusion bodies exhibited similar properties to that obtained from the soluble fraction using the conventional lipid-partitioning approach. Our purification protocol for annexin a5 elaborated herein is equally effective for purification of annexin A2, and we believe, will serve as general protocol for purifying other annexins in bulk quantities for diagnostic as well as detailed biophysical studies.

Position of synaptotagmin I at the membrane interface: cooperative interactions of tandem C2 domains

Synaptotagmin I is a synaptic vesicle associated membrane protein that appears to regulate Ca(2+)-mediated exocytosis. Here, the Ca(2+)-dependent membrane interactions of a water soluble fragment of synaptotagmin I (C2AB) that contains its two C2 domains (C2A and C2B) were determined using site-directed spin labeling. Membrane depth parameters were obtained for 19 spin-labeled mutants of C2AB when bound to phosphatidylcholine and phosphatidylserine membranes, and these distance constraints were used in combination with the high-resolution structures of C2A and C2B to generate a model for the membrane orientation and position of synaptotagmin at the bilayer interface. Both C2A and C2B bind to the membrane interface with their first and third Ca(2+) binding loops penetrating the membrane interface. The polybasic face of C2B does not interact with the membrane lipid but is available for electrostatic interaction with other components of the fusion machinery. When compared to positions determined previously for the isolated domains, both C2A and C2B have similar orientations; however, the two domains are positioned deeper into the bilayer interior when present in the tandem construct. These data indicate that C2A and C2B do not act independently but influence their mutual membrane penetration. This may explain the occurrence of multiple C2 domains in proteins that function in membrane trafficking and repair.

Cooperative adsorption of proteins onto lipid membranes

The adsorption of proteins onto a lipid membrane depends on and thus reflects the energetics of the underlying substrate. This is particularly relevant for mixed membranes that contain lipid species with different affinities for the adsorbed proteins. In this case, there is an intricate interplay between lateral membrane organization and the number of adsorbed proteins. Most importantly, proteins often tend to enhance the propensity of the lipid mixture to form clusters, domains, or to macroscopically phase separate. Sigmoidal binding isotherms are the typical signature of the corresponding cooperativity in protein adsorption. We discuss the underlying thermodynamic basis, and compare various theoretical binding models for protein adsorption onto mixed membranes. We also present experimental data for the adsorption of the C2A protein motif and analyse to what extent these data reflect cooperative binding.

Temperature and composition dependence of the interaction of delta-lysin with ternary mixtures of sphingomyelin/cholesterol/POPC

The kinetics of carboxyfluorescein efflux induced by the amphipathic peptide delta-lysin from vesicles of porcine brain sphingomyelin (BSM), 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-phosphatidylcholine (POPC), and cholesterol (Chol) were investigated as a function of temperature and composition. Sphingomyelin (SM)/Chol mixtures form a liquid-ordered (L(o)) phase whereas POPC exists in the liquid-disordered (L(d)) phase at ambient temperature. delta-Lysin binds strongly to L(d) and poorly to L(o) phase. In BSM/Chol/POPC vesicles the rate of carboxyfluorescein efflux induced by delta-lysin increases as the POPC content decreases. This is explained by the increase of delta-lysin concentration in L(d) domains, which enhances membrane perturbation by the peptide. Phase separations in the micrometer scale have been observed by fluorescence microscopy in SM/Chol/POPC mixtures for some SM, though not for BSM. Thus, delta-lysin must detect heterogeneities (domains) in BSM/Chol/POPC on a much smaller scale. Advantage was taken of the inverse variation of the efflux rate with the L(d) content of BSM/Chol/POPC vesicles to estimate the L(d) fraction in those mixtures. These results were combined with differential scanning calorimetry to obtain the BSM/Chol/POPC phase diagram as a function of temperature.

Partitioning of organic compounds in phases imitating the headgroup and core regions of phospholipid bilayers

Solvation free energies of drugs, peptides, and other small molecules in the core and headgroup regions of phospholipid bilayers determine their conformations, accumulation, and transport properties. The transfer free energy includes the energy terms for the formation of a cavity for the solute, the interactions of the solute with phospholipids, electrostatic interactions of the solute with the membrane, and dipole potentials and entropy terms. The interaction energies with phospholipids can be estimated by correlating the partitioning in surrogate solvent systems and in the bilayer. As the headgroup surrogate, we use diacetylphosphatidylcholine (DAcPC), the acetylated headgroup of the most abundant mammalian phospholipid, phosphatidylcholine, which forms a homogeneous solution with acceptable viscosity when mixed with water in ratios similar to those in the fully hydrated bilayer. The two-phase system of n-hexadecane (C16) as the core surrogate and hydrated DAcPC was used to monitor partitioning of 16 nonionizable compounds. On the bilogarithmic scale, the C16/DAcPC partition coefficients correlate neither with those in the C16/water and 1-octanol/water systems nor with their difference, which is frequently used as a parameter of hydrogen bonding for prediction of the bilayer location of the solutes. The C16/DAcPC system provides a satisfactory emulation of the solvation properties of the bilayer regions, as reflected in correct predictions of the bilayer location for those of the studied chemicals, for which this information is available.

Thermodynamics of membrane domains

The concept of lipid rafts and the intense work toward their characterization in biological membranes has spurred a renewed interest in the understanding of domain formation, particularly in the case of cholesterol-containing membranes. The thermodynamic principles underlying formation of domains, rafts, or cholesterol/phospholipid complexes are reviewed here, along with recent work in model and biological membranes. A major motivation for this review was to present those concepts in a way appropriate for the broad readership that has been drawn to the field. Evidence from a number of different techniques points to the conclusion that lipid-lipid interactions are generally weak; therefore, in most cases, massive phase separations are not to be expected in membranes. On the contrary, small, dynamic lipid domains, possibly stabilized by proteins are the most likely outcome. The results on mixed lipid bilayers are used to discuss recent experiments in biological membranes. The clear indication is that proteins partition preferentially into fluid, disordered lipid domains, which is contrary to their localization in ordered, cholesterol/sphingomyelin rafts inferred from detergent extraction experiments on cell membranes. Globally, the evidence appears most consistent with a membrane model in which the majority of the lipid is in a liquid-ordered phase, with dispersed, small, liquid-disordered domains, where most proteins reside. Co-clustering of proteins and their concentration in some membrane areas may occur because of similar preferences for a particular domain but also because of simultaneous exclusion from other lipid phases. Specialized structures, such as caveolae, which contain high concentrations of cholesterol and caveolin are not necessarily similar to bulk liquid-ordered phase.

Allosterism in Membrane Binding: A Common Motif of the Annexins?

Annexins are a family of proteins generally described as Ca(2+)-dependent for phospholipid binding. Yet, annexins have a wide variety of binding behaviors and conformational states, some of which are lipid-dependent and Ca(2+)-independent. We present a model that captures the cation and phospholipid binding behavior of the highly conserved core of the annexins. Experimental data for annexins A4 and A5, which have short N-termini, were globally modeled to gain an understanding of how the lipid-binding affinity of the conserved protein core is modulated. Analysis of the binding behavior was achieved through use of the lanthanide Tb(3+) as a Ca(2+) analogue. Binding isotherms were determined experimentally from the quenching of the intrinsic fluorescence of annexins A4 and A5 by Tb(3+) in the presence or absence of membranes. In the presence of lipid, the affinity of annexin for cation increases, and the binding isotherms change from hyperbolic to weakly sigmoidal. This behavior was modeled by isotherms derived from microscopic binding partition functions. The change from hyperbolic to sigmoidal binding occurs because of an allosteric transition from the annexin solution state to its membrane-associated state. Protein binding to lipid bilayers renders cation binding by annexins cooperative. The two annexin states denote two affinities of the protein for cation, one in the absence and another in the presence of membrane. In the framework of this model, we discuss membrane binding as well as the influence of the N-terminus in modifying the annexin cation-binding affinity by changing the probability of the protein to undergo the postulated two-state transition.

Membrane-Bound Orientation and Position of the Synaptotagmin C2B Domain Determined by Site-Directed Spin Labeling

Site-directed spin labeling is used to determine the orientation and depth of insertion of the second C2 domain from synaptotagmin I (C2B) into membrane vesicles composed of phosphatidylcholine (PC) and phosphatidylserine (PS). EPR line shapes of spin-labeled mutants located with the Ca(2+)-binding loops of C2B broaden in the presence of Ca(2+) and PC/PS vesicles, indicating that these loops undergo a Ca(2+)-dependent insertion into the membrane interface. Power saturation of the EPR spectra provides a position for each spin-labeled site along the bilayer normal, and these EPR-derived distance constraints, along with a high-resolution structure of the C2B domain, are used to generate a model for the domain orientation and position at the membrane interface. Our data show that the isolated C2B domain from synaptotagmin I penetrates PC/PS membranes, and that the backbone of Ca(2+)-binding loops 1 and 3 is inserted below the level of a plane defined by the lipid phosphates. The side chains of several loop residues are within the bilayer interior, and both Ca(2+)-binding sites are positioned near a plane defined by the lipid phosphates. A Tb(3+)-based fluorescence assay is used to compare the membrane affinity of the C2B domain to that of the first synaptotagmin C2 domain (C2A). Both C2A and C2B bind PC/PS (75:25) membrane vesicles with a micromolar lipid affinity in the presence of metal ion. These results indicate that C2A and C2B have a similar membrane affinity and position when bound to PC/PS (75:25) membrane vesicles. EPR spectroscopy indicates that the C2B domain has different interactions with PC/PS membranes containing 1 mol % phosphatidylinositol 4,5-bisphosphate.

Lipid modulation of protein-induced membrane domains as a mechanism for controlling signal transduction

The reason for the enormous lipid variety present in eukaryotic membranes remains largely an enigma. We suggest that its role is to provide an on-off switch for a signaling event at the membrane level. This is achieved through lipid-lipid interactions that convert membrane protein binding and association events into very cooperative processes while maintaining reversibility. We have previously shown [Hinderliter, A., at al. (2001) Biochemistry 40, 4181-4191] that thermodynamic linkage between an intrinsic tendency for lipid demixing and a preferential interaction of a protein with a specific lipid within the mixture leads to dramatic changes in lipid and protein domain formation. Here, we tested the hypothesis that small alterations in lipid chemical structure alter the magnitude of the net interaction free energy (omega(AB)) between unlike lipids in a predictable manner, and that even very small changes in omega(AB) lead to dramatic changes in bilayer organization when coupled with protein binding. We systematically varied the chemical structure of phosphatidylcholine (PC), in mixtures with a fixed phosphatidylserine (PS), by changing the PC acyl chain length and the degree of unsaturation, and examined domain formation upon addition of a peripheral protein, the synaptotagmin I C2A motif. Experimental excimer/monomer ratios (E/M) of pyrene-substituted lipids mimicking the PS were interpreted using Monte Carlo computer simulations. E/M is larger if the PC melting temperature is lower, suggesting that domain formation is a thermodynamic consequence of weak interactions between PC and PS. Consistent with our hypothesis, only very small changes in omega(AB) were required for prediction of large changes in lipid and protein domain formation.

Membrane-bound orientation and position of the synaptotagmin I C2A domain by site-directed spin labeling

Site-directed spin labeling was used to determine the membrane orientation and insertion of the C2A domain from synaptotagmin I. A series of single cysteine mutants of the C2A domain of synaptotagmin I was prepared and labeled with a sulfhydryl specific spin label. Upon Ca2+ or membrane binding, the EPR line shapes of these mutants reveal dramatic decreases in label mobility within the Ca2+-binding loops. This loss in mobility is likely due in part to a reduction in local backbone fluctuations within the loop regions. Power saturation was then used to determine the position of each spin-labeled site along the bilayer normal, and these EPR distance constraints were used along with the high-resolution solution structure of C2A to generate a model for the orientation and position of the domain at the membrane interface. This model places the polypeptide backbone of both the first and third Ca2+-binding loops in contact with the membrane interface, with several labeled side chains lying within the bilayer interior. All three Ca2+-binding sites lie near a plane defined by the lipid phosphates. This model indicates that there is some desolvation of this domain upon binding and that hydrophobic as well as electrostatic interactions contribute to the binding of C2A. When compared to the C2 domain from cPLA2 (Frazier et al. (2002) Biochemistry 41, 6282), a similar orientation for the beta-sandwich region is found; however, the cPLA2 C2 domain is translocated 5-7 A deeper into the membrane hydrocarbon. This difference in depth is consistent with previous biophysical data and with the difference that long-range electrostatic interactions and desolvation are expected to make to the binding of these two C2 domains.