Evaluation of BRCA1 and BRCA2 mutation prevalence, risk prediction models and a multistep testing approach in French-Canadian families with high risk of breast and ovarian cancer

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

In clinical settings with fixed resources allocated to predictive genetic testing for high-risk cancer predisposition genes, optimal strategies for mutation screening programmes are critically important. These depend on the mutation spectrum found in the population under consideration and the frequency of mutations detected as a function of the personal and family history of cancer, which are both affected by the presence of founder mutations and demographic characteristics of the underlying population. The results of multistep genetic testing for mutations in BRCA1 or BRCA2 in a large series of families with breast cancer in the French-Canadian population of Quebec, Canada are reported.

METHODS

A total of 256 high-risk families were ascertained from regional familial cancer clinics throughout the province of Quebec. Initially, families were tested for a panel of specific mutations known to occur in this population. Families in which no mutation was identified were then comprehensively tested. Three algorithms to predict the presence of mutations were evaluated, including the prevalence tables provided by Myriad Genetics Laboratories, the Manchester Scoring System and a logistic regression approach based on the data from this study.

RESULTS

8 of the 15 distinct mutations found in 62 BRCA1/BRCA2-positive families had never been previously reported in this population, whereas 82% carried 1 of the 4 mutations currently observed in > or =2 families. In the subset of 191 families in which at least 1 affected individual was tested, 29% carried a mutation. Of these 27 BRCA1-positive and 29 BRCA2-positive families, 48 (86%) were found to harbour a mutation detected by the initial test. Among the remaining 143 inconclusive families, all 8 families found to have a mutation after complete sequencing had Manchester Scores > or =18. The logistic regression and Manchester Scores provided equal predictive power, and both were significantly better than the Myriad Genetics Laboratories prevalence tables (p<0.001). A threshold of Manchester Score > or =18 provided an overall sensitivity of 86% and a specificity of 82%, with a positive predictive value of 66% in this population.

CONCLUSION

In this population, a testing strategy with an initial test using a panel of reported recurrent mutations, followed by full sequencing in families with Manchester Scores > or =18, represents an efficient test in terms of overall cost and sensitivity.

No Evidence of BRCA1/2 Genomic Rearrangements in High-Risk French-Canadian Breast/Ovarian Cancer Families

The discovery of deleterious mutations in the breast and ovarian cancer susceptibility genes, BRCA1 and BRCA2, has facilitated the identification of individuals at particularly high risk of these diseases. There is a wide variation between populations in the prevalence and related risks of various types of BRCA1/2 mutations, so estimates cannot be extrapolated to Canadians, especially not founder populations such as French- Canadians. Polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-based methods were used to detect the majority of these mutations. These approaches usually failed to detect large DNA rearrangements, which have been claimed to be involved in other populations in 5% to up to 36% of BRCA1-positive families. There is very little information about the contribution of this type of mutation in BRCA2-positive families. To investigate if our available mutation spectrum of BRCA1 and BRCA2 in high-risk French-Canadian breast/ovarian cancer families has been biased by PCR-based direct sequencing methods, we first used Southern blot analysis to test DNA samples from 61 affected/obligate carrier individuals from 58 families in which no BRCA1/2 deleterious mutation was found. Finally, 154 individuals from 135 BRCA1/2 nonconclusive families, including all those tested previously by Southern blot analysis, were tested with the new multiplex ligation probe amplification (MLPA) technique. These approaches failed to detect any rearrangement. Moreover, if the frequency of MLPA-detectable rearrangements in our cohort of 135 BRCA1/2 nonconclusive families was 2.2% or higher, we would have had a 95% or greater chance of observing at least one such rearrangement. As no rearrangements were identified, such large rearrangements must be quite rare in our population.

A new alternative splice variant of BRCA1 containing an additional in-frame exon

The breast/ovarian cancer susceptibility gene BRCA1 interact with multiple protein complexes involved in cellular mechanisms, such as DNA repair, transcription, homologous recombination and cell cycle regulation. Extensive analyses over the past decade led to the detection of several BRCA1 alternative splice variants. Here, we identify the first BRCA1 alternative splice variant containing an additional in-frame exon. This previously unknown exon 13A-containing transcript is generated by the insertion of 66 nucleotides between exons 13 and 14, due to alternative splicing in intron 13 (IVS13-2786-2720). Furthermore, exon 13A-containing transcript was detectable in total RNA samples from 12 normal tissues and several breast and other cancer cell lines. As revealed by real-time PCR analysis, this transcript corresponds to 20 to 25% of the total BRCA1 mRNA expression levels in leukocytes, brain and cerebellum tissues, whereas its relative level of expression is less than 5% in other tested tissues and cancer cell lines. This novel alternative transcript adds 22 amino acids after residue 1452, thus modifying the primary structure of the trans-activation domain 1 (AD1) and the protein-protein interacting domain of BRCA1 with BRCA2, AR and MSH2. No sequence variant has been detected by direct genomic sequencing of exon 13A in individuals originating from high-risk breast/ovarian cancer families.

17alpha-hydroxylase/17,20-Lyase deficiency due to novel compound heterozygote mutations: treatment for tall stature in a female with male pseudohermaphroditism and spontaneous puberty in her affected sister

We report on two German sisters with deficiency in the 17alpha-hydroxylase/17,20-lyase enzyme corresponding to typical hormone profile. A paternal nonsense mutation R388X in exon 7 and a maternal missense mutation P428L in exon 8 of the CYP17 gene have been identified in both girls. Residual in vitro 17alpha-hydroxylase activity for the conversion of [3H]-Preg to [3H]-17OH-Preg has been detected in transfected 293-cells expressing P428L mutant enzyme; however, no 17,20-lyase activity was observed converting [3H]-17OH-Preg into [3H]-DHEA. The 46,XX-sister spontaneously entered puberty. The 46,XY-sister with a predicted adult height of 203 cm was treated with a high dose of conjugated estrogens and resulted with a final height of 186.9 cm. The present data suggest that compound heterozygous 46,XX females bearing a P428L allele may develop spontaneous onset of puberty. Furthermore, in 46,XY females with tall stature, treatment with conjugated estrogens may lead to a significant reduction of their predicted adult height.

Common BRCA2 variants and modification of breast and ovarian cancer risk in BRCA1 mutation carriers

The HH genotype of the nonconservative amino acid substitution polymorphism N372H in the BRCA2 gene was reported to be associated with a 1.3- to 1.5-fold increase in risk of both breast and ovarian cancer. As these studies concerned sporadic cancer cases, we investigated whether N372H and another common variant located in the 5'-untranslated region (203G > A) of the BRCA2 gene modify breast or ovarian cancer risk in BRCA1 mutation carriers. The study includes 778 women carrying a BRCA1 germ-line mutation belonging to 403 families. The two BRCA2 variants were analyzed by the TaqMan allelic discrimination technique. Genotypes were analyzed by disease-free survival analysis using a Cox proportional hazards model. We found no evidence of a significant modification of breast cancer penetrance in BRCA1 mutation carriers by either polymorphism. In respect of ovarian cancer risk, we also saw no effect with the N372H variant but we did observe a borderline association with the 5'-untranslated region 203A allele (hazard ratio, 1.43; CI, 1.01-2.00). In contrast to the result of Healey et al. on newborn females and adult female controls, we found no departure from Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium in the distribution of N372H alleles for our female BRCA1 carriers. We conclude that if these single-nucleotide polymorphisms do modify the risk of cancer in BRCA1 mutation carriers, their effects are not significantly larger than that of N372H previously observed in the general population.

Common BRCA2 Variants and Modification of Breast and Ovarian Cancer Risk in BRCA1 Mutation Carriers

The HH genotype of the nonconservative amino acid substitution polymorphism N372H in the BRCA2 gene was reported to be associated with a 1.3- to 1.5-fold increase in risk of both breast and ovarian cancer. As these studies concerned sporadic cancer cases, we investigated whether N372H and another common variant located in the 5′-untranslated region (203G &gt; A) of the BRCA2 gene modify breast or ovarian cancer risk in BRCA1 mutation carriers. The study includes 778 women carrying a BRCA1 germ-line mutation belonging to 403 families. The two BRCA2 variants were analyzed by the TaqMan allelic discrimination technique. Genotypes were analyzed by disease-free survival analysis using a Cox proportional hazards model. We found no evidence of a significant modification of breast cancer penetrance in BRCA1 mutation carriers by either polymorphism. In respect of ovarian cancer risk, we also saw no effect with the N372H variant but we did observe a borderline association with the 5′-untranslated region 203A allele (hazard ratio, 1.43; CI, 1.01-2.00). In contrast to the result of Healey et al. on newborn females and adult female controls, we found no departure from Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium in the distribution of N372H alleles for our female BRCA1 carriers. We conclude that if these single-nucleotide polymorphisms do modify the risk of cancer in BRCA1 mutation carriers, their effects are not significantly larger than that of N372H previously observed in the general population.

Structure of primate and rodent orthologs of the prostate cancer susceptibility gene ELAC2

The human ELAC2 gene was the first candidate prostate cancer susceptibility gene identified by linkage analysis and positional cloning. DNA sequence indicates a protein of 826 amino acids encoded by 24 exons. In the present study, we characterized the coding sequence of chimpanzee and gorilla ELAC2 orthologs by direct sequencing of genomic fragments, and of cynomolgus monkey and rat orthologs by screening cDNA libraries. The orthologs characterized in the chimpanzee, gorilla and cynomolgus monkey also encode proteins of 826 amino acids, sharing 98.9%, 98.5% and 93.7% sequence identity with the human protein. Our analyses of the mouse ELAC2 gene identified two alternative mRNA transcripts. One is translated into a protein of 824 a.a. (mouse ELAC2), whereas the other one encodes a protein of 831 amino acids (mouse ELAC2A) resulting from an alternatively spliced form of 25 exons. The rat ELAC2 gene ortholog also expressed two similar alternatively spliced transcripts. These two forms are ubiquitously expressed in mouse and rat tissues. The highest levels of expression of the ELAC2 form are observed in the testis while the lowest levels are seen in the prostate and in the muscle. However, it is of interest to note that the relative abundance of the rat and mouse ELAC2 transcripts, measured by real-time quantitative PCR, is higher than the respective ELAC2A forms in all surveyed tissues except for the prostate and the muscle. The ELAC2A transcript levels are 4.1 to 5.0-fold higher than the ELAC2 levels in the prostate of rat and mouse, respectively. A fine analysis of the conserved domains on the primary structure of ELAC2 orthologs revealed the presence of a putative beta-CASP domain shared by the PSO2 (SNM1) DNA interstrand cross-link repair proteins, and the 73-kDa subunit of mRNA 3' end cleavage and polyadenylation specificity factor (CPSF73) as well as Artemis proteins, thus suggesting a potential interaction of ELAC2 gene product with nucleic acids and more specifically with RNA targets. Taken together, these data offer useful tools to further study the regulation and cellular function of ELAC2 gene in experimental models and provide further insight concerning conserved amino acid motifs that could have biological significance.

BRCA1 wild-type allele modifies risk of ovarian cancer in carriers of BRCA1 germ-line mutations

Strong inter- and intrafamilial variation of penetrance of breast and ovarian cancer is observed in BRCA1 mutation carriers. The wild-type copy of the BRCA1 gene is a plausible candidate as a cancer risk modifier given that the residual function corresponding to the intact BRCA1 allele may influence the process of tumor formation in BRCA1 carriers. Indeed, growing evidence is now becoming available on impaired reparation of double-strand DNA breaks in cells heterozygous for BRCA1 mutations, implying an enhanced mutability of BRCA1(+/-) cells. To determine whether certain variant forms of the wild-type BRCA1 allele are implicated in variation of the BRCA1-related cancer risk, their effect was studied in a panel of 591 women with BRCA1 germ-line mutations. We found that BRCA1 carriers with the wild-type BRCA1 copy bearing a common Gly1038 variant were at increased risk of ovarian cancer (hazards ratio, 1.50; 95% confidence interval, 1.03-2.19). The results of our study imply that a quite significant proportion of the interindividual variability in ovarian cancer penetrance in BRCA1 carriers may be explained by a common BRCA1 Gly1038 wild-type allele, given its high frequency (0.27).

A new insight into the molecular basis of 3beta-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase deficiency

Classical 3beta-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase/delta5-delta4 isomerase (3beta-HSD) deficiency is a rare form of congenital adrenal hyperplasia that impairs steroidogenesis in both the adrenals and gonads resulting from mutations in the HSD3B2 gene, causing varying degrees of salt-loss in both sexes and incomplete masculinization of the external genitalia in genetic males. To date a total of 34 mutations (including 5 frameshift, 4 nonsense, 1 in-frame deletion, 1 splicing and 23 missense mutations) have been identified in the HSD3B2 gene. Results from functional charaterization studies of the mutant proteins agrees with the prediction that no functional type II 3beta-HSD isoenzyme is expressed in the adrenals and gonads of the patients with the severe salt-losing form, whereas the nonsalt-losing form causes an incomplete loss in enzymatic activity, thereby leaving sufficient enzymatic activity to prevent salt loss. Recent studies have highlighted the fact that various mutations appear to have a drastic effect upon the stability of the protein, therefore providing molecular evidence of a new mechanism involved in classical 3beta-HSD deficiency. Finally, the functional characterization of the missense mutations known to be involved in this autosomal recessive disorder provides valuable information concerning the structure-function relationships of the 3beta-HSD enzyme superfamily.

A novel A10E homozygous mutation in the HSD3B2 gene causing severe salt-wasting 3beta-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase deficiency in 46,XX and 46,XY French-Canadians: evaluation of gonadal function after puberty

Severe 3beta-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase (3betaHSD) deficiency is a rare form of congenital adrenal hyperplasia resulting from mutations in the HSD3B2 gene that impair steroidogenesis in both the adrenals and gonads and cause salt-wasting in both sexes and incomplete masculinization of the external genitalia in genetic males. About two thirds of the reported patients are 46,XY. We describe two French-Canadian patients from two families without a known relationship who presented with severe salt-wasting 3betaHSD deficiency in infancy. Although the diagnosis was considered clinically, plasma steroid profiles were confusing. We have thus directly sequenced DNA fragments generated by PCR amplification of the four exons, exon-intron boundaries, and the 5'-flanking regions of the HSD3B2 gene. Sequencing of exon II revealed the presence of a C to A transversion in both alleles of these two cases, thus converting codon 10 (GCA), which codes for Ala, into GAA, encoding Glu. This Ala is highly conserved in the vertebrate 3betaHSD gene family and is located in the putative NAD-binding domain of the enzyme. The mutant type II 3betaHSD enzyme carrying an A10E substitution exhibited no detectable activity in intact transfected Ad293 cells. Both homozygous patients share the same haplotype, spanning approximately 3.3 centimorgans surrounding the HSD3B2 locus, which is consistent with a founder effect for this missense mutation. The 46,XY patient presented with ambiguous genitalia at birth and underwent normal masculinization at puberty, but was azoospermic at 18.5 yr of age. The 46,XX patient presented progressive breast development, menarche, and evidence of progesterone secretion. The only previously reported cases with pubertal follow-up revealed paternity in one male and hypogonadism in one female. These findings demonstrate the complex relationships between the genotype and the gonadal phenotype in severe 3betaHSD deficiency and the difficulty in predicting fertility.

New insight into the molecular basis of 3beta-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase deficiency: identification of eight mutations in the HSD3B2 gene eleven patients from seven new families and comparison of the functional properties of twenty-five mutant enzymes

Classical 3beta-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase/delta5-delta4 isomerase (3betaHSD) deficiency is a form of congenital adrenal hyperplasia that impairs steroidogenesis in both the adrenals and gonads resulting from mutations in the HSD3B2 gene and causing various degrees of salt-wasting in both sexes and incomplete masculinization of the external genitalia in genetic males. To identify the molecular lesion(s) in the HSD3B2 gene in the 11 patients from the seven new families suffering from classical 3betaHSD deficiency, the complete nucleotide sequence of the whole coding region and exon-intron splicing boundaries of this gene was determined by direct sequencing. Five of these families were referred to Morel's molecular diagnostics laboratory in France, whereas the two other families were investigated by Peter's group in Germany. Functional characterization studies were performed by Simard's group in Canada. Following transient expression in 293 cells of each of the mutant recombinant proteins generated by site-directed mutagenesis, the effect of the 25 mutations on enzyme activity was assessed by incubating intact cells in culture with 10 nM [14C]-DHEA as substrate. The stability of the mutant proteins has been investigated using a combination of Northern and Western blot analyses, as well as an in vitro transcription/translation assay using rabbit reticulocyte lysates. The present report describes the identification of 8 mutations, in seven new families with individuals suffering from classical 3betaHSD deficiency, thus increasing the number of known HSD3B2 mutations involved in this autosomal recessive disorder to 31 (1 splicing, 1 in-frame deletion, 3 nonsense, 4 frameshift and 22 missense mutations). In addition to the mutations reported here in these new families, we have also investigated for the first time the functional significance of previously reported missense mutations and or sequence variants namely, A82T, A167V, L173R, L205P, S213G and K216E, P222H, T259M, and T259R, which have not previously been functionally characterized. Furthermore, their effects have been compared with those of the 10 previously reported mutant enzymes to provide a more consistent and comprehensive study. The present results are in accordance with the prediction that no functional 3betaHSD type 2 isoenzyme is expressed in the adrenals and gonads of the patients suffering from a severe salt-wasting form of CAH due to classical 3betaHSD deficiency. Whereas the nonsalt-losing form also results from missense mutation(s) in the HSD3B2 gene, which cause an incomplete loss in enzyme activity, thus leaving sufficient enzymatic activity to prevent salt wasting. The functional data described in the present study concerning the sequence variants A167V, S213G, K216E and L236S, which were detected with premature pubarche or hyperandrogenic adolescent girls suspected to be affected from nonclassical 3betaHSD deficiency, coupled with the previous studies reporting that no mutations were found in both HSD3B1 and/or HSD3B2 genes in such patients strongly support the conclusion that this disorder does not result from a mutant 3betaHSD isoenzyme. The present study provides biochemical evidence supporting the involvement of a new molecular mechanism in classical 3betaHSD deficiency involving protein instability and further illustrates the complexity of the genotype-phenotype relationships of this disease, in addition to providing further valuable information concerning the structure-function relationships of the 3betaHSD superfamily.